Skip to main content
Movie poster for Harriet (2019)

Harriet

“Be free or die”

2019
2h 5m
PG-13 · English
Director: Kasi Lemmons
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

The extraordinary tale of Harriet Tubman's escape from slavery and transformation into one of America's greatest heroes. Her courage, ingenuity and tenacity freed hundreds of slaves and changed the course of history.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

6 min read

The Woman Who Moved Like a Ghost

I’ve seen this story before. Not Harriet Tubman’s story—though I’ve read the textbooks, the children’s books, the solemn plaques—but the way Hollywood tells it. The escape, the chase, the hero’s journey with a historical twist. Harriet, Kasi Lemmons’ 2019 biopic, doesn’t reinvent the wheel.

What it does, instead, is something quieter and more stubborn: it insists on Tubman’s interiority. Not just what she did, but how it felt to do it. And in that insistence, it becomes something rare—a biopic that doesn’t just honor its subject but tries, however imperfectly, to crawl inside her skin.

The film opens with a close-up of Cynthia Erivo’s face, half-lit by firelight, her eyes wide and unblinking. She’s not yet Harriet Tubman; she’s still Araminta "Minty" Ross, an enslaved woman in Maryland, praying for deliverance. The camera lingers on her features—sharp cheekbones, a mouth that seems to hold back words, a gaze that flickers between fear and defiance.

It’s a face built for close-ups, and Lemmons knows it. This isn’t the Tubman of statues or stamps, the stern matriarch with a rifle. This is a woman who, in one scene, collapses mid-field, her body wracked by a seizure, only to wake with a vision of the path north.

The film treats these episodes not as quirks of history but as sacred glimpses—divine interventions, yes, but also the raw material of a mind that refused to be broken.

A close-up of Cynthia Erivo as Harriet Tubman, her face half-lit by firelight, eyes wide with a mix of fear and determination.

The problem with telling Harriet Tubman’s story is that it’s already a myth. She’s the Moses of her people, the woman who led hundreds to freedom, the spy, the nurse, the suffragist. How do you humanize a legend without sanding down her edges?

Lemmons’ solution is to ground the film in Erivo’s physicality. Watch the way she moves: not with the swagger of a superhero, but with the cautious, deliberate steps of someone who knows the cost of every misplaced footfall. When she first escapes, she doesn’t sprint—she walks, then jogs, then runs only when she has to, her breath ragged, her dress torn.

The camera doesn’t glamourize the journey. The woods are dark, the rivers cold, the dogs relentless. And yet, there’s a moment—just one—where the score swells, Terence Blanchard’s strings lifting like a hymn, and Erivo’s Tubman looks up at the sky, her face alight with something like wonder.

It’s the kind of moment that could feel manipulative in lesser hands, but here, it lands. Because we’ve earned it. We’ve been with her in the mud, the blood, the terror.

That said, Harriet isn’t immune to the pitfalls of the biopic form. The film’s second act, which follows Tubman’s return trips to Maryland to rescue others, starts to feel like a checklist: the reluctant ally, the narrow escape, the triumphant return. The Underground Railroad sequences, while tense, occasionally slip into action-movie rhythms—quick cuts, dramatic music, a sense of inevitability.

Owen Gleiberman, writing for Variety, put it bluntly: the film "feels more dutiful than inspired." He’s not wrong. There’s a scene where Tubman confronts her former enslaver, Gideon Brodess (Joe Alwyn), in a Philadelphia boarding house.

The dialogue is sharp, the tension palpable, but the moment plays out like a Western standoff, complete with a slow zoom on Alwyn’s sneering face. It’s effective, but it’s also familiar. The film knows its audience has seen this before.

What saves Harriet from becoming just another historical drama is its refusal to let Tubman’s faith be mere set dressing. The visions that guide her—flashes of light, premonitions of danger—are treated as both real and metaphorical. They’re the film’s way of grappling with the unknowable: how a woman who was beaten, starved, and dehumanized could still believe in a God who cared.

In one of the film’s most striking scenes, Tubman, mid-seizure, sees a vision of her dead father standing in a field. He doesn’t speak. He just looks at her, and in that look, there’s a kind of permission.

Not to be free—she’s already free—but to be more than free. To be a leader. The moment is hushed, almost wordless, and it’s the closest the film comes to capturing the mystery of Tubman’s resilience.

Harriet Tubman, mid-seizure, sees a vision of her father standing in a sunlit field, his presence silent but comforting.

Erivo’s performance is the film’s anchor, and it’s easy to see why she earned an Oscar nomination. She doesn’t just play Tubman; she inhabits her. There’s a scene where Tubman, now in Philadelphia, meets a group of Black abolitionists for the first time.

She’s wary, her posture stiff, her voice low. When one of them, Marie Buchanon (Janelle Monáe), offers her a place to stay, Tubman’s response is a quiet, "I don’t know you." It’s a small moment, but it’s revelatory.

This isn’t a woman who trusts easily. This is someone who has learned, the hard way, that safety is an illusion. Erivo’s Tubman is never just one thing—she’s fierce, but she’s also afraid; she’s devout, but she’s pragmatic; she’s a leader, but she’s still, in many ways, a fugitive.

The supporting cast is solid, if underutilized. Leslie Odom Jr. Brings warmth and gravitas to William Still, the abolitionist who documents Tubman’s rescues, but his role is largely functional.

Janelle Monáe’s Marie Buchanon is a welcome presence—a free Black woman who runs a boarding house and offers Tubman a glimpse of what life could be like beyond survival. But the film’s most chilling performance comes from Joe Alwyn as Gideon Brodess. Alwyn plays him as a man who is equal parts entitled and pathetic, a slave owner who can’t comprehend why his "property" would ever want to leave.

