Skip to main content
Movie poster for Ismael's Ghosts (2017)

Ismael's Ghosts

“The past never dies.”

2017
1h 54m
R · French
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Just as the disheveled and alcoholic filmmaker Ismaël embarks on a difficult new film project, his life is sent into a tailspin. His wife Carlotta, presumed dead for 20 years, come crashing back into his life creating chaos in his work and his current romantic relationship with the starry-eyed astronomer Sylvia.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Ghosts We Carry

I’ve always been drawn to films that feel like they’re unspooling from a dream—where the logic isn’t linear, but emotional, where the past isn’t just remembered but lived again, pressing against the present like a bruise. Arnaud Desplechin’s Ismael’s Ghosts is one of those films. It’s messy, frustrating, and at times maddeningly opaque, but it clings to you long after the credits roll, like the residue of a half-remembered nightmare.

That’s not an accident. Desplechin isn’t interested in tidy resolutions or clear-cut answers. He’s interested in the way people fracture under the weight of their own histories, in the way love curdles into obsession, and in the ghosts that refuse to stay buried.

The film opens with Ismaël (Mathieu Amalric), a filmmaker in the throes of creative and personal chaos, trying to finish a movie about a diplomat named Ivan Dedalus (Louis Garrel). The project is a mess—Ismaël drinks too much, sleeps too little, and is haunted (literally, it seems) by the memory of his wife Carlotta (Marion Cotillard), who vanished two decades earlier. His current lover, Sylvia (Charlotte Gainsbourg), a scientist who studies the cosmos, watches this unraveling with a mix of exasperation and tenderness.

Then, just as Ismaël’s life seems to be spiraling into its own kind of black hole, Carlotta reappears. Not as a memory, not as a figment, but as flesh and blood. The past, it turns out, isn’t just a ghost.

It’s a person who can walk back into your life and demand to be seen.

A dimly lit room where Ismaël and Carlotta stand at opposite ends, the tension between them palpable, as if the air itself is charged with twenty years of absence.

What makes Ismael’s Ghosts so unsettling is the way Desplechin refuses to let us—or his characters—off the hook. There’s no catharsis here, no grand reconciliation. Carlotta’s return isn’t a miracle; it’s a disruption, a reckoning.

The film oscillates between Ismaël’s present-day turmoil and the story of Ivan Dedalus, the diplomat whose life seems to mirror Ismaël’s own in uncanny ways. Ivan, too, is haunted—by a brother who may or may not be dead, by a past that refuses to stay buried. The two narratives bleed into each other, not just thematically but visually, with Desplechin blurring the lines between reality and fiction, memory and delusion.

It’s a trick he’s pulled before, most notably in My Sex Life... Or How I Got into an Argument and A Christmas Tale, but here it feels more urgent, more desperate. The film isn’t just about ghosts; it’s about the stories we tell ourselves to survive them.

Amalric, a frequent Desplechin collaborator, is magnetic in the role of Ismaël. He’s all nervous energy, a man teetering on the edge of collapse, his body coiled like a spring. There’s a scene early in the film where he’s trying to explain his movie to Sylvia, his words tumbling out in a frenzy, his hands gesturing wildly.

It’s a performance that feels lived-in, unpolished, the kind of acting that makes you forget you’re watching a movie. Cotillard, too, is remarkable as Carlotta, a woman who has spent twenty years in the shadows, only to reemerge with a quiet, unsettling intensity. She doesn’t so much act as exist in the frame, her presence a reminder of all the things Ismaël has tried—and failed—to forget.

Carlotta standing in a doorway, her face half in shadow, as if she’s both there and not there, a specter of the past made flesh.

But for all its strengths, Ismael’s Ghosts isn’t an easy film to love. It’s deliberately frustrating, a puzzle that refuses to be solved. Desplechin’s approach to storytelling is associative, not linear, and there were moments when I found myself adrift, unsure of where the film was taking me.

