
Neil Crone
Gordon (voice, US)

Percy discovers a child's letter to Santa Claus forgotten at the bottom of his mail van on Christmas Eve, but he is determined to make things right, even if that means tracking down Mr. Claus himself! With help from Thomas and his friends, Percy travels through dazzling parades, sweet-smelling gingerbread bakes, and snowflake flurries on a quest to deliver the letter to Santa and make a child’s Christmas Wish come true.
I’ll admit it: I wasn’t expecting to spend Christmas Eve with Percy the Small Engine. But there I was, curled up on the couch with a mug of cocoa (okay, fine, it was decaf coffee), watching The Christmas Letter Express unfold like a pop-up book of childhood memories. Sixty minutes later, I wasn’t transformed, exactly—but I was oddly charmed.
And that, I think, is the point.
This isn’t a film that demands to be dissected like Citizen Kane or The Godfather. It’s a holiday special, designed to be consumed between cookie decorating and last-minute wrapping, a gentle hum of warmth in the background of a chaotic season. But that doesn’t mean it’s without craft, or even a kind of quiet ambition.
The question is: does it work for anyone beyond the preschool set?

The premise is simple, almost to a fault. Percy discovers a lost letter to Santa tucked in his mail van, and—because Christmas magic depends on last-minute heroics—he sets off to deliver it before midnight. Along the way, he’s joined by Thomas, James, and a rotating cast of Sodor’s most reliable engines, each contributing their own brand of holiday cheer (or, in Gordon’s case, grumbling about being late for his own parade).
The journey takes them through gingerbread tunnels, past ice-skating ponds, and into a snowstorm that, in the film’s most visually striking moment, blankets the island in a shimmering white haze.
That moment—when the engines emerge from the storm to find Santa’s sleigh tracks in the snow—is the closest the film comes to genuine magic. The animation, a 2D style that’s brighter and more exaggerated than the original model-work series, lends itself well to the whimsy of the season. Colors pop: Percy’s green coat gleams against the snow, the red of Santa’s sleigh is almost aggressively festive, and the gingerbread houses look good enough to eat.
It’s the kind of visual palette that feels designed for a child’s wide eyes, where every detail is just a little too vibrant to be real.
And that’s where the first divide appears. For parents or older fans of the franchise, this aesthetic shift can feel jarring. The original Thomas & Friends, with its stop-motion models and meticulously crafted sets, had a tactile, almost artisanal quality.
The All Engines Go! reboot, of which The Christmas Letter Express is a part, trades that physicality for something sleeker and more digital. It’s not bad—in fact, the animation is fluid and expressive—but it lacks the weight of the old series, the sense that these trains exist in a world you could almost touch. For some, that’s a betrayal.
For others, it’s progress.
The film’s biggest gamble, though, isn’t its animation. It’s Santa.
Or, more precisely, it’s the decision not to show Santa’s face. Writer Rick Suvalle has explained that this was a deliberate choice, made to avoid associating Santa with any specific race or ethnicity. It’s a noble intention, and one that reflects a growing awareness in children’s media about representation and inclusivity.
But in practice, it creates an odd disconnect. Santa is a voice—warm, jolly, and reassuring—but he’s also a pair of boots, a red coat, and a sleigh. The film’s Santa feels like a concept rather than a character, and that abstraction undercuts the emotional payoff of Percy’s journey.
When the engines finally reach him, the moment lands with a whimper, not a cheer.

That’s not to say the film lacks heart. The themes of friendship, perseverance, and the spirit of giving are woven into every scene, and for young viewers, they’ll likely resonate deeply. There’s a sweet subplot involving Bruno the Brake Car, who insists on keeping the holiday decorations exactly as they were in previous years—a nod to tradition that feels particularly poignant in a franchise that’s undergone so many changes.
And the film’s three original songs, while not destined for Billboard charts, are catchy enough to get stuck in your head (trust me, I’ve been humming “Christmas Wish” for days).
But here’s the thing: The Christmas Letter Express is a film that knows its audience, and its audience is very specific. Common Sense Media called it “a perfect gentle holiday special for preschoolers,” and that’s not wrong. For a three- or four-year-old, this is a world of wonder: trains that talk, snow that sparkles, and the promise that even the smallest among us can make a difference.
For adults, though, it can feel like a missed opportunity. The plot is predictable, the conflicts are resolved with minimal effort, and the emotional stakes never rise above “mildly inconvenienced.” It’s the cinematic equivalent of a sugar cookie: sweet, but not particularly filling.
That’s not a flaw, exactly. Not every film needs to be The Polar Express or Miracle on 34th Street. Sometimes, a movie’s job is to be a comforting presence, a familiar friend who shows up every year with the same stories and the same warmth. The Christmas Letter Express understands that role, and for the most part, it plays it well.
But it’s hard not to wonder what it could have been if it had taken a few more risks—if it had given us a Santa with a face, or a conflict with real stakes, or even just a moment of genuine surprise.
As it stands, the film is a Rorschach test for Thomas & Friends fans. Older viewers will see a franchise that’s lost its way, a shadow of the series they grew up with. Younger ones will see a world of adventure and possibility, where even the smallest engine can save Christmas.
And parents? They’ll see an hour of peace and quiet, which, let’s be honest, is a gift in itself.

