Skip to main content
Movie poster for Is That Black Enough for You?!? (2022)

Is That Black Enough for You?!?

“Representation is revolution”

2022
2h 15m
R · English
Director: Elvis Mitchell
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A look at the Black revolution in 1970s cinema, from genre films to social realism, from the making of new superstars to the craft of rising auteurs.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Scrapbook That Fights Back

I’ve watched Is That Black Enough for You?!? three times now, and each time I’m struck by how it feels less like a documentary and more like a conversation—one that’s been happening in my head for years. Elvis Mitchell, the film’s director and narrator, doesn’t just present the history of Black cinema; he argues with it, celebrates it, and occasionally yells at it, all while flipping through a scrapbook of clips, interviews, and memories that refuse to stay neatly in the past.

The title itself, with its all-caps urgency and triple punctuation, isn’t just a question. It’s a challenge. And by the end, you realize it’s also an invitation: Are you paying attention?

Mitchell, a critic and historian with the kind of encyclopedic knowledge that makes you jealous, structures the film like a mixtape—one where the tracks aren’t just songs but entire movements. The 1970s are the focal point, and for good reason. This was the decade when Black cinema exploded into something raw, unapologetic, and often contradictory.

It was the era of Blaxploitation, yes, but also of films like Charles Burnett’s Killer of Sheep (1978), a quiet, neorealist masterpiece that barely saw the light of day. Mitchell doesn’t just chronicle these films; he resurrects them, pulling them from the margins of film history and placing them front and center, where they belong.

A collage of Black cinema icons, their faces and film stills layered like a visual manifesto

The film’s collage-like approach—part archival footage, part new interviews, part Mitchell’s own narration—mirrors the chaos and creativity of the era it documents. There’s no linear timeline here, no neat progression from point A to point B. Instead, Mitchell jumps between genres, themes, and even tones, much like the films he’s discussing.

One moment, you’re watching a clip from Shaft (1971), Isaac Hayes’ iconic theme blaring as Richard Roundtree strides down a New York street like he owns it. The next, you’re in the quiet, sun-drenched world of Killer of Sheep, where a man’s exhaustion is palpable in every frame. The contrast isn’t just striking; it’s deliberate.

Mitchell wants you to see the breadth of Black storytelling, the way it could be both loud and quiet, commercial and avant-garde, angry and tender—sometimes all at once.

What makes Is That Black Enough for You?!? so compelling is Mitchell’s refusal to simplify. Blaxploitation, for example, is often reduced to its stereotypes: the pimps, the drug dealers, the hyper-masculine heroes. But Mitchell complicates that narrative.

He interviews actors like Antonio Fargas and Sheila Frazier, who played some of those very roles, and lets them speak about the agency they found in those characters. Fargas, in particular, is a revelation. He talks about playing Huggy Bear in Starsky & Hutch with a mix of pride and self-awareness, acknowledging the limitations of the role while also embracing what it meant to see a Black character who was cool, confident, and unapologetically himself.

It’s a reminder that representation isn’t just about being seen; it’s about being seen on your own terms.

A still from a 1970s Blaxploitation film, the camera angled low to emphasize the power of the Black protagonist

Mitchell’s own voice is a crucial part of the film’s DNA. He’s not just a disembodied narrator; he’s a participant in the conversation, offering his own memories and reflections alongside the archival material. At one point, he talks about seeing Super Fly (1972) as a teenager and the way it made him feel both exhilarated and uneasy.

That tension—between celebration and critique—runs through the entire film. Mitchell isn’t here to give you a sanitized version of Black cinema. He’s here to show you the messiness, the contradictions, the moments when art and commerce collided, and the artists who found a way to make something extraordinary out of it.

The interviews are where the film truly comes alive. Whoopi Goldberg, ever the raconteur, talks about the first time she saw a Black woman on screen who wasn’t a maid or a mammy. Harry Belafonte, with the gravitas of someone who’s seen it all, reflects on the political power of cinema.

And then there’s Laurence Fishburne, who delivers a monologue about the importance of representation that feels like it could be its own TED Talk. These aren’t just talking heads; they’re storytellers, each adding their own layer to the narrative. RogerEbert.com’s praise for the film’s "deep understanding of film history" and "passion of a true lover of the form" rings true here.

Mitchell doesn’t just know these films; he feels them, and that passion is infectious.

![A close-up of a Black actor in a 1970s film, their expression a mix of defiance and vulnerability](https://cdn.latestnetflix.com/t/p/w1280/86x5Hpwtj0CIndieWire’s description of the documentary as one that "explores decades of Black representation onscreen, from little-known films to Blaxploitation" captures the film’s scope, but it doesn’t quite convey the emotional weight of the journey. This isn’t just a history lesson; it’s a reckoning. Mitchell doesn’t shy away from the industry’s failures—the way Black films were (and often still are) marginalized, the way Black artists were (and often still are) pigeonholed. But he also celebrates the moments when they broke through, when they demanded to be seen, when they changed the game.

