Skip to main content
Movie poster for Velvet Buzzsaw (2019)

Velvet Buzzsaw

“All Art Is Dangerous”

2019
1h 52m
Director: Dan Gilroy
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Big money artists and mega-collectors pay a high price when art collides with commerce. After a series of paintings by an unknown artist are discovered, a supernatural force enacts revenge on those who have allowed their greed to get in the way of art.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Art of the Kill

I’ve been thinking about Velvet Buzzsaw for days, and not just because it’s the kind of movie that lingers like a bad gallery opening—all forced small talk and cheap wine. No, what sticks with me is how it weaponizes the very thing it critiques: the art world’s obsession with surfaces. Dan Gilroy’s film isn’t just a satire; it’s a hall of mirrors where every reflection is a little more grotesque than the last.

And yet, for all its sharp edges, I’m not entirely sure it cuts deep enough. The premise is deliciously simple: a cache of paintings by a reclusive artist, Vetril Dease, is discovered after his death, and the Los Angeles art machine immediately begins grinding them into cash. Enter our ensemble—Jake Gyllenhaal’s Morf Vandewalt, a critic whose prose is as inflated as his ego; Rene Russo’s Rhodora Haze, a gallery owner with the moral flexibility of a used-car salesman; and Zawe Ashton’s Josephina, an assistant who stumbles into a career-making discovery and immediately regrets it.

The paintings, it turns out, are cursed. Or haunted. Or maybe just really, really bad for your health.

The film never bothers to clarify, and that’s part of the point. In the art world, ambiguity is currency.

A neon-lit gallery space, where a crowd of well-dressed patrons mill around a series of abstract paintings, their faces half-lit by the glow of pretension.

Gilroy, who also gave us Nightcrawler’s sleazy neon-noir, knows how to stage a scene. The film’s Los Angeles is a place where the sun never quite breaks through the smog, where every conversation feels like a transaction, and where the only thing more valuable than a good review is a bad one that goes viral. The cinematography (by Robert Elswit, a frequent collaborator) bathes everything in a sickly, saturated glow—think Eyes Wide Shut meets a high-end boutique.

The camera lingers on the paintings themselves, which are unsettling in a way that feels intentional but never quite transcends their own gimmick. They’re not so much art as they are Rorschach tests for the characters’ greed. (And, let’s be honest, for ours.)

The film’s first act is its strongest, a razor-sharp comedy of manners where the dialogue crackles with the kind of venom usually reserved for private texts between ex-friends. Gyllenhaal, in particular, is a revelation. Morf Vandewalt is the kind of critic who writes in all caps and probably has a Google Alert for his own name.

He’s all sharp angles and nervous energy, a man who’s spent so long dissecting art that he’s forgotten how to feel anything. There’s a scene where he delivers a monologue about the "soul of art" while standing in front of a painting that looks like it was made by a sleep-deprived toddler. The irony isn’t subtle, but it’s effective—because, of course, Morf wouldn’t recognize a soul if it bit him on the ass.

But here’s the problem: Velvet Buzzsaw wants to have its cake and eat it too. It wants to skewer the art world’s pretensions while also indulging in the very excesses it mocks. The supernatural elements—paintings that kill, a mobile that strangles, a sculpture that somehow becomes sentient—feel like a cop-out, a way to avoid the harder work of making its satire land without a literal deus ex machina.

The horror elements are tonally jarring, not because they’re scary (they’re not), but because they feel like a different movie—a schlocky B-picture grafted onto what was, up until that point, a biting social satire.

A close-up of a painting with swirling, chaotic brushstrokes, its colors bleeding into one another like a bruise.

And then there’s the ending. Without spoiling anything, it’s the kind of conclusion that feels less like a statement and more like a shrug. The film’s body count is high, but the emotional stakes never quite match the carnage.

Part of that is by design—the art world, after all, is a place where people die (metaphorically) all the time, only to be resurrected by a well-timed Instagram post. But the supernatural revenge plot undercuts the film’s own critique. If the message is that art is dangerous when commodified, why does the danger have to be literal?

Why not let the satire do the work? That’s not to say Velvet Buzzsaw doesn’t have its moments. Toni Collette, as the collector Gretchen, is a masterclass in how to convey entire backstories with a single arched eyebrow.

John Malkovich, playing an artist who’s sold out so thoroughly he’s become a parody of himself, delivers some of the film’s best lines with the kind of weary resignation that only comes from decades of being in on the joke. And there’s a scene where a performance artist (played by Billy Magnussen) stages a piece so aggressively pointless that I found myself laughing out loud—not because it was funny, but because it was true.

I’ve been to that gallery. I’ve seen that guy. But the film’s biggest flaw might be its timing.

Released in 2019, Velvet Buzzsaw arrived just as the art world’s absurdities were becoming impossible to ignore. The rise of NFTs, the spectacle of auction houses treating art like stock options, the way a banana taped to a wall could sell for a reported budget—it all made Gilroy’s satire feel, if not prescient, then at least relevant. But the film’s supernatural elements feel like a distraction from the real horror: that the art world’s excesses are already grotesque enough without needing a haunted canvas to make them so.

A dimly lit storage room filled with paintings, their frames stacked haphazardly like forgotten relics, the air thick with dust and something darker.

