Skip to main content
Movie poster for Single All the Way (2021)

Single All the Way

“Peter and Nick are just friends. Peter's family knows better.”

2021
1h 39m
10 · English
Director: Michael Mayer
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Desperate to avoid his family’s judgment about his perpetual single status, Peter convinces his best friend Nick to join him for the holidays and pretend that they’re now in a relationship. But when Peter’s mother sets him up on a blind date with her handsome trainer James, the plan goes awry.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Holidays Are a Lie (And So Are We)

I’ve always had a soft spot for holiday movies that treat the season like a pressure cooker—where the forced cheer and family gatherings expose the cracks in our carefully constructed lives. Single All the Way leans into that tradition, but with a twist: it’s not just about the lies we tell others, but the ones we tell ourselves. The film, a Netflix holiday rom-com from director Michael Mayer, arrives with all the expected trappings—a snowy small-town setting, a meddling family, a fake relationship that might not be so fake after all—but it’s the moments when it stumbles that make it worth talking about. Because in those stumbles, it accidentally reveals something true about how we perform happiness, especially during the holidays.

The premise is simple, almost aggressively so: Peter (Michael Urie), a perpetually single gay man, is dreading another Christmas of his family’s pitying looks and not-so-subtle questions about his love life. To avoid the annual interrogation, he convinces his best friend Nick (Philemon Chambers) to pose as his boyfriend for the holidays. The plan goes awry when Peter’s mother (Kathy Najimy) sets him up on a blind date with her impossibly handsome trainer, James (Luke Macfarlane).

Cue the farcical complications, the obligatory mistletoe moments, and the inevitable realization that the fake relationship might be the realest thing in the room.

A cozy living room bathed in warm holiday lights, with Peter and Nick sitting awkwardly on a couch while Peter’s family watches them with knowing smiles.

What’s interesting about Single All the Way isn’t the plot—it’s the way it treats its characters’ performances. Peter and Nick aren’t just lying to Peter’s family; they’re lying to themselves, too. Peter, in particular, is so used to playing the role of the carefree single guy that he can’t even admit to himself that he’s lonely.

Urie, who’s built a career on playing characters who are just a little too extra (see: Ugly Betty), brings a brittle charm to Peter. There’s a moment early in the film where Peter’s sister (Jennifer Robertson) asks him why he’s never brought anyone home, and Urie’s response—a too-quick laugh, a dismissive wave—feels less like a line reading and more like a reflex. It’s the kind of small, human detail that elevates the film beyond the usual rom-com pablum.

But here’s the thing: Single All the Way doesn’t always trust its own instincts. For every sharp, understated moment, there’s a scene that leans too hard into the broad comedy, as if the film is worried it won’t be taken seriously as a holiday rom-com unless it’s also a farce. The blind date subplot, for example, is played for laughs—James is so perfect that he might as well be a mannequin—but it undercuts the film’s more interesting tension: the slow-burning chemistry between Peter and Nick.

Chambers, in his first major film role, has a quiet, grounded presence that contrasts nicely with Urie’s manic energy. When the two of them are on screen together, the film feels like it’s about something real. When it’s not, it feels like it’s checking boxes.

Peter and Nick standing outside in the snow, their breath visible in the cold air, as they share an awkward but charged moment.

That tension—between sincerity and schtick—is what makes Single All the Way feel like a microcosm of the holiday rom-com genre as a whole. These films are often dismissed as fluff, but they’re also a rare space where queer stories can exist without the weight of tragedy or coming-out narratives. Single All the Way isn’t groundbreaking in its representation—Peter’s sexuality is treated as a given, not a plot point—but it’s refreshing in its lack of angst.

The film doesn’t treat being gay as a problem to be solved or a secret to be revealed; it’s just part of the fabric of Peter’s life. That might not sound like much, but in a genre that’s still catching up to the idea that queer people deserve happy endings, it’s something.

The supporting cast, led by Jennifer Coolidge and Kathy Najimy, is where the film’s heart really lies. Coolidge, in particular, steals every scene she’s in as Peter’s aunt Sandy, a woman who’s equal parts warm and unhinged. There’s a scene where she drunkenly confesses her own regrets about love, and Coolidge plays it with a vulnerability that’s surprising and deeply moving.

It’s the kind of moment that reminds you why she’s one of the best character actors working today. Najimy, meanwhile, brings a maternal warmth to Peter’s mother, Carol, that makes her meddling feel less like a plot device and more like a genuine (if misguided) attempt to connect with her son.

A festive holiday party scene, with Peter’s family gathered around a table, laughing and raising glasses in a toast.

If there’s a flaw in Single All the Way, it’s that it doesn’t fully commit to either its rom-com or farcical impulses. The film wants to be a heartfelt story about self-discovery, but it also wants to be a wacky holiday comedy. The result is a tonal whiplash that never quite resolves.

There’s a scene near the end where Peter and Nick finally admit their feelings for each other, and it’s played with a sweetness that feels earned. But just a few minutes later, the film veers back into slapstick territory, as if it’s afraid to let the moment breathe. It’s a shame, because the quieter scenes are where Single All the Way shines.

That said, maybe the film’s indecision is part of its charm. The holidays, after all, are a time of contradictions—joy and loneliness, connection and isolation, the pressure to perform happiness even when you’re not feeling it. Single All the Way captures that push and pull, even if it doesn’t always stick the landing. It’s not a perfect film, but it’s a sincere one, and in a genre that often prioritizes polish over authenticity, that’s something.

I left Single All the Way thinking about the lies we tell ourselves, especially during the holidays. The ones about being fine when we’re not, about having it all together when we’re barely holding on. The film doesn’t judge its characters for those lies; it just asks them (and us) to be a little more honest.