His final confrontation with Tubman is electric, not because it’s a grand showdown, but because it’s so small. He’s not a mustache-twirling villain; he’s a man who has never had to question his own cruelty.

Harriet has its flaws. The score, while lush, sometimes overplays its hand, swelling at moments that could have used more restraint. The action sequences, while tense, occasionally feel too slick for a story that is, at its core, about the brutality of slavery.

And the film’s decision to include a fictional character in Marie Buchanon—while not without purpose—feels like a missed opportunity to delve deeper into the real-life figures who surrounded Tubman. But these are quibbles. What lingers is Erivo’s face, the way she carries the weight of history without letting it crush her.

The film’s final shot is of Tubman standing on a battlefield, her rifle slung over her shoulder, her expression unreadable. It’s not a triumphant ending. It’s something more complicated: a woman who has done the impossible, but who knows the fight isn’t over.

Harriet Tubman stands on a battlefield, rifle slung over her shoulder, her expression unreadable as she gazes into the distance.

In the end, Harriet is a film that doesn’t need to reinvent the biopic to justify its existence. It just needs to remind us that behind every legend is a person who was, at one point, just trying to survive. And that, in its own way, is revolutionary.

As Richard Roeper wrote in the Chicago Sun-Times, Erivo’s performance is "convincing and powerful, a portrayal that honors Tubman’s legacy while making her feel like a flesh-and-blood human being." That’s the highest praise I can think of. Because the best historical dramas don’t just tell us what happened.

They make us feel what it was like to live it. And for 125 minutes, Harriet does exactly that.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.3/10
"A powerful but uneven biopic that shines brightest in its lead performance and emotional moments, though it struggles with pacing and depth."

Cynthia Erivo's Harriet Tubman is intense and emotionally gripping, anchoring the film's best scenes. The storytelling is uneven: the first half drags and the second rushes key events, leaving little room for nuance in supporting characters or historical context.

What viewers praise
  • Cynthia Erivo’s performance Erivo's raw emotion and physicality capture Tubman's determination and spirit.
  • Emotional impact The most powerful moments, particularly Tubman's escape and rescue missions, hit hard.
  • Historical significance It brings Harriet Tubman's story to a wider audience, highlighting her bravery and the Underground Railroad's role in history.
  • Music and score The soundtrack and score stand out, adding emotional and dramatic weight.
Common complaints
  • Uneven pacing The first half drags, while the second rushes through key events without enough depth.
  • Lack of depth in supporting roles Supporting characters, including Leslie Odom Jr.'s William Still and Janelle Monáe's Marie Buchanon, are underdeveloped, with little screen time or backstory.
  • Predictable storytelling It follows a familiar biopic formula, with no surprises or fresh perspectives on Tubman's life.
  • Simplistic villain portrayal The antagonists, particularly the slave catchers, are one-dimensional, flattening the historical conflict.
Recommended for
Fans of historical biopics Cynthia Erivo admirers Those interested in Black history Viewers who enjoy emotional dramas Underground Railroad story enthusiasts

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Cynthia Erivo and Kasi Lemmons Fought Backlash—and Gravity—While Bringing Harriet Tubman to the Screen

Kasi Lemmons’ Harriet (2019) wasn’t just a biopic—it was a lightning rod. The film, starring Cynthia Erivo as the legendary abolitionist Harriet Tubman, sparked debates before it even hit theaters, from casting choices to how Tubman’s story should be told. Behind the scenes, Erivo and Lemmons faced the fallout head-on, latestnetflix.com contends, while also pulling off some of the movie’s most demanding physical feats themselves.

The Casting Controversy That Wouldn’t Quit

When Cynthia Erivo was cast as Harriet Tubman, the backlash was immediate. Critics argued that a British actress shouldn’t play the iconic American hero, igniting a debate about representation and authenticity. Erivo, who had already earned acclaim for her Tony-winning role in The Color Purple, didn’t shy away from the criticism. In interviews, she addressed the uproar directly, defending her right to take on the role while acknowledging the weight of Tubman’s legacy.

Director Kasi Lemmons also stepped into the fray, pushing back against social media criticism that dismissed the film before its release. In one clip, she called out the "armchair critics" who condemned Harriet without seeing it, framing the movie as a necessary corrective to the erasure of Black heroes in mainstream cinema. The tension underscored a larger question: Who gets to tell Harriet Tubman’s story—and how?

A Superhero Movie, Not a Slave Movie

Lemmons and Erivo had a clear vision for Harriet: it wasn’t just a historical drama, but a "superhero movie". The director emphasized that Tubman’s story was one of extraordinary courage and agency, not just suffering. This framing helped shape the film’s tone, blending the brutality of slavery with moments of triumph and defiance.

Erivo, who trained extensively for the role, described the physical demands as grueling. She insisted on doing her own stunts, including a harrowing river crossing, to stay connected to Tubman’s experience. "I wanted to be connected in every way," she said, explaining that the physicality helped her embody the abolitionist’s resilience. The result was a performance that balanced vulnerability with steely determination, earning Erivo an Oscar nomination for Best Actress.

**The Legacy of Harriet—and Its Critics**

Despite the controversy, Harriet found an audience, earning a 73% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes and praise for its unflinching portrayal of Tubman’s life. Yet the film’s reception remained divided. Some viewers lauded it as a long-overdue tribute, while others criticized its pacing or historical liberties. On SensCritique, it holds a 6.3/10 rating, with users debating its balance of action and drama.

For Lemmons and Erivo, the film’s legacy was never just about box office numbers or awards. It was about reclaiming a narrative too often sidelined in Hollywood. As Erivo put it, playing Tubman was a responsibility—one she approached with humility and fire.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.