That’s not necessarily a flaw—some of the most rewarding films are the ones that resist easy interpretation—but it does require a certain kind of patience. This isn’t a movie that holds your hand. It’s a movie that grabs you by the shoulders and shakes you, demanding that you pay attention, that you feel something, even if you’re not entirely sure what that something is.

The film’s visual language is just as layered as its narrative. Desplechin and cinematographer Irina Lubtchansky shoot the present-day scenes in a way that feels immediate and raw, all handheld camerawork and natural light. The scenes set in the past, or in Ismaël’s film-within-a-film, are more stylized, with a cooler palette and a more deliberate framing.

It’s a contrast that mirrors the film’s central tension: the past is always with us, but it’s also always slightly out of reach, a story we can never quite get right.

A close-up of Ismaël’s face, his expression a mix of exhaustion and desperation, as if he’s trying to outrun his own thoughts.

There’s a moment late in the film that stuck with me. Ismaël, drunk and disheveled, stumbles into a room where Carlotta is waiting. They don’t speak.

They don’t need to. The air between them is thick with everything that’s been left unsaid, with twenty years of grief and longing. It’s a scene that could have been maudlin in the wrong hands, but Desplechin plays it with a restraint that makes it all the more devastating.

There’s no grand confrontation, no emotional breakdown. Just two people, standing in the wreckage of their own lives, trying to figure out what comes next.

That, in the end, is what Ismael’s Ghosts is about: the impossibility of moving on. The past isn’t something we can neatly pack away and store in the attic. It’s something we carry with us, something that shapes us in ways we don’t always understand.

Desplechin’s film doesn’t offer any easy answers, but it does something just as valuable: it makes you feel the weight of that truth. It’s a film that lingers, not because it’s perfect, but because it’s honest. And in a world where so much art is polished to a shine, that honesty feels like a gift.

Audience Opinions

Limited evidence
Audience 6.7/10
"A visually rich but convoluted drama whose fragmented storytelling and emotional intensity divide opinion."

Atmospheric direction and strong performances, particularly from Mathieu Amalric and Marion Cotillard, add depth to the complex narrative. The plot is overly intricate and hard to follow, though, and some characters are underdeveloped or disconnected from the central story.

What viewers praise
  • Strong lead performances Amalric and Cotillard give compelling performances that anchor the film's emotional weight.
  • Visually striking The cinematography and direction create a moody, immersive atmosphere that suits the film's themes.
  • Ambitious storytelling A layered narrative with psychological depth for fans of complex dramas.
Common complaints
  • Confusing plot The fragmented structure and shifting timelines make the story hard to follow.
  • Underdeveloped characters Supporting roles, including some key figures, are thinly sketched or disconnected from the main arc.
  • Pacing issues The slow, meandering rhythm frustrates anyone expecting a tighter narrative.
Recommended for
Fans of psychological dramas Arnaud Desplechin enthusiasts Lovers of moody cinematography Fans of nonlinear storytelling

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Arnaud Desplechin’s "Ismael’s Ghosts": A Cannes Premiere Steeped in Mystery and Star Power

Arnaud Desplechin’s Ismael’s Ghosts (2017) arrived at the Cannes Film Festival with the kind of buzz that only a director of his stature could command. Starring a powerhouse ensemble—Mathieu Amalric, Marion Cotillard, Charlotte Gainsbourg, and Louis Garrel—the film promised a labyrinthine narrative blending psychological drama, espionage, and family secrets. But behind the scenes, latestnetflix.com argues, whispers of creative tension and a last-minute twist kept the conversation going long after the credits rolled.

A Director’s Obsession with Memory and Reinvention

Desplechin, known for his emotionally layered character studies (A Christmas Tale, My Golden Days), has never shied away from revisiting themes of memory, identity, and the ghosts of the past. Ismael’s Ghosts was no exception. The film follows Ismael (Amalric), a filmmaker grappling with the sudden reappearance of his presumed-dead wife, Carlotta (Cotillard), while simultaneously navigating a new romance with Sylvia (Gainsbourg). The story fractures into a film-within-a-film, blurring the lines between reality and fiction—a signature Desplechin move.