And maybe that’s the best holiday gift of all.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.5/10
"A lighthearted, festive holiday rom-com with charming leads, held back by predictable plotting and uneven humor."

Viewers enjoy the warm, inclusive holiday vibe and the leads' genuine chemistry. Clichéd rom-com tropes and thin supporting characters leave many wanting more originality.

What viewers praise
  • Charming lead performances Michael Urie and Philemon Chambers give heartfelt performances.
  • Festive holiday atmosphere A cozy, inclusive Christmas setting.
  • Heartwarming romance A sweet love story that brings an LGBTQ+ perspective to the holiday rom-com.
  • Jennifer Coolidge’s comedic role Coolidge's over-the-top, hilarious turn is a standout.
Common complaints
  • Predictable plot Well-worn rom-com formulas.
  • Weak supporting characters Apart from Jennifer Coolidge, side characters are forgettable.
  • Uneven humor Inconsistent jokes.
  • Lack of depth Light at the expense of emotional or narrative depth.
Recommended for
Holiday rom-com fans LGBTQ+ romance lovers Jennifer Coolidge enthusiasts Lighthearted movie nights Festive feel-good seekers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s First Gay Holiday Rom-Com: The Making of Single All the Way

Netflix’s Single All the Way (2021) broke ground as the streamer’s first gay holiday romantic comedy, but behind the festive cheer, the film’s cast and crew were busy crafting a story that felt both fresh and familiar. Directed by Michael Mayer, the movie stars Michael Urie and Philemon Chambers as best friends who fake a relationship to avoid awkward holiday questions—only to find themselves navigating real feelings. With a supporting cast including Jennifer Coolidge and Kathy Najimy, the film promised warmth, humor, and a little holiday magic. But how did this milestone project come together?


A Milestone for LGBTQ+ Holiday Films

Single All the Way arrived at a time when queer holiday rom-coms were still rare, especially on major platforms. Netflix marketed it as a first, and the cast embraced the significance. In interviews, Urie and Chambers highlighted the importance of representation in a genre often dominated by heteronormative storylines.

  • Philemon Chambers called the film “a big deal” in a conversation about its impact, noting that LGBTQ+ audiences deserved holiday movies that reflected their experiences. - Michael Urie echoed the sentiment, emphasizing how the film’s lighthearted tone could help normalize queer relationships during a season often centered on traditional family dynamics.

The trailer, released ahead of the film’s debut, teased a classic rom-com setup with a queer twist, complete with awkward family gatherings, festive sweaters, and a slow-burn romance. Early reactions suggested audiences were hungry for this kind of story—one that didn’t treat LGBTQ+ identities as a punchline or a tragedy but as the foundation for a feel-good holiday flick.


Behind the Scenes: Chemistry and Challenges

The film’s success hinged on the chemistry between its leads, and by all accounts, Urie and Chambers delivered. The two actors, who had never worked together before, quickly developed a rapport that translated onscreen.

  • Rehearsal Bonding: In multiple interviews, Urie and Chambers described how they bonded over shared experiences as gay actors navigating Hollywood. Chambers, a relative newcomer at the time, credited Urie with making him feel at ease on set. - Improv and Playfulness: While the script provided the backbone, the actors admitted to adding their own touches. Urie, known for his comedic timing, reportedly improvised some of his funnier lines, while Chambers brought a grounded sincerity to his role.

The supporting cast added their own sparkle. Jennifer Coolidge, a rom-com veteran, played Urie’s eccentric aunt, while Kathy Najimy brought her signature wit to the role of Chambers’ mother. The ensemble’s dynamic was a key selling point, with early buzz suggesting their interactions would steal scenes.

That said, the film’s production wasn’t without its challenges. As Netflix’s first foray into the gay holiday rom-com space, there was pressure to get it right. Rumors (unconfirmed) swirled about last-minute script tweaks to balance humor and heart, but neither Mayer nor the cast addressed these directly in available interviews.


Director Michael Mayer: From Techno to Tinsel

Michael Mayer’s involvement in Single All the Way raised eyebrows among fans familiar with his primary career—as a DJ and electronic music producer. Mayer, a co-founder of the influential label Kompakt, is better known for shaping Cologne’s minimal techno scene than for directing rom-coms.

  • A Surprising Pivot: Mayer’s filmography before Single All the Way was sparse, with no prior feature films listed in the available evidence. His most notable credit in the music world was the Fabric 13 DJ mix, a 2003 release that earned a 7.1/10 rating on SensCritique. How he landed the director’s chair for a Netflix holiday rom-com remains unclear, as no interviews or sources in the evidence explain the connection. - A One-Off or a New Path?: As of the film’s release, there was no indication Mayer planned to abandon music for filmmaking. Whether Single All the Way was a passion project or a one-time experiment is still unconfirmed.

Reception and Legacy: Did It Deliver?

Single All the Way arrived with high expectations, but its reception was mixed. Critics praised its heart and representation, while some found the plot predictable.

  • Audience Reactions: Early reviews highlighted the film’s charm and the cast’s performances, particularly Urie and Chambers’ chemistry. Jennifer Coolidge’s scene-stealing antics also earned mentions. - Critic Divide: While some called it a refreshing addition to the holiday rom-com canon, others felt it played it too safe, relying on familiar tropes rather than subverting them.

Despite the divided opinions, the film’s place in Netflix history is secure. It opened the door for more LGBTQ+ holiday stories on the platform, proving there was an audience eager for inclusive festive fare. Whether it becomes a cult classic or a footnote in rom-com history remains to be seen—but for many viewers, its mere existence was a win.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.