Skip to main content
Movie poster for Edmilson Filho: Notas, Comedy about Relationships (2018)

Edmilson Filho: Notas, Comedy about Relationships

2018
1h 19m
15 · Portuguese
Director: Halder Gomes
Search on Netflix

Overview

Brazilian comedian Edmilson Filho walks his audience through the stages of a modern relationship, playing up the differences between men and women.

Cast

Reviews

5 min read

The Loneliness of the Stand-Up Philosopher

I’ve seen this trick before. A comedian steps out from behind the microphone, trades the spotlight for a camera, and decides to teach us something about love. The formula is as old as Woody Allen’s neurotic monologues, as recent as Hannah Gadsby’s Nanette—a blend of humor and heartache, delivered with the promise that laughter might soften the blow of hard truths. Edmilson Filho: Notas, Comedy about Relationships follows this well-trod path, but with a twist: it’s less a film than a one-man show stretched to feature length, a 79-minute stand-up set dressed in the thinnest of narrative guises.

latestnetflix.com's view is that the question isn’t whether it’s funny—sometimes it is—but whether it earns the emotional weight it so desperately wants to carry.

Edmilson Filho, a Brazilian comedian with a face built for expressive despair, plays himself, or at least a version of himself. The film’s conceit is simple: he’s a man reflecting on the absurdities of modern romance, the push-and-pull between men and women, the way love curdles into resentment, and how we’re all just stumbling through it with varying degrees of grace. The problem isn’t the material—relationships are an endless well of comedy and tragedy—but the delivery.

Filho’s schtick leans heavily on broad physical comedy, exaggerated facial expressions, and a kind of performative bewilderment that feels borrowed from a silent film star. There’s a moment where he mimes being strangled by an invisible force, his eyes bulging, tongue lolling, as if to say, See? This is what love does to me. It’s the kind of bit that works in small doses, in a club where the energy of the crowd can carry it.

Here, stretched over nearly 80 minutes, it starts to feel like watching someone practice their act in an empty room.

That’s the film’s central tension: it wants to be both a comedy and a meditation on love, but it never quite commits to either. The stand-up segments are intercut with what passes for narrative—a series of vignettes where Filho interacts with women (played by a rotating cast of actresses) in scenarios that range from awkward to mildly amusing. In one, he’s on a date where the woman spends the entire meal talking about her ex.

In another, he’s trying to impress a woman by pretending to be a wine connoisseur, only to be exposed as a fraud. These scenes are fine, but they lack the bite of real observation. They’re sketches, not stories, and they don’t build toward anything deeper than the punchline.

The film’s tagline might as well be: Men and women, am I right?

What’s missing is specificity. Filho’s jokes about relationships are so general they could apply to anyone, anywhere. The film never digs into the particularities of Brazilian culture, or even Filho’s own life, in a way that would make his insights feel earned.

Instead, it relies on the kind of universalizing platitudes that populate bad self-help books: Women want commitment, men want freedom. Love is hard. Communication is key. There’s a scene where he breaks the fourth wall to deliver a monologue about how men and women are fundamentally different, as if this is some kind of revelation.

It’s the kind of thing that might get a knowing chuckle in a comedy club, but on screen, it feels lazy. Where’s the nuance? Where’s the mess?

Real relationships aren’t punchlines; they’re a tangle of contradictions, and the best comedies about love—Annie Hall, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, even The Big Sick—understand that.

Filho is a charismatic performer, no doubt. He has a rubbery face that can shift from goofy to heartbroken in an instant, and there’s a moment where he’s sitting alone in a bar, nursing a drink, and the camera lingers on him just long enough to let the silence settle. For a second, it feels like the film might actually say something.

But then the moment passes, and we’re back to the jokes. It’s frustrating because Filho is clearly capable of more. There’s a scene where he’s arguing with a woman over the phone, his voice rising in pitch, his gestures growing more frantic, and for a brief moment, it feels real.

The anger, the defensiveness, the way he’s trying to win an argument he’s already lost—it’s the most honest thing in the film. But then the scene cuts away, and the moment is gone.

