Skip to main content
Movie poster for Pete Davidson: Alive from New York (2020)

Pete Davidson: Alive from New York

2020
49m
16 · English
Director: Jason Orley
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Comedian and "SNL" star Pete Davidson drops a candid and intimate stand-up special shot live in New York City.

Trailer

Official

Cast

Reviews

4 min read

The Joke’s on Him (And Maybe Us)

I’ve seen Pete Davidson on stage before—not in a theater, but in the way he exists in public. He’s the guy who shows up to SNL after-parties with a cigarette in one hand and a story in the other, the kind of story that makes you lean in even if you know you shouldn’t. Alive from New York, his 2020 Netflix special, feels like eavesdropping on that exact moment. The problem is, the room isn’t as interesting as it thinks it is.

Pete Davidson on stage, mid-gesture, under warm stage lights

Davidson’s stand-up has always been less about punchlines and more about proximity. He’s the comedian who treats the audience like his group chat, oscillating between self-deprecation and self-mythology with the manic energy of someone who’s had three espressos and a Xanax. Here, that energy is dialed up to eleven, but the special never quite decides whether it’s a confessional, a therapy session, or just a guy talking too fast to avoid silence.

The result is something that feels alive—in the way a live wire is alive, sparking and dangerous but not always illuminating.

The special’s most revealing moment comes early, when Davidson turns to the camera (or maybe to director Jason Orley, who’s visible in the wings) and asks, "Should I do the bit about Ariana?" It’s a meta joke, but it’s also the whole thesis of the special: Do I perform this pain, or do I just live it? The answer, unfortunately, is both. Davidson spends the next 49 minutes doing neither particularly well.

The Ariana Grande material—his riff on "thank u, next" and the way the public’s fixation on their relationship turned him into a meme—is the closest the special comes to a throughline. It’s funny, in a squirm-inducing way, because it’s not really a joke. It’s a guy recounting how it felt to be reduced to a punchline in someone else’s song.

The laughter in the room feels nervous, like we’re all complicit in the thing he’s describing.

Close-up of Davidson, smirking, with a blurred audience in the background

Critics were split, and it’s easy to see why. Vulture called it "raw and under-formed," which is a polite way of saying it feels like a first draft. The A.V.

Club was blunter: "thin and padded." Both are right. The special meanders, jumping from his father’s death on 9/11 to his struggles with mental health to the time Louis C.K. Allegedly tried to get him fired from SNL.

There’s no arc, just a series of anecdotes strung together like beads on a necklace that keeps getting tangled. Davidson’s delivery—jittery, anxious, like he’s trying to outrun his own thoughts—makes it hard to tell whether the lack of structure is intentional or just the result of a comedian who’s more comfortable riffing than crafting.

That’s not to say there aren’t flashes of brilliance. The Louis C.K. Story, for instance, is a masterclass in how to weaponize vulnerability.

Davidson recounts how C.K. Cornered him after a show, telling him he was "too sensitive" to be on SNL. The way he tells it, you can hear the echo of every insecure kid who’s ever been told they’re too much—too loud, too weird, too sensitive.

It’s the kind of story that makes you want to hug him and also never let him near a microphone again, because you know he’s going to say something that will make you cringe in three seconds flat.

The special’s biggest flaw, though, is that it mistakes exposure for depth. Davidson treats his life like an open wound, but he never quite figures out what to do with the blood. There’s a difference between being honest and being exhibitionist, and Alive from New York often feels like the latter.

It’s not that his pain isn’t real—it’s that he hasn’t yet turned it into something that feels earned. The best stand-up comedians use their lives as raw material, but they also shape it into something that transcends the personal. Richard Pryor didn’t just talk about his addictions; he turned them into a mirror held up to America.

Dave Chappelle doesn’t just riff on race; he forces you to confront your own complicity. Davidson, here, is still stuck in the first part of that equation. He’s got the raw material, but he hasn’t yet figured out what to build with it.

Davidson mid-laugh, gesturing with his hands, under a spotlight

That’s not to say the special isn’t worth watching. It is, if only because Davidson is one of the few comedians who feels like he’s actually living in the moment, even when that moment is messy. There’s a scene where he talks about his struggles with borderline personality disorder, and for a second, the room goes quiet.

Not because it’s a particularly profound observation, but because you can feel the weight of it. It’s the kind of moment that makes you realize why people keep coming back to him, even when he’s not at his best. He’s not just a comedian; he’s a walking, talking Rorschach test for how we process pain in the age of social media.

The special’s title, Alive from New York, is both a promise and a question. Is he alive? Yes.

Is he from New York in the way that, say, George Carlin was from New York—a voice shaped by the city’s cynicism and resilience? Not yet. But maybe that’s the point.

Davidson is still figuring out what kind of comedian he wants to be, and Alive from New York is less a finished product than a snapshot of a guy in the middle of that process. It’s flawed, uneven, and often frustrating, but it’s also real in a way that most comedy specials aren’t. The question is whether that’s enough.

I’m not sure it is. But I’m also not sure I could look away.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.