Beritan Balcı
Mavi
Overview
When German-raised Mavi learns she belongs to a superrich Turkish dynasty, new family expectations quickly turn her world and love life upside down.
Cast
12 people
Reviews
4 min readThe Fairy Tale That Forgot to Believe in Itself
I kept waiting for She Said Maybe to commit—to its romance, its satire, its own ridiculous premise. Instead, it hovers in a limbo of half-hearted charm, like a rom-com that’s been watered down for mass appeal. The film wants to be Crazy Rich Asians meets The Princess Diaries, a fish-out-of-water fantasy where a German woman discovers she’s heir to a Turkish dynasty.
But somewhere between the lavish palaces and the culture-clash gags, it loses the thread of what makes those stories work: the conviction that the fairy tale matters.
The premise is catnip. Mavi (Beritan Balcı), a Berlin-based influencer with a modest following, learns she’s the long-lost granddaughter of a Turkish tycoon. Overnight, she’s whisked into a world of private yachts, gold-plated everything, and a family that oscillates between warm embraces and passive-aggressive power plays.
It’s the kind of setup that should crackle with tension—class, identity, the absurdity of inherited wealth—but the film treats it all with a shrug. The satire never lands, the romance never sizzles, and the family drama feels like it was written on a napkin between takes.
The problem isn’t the premise; it’s the execution. Take the scene where Mavi first meets her extended family. The camera lingers on the opulence—the chandeliers, the marble, the way the sunlight turns the room into a gilded cage—but the dialogue is pure exposition.
"You’re one of us now," her uncle says, as if that explains anything. What should be a moment of disorientation, of Mavi realizing she’s both an outsider and the heir to this empire, instead plays like a checklist: rich family, check; culture shock, check; awkward small talk, check. The film never digs into the psychological weight of the situation. It’s all surface, no soul.
Audience Opinions
Audience 4.5/10
"A glossy, culture-clash fairy-tale romance carried by pretty vistas but dragged down by shallow writing and uneven chemistry."
The mix of German-Turkish setting, wealth fantasy, and fish‑out‑of‑water setup is seen as fun escapism, with Istanbul locations and opulent production design getting consistent praise. latestnetflix.com's read is that at the same time, the story is viewed as predictable and sometimes illogical, the dialogue often feels cringe or stilted, and reactions to the central couple range from cute and easygoing to flat and unconvincing, leaving the film sitting in guilty‑pleasure territory for some and outright frustrating for others.
What viewers praise
- Gorgeous locations Istanbul backdrops, palaces, and waterfront settings are repeatedly called beautiful and make the movie pleasant to look at even when the story falters.
- Fairy‑tale escapism The fantasy of a German woman discovering she belongs to a super‑rich Turkish dynasty scratches the same itch as Princess Diaries or Crazy Rich Asians for light, wish‑fulfillment romance.
- Breezy, easy watch Several viewers describe it as cute, simple, and easy to throw on during a rom‑com binge despite its flaws.
- Entertaining side characters Secondary figures like Leyla, Edo, and some cousins are singled out as amusing, adding humor and charm when the leads or plot sag.
- Appealing culture mix The German‑Turkish perspective and cross‑cultural family dynamics are appreciated as a fresher backdrop than the standard Hollywood rom‑com setting.
Common complaints
- Weak or uneven acting One review slams the lead performance as almost unwatchable, and others feel that no amount of talent can fully rescue the lines they are given.
- Unnatural dialogue Conversations are often described as superficial, awkward, or downright cringe, especially in German, making emotional beats hard to take seriously.
- Thin, illogical plotting Beyond the initial hook, the story is called lame or messy, with missing connective tissue, rushed turns, and motivations that do not always make sense.
- Divisive chemistry and love triangle Some viewers enjoy Mavi’s pairing with Can, but others find more spark with Kent or feel no chemistry at all, which makes the chosen endgame and reconciliation unsatisfying.
- Rich‑fantasy and propaganda vibe A subset of viewers bristle at the nonstop parade of ultra‑wealthy lifestyles in Istanbul and complain that the film glosses over real‑world Turkish problems in favor of glossy tourism‑style promotion.
Recommended for
Light rom-com binge watchers Princess Diaries style story fans Crazy Rich Asians enjoyers German-Turkish culture story seekers Hallmark-style romance viewers Scenic travel romance lovers
Buzz & Rumors
Public reportsShe showed up to the rom-com callback in baggy jeans
Beritan Balci told Bunte she did not even know the first round was for a rom-com. She arrived in a T-shirt. When the call came that she had made the next round, she said she "fell from the clouds." She had just finished a compressed acting degree, done Vienna Tatort, and now Netflix wanted her as Mavi Simsek, a Hamburg-raised architect who learns she belongs to a Turkish dynasty. She Said Maybe, directed by Buket Alakus and Ngo The Chau from Ipek Zubert's screenplay, went live worldwide on 19 September 2025. Balci, 26 in that interview, called herself a guest-worker granddaughter. One grandfather opened the first doner shop in Kassel. She lived her first three years in Turkey, then Austria, then Munich. In Germany she is read as Turkish. In Turkey she is the German with the hard accent. latestnetflix.com's view is that she called this the first German-Turkish rom-com and said both groups finally get a story.That is her claim, not a festival prize. 
, ,
Sinan Gulec plays Can, the boyfriend who books a surprise trip to Istanbul and tries to propose at the worst possible times. Serkan Cayoglu is Kent, the polished option grandmother Yadigar prefers. Meral Perin plays Yadigar. Katja Riemann is Can's mother. Caro Daur, the influencer, is Mavi's best friend Nora. Balci said the whole cast sat through acting coaching so Daur and the trained actors would share a connection, then they shot nearly three months in Hamburg, Istanbul, and Cappadocia. Daur was on every stop and "very well prepared." The balloon scenes over Cappadocia had to be done twice because the wind failed the first time. The balloonist told her about 500 balloons go up a day. ,
They wrote some of the proposal themselves
Schon Magazine got Balci and Gulec after release. She named the film's feeling as "compassion and also the longing for identity." He talked about Can proposing when it is completely inappropriate. They were allowed to add lines to the last proposal, text they wrote together just before cameras. Balci loved the beat after Turkish papers pair Mavi with Kent, when Can says, "I know who we are, don't worry." She also clocked Yadigar as a matriarch, a woman running the dynasty, which she said is rarely how these families are filmed. The crew mixed Turkish and German speakers, about 100 people a day, and agreed to work in English when they had to. After they were cast, the two leads went to Hamlet in Hamburg. That is not a publicist invention. They said it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUqTDNseybk
CB Medya made it with Dark Bay. Filmdienst lists Tim Tamke and Burak Yerlikaya among the producers, 107 minutes, Germany and Turkey, Netflix on 19 September. TMDB files 1 hour 48 minutes, original language German, Balci, Gulec, Cayoglu. ScreenRant called it more heart than laughs and a tourist-trap rom-com, which is a critic's line, not a box-office report. Balci told Bunte the film could reach 300 million Netflix accounts and that she still gets nervous at theatre premieres. Women wrote to her that they watched with their mothers and grandmothers. The official trailer went up 25 August. , , , ,
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Movies
Similar Movies
Related titles ranked by rating and popularity.
