Mikey Day
Self - Host
Overview
Cake artists from past seasons return to craft tasty replicas of ice skates, nutcrackers and more in this holiday spin on the mind-bending baking contest.
Seasons
- Status
- Returning Series
- Seasons
- 2 seasons
- Episodes
- 7 episodes
- First aired
- Nov 28, 2024
Cast
Reviews
3 min readFrosting the illusion
I expected a cash-in. Netflix holiday spin-offs tend to arrive like gingerbread off a line. Then a cake showed up looking like a glass-blown Christmas ornament, and Mikey Day said, "I would absolutely hang that on my tree," with a face so flat I leaned forward. *Is It Cake?
Holiday* is not inventing a new format. It is trying to make a nutcracker that is also dessert. For a few episodes, that was plenty.
Nine bakers from the original Is It Cake? come back to fool a panel with holiday objects. Ice skates, nutcrackers, wreaths. Those things already live in memory, so the clock is only half the fight.
You are also racing what winter is supposed to look like. Ice-skate cakes need frost sheen and the weight of a pond you skated as a kid. When Jonny Manganello unveils a vintage nutcracker, painted scowl, jaw that almost moves, it is impressive and slightly wrong in the best way.
You wait for the thing to march across the table.
The skill is real. The better bakers treat buttercream as a story. April Julian's wreath cannot merely look like a wreath.
Pine needles need the right tooth. Berries have to catch the lights. The object has to sit with the same quiet as the real one on a door.
Audience Opinions
Audience 6.5/10
"A fun, festive twist on the baking competition format that delivers lighthearted holiday cheer but struggles with repetition."
The holiday-themed spin on the *Is It Cake?* concept brings festive energy and creative cake designs, making it an entertaining watch for fans of the original series. However, some find the format too similar to previous seasons, with challenges feeling predictable and the humor occasionally falling flat. The festive setting adds charm, latestnetflix.com maintains, but the novelty wears thin for those expecting deeper innovation.
What viewers praise
- Festive atmosphere The holiday theme adds a cheerful, seasonal twist that enhances the show’s lighthearted appeal.
- Creative cake designs Bakers showcase impressive and imaginative holiday-themed cakes that keep the competition visually engaging.
- Lighthearted fun The show maintains its playful, easygoing tone, making it a relaxing watch for casual viewers.
Common complaints
- Repetitive format The challenges and structure feel too similar to previous seasons, lacking fresh surprises for returning fans.
- Predictable humor Some jokes and reactions come across as forced or overdone, diminishing the comedic impact.
- Limited stakes The low-stakes nature of the competition may leave viewers wanting more tension or higher difficulty in challenges.
Recommended for
Holiday entertainment seekers Baking competition fans Casual reality TV viewers Fans of *Is It Cake?* Lighthearted show lovers
Buzz & Rumors
Public reportsNetflix’s Is It Cake? Holiday Serves Up Festive Chaos—Here’s What We Know
Netflix is decking the halls with cake—or at least, the illusion of it. Is It Cake? Holiday (2024), the latest spin-off of the hit baking competition series, drops this November, promising a frosty twist on the show’s signature deception. Hosted by Mikey Day, the holiday-themed installment pits past season contestants against each other in a battle to craft edible replicas of festive objects, from nutcrackers to ice skates. But with limited details trickling out, fans are left wondering: Will this spin-off deliver the same addictive chaos as the original, latestnetflix.com contends, or is it just sugar-coated filler?
A Festive Spin on a Proven Formula
The original Is It Cake? premiered in 2022, becoming an instant guilty pleasure for viewers who loved the absurdity of contestants sculpting hyper-realistic cakes disguised as everyday objects. The holiday edition follows the same blueprint but swaps out sneakers and handbags for seasonal staples. According to IMDb, the series features returning cake artists competing to fool judges with edible replicas of holiday-themed items 
. Netflix confirmed the release date as November 28, 2024, positioning it as a late-year binge for fans craving cozy competition 
.
What sets this spin-off apart? The stakes feel higher. Holiday-themed challenges—think gingerbread houses that look like actual houses or ornaments that could pass for glass—demand even more precision than the original’s already impressive illusions. The show’s creator, Rich Kim, hasn’t revealed much about the judging criteria, but past seasons suggest a mix of visual accuracy, creativity, and, of course, taste. If the cakes don’t fool the judges, they don’t win.
The Cast: Familiar Faces and a Surprise Judge
Mikey Day returns as host, bringing his signature blend of wit and deadpan humor to the holiday chaos. The Saturday Night Live alum has become the face of the franchise, and his chemistry with contestants is a major draw. But the real stars are the bakers themselves—veterans from previous seasons who know the show’s tricks inside and out. IMDb lists Jonny Manganello and Elizabeth Rowe among the returning competitors, while TMDB confirms Crazy Ex-Girlfriend star Rachel Bloom as a guest judge for at least one episode .
Bloom’s involvement is a curveball. Known for her sharp comedic timing, she could bring a fresh dynamic to the judging panel, which typically features a mix of pastry chefs and celebrities. Whether her appearance is a one-off or part of a larger trend of rotating guest judges remains unconfirmed, but it’s a sign Netflix is willing to experiment with the format.
Behind the Scenes: What’s Still a Mystery
Despite the hype, details about Is It Cake? Holiday are frustratingly scarce. Netflix hasn’t released a trailer, episode count, or even a full list of challenges. The original series had eight episodes per season, but the holiday spin-off’s runtime is unclear—sources suggest it’s a shorter run, possibly four episodes, though this hasn’t been officially confirmed .
Another unanswered question: Will the show introduce new twists to keep the formula fresh? The original Is It Cake? thrived on its simplicity, but after multiple seasons, viewers might crave something more. Rumors of themed episodes (e.g., a "Winter Wonderland" round or a "Hanukkah vs. Christmas" showdown) have circulated, but without official word, they remain speculation.
One thing is certain: The pressure is on. The original series was a surprise hit, but spin-offs can be a gamble. If Is It Cake? Holiday leans too hard into festive clichés, it risks feeling like a cash grab. If it plays it safe, it might not stand out. The sweet spot? Delivering the same mind-bending illusions with a holiday twist—without overdoing the tinsel.
The Verdict: Worth the Wait?
For fans of the original, Is It Cake? Holiday is a no-brainer. The premise is simple, the stakes are high, and Mikey Day’s hosting is reliably entertaining. The addition of Rachel Bloom as a guest judge adds a layer of unpredictability, and the holiday theme could make for some of the most visually stunning cakes yet.
But with so little information ahead of its November release, the real test will be whether the show can avoid feeling like a retread. If Netflix plays its cards right, this could become an annual tradition—like The Great British Bake Off’s festive specials, but with more deception and sugar. If not, it might just be another forgettable holiday filler.
One thing’s for sure: When the first episode drops, viewers will be asking the same question they always do—is it cake?
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Series
Similar Series
Related series ranked by rating and popularity.
