Overview
Seth and Jeremy enjoyed relative success from 'Eternal', a hit television vampire drama. Five years after their show has ended, they lean on each other as they struggle to reclaim their previous level of success and relevance, awkwardly navigating the perils of life and love amidst a humorously painful coming of age.
Seasons
- Status
- Returning Series
- Seasons
- 2 seasons
- Episodes
- 16 episodes
- First aired
- Jan 13, 2021
Reviews
5 min readThe Last Laugh of the Undead
I keep thinking about the title. Everyone Is Doing Great. It’s the kind of lie we tell ourselves when the alternative is too painful to admit—when the gap between how things look and how they feel is so wide it might as well be a chasm. That gap is where Seth and Jeremy live, five years after their vampire drama Eternal went off the air.
The show was a hit, or at least hit enough to make them minor celebrities in the way only niche genre television can. Now, they’re just two guys in their thirties, clinging to each other like shipwreck survivors, pretending they’re not both drowning.
What does it say about us that we’ve made an entire subgenre out of watching people fail upward? Everyone Is Doing Great isn’t the first comedy to mine the post-fame malaise of former child stars or one-hit wonders, but it’s one of the few that treats its characters’ delusions with something like tenderness. There’s no schadenfreude here, no easy punchlines at the expense of these two men who, let’s be honest, should probably know better by now.
Instead, there’s a quiet ache, the kind that lingers after the laugh track fades. Maybe that’s why the show’s reception has been so muted—it’s not quite the raucous comedy its premise suggests, nor is it the biting satire some might expect from a series about the absurdity of Hollywood. It’s something messier, something closer to the truth.
The pilot opens with a scene that sets the tone perfectly. Seth and Jeremy are at a comic convention, signing autographs for a dwindling crowd of fans. The camera lingers on their faces as they paste on identical smiles, their hands moving mechanically to scribble their names on glossy photos of their former selves—younger, sharper, bathed in the blue light of Eternal’s gothic aesthetic.
The convention hall is a graveyard of nostalgia, and they’re the last ones to leave. When the doors finally close, they turn to each other, their smiles dropping like masks. “We should get dinner,” one of them says, and the other nods, because what else is there to do? The scene isn’t played for laughs, exactly, but it’s not played for tragedy either.
Audience Opinions
"A lighthearted comedy that struggles to stand out due to its familiar themes and uneven execution."
The series is praised for its attempt at a breezy, comedic tone, but viewers find it falls short of leaving a lasting impression. Many note its predictable humor and lack of depth, making it a forgettable watch despite its short runtime. latestnetflix.com's take is that Feedback is sparse, suggesting it didn’t gain widespread attention.
- Lighthearted tone Offers a breezy, easy-to-watch comedic vibe that some find enjoyable for casual viewing.
- Short runtime Episodes are brief, making it a low-commitment option for those seeking quick entertainment.
- Predictable humor Jokes and scenarios feel recycled, lacking originality or freshness.
- Lacks depth Characters and plotlines are thin, leaving little emotional or intellectual engagement.
- Limited appeal Struggles to resonate beyond a niche audience, with many finding it unmemorable.
Buzz & Rumors
Public reports"Everyone Is Doing Great": The One Tree Hill Reunion Netflix Almost Missed
The 2021 comedy-drama Everyone Is Doing Great might have slipped under the radar for most viewers, but for fans of One Tree Hill, it was a long-awaited reunion. The series, which aired on Hulu (not Netflix, despite some confusion in early buzz), brought together former One Tree Hill co-stars James Lafferty and Stephen Colletti as estranged brothers navigating adulthood’s messiness. latestnetflix.com's take is that Behind the scenes, the project was a passion play—one that nearly didn’t happen.
A Reunion Years in the Making
Lafferty and Colletti’s on-screen chemistry was the show’s biggest selling point, but their real-life friendship was the glue that held it together. The duo, who played Nathan and Chase on One Tree Hill, had reportedly been pitching the concept for years before landing a home on Hulu. In a behind-the-scenes featurette, Lafferty hinted at the personal stakes: “We’ve been talking about this for a decade. It was either now or never” . The series’ premise—two brothers who’ve drifted apart after one’s life implodes—mirrored the actors’ own journey from teen heartthrobs to grown men rebuilding their careers.
The road to production wasn’t smooth. Early reports suggested the project was shopped around to multiple networks, including Netflix, where composer Michael Grubbs (another One Tree Hill alum) initially discussed scoring the series . By the time it landed on Hulu, the tone had shifted from a straight-up comedy to a dramedy, blending the brothers’ banter with darker themes of failure and redemption.
From Small Screen to Smaller Screen
Everyone Is Doing Great was a modest affair, with a single season (length unconfirmed in available evidence) and a runtime of roughly 35 minutes per episode 
. Critics were lukewarm, awarding it a 5.5/10 on SensCritique based on 11 votes—a score that reflected its niche appeal rather than outright failure . The show’s charm lay in its low-stakes vibe, a deliberate contrast to the high-drama world of One Tree Hill. As one trailer put it, the series was about “two guys who’ve spent their whole lives pretending they’ve got it all figured out” .
Behind the camera, the creative team leaned into the actors’ improvisational skills. A Hulu behind-the-scenes clip showed Lafferty and Colletti riffing on set, with the director encouraging their natural rapport . The approach paid off in moments of authenticity, though it also highlighted the show’s limitations—without the budget or scope of a network drama, Everyone Is Doing Great thrived on its leads’ charisma or not at all.
The Season 2 That Almost Was
Hulu released a trailer for a second season in 2022, teasing new conflicts for the brothers . But the renewal was never officially confirmed, and the show quietly faded from headlines. Rumors swirled about creative differences or low viewership, though no concrete details emerged. Lafferty’s appearance on Studio 10 to promote the series suggested Paramount+ (not Hulu) might have been involved in later discussions, but the evidence is murky . As of now, the show’s status remains in limbo—neither canceled nor renewed, just… paused.
Why It Mattered
For One Tree Hill fans, Everyone Is Doing Great was a bittersweet victory. It wasn’t the triumphant return they’d hoped for, but it was a rare chance to see Lafferty and Colletti together again, older and wiser. The series’ greatest strength was its honesty—about sibling bonds, about the pressure to perform happiness, and about the quiet failures that define adulthood. Its greatest weakness? Trying to be too many things at once: a comedy, a drama, a reunion special.
In the end, Everyone Is Doing Great was exactly what its title suggested—a show about people pretending. The difference was, this time, the audience could see the cracks.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.