Jimmy Shergill
Jaswinder Singh
Overview
After an unsolved diamond heist, a hard-nosed cop’s pursuit of his key suspect turns into obsession, until they finally face each other — and the truth.
Cast
12 people
Reviews
5 min readNeeraj Pandey’s Sikandar Ka Muqaddar is one of those stories. It’s a film that wants to be about the hunt, the chase, the relentless pursuit of truth, but somewhere along the way, it becomes something messier: a study of how obsession distorts the hunter as much as the hunted. The opening sequence is a masterclass in tension.
A diamond heist unfolds in near-silence, the camera lingering on gloved hands, the flicker of security monitors, the hushed panic of a museum guard realizing too late that the red solitaires on display are gone. There’s no gunfire, no explosions—just the cold precision of a theft executed with surgical skill. It’s the kind of scene that makes you lean forward, even if you’ve seen this trick before.
(And let’s be honest, we’ve all seen this trick before.) But Pandey isn’t interested in reinventing the heist genre. He’s interested in what happens after the money—or in this case, the diamonds—disappears.
The film’s structure is a game of cat and mouse, toggling between two timelines: the immediate aftermath of the heist in 2009 and a decade later, when Jaswinder Singh (Jimmy Shergill), a disgraced but dogged investigator, finally corners his prime suspect, Sikandar (Avinash Tiwary). The problem is that neither man is entirely who he seems. Jaswinder’s obsession with the case has cost him his career, his reputation, and nearly his sanity.
Sikandar, meanwhile, is either a brilliant criminal mastermind or an unlucky schmuck who got caught in the wrong place at the wrong time. The film teases this ambiguity, but it’s never quite as clever as it thinks it is. Pandey’s direction is, as always, precise.
He has a knack for building tension through small details—the way a character’s fingers tap against a table, the pause before an answer, the unspoken weight of a glance. But Sikandar Ka Muqaddar suffers from the same affliction as many of his other films: it mistakes convolution for complexity. The nonlinear storytelling, which jumps between past and present, is meant to keep the audience guessing, but it often feels like a gimmick rather than a necessity.
Audience Opinions
Audience 6.5/10
"A gripping but uneven crime thriller with strong performances, held back by a predictable plot and underdeveloped side characters."
Viewers appreciate the intense cat-and-mouse dynamic between Jimmy Shergill and Avinash Tiwary, which keeps the tension high throughout the film. The heist thriller setup and Neeraj Pandey’s direction are praised for maintaining suspense, though some find the story too familiar. latestnetflix.com's view is that the supporting cast, including Tamannaah Bhatia and Divya Dutta, is often criticized for lacking depth, leaving the leads to carry most of the emotional weight.
What viewers praise
- Strong lead performances Jimmy Shergill and Avinash Tiwary deliver compelling performances, making their characters’ rivalry engaging.
- Tense storytelling The film’s pacing and suspenseful moments keep audiences hooked, especially in the second half.
- Neeraj Pandey’s direction Pandey’s signature style of tight storytelling and realistic tension is well-executed.
Common complaints
- Predictable plot The story follows well-worn crime thriller tropes, leaving little room for surprises.
- Underdeveloped side characters Supporting roles, including Tamannaah Bhatia and Divya Dutta, feel shallow and underutilized.
- Weak emotional payoff Some viewers felt the climax lacked the depth needed to fully satisfy the buildup.
Recommended for
Crime thriller enthusiasts Jimmy Shergill fans Neeraj Pandey admirers Heist movie lovers Suspense-driven story seekers
Buzz & Rumors
Public reportsNeeraj Pandey’s Sikandar Ka Muqaddar: The Secretive Shoot and Polarizing Reception
Neeraj Pandey’s latest heist thriller, Sikandar Ka Muqaddar (2024), has been making waves—not just for its star-studded cast but for the director’s unconventional approach to filmmaking. The movie, which dropped on Netflix on November 29, pits Jimmy Shergill’s relentless cop against Avinash Tiwary’s enigmatic suspect in a high-stakes battle of wits. But behind the scenes, Pandey’s methods have left even his actors in the dark.
A Script Shrouded in Mystery
Pandey, known for his meticulous storytelling in films like A Wednesday! and Special 26, took secrecy to another level with Sikandar Ka Muqaddar. Instead of handing out full scripts, he reportedly shared only a few pages with his cast during the initial stages, keeping everyone guessing about the bigger picture. Jimmy Shergill and Avinash Tiwary, the film’s leads, later revealed that this approach left them "curious" but trusting of Pandey’s vision 
. The director’s gamble seems to have paid off in some ways—the film’s nonlinear narrative, toggling between the perspectives of Shergill’s Jaswinder Singh and Tiwary’s Sikandar, has been a talking point .
The Cast’s Impressions vs. Audience Reactions
The ensemble cast, including Tamannaah Bhatia, Divya Dutta, and Rajeev Mehta, delivered performances that impressed netizens. Bhatia, in particular, earned praise for her role as Kamini Singh, a key suspect in the 2008 diamond heist that sets the story in motion . However, not all feedback has been glowing. Critics have called out the film’s "convoluted screenplay," arguing that the back-and-forth storytelling, while ambitious, sometimes drags the tension . One review described it as an "overdrawn battle of wills," where the cat-and-mouse dynamic between Shergill and Tiwary loses steam due to repetitive confrontations .
Netflix’s Gamble on a Heist Thriller
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar marks another foray into the crime genre for Netflix India, following the success of Class of ’83 and Khakee: The Bihar Chapter. The streaming giant’s plot summary teases a high-stakes investigation where Jaswinder Singh’s instincts lead him to three suspects, including Bhatia’s character . But with mixed reviews, the film’s fate hinges on whether audiences will embrace its slow-burn tension or dismiss it as a missed opportunity. Early buzz suggests that while the performances are strong, the execution may not fully justify the hype.
What’s Next for Pandey?
Given Pandey’s track record, Sikandar Ka Muqaddar could either be a cult favorite or a cautionary tale about overcomplicating a thriller. If the film finds its audience, it might pave the way for more experimental storytelling from the director. For now, though, the jury’s out—and the cast’s reactions suggest they’re as eager as viewers to see how it all plays out.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Movies
Similar Movies
Related titles ranked by rating and popularity.