There’s a moment late in the film where Mitchell plays a clip from The Spook Who Sat by the Door (1973), a film about a Black CIA agent who uses his training to organize a guerrilla movement. The film was so controversial that it was pulled from theaters shortly after its release, and for years, it existed only as a rumor, a ghost story passed down among cinephiles. Watching it now, in the context of Mitchell’s film, it feels like a missing piece of history finally clicking into place.

That’s the power of Is That Black Enough for You?!?—it doesn’t just tell you about these films; it makes you feel their absence, their erasure, and ultimately, their triumph.

The film’s title, of course, is a question that lingers. Is that Black enough for you?!? It’s a challenge to the audience, to the industry, to history itself. Are we paying attention? Are we giving these films the space they deserve?

Are we willing to see Black cinema not as a monolith but as a living, breathing, changing art form? Mitchell’s answer, and the film’s, is a resounding yes. But the question isn’t just for him to answer.

It’s for all of us.

Audience Opinions

Broad evidence
Audience 7.1/10
"A rich, nostalgic deep-dive into Black cinema that works best if you already know its cultural touchstones."

The documentary celebrates the golden era of Black cinema with strong archival footage and insightful commentary from iconic figures. It is niche, though, and assumes prior knowledge of the films and figures discussed, which makes it less accessible to casual viewers.

What viewers praise
  • Celebration of Black cinema A heartfelt tribute to the impact and legacy of Black filmmakers and actors.
  • Archival footage Rare, nostalgic clips from classic films carry real emotional and historical value.
  • Insightful commentary Contributions from legendary figures like Harry Belafonte, Laurence Fishburne, and Whoopi Goldberg add depth and authenticity.
  • Engaging narrative style Elvis Mitchell's direction and personal perspective make it compelling and immersive.
Common complaints
  • Niche appeal It assumes too much prior knowledge, making it less accessible if you don't know the films discussed.
  • Pacing issues The 135-minute runtime is excessive, with some segments drawn out or repetitive.
  • Limited scope The focus on a specific era leaves out broader coverage of modern contributions.
Recommended for
Black cinema enthusiasts Fans of classic film history Documentary lovers Cultural studies audiences

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Elvis Mitchell’s Love Letter to Black Cinema: The Making of Is That Black Enough for You?!?

Elvis Mitchell’s 2022 documentary Is That Black Enough for You?!? isn’t just a film—it’s a manifesto. The acclaimed critic and historian turns the camera on himself to dissect the evolution of Black cinema, blending archival footage, sharp commentary, and interviews with legends like Harry Belafonte, Laurence Fishburne, and Whoopi Goldberg. latestnetflix.com's take is that but behind the scenes, the project was as much a personal reckoning as it was a cultural deep dive.

A Critic’s Passion Project

Mitchell, best known for his work as a film critic and radio host, didn’t just direct Is That Black Enough for You?!?—he narrated it, framed it, and poured decades of expertise into its 135-minute runtime. The documentary traces Black cinema from the 1970s onward, with a particular focus on the Blaxploitation era, a movement that redefined Hollywood’s relationship with race and representation. Mitchell’s approach isn’t academic; it’s intimate, blending his own memories with the voices of those who shaped the industry.

The film’s title itself—a phrase Mitchell borrowed from a 1970s ad—reflects its defiant tone. It’s a challenge to audiences, a demand for recognition of Black artistry in an industry that has often sidelined it. As Mitchell put it in interviews, the documentary was his way of "correcting the record".

Assembling the Dream Team

The cast reads like a who’s who of Black Hollywood. Harry Belafonte, a civil rights icon and actor, lends gravitas to the project, while Laurence Fishburne and Samuel L. Jackson reflect on their careers in an era when Black actors were often confined to narrow roles. Whoopi Goldberg, another key voice, brings her signature wit and perspective, bridging the gap between classic cinema and modern storytelling.

But the documentary isn’t just about stars. Filmmakers like Charles Burnett (Killer of Sheep) and producer Suzanne de Passe (Lady Sings the Blues) provide insider insights into the struggles and triumphs of Black creatives in a predominantly white industry. Their contributions underscore the film’s central argument: Black cinema has always been more than just a genre—it’s a movement.

The Netflix Factor

Is That Black Enough for You?!? found a home on Netflix, a platform that has increasingly championed diverse storytelling. The streaming giant gave Mitchell the creative freedom to craft a documentary that’s as bold as its title, complete with a soundtrack that pulses with soul and funk. The trailer, released in October 2022, teases the film’s energy, blending vintage clips with Mitchell’s razor-sharp narration.

In conversations with fellow filmmakers like Steven Soderbergh, Mitchell has described the documentary as a "necessary intervention" in the way Black cinema is remembered. It’s not just a retrospective; it’s a call to action for future generations of filmmakers.

Legacy and Impact

Since its release, Is That Black Enough for You?!? has been praised for its depth and urgency. Critics have noted how Mitchell’s personal connection to the material elevates it beyond a standard documentary. For many, the film serves as both an education and a celebration—a reminder of the resilience and creativity of Black artists in an industry that has often failed them.

Yet, as Mitchell himself has acknowledged, the documentary is just one chapter in an ongoing conversation. The questions it raises—about representation, authenticity, and the power of cinema—are far from settled. But with Is That Black Enough for You?!?, Mitchell has ensured that the voices of the past won’t be forgotten.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.