The film’s biggest flaw, though, isn’t its reliance on broad humor or its lack of depth. It’s that it never trusts its audience. Stand-up comedy is, at its best, a conversation.

The comedian riffs, the audience reacts, and the energy builds. But Notas is a monologue, not a dialogue. Filho is performing for the camera, not for us, and the result is a film that feels hermetically sealed.

There’s no room for the audience to bring their own experiences to the table, no space for the kind of reflection that makes great comedy about relationships resonate. Instead, we’re left with a series of observations that feel like they’ve been focus-grouped to death.

That’s not to say the film is without charm. Filho’s physical comedy is often inventive, and there’s a certain joy in watching him commit fully to the bit, even when the bit isn’t working. There’s a sequence where he’s trying to impress a woman by pretending to be a fitness guru, and his increasingly absurd attempts to mimic workout routines are genuinely funny.

But these moments are fleeting, and they’re not enough to sustain the film’s emotional ambitions. By the time the credits roll, I was left with the same feeling I get after watching a mediocre stand-up set: That was fine, but I’m not sure I’d recommend it to a friend.

Maybe that’s the point. Relationships, after all, are often just fine. They’re not grand romances or epic tragedies; they’re a series of small, messy moments that add up to something that’s neither great nor terrible, just… there. Notas captures that feeling, but it doesn’t elevate it.

It’s a film that wants to be profound but settles for being passable. And in a way, that’s its most honest quality. Because sometimes, that’s all love is: not a grand gesture, not a life-altering revelation, but something that’s just… okay.

Not terrible. Not great. Just okay.

I’m not sure that’s enough.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Fortaleza filled the Art Deco house. Then Netflix took the notes.

Cineteatro Sao Luiz holds about a thousand people. Art Deco, listed as Ceara heritage since 1991, the room Cearense film people keep coming back to. In September 2017 Edmilson Filho taped Notas, Uma Comedia de Relacionamentos there for Halder Gomes. O Povo's Rubens Rodrigues wrote that the house was full on the back of Cine Holliudy and Shaolin do Sertao, both with Gomes directing and Filho starring. latestnetflix.com's view is that the monologue came from a run of posts about men and women at each stage of a relationship.IMDb lists Filho as writer, Gomes as director, 79 minutes.,,,

The notes were already a stage show. Portuguese Wikipedia puts Notas on his theatre list for 2016 and 2017, after Made in Ceara, the piece he built with Gomes once he had lived in the United States and clocked how Brazilians and Americans date. Made in Ceara had been running since 2013. Notas was the follow-up once the movies meant he could fill Sao Luiz without a kung fu plot. AdoroCinema's Netflix synopsis still sells two bits. How to seduce with Russian poetry. How to cure a broken heart in three days. Netflix Wiki adds Juliana Beirac as herself. The English title on the service is Edmilson Filho: Notas, Comedy about Relationships.,,

O Povo dated the Brazil drop around 5 March 2018. TMDB's release is 8 March 2018. US trackers later print 1 November 2018 as the date added. That is a catalog stagger, not a reshoot.,,

Halder used to own the gym.

VEJA told the origin. Filho, a taekwondo tricampeao from Fortaleza, trained at a gym Halder Gomes ran. Gomes cast him in the 2004 short that became Cine Holliudy. Distributors passed. They said the film was odd and spoken in "cearenses" and the rest of Brazil would not get it. Nine rooms in Ceara. A humble target of 20,000 tickets. Filho joked he would have been happy with 100. VEJA printed 380,000 sold. Wikipedia's film page later lists 481,203 spectators and 4.9 million reais. Either way the pair had a local movie star who could fill Sao Luiz.,

The relationship hour is the odd one in that filmography. No kung fu. No interior cinema. A Cearense movie star walking a packed hometown theatre through dating, then handing the tape to Netflix. Portal IN later quoted him on the partnership as a life one, teacher and student, Hong Kong movies to Cearense comedies. The special is the quiet sibling of that run.,

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.