
Mario López
Tony Ortega

Sparks fly when a greeting card executive arrives in Santa Fe to acquire a tight-knit family company that creates ornaments inspired by Mexican Christmas traditions.
I’ll admit it: I went into Holiday in Santa Fe expecting the cinematic equivalent of a store-bought fruitcake—inoffensive, slightly stale, but reliable enough to leave out for company. What I got instead was something stranger: a film that looks like a holiday postcard, sounds like a Hallmark commercial, and feels like it was written by a committee that had heard of Mexican Christmas traditions but never actually experienced one.
It’s not bad, exactly. It’s just… there. Like a decoration you hung up in November and forgot to take down until March.
The premise is as familiar as eggnog: Tony (Mario López), a slick greeting-card executive from New York, rolls into Santa Fe to acquire a family-owned ornament business run by Belinda (Emeraude Toubia) and her tight-knit clan. Cue the culture clash, the forced proximity, the snowfall montage, and—inevitably—the moment when Tony realizes money can’t buy love (or hand-painted alebrijes).
It’s the kind of story that could work if the film committed to either sincerity or satire. Instead, it waffles somewhere in the middle, like a waffle iron that’s been left on too long.

The first act is all warm hues and promise. The film was shot on location in Santa Fe, and the city’s golden light, adobe architecture, and winding streets give the movie a visual authenticity that most holiday romances lack. When Belinda’s family gathers around a table laden with posole and buñuelos, the scene has the easy rhythm of real life—until the script undercuts it with dialogue that sounds like it was translated from English to Spanish and back again by Google.
(“This business is our corazón!” “Yes, and our corazón must evolve!”) The film wants to celebrate tradition, but it treats its own cultural details like garnish, sprinkled on top for flavor rather than baked into the dough.
That disconnect is most glaring in the central romance. López and Toubia are both charming performers, but their chemistry is about as electric as a string of LED lights with a loose bulb. There’s no real friction, no heat—just two attractive people reciting lines while the camera lingers on their faces like it’s waiting for something to happen.
(Maybe it’s the script’s fault. Maybe it’s the direction. Maybe it’s the fact that Tony’s corporate villainy is so half-hearted he might as well be selling artisanal kale chips.) Whatever the reason, the love story never feels like more than a series of boxes being ticked: meet-cute, misunderstanding, grand gesture.
By the time Tony delivers his big speech about the importance of family, I half-expected the film to cut to a laugh track.

The film’s heart, such as it is, lies with Belinda’s family. Aimee Garcia, as her sharp-witted sister, steals every scene she’s in, and Efrain Figueroa brings quiet warmth as the family patriarch. There’s a lovely moment where the whole clan gathers to decorate the store for Christmas, passing down ornaments and stories like heirlooms.
It’s the kind of scene that should feel lived-in, but the film undercuts it with a subplot about a rival business that feels lifted from a Saved by the Bell episode. (The villain’s name is Dirk. I wish I were making that up.) The family’s grief over a lost loved one is handled with similar clumsiness—mentioned just enough to feel like a plot device, then dropped like a hot tamale.
What’s frustrating is that Holiday in Santa Fe has all the ingredients for something special. A Latino-led cast, a story centered on cultural traditions, a setting that feels specific and alive—these are things we don’t see nearly enough of in holiday movies. But the film treats its own assets like afterthoughts.
The Christmas ornaments the family makes are supposed to be inspired by Mexican folklore, but the designs we see are generic enough to be sold at Target. The film name-drops Las Posadas and luminarias, but the traditions themselves are reduced to set dressing. It’s like watching a movie about Thanksgiving that only shows turkey and never mentions gratitude.

The audience reception, at least, has been refreshingly honest. Some viewers praise the film for its representation and cozy vibes, while others—especially those familiar with Santa Fe—call out its cultural missteps. One Reddit user from New Mexico summed it up perfectly: “It’s like they Googled ‘Mexican Christmas’ and then wrote a script based on the first three images that popped up.” That’s not entirely fair, but it’s not entirely wrong, either.
In the end, Holiday in Santa Fe is a movie that wants to be a warm hug but ends up feeling like a handshake from someone who’s already looking over your shoulder. It’s not offensive, just… forgettable. The kind of film you put on while wrapping presents, half-paying attention, and then can’t remember the plot of by New Year’s.
That’s not nothing, I suppose. But in a season that’s supposed to be about joy and connection, it’s hard not to wish for something with a little more spark.
"A well-intentioned holiday romance with authentic Santa Fe flavor and Latino representation that is held back by flat chemistry and a formulaic, culturally shaky script."
The real Santa Fe locations, warm family dynamic, and more diverse cast make this feel fresher than many cookie-cutter holiday movies, and it can be pleasant, cozy, and visually appealing. A lack of romantic spark between the leads, corny plotting, and shallow or inaccurate portrayals of Santa Fe culture and traditions leave the film feeling undercooked despite good intentions.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
When Mario Lopez brought his Christmas crown to Santa Fe, fans braced for Lifetime-level romance and Hollywood-level mess. Instead, Holiday in Santa Fe turned out to be that rare thing in showbiz: a warm, mostly drama-free shoot. latestnetflix.com's take is that but don’t put your cocoa down yet—between family casting, fan backlash, and a few spicy tidbits, there is some tea to sip.
Where the claws do come out is in the audience reaction:
No organized “boycott Lifetime” campaigns, but plenty of social-media side‑eye and meme-able one-liners.
So, if you were hoping for explosive on‑set fights, secret romances, or leaked scripts…this is not that movie. The real-world “gossip” around Holiday in Santa Fe is mostly:
In other words: the messiest thing about Holiday in Santa Fe isn’t what happened on set—it’s what people said about it once the credits rolled.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.