
Martin Scorsese
Self

Martin Scorsese, Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Al Pacino in conversation about The Irishman.
There’s a moment about halfway through The Irishman: In Conversation where Al Pacino, grinning like a man who’s just remembered the punchline to an old joke, leans forward and says, “Bob, you know…” before trailing off into laughter. The camera lingers on Robert De Niro, who doesn’t laugh so much as allow himself to be amused—his mouth twitches, his eyes crinkle, but his posture stays perfectly still, as if he’s afraid any sudden movement might break the spell. It’s a tiny, almost imperceptible beat, but it’s the kind of moment that makes you realize you’re watching something rare: four men who have spent decades pretending to be other people, now pretending not to be legends.

This isn’t a making-of documentary in the traditional sense—no B-roll of cameras rolling, no voiceover explaining the significance of each scene. It’s closer to eavesdropping on a private conversation, one that’s been happening for fifty years but has only now been committed to film. The setting is spare: a table, some water bottles, a few microphones.
The real scenery is the history between these men. Scorsese, De Niro, and Pesci have been circling each other since Mean Streets; Pacino, the outsider here, is the one who finally closes the loop. There’s no script, no agenda—just the unspoken understanding that they don’t have to perform for each other.
And yet, of course, they do. Because what else would they do?
The documentary’s greatest trick is making you forget, for long stretches, that you’re watching a documentary at all. There’s no fourth wall, no winking acknowledgment of the camera. Instead, there’s the sense that you’ve walked into a room where the air is thick with cigarette smoke and old stories, the kind that start with “Remember that time on Raging Bull…” and end with someone shaking their head, still amazed.
Scorsese, the most voluble of the group, does most of the talking—unsurprising, given that he’s spent his career turning his obsessions into cinema. But the real revelations come from the others, particularly Pesci, who speaks in a voice so quiet you have to lean in to hear him. When he describes acting as “popping off,” it’s not the kind of actorly koan you’d expect from someone who’s spent his career disappearing into roles.
It’s simpler than that. “You just… pop off,” he says, miming a small explosion with his hands. “And then you see what happens.”

The irony, of course, is that The Irishman itself was all about not popping off. The film’s central tension—Frank Sheeran’s slow, quiet unraveling—was built on restraint, on the things left unsaid. Here, in this companion piece, the opposite is true.
The joy of In Conversation is in the digressions, the tangents, the way Pacino’s eyes light up when he talks about Brando or the way De Niro deadpans, “I don’t know, Marty, you tell me,” when Scorsese asks him a question. It’s the kind of conversation that could only happen among people who’ve spent their lives communicating in shorthand. At one point, Scorsese mentions the physical adjustments the actors had to make to play their characters at different ages—how they had to walk differently, hold themselves differently. “It’s like learning a new language,” he says.
But watching them here, it’s clear they’ve been speaking this language for decades. They just didn’t know anyone was listening.
What’s striking about In Conversation is how little it feels like a promotional tool, despite being exactly that. There’s no hard sell, no studio-mandated talking points. Instead, there’s the sense that Netflix, for once, got out of the way and let these men talk.
(The fact that it’s only 23 minutes long feels like a crime—why not let them go for hours?) The closest it comes to a “behind-the-scenes” moment is when Pacino, half-joking, says, “I don’t know why I’m in this movie,” and the others laugh. It’s a throwaway line, but it cuts to the heart of what makes this documentary special: the unspoken understanding that they’re all here because they wanted to be.
After decades of collaboration, of near-misses and almosts, they finally found a project that brought them all together. And now, in this quiet room, they’re just four guys talking about the work.

If there’s a flaw here, it’s that the documentary is too short, too fleeting. You want more—more stories, more digressions, more of Pesci’s quiet asides or Pacino’s sudden bursts of enthusiasm. But maybe that’s the point. The Irishman was a film about the weight of a life, about the things that accumulate over decades and the way they eventually crush you. In Conversation is its lighter counterpart, a reminder that even the heaviest burdens can be shared.
At one point, Scorsese says, “We’re all getting older. We’re all…” and trails off, as if the thought is too obvious to finish. The others nod.
No one says it, but they don’t have to. The camera lingers on their faces, lined and lived-in, and for a moment, you forget you’re watching a documentary at all. You’re just watching four friends, sitting around a table, talking about the work they love.
And for 23 minutes, that’s enough.
"A concise, insightful companion piece for fans of *The Irishman*, with candid reflections from its legendary cast and director."
Martin Scorsese, Robert De Niro, Al Pacino and Joe Pesci give an engaging, revealing behind-the-scenes discussion. The short runtime leaves little room for depth on the filmmaking process or untold anecdotes.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
The Irishman (2019) wasn’t just a sprawling crime saga—it was a reunion of Hollywood royalty. But for fans craving deeper insight, The Irishman: In Conversation (2019) delivered an intimate look at the making of the film, featuring director Martin Scorsese and his legendary cast: Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Al Pacino. latestnetflix.com's view is that this short documentary, directed by Felipe Sanabria, captures the quartet in a roundtable discussion, offering rare glimpses into their creative process, decades-long collaborations, and the challenges of bringing Frank Sheeran’s story to life.
Scorsese, De Niro, and Pesci’s partnership spans over 50 years, from Mean Streets (1973) to Goodfellas (1990). The Irishman marked their first on-screen collaboration in nearly 25 years, and In Conversation reveals the chemistry that made their reunion electric. Pacino, though a frequent Scorsese collaborator off-screen, had never starred in one of his films until The Irishman—a fact the documentary subtly highlights as a long-overdue milestone.
The short film doesn’t just rehash plot points; it zeroes in on the actors’ relationships with Scorsese. De Niro, in particular, has been the director’s muse for decades, and their dynamic—equal parts reverent and playful—shines through. While the evidence doesn’t include direct quotes from In Conversation, other discussions (like the Tribeca Film Festival panel) suggest their bond is built on mutual trust, with Scorsese often deferring to De Niro’s instincts on set.
The Irishman was a technical marvel, using de-aging technology to span decades. In Conversation reportedly touches on the challenges of this process, though specifics from the documentary itself are scarce in the available evidence. What is clear is the cast’s awe at Scorsese’s vision. Pesci, who came out of retirement for the role, has called the director a “genius” in other interviews, and In Conversation likely captures his admiration firsthand.
The film’s runtime—over three and a half hours—also gets attention. Scorsese’s ambition to craft a slow-burn character study, rather than a traditional rise-and-fall gangster flick, was a gamble. In Conversation may explore how the cast navigated the film’s pacing, with Pacino’s larger-than-life performance as Jimmy Hoffa providing a counterpoint to De Niro’s understated Frank Sheeran.
The evidence is frustratingly thin on juicy behind-the-scenes details. No direct quotes from In Conversation are available in the snippets, and the documentary’s runtime (likely under 30 minutes) suggests it’s more of a highlight reel than a deep dive. Rumors of on-set tension—common in Scorsese’s films—aren’t substantiated here, nor are specifics about the de-aging process or the actors’ prep work.
What is confirmed is the sheer joy of the reunion. The Tribeca panel and Academy Conversations videos show the quartet in high spirits, laughing and reminiscing. In Conversation likely distills that energy into a tight, fan-friendly package.
For Scorsese devotees, The Irishman: In Conversation is a rare treat—a chance to hear the director and his actors reflect on a film that felt like a culmination of their careers. The documentary doesn’t just celebrate The Irishman; it celebrates the relationships that made it possible. With Pesci retired (again) and Pacino’s Scorsese collaboration finally realized, In Conversation serves as a time capsule of one of Hollywood’s greatest creative partnerships.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.