Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Trouble with Jessica (2024)

The Trouble with Jessica

“They were already in trouble... then she turned up.”

2024
1h 30m
Director: Matt Winn
Play trailer

Overview

Sarah and Tom are in terrible financial trouble. On the brink of losing everything, they’ve managed to find a buyer for their stylish London home. When their best friends Richard and Beth come round for a final dinner, an uninvited old friend, Jessica, tags along.

Cast

12 people

Reviews

CinemaSerf

A dinner party from hell or what? We quickly learn that hosts "Sarah" (Shirley Henderson) and husband "Tom" (Alan Tudyk) are having to sell their luxury home else face repossession. For some reason that seemed like a good reason to invite long-term friends "Richard" (Rufus Sewell) and wife "Beth" (Olivia Williams) round for food. It's the latter who throws a real spanner in the works by inviting the eponymous "Jessica" (Indira Varma). Let's just say that the hostess and this guest get on like a house that's already burnt down, and as the vino flows (tiny measures in huge great glasses) things come to an head that leaves the four with quite an headache. What now ensues might well have worked on stage, indeed the entire film has a theatrical style to it, but I found it all just a bit to hysteria-prone, contrived and over-dramatic. None of the actors are on especially good form, especially the lacklustre Tudyk and the script seems more determined to make sure each character gets their moment in the spotlight rather than designed to offer us something to laugh - or even smile at. On that front, there are the odd lines to make you titter, but just not enough of them to pass this feature-length more miss than hit sit-com. It will pass ninety minutes easily enough at Christmas on the telly, but nothing much more than that, sorry.

Read full review

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.9/10
"A darkly comedic take on middle-class panic with strong performances but uneven pacing and tonal shifts."

The film’s sharp satire of upper-middle-class hypocrisy and the chaotic energy of its lead cast, particularly Alan Tudyk and Shirley Henderson, resonate well with viewers. However, some find the humor too niche or the plot’s escalating absurdity hard to sustain, leading to mixed reactions on whether the dark comedy lands consistently.

What viewers praise
  • Sharp satirical edge The film’s critique of bourgeois pretensions and social awkwardness hits home for many, offering a biting yet funny perspective.
  • Strong lead performances Alan Tudyk and Shirley Henderson are frequently praised for their comedic timing and ability to ground the film’s darker moments.
  • Unique premise The setup of hiding a dead body to avoid scandal provides a fresh twist on dark comedy tropes, keeping viewers engaged.
  • Dark humor execution Those who enjoy dry, British-style dark comedy appreciate the film’s willingness to push boundaries without softening its edge.
Common complaints
  • Uneven pacing Some viewers feel the film drags in the middle, with the escalating chaos losing steam before the climax.
  • Tonal whiplash The balance between satire and farce doesn’t always work, leaving some scenes feeling disjointed or overly broad.
  • Niche appeal The humor and themes may not resonate with everyone, particularly those expecting a more straightforward comedy or thriller.
  • Underdeveloped side characters Supporting roles, like those played by Rufus Sewell and Olivia Williams, are seen as underutilized or lacking depth.
Recommended for
Dark comedy enthusiasts Fans of British satire Alan Tudyk admirers Indie film buffs Crime-comedy lovers Shirley Henderson fans