
Rami Malek
Douglas Kelley

In postwar Germany, an American psychiatrist must determine whether Nazi prisoners are fit to go on trial for war crimes, and finds himself in a complex battle of intellect and ethics with Hermann Göring, Hitler's right-hand man.
Official
Historical procedurals usually make me wary. Too many of them file the past down into something neat and finished, a solved puzzle where the heroes look sharp and the villains get ushered toward punishment on cue. James Vanderbilt’s Nuremberg is at least trying to disturb that comfort.
It wants the claustrophobia of a psychological duel inside the shell of a courtroom drama, even if it keeps pressing its point harder than it needs to. The idea underneath it is chilling enough on its own: what if the men behind the most mechanized genocide in human history were not supernatural monsters, but ordinary, ambitious, brutally efficient bureaucrats? That’s a terrifying place to begin.
latestnetflix.com's view is that Whether the film really gets there depends a lot on who happens to own the frame from one scene to the next.

Vanderbilt, still clearly carrying his fascination with systems from David Fincher's Zodiac, moves away from the grand theater of the trials and into the cramped cells beneath the courthouse in his adaptation of Jack El-Hai’s nonfiction book The Nazi and the Psychiatrist. That’s where American psychiatrist Douglas Kelley (Rami Malek) is assigned to evaluate the surviving Nazi leadership, especially Hermann Göring (Russell Crowe).
You can feel what the director wants: a battle of intellects played out in concrete confinement. But the execution can be awfully blunt. When Göring smiles and explains his devotion to Hitler by saying "he made us feel German again," the contemporary political echo isn’t merely suggested; it’s outlined in heavy marker.
I don’t mind the warning. I just wish the movie trusted the audience enough to hear it without being elbowed.
If the movie keeps its footing at all, Russell Crowe is the reason. After years of performances that often felt content to run on volume alone, he’s startlingly controlled here. His Göring isn’t a foaming fanatic.
Crowe plays him as a puffed-up narcissist, vain and almost avuncular, which somehow makes him worse. The cruelty hides behind manners and charm. Watch how he moves around that tiny cell: not like a condemned man, but like someone who still believes he’s hosting the evening.
It’s easily his best work in more than a decade. The Irish Times' Tara Brady had it exactly right when she wrote that Crowe "walks a theatrical line between repulsive and magnetic."

The problem is the person facing him. I honestly never settled on what Rami Malek thinks he’s doing here. Since Bohemian Rhapsody, he’s leaned hard into that twitchy, wide-eyed, faintly extraterrestrial mode, and as Kelley it never clicks.
He’s meant to be an opportunist slowly unraveling under the pressure of staring into evil, but the performance doesn’t feel rooted in recognizable human behavior. Every line comes out with the same breathy enigma, until Kelley stops reading like a complicated historical figure and starts feeling like an acting exercise. The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw was brutal when he called it "an eye-rolling, enigmatic-smiling, scenery-nibbling hamfest," but he wasn’t wrong.
Once the interrogator feels stranger than the war criminal, the tension is gone.
For all its lurching structure and mismatched performances, though, Nuremberg does contain one stretch I can’t shake. Partway through, US chief prosecutor Robert H. Jackson (Michael Shannon, supplying his usual slab-of-granite authority) decides the room needs to confront what these men actually did.
He kills the lights and screens real, unedited footage from the concentration camps. Vanderbilt makes the right choice and simply stays there, holding on the images long enough for the air to curdle. We sit in the dark with the defendants, hearing nothing but the merciless click-clack of the projector.
All the slick, Aaron Sorkin-lite chatter from earlier in the film dies on contact with actual mass graves. It’s an ugly collision between Hollywood craft and historical fact, and it works because the movie finally stops performing.

Maybe that ugliness is the point. For all its failings, the film refuses to tuck the Nazis away as some freak aberration beyond the human norm. Kelley’s final, deeply unpopular conclusion is that the capacity for this kind of organized cruelty is not uniquely German; it sits everywhere, waiting for the right economic panic and the right charismatic monster to wake it up.
That is an ugly thought, and a necessary one. Nuremberg may be a clumsy vehicle for it, weighed down by courtroom clichés and a genuinely distracting lead performance, but the idea still lands like a thrown brick. You leave not reassured that justice happened in 1946, but rattled by how easily the same machinery could be rebuilt.
"A gripping showcase for Russell Crowe inside a solid but uneven Nuremberg drama that wrestles with tone and historical shortcuts."
An intense, mesmerizing turn from Russell Crowe and a generally strong ensemble make the film entertaining, thought‑provoking, and one of the better takes on this subject. Real Holocaust footage and the focus on belief, evil, and the psychology around the trials leave a strong emotional impact that lingers. Quippy dialogue, an Americanized, simplified take on complex history, and noticeable factual liberties frustrate—leaving the script shallow, tonally confused, or even uncomfortably sympathetic to Nazis for some.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Forget the war crimes. latestnetflix.com's take is that the real fireworks around Nuremberg (2025) were happening off camera — from Budapest bust-ups to 17-page scream-fests and a deleted scene that practically rewrites Göring’s image.Court is now in session for the gossip.
But the producers say… absolutely not. Co‑producer István Major publicly denied any feud, insisted Crowe finished his work as scheduled, and framed the stand‑in as a pure lighting double, not a secret recast. He even claims Crowe and Malek exchanged gifts at wrap, which is either wholesome… or immaculate damage control.
If you thought the drama stopped there, think again.
The result? One of the most intense days of Crowe’s entire career, by his own admission — and a centerpiece scene fueled by very real off-camera friction.
Nuremberg isn’t just hiding drama in the dailies — there’s a pretty revealing moment left on the cutting-room floor.
Behind the camera, James Vanderbilt was quietly orchestrating his own psychological experiment.
The film may be about 1940s justice, but the discourse is pure 2020s internet.
In other words: the Nuremberg jury is very much still out.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.