In a rare behind-the-scenes glimpse, a Cannes Q&A revealed that Desplechin initially conceived the project as a sequel to his 2015 film My Golden Days, with Amalric reprising his role as Paul Dédalus. However, the script evolved into something far more ambitious, weaving in elements of espionage and surrealism. "I wanted to explore the idea of a man haunted by his own creations," Desplechin reportedly said, though the exact quote remains unverified outside of the snippet. What’s clear is that the film’s nonlinear structure was deliberate, forcing audiences to piece together Ismael’s fractured psyche alongside the characters.

The Cast: A Reunion of Desplechin’s Regulars

Ismael’s Ghosts marked another collaboration between Desplechin and Amalric, who has become the director’s on-screen alter ego in many ways. Their partnership stretches back to My Sex Life... Or How I Got Into an Argument (1996), and Amalric’s portrayal of Ismael—a man unraveling under the weight of his own lies—was widely praised as one of his most complex performances.

But the real intrigue lay in the film’s female leads. Cotillard, who had previously worked with Desplechin on A Christmas Tale (2008), returned in a role that was equal parts ethereal and destabilizing. Her character, Carlotta, is a specter from Ismael’s past, and her sudden reappearance sends shockwaves through his present. Meanwhile, Gainsbourg, another Desplechin veteran (Kings and Queen, 2004), played Sylvia, the new woman in Ismael’s life, bringing a grounded contrast to the film’s surreal elements.

Louis Garrel, who joined the project as Ismael’s half-brother, added another layer of familial tension. Garrel’s collaboration with Desplechin was a first, but their shared interest in exploring masculinity and artistic obsession made the pairing feel inevitable. Alba Rohrwacher, László Szabó, and Hippolyte Girardot rounded out the ensemble, each contributing to the film’s dense, dreamlike atmosphere.

Cannes 2017: A Premiere Plagued by Rumors

Ismael’s Ghosts opened the 70th Cannes Film Festival, a slot typically reserved for high-profile, crowd-pleasing films. But the reception was anything but unanimous. While some critics hailed it as a bold, inventive return to form for Desplechin, others found its narrative too convoluted, with one review calling it "a puzzle missing half its pieces". The film’s 5.6/10 rating on SensCritique suggests a divisive reaction, though its defenders argued that its ambiguity was the point.

Behind the scenes, rumors swirled about last-minute edits. In an interview tied to the festival, Desplechin hinted at a significant change made just before the premiere, though he didn’t specify what it was. "Sometimes you have to listen to the film itself," he reportedly said, leaving fans to speculate whether the final cut was drastically different from earlier versions. Given Desplechin’s reputation for meticulous, sometimes obsessive, editing, it wouldn’t be surprising if the film underwent late revisions.

Another point of contention was the film’s abrupt tonal shifts. The trailer promised a sleek spy thriller, but the final product leaned harder into psychological drama and surrealism. Some viewers felt misled, while others appreciated the subversion. Either way, it added to the film’s mystique.

Legacy: A Cult Favorite or a Missed Opportunity?

Nearly seven years after its premiere, Ismael’s Ghosts remains a polarizing entry in Desplechin’s filmography. Its defenders praise it as a daring, visually sumptuous exploration of grief and creativity, while detractors argue that its narrative ambition outstripped its execution. What’s undeniable is its place in Desplechin’s broader body of work—a film that refuses to be pinned down, much like the ghosts that haunt its protagonist.

For fans of the director, the film is a fascinating puzzle, rich with callbacks to his earlier works. For newcomers, it’s a challenging but rewarding dive into the mind of one of France’s most distinctive auteurs. And for the cast, it was another opportunity to collaborate with a director who pushes them to their limits.

Whether Ismael’s Ghosts will be remembered as a masterpiece or a misfire may depend on who you ask. But one thing is certain: it’s a film that lingers, much like the specters at its core.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.