I left the film feeling… content. Not moved, not challenged, but content in the way you feel after a good nap or a warm meal. And maybe that’s enough.
Maybe the measure of a holiday special isn’t in how it changes you, but in how it makes you feel in the moment. For the children watching, The Christmas Letter Express will likely be a cherished part of their holiday traditions. For the rest of us, it’s a reminder of the stories we loved as kids—and the ones we’re still learning to love as adults.
In the end, Percy delivers the letter. Santa’s sleigh takes off into the night. The engines return to the roundhouse, their mission complete.
And somewhere, a child’s Christmas wish comes true. That’s the magic of it, I suppose. Not in the grand gestures, but in the quiet moments in between.
The ones that feel, just for a little while, like home.
"A warm but lightweight holiday special for young fans that feels too familiar for older viewers."
Festive cheer and colorful animation make it a hit with young children who love classic *Thomas & Friends*. The story follows a predictable formula, though, and with no real character development or surprises, older viewers will want more substance.
The beloved Thomas & Friends franchise is reviving its holiday spirit with The Christmas Letter Express, a 2024 feature-length special set to deliver cheer—and a last-minute rescue mission—this Christmas Eve. Directed by Campbell Bryer, the film marks the third installment in the All Engines Go reboot series and the seventeenth Thomas & Friends movie overall. But this year’s adventure comes with a twist: Percy, the plucky little engine, takes center stage in a race against time to ensure a child’s letter reaches Santa.
While Thomas the Tank Engine often steals the spotlight, The Christmas Letter Express shifts focus to Percy, who discovers a misplaced letter to Santa in his mail cart on Christmas Eve. The stakes? High. The child’s holiday wish hangs in the balance, forcing Percy to track down Santa before it’s too late. The premise leans into the franchise’s signature blend of heartwarming storytelling and gentle adventure, a formula that has kept Thomas & Friends a holiday staple for decades.
The special also reunites fans with the All Engines Go reboot’s vibrant animation style, which debuted in 2021. Unlike the classic model animation of earlier Thomas films, this iteration uses 2D digital animation, a shift that has divided longtime fans but introduced the series to a new generation. With The Christmas Letter Express, the reboot continues its mission to modernize the franchise while retaining its nostalgic charm.
Little is known about the production process, but the film’s existence confirms that Thomas & Friends remains a priority for Mattel, the brand’s parent company. Campbell Bryer, the director, has been a steady hand behind the All Engines Go series, though his previous work on the franchise hasn’t garnered the same attention as the original Thomas films. The cast, including Neil Crone, Charlie Zeltzer, Luke Marty, and Kai Harris, brings fresh voices to Sodor’s familiar faces, though details about their roles remain scarce.
One unanswered question: How does The Christmas Letter Express fit into the broader All Engines Go timeline? The film is the third in the reboot’s movie series, following Race for the Sodor Cup (2021) and The Mystery of Lookout Mountain (2022). Yet, unlike those films, which leaned into action and mystery, this special returns to the franchise’s holiday roots—a move that could reassure fans wary of the reboot’s more fast-paced tone.
With The Christmas Letter Express set to air in late 2024, the film’s reception could shape the future of All Engines Go. If successful, it may pave the way for more holiday specials or even a return to the classic model animation style that defined the franchise’s golden era. For now, though, the focus is on Percy’s Christmas Eve dash—a simple but effective hook for a new generation of young viewers.
As for rumors of cameos or surprise appearances? The evidence is silent. But given the franchise’s history of cross-engine team-ups, it wouldn’t be surprising if Thomas, Gordon, or even Sir Topham Hatt made an appearance to lend a hand. Until then, fans will have to wait to see if Percy can save Christmas—one letter at a time.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.