In the end, Velvet Buzzsaw is a movie that wants to be The Player meets Suspiria, but it never quite commits to either. It’s too smart to be a straightforward horror flick, but too silly to be a pure satire. And maybe that’s the point.

The art world, after all, is a place where contradictions thrive—where a urinal can be a masterpiece and a million-dollar painting can be a scam. Gilroy’s film captures that chaos, but it never quite tames it. It leaves you with the uneasy feeling that you’ve just spent two hours at an opening where the art wasn’t the only thing that left a bad taste in your mouth.

And maybe that’s enough. Maybe the best satires don’t need to tie everything up in a neat bow. Maybe they just need to hold up a mirror and let us squirm at what we see. Velvet Buzzsaw does that, even if it can’t resist taking a few cheap shots along the way.

Audience Opinions

Audience 5.0/10
"A visually striking but divisive horror-thriller that struggles to balance satire with genuine scares."

The film’s bold visual style and dark humor offer a distinctive take on the art world’s cutthroat nature. Its uneven tone and loose storytelling frustrate, though, with horror elements that underwhelm and satire that can be heavy-handed.

What viewers praise
  • Visually stunning Creative art direction and cinematography with a bold aesthetic.
  • Darkly humorous The satirical edge and dark comedy deliver a sharp critique of the art industry.
  • Strong cast performances The ensemble, particularly Jake Gyllenhaal and Rene Russo, elevates the material.
  • Unique premise Cursed art wreaking havoc on the art world is a fresh, intriguing concept.
Common complaints
  • Inconsistent tone The mix of horror, satire and thriller feels disjointed, muddying the film’s intent.
  • Weak horror elements The horror is underdeveloped and delivers few genuine scares.
  • Slow pacing The deliberate pace and lack of momentum frustrate.
  • Underwhelming payoff The ending feels unsatisfying and anticlimactic.
Recommended for
Fans of dark satire Art world enthusiasts Lovers of stylish thrillers Jake Gyllenhaal fans Netflix horror seekers Indie film aficionados

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s Velvet Buzzsaw: The Art World’s Darkest Satire Comes to Life

Dan Gilroy’s Velvet Buzzsaw (2019) arrived with a buzz—part horror, part biting satire—skewering the pretensions of the high-art world. The Netflix original, starring Jake Gyllenhaal, Rene Russo, and Toni Collette, premiered at Sundance before dropping on the streaming platform, where it quickly became a cult favorite for its eerie blend of supernatural revenge and sharp industry critique. But behind the film’s glossy, blood-soaked veneer, the making of Velvet Buzzsaw had its own share of intrigue.

A Sundance Premiere with Star Power

The film’s debut at the 2019 Sundance Film Festival was a star-studded affair. Director Dan Gilroy, known for his work on thrillers like Nightcrawler (2014), was joined by the cast for a post-screening Q&A, where they teased the film’s darkly comedic take on the art world’s cutthroat nature. Clips from the event show the ensemble—including Gyllenhaal, Russo, and Collette—discussing the film’s themes of greed, exploitation, and the macabre consequences of commodifying creativity.

The trailer, released ahead of the premiere, leaned hard into the film’s horror elements, with eerie visuals of paintings coming to life and a sinister score setting the tone,,. Netflix’s marketing positioned Velvet Buzzsaw as a supernatural thriller, but those who saw it at Sundance knew it was just as much a scathing satire of the art industry’s elitism,.

The Cast’s Take on the Art World’s Dark Side

The ensemble cast brought their own perspectives to the film’s critique. Gyllenhaal, playing art critic Morf Vandewalt, described the character as a man obsessed with power and prestige—a reflection of the industry’s gatekeepers. Russo, as gallery mogul Rhodora Haze, embodied the ruthless ambition of art dealers, while Collette’s character, Gretchen, represented the desperate artists willing to sell out for fame.

Zawe Ashton, who played assistant Josephina, and John Malkovich, as struggling artist Piers, added layers to the film’s exploration of authenticity versus commercialism. The cast’s chemistry was palpable during the Sundance panel, where they joked about the film’s over-the-top violence and the absurdity of the art world’s excesses.

Mixed Reactions and Cult Status

Despite the hype, Velvet Buzzsaw received mixed reviews. Rotten Tomatoes lists it with a critic score that reflects its divisive nature, while French review site SensCritique gave it a middling 5/10, calling it a flawed but ambitious genre mashup. Some viewers praised its bold visuals and sharp satire, while others found the horror elements underwhelming.

Still, the film’s unique premise—artworks that kill those who exploit them—has kept it in conversations about unconventional horror. Gilroy’s direction, blending dark comedy with supernatural dread, ensured Velvet Buzzsaw stood out in Netflix’s 2019 lineup,.

The Unanswered Questions

One lingering mystery is whether the film’s supernatural elements were always part of Gilroy’s vision. The director, known for his work in thriller genres, has never fully detailed how the horror angle evolved. Rumors suggest Netflix pushed for more overt scares, but without confirmation, it remains speculation.

What’s clear is that Velvet Buzzsaw was a passion project for Gilroy, who used the film to skewer the art world’s hypocrisy. Whether audiences loved or loathed it, the movie’s legacy as a bold, bloody satire is secure.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.