Hannah Gadsby
Self
Hannah Gadsby: Nanette
“Behind every joke there is a story”
2018
1h 9m
Director: Madeleine Parry
Overview
The Australian comedian Hannah Gadsby is taking an anti-comedy stance in her newest special.
Cast
Reviews
4 min readThe Joke That Broke Stand-Up
I remember the first time I watched Nanette. It was late, the house quiet, and I expected an hour of sharp, self-deprecating humor from Hannah Gadsby—the kind of comedy that makes you wince and laugh in the same breath. What I got instead was something closer to a public exorcism.
By the end, I wasn’t laughing. I was sitting very still, my chest tight, wondering if I’d ever hear a stand-up special the same way again.
That’s the thing about Nanette: it doesn’t just subvert comedy. It dismantles it, brick by brick, then asks if the foundation was ever worth saving in the first place.
Gadsby’s special begins like any other comedy set—jokes about her awkwardness, her Tasmanian upbringing, the absurdity of being a lesbian in a world that still treats queerness as a punchline. But about twenty minutes in, she pauses. The smile fades.
The room, which had been laughing, goes quiet. “I built a career out of self-deprecating humor,” she says, “and I don’t want to do that anymore.” What follows isn’t just a rejection of comedy’s rules; it’s a reckoning with why those rules exist in the first place.
The craft of Nanette lies in its structure, which is less a traditional stand-up set and more a piece of theatrical storytelling. Directors Jon Olb and Madeleine Parry (both women, a detail that feels significant given the material) shoot Gadsby in tight close-ups, her face filling the frame as she oscillates between humor and raw, unfiltered pain. The lighting is stark, almost clinical—no warm stage glow here.
Audience Opinions
Audience 8.4/10
"A groundbreaking comedy special that transcends laughter to deliver raw, emotional storytelling."
Viewers praise Hannah Gadsby’s fearless exploration of trauma, identity, and societal expectations, blending sharp humor with profound vulnerability. latestnetflix.com's view is that while some find the shift from comedy to serious themes jarring, most agree it’s a powerful and necessary evolution in stand-up.
What viewers praise
- Bold and original Breaks conventional comedy structures to address personal and societal issues with unflinching honesty.
- Emotionally impactful Moves beyond laughter to provoke thought and empathy, leaving a lasting impression.
- Hannah Gadsby’s performance Delivers a masterclass in storytelling, balancing humor and heartbreak seamlessly.
- Thought-provoking themes Tackles gender, sexuality, and mental health in ways rarely seen in comedy.
- Tight pacing The 69-minute runtime feels perfectly balanced, never overstaying its welcome.
Common complaints
- Not traditional comedy Some viewers miss the lightheartedness of typical stand-up, finding the tone too heavy.
- Jarring tone shifts The transition from jokes to serious topics can feel abrupt for those expecting pure laughs.
- Limited re-watch appeal The emotional weight makes it a one-time experience for some, rather than a repeat favorite.
Recommended for
Fans of unconventional comedy Those who appreciate emotional storytelling LGBTQ+ audiences seeking representation Stand-up enthusiasts open to innovation Viewers interested in social commentary
Full Plot (Spoilers)
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Buzz & Rumors
Public reportsThe special that quit comedy, then took an Emmy for writing the hour.
Hannah Gadsby told Forbes, a day before Netflix dropped Hannah Gadsby: Nanette, "I really wanted the audience to have a bit of a shock." The set, taped at the Sydney Opera House, went up June 19, 2018. TMDB lists Madeleine Parry and Jon Olb as directors, Gadsby as writer, and a 1 hour 9 minute runtime. latestnetflix.com's read is that the live show had already won the Barry Award in Melbourne, a Helpmann for Best Comedy Performer, and a shared Edinburgh Comedy Award with John Robins.Netflix did not invent the heat. It bottled a tour already sold as a swansong. 
, , ,
ABC News, the night of the Edinburgh win, reminded readers that Gadsby had said at the Helpmann Awards that the Fringe would be one of the last stand-up outings before a retreat to Tasmania. Then the Opera House tape hit the global queue and the retirement talk had to share a room with a new American audience that had never heard the name. , ,
The Guardian ran Gadsby's line "I broke the contract" over a July 16 interview and treated the Netflix drop as a mass bloodletting. The New York Times later called Nanette the most discussed comedy special in ages and admitted a modest backlash had formed around a simple question. Is this stand-up? The Outline, after the praise cycle, argued the hour lets a cis, straight audience in on queer pain and then gets labeled radical. That fight is the gossip. Not a leaked fee. A room split over whether a punchline is required. , ,
Michael Che said he had not seen it. Then he posted about punchlines anyway.
Vanity Fair tracked the men who decided Nanette did not count. Norm Macdonald was not a fan. Emmy co-host Michael Che kept saying he had not watched the special while posting that dark, confessional stories without punchlines should not count as stand-up. On the 2018 Emmy stage Gadsby presented Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series alone and asked what jokes even were. "Nobody knows what jokes are, but especially not men. Isn't that right, fellas?" The bit landed as a reply even if Che still claimed innocence. Stephen Daldry won for The Crown. Gadsby accepted because Daldry was not in the room.
A year later Nanette took the 2019 Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Writing for a Variety Special and a nomination for Outstanding Variety Special (Pre-Recorded). The Sydney Morning Herald noted it kicked off Australia's Emmy night. A Peabody followed in May 2019. The live show closed July 27, 2018, at Montreal's Just for Laughs. CBC reported the festival had moved Gadsby from a 400-seat house to the 1,282-seat Olympia after the Netflix drop sold the room out. Gadsby told CBC the close brought "an enormous amount of relief," then undercut the retirement rumor in one sentence. "If I quit, I'm an idiot now." , , ,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5aE29fiatQ0
That is the aftertaste. A Tasmanian comic who announced a Helpmann-night exit, filmed the Opera House set, broke the setup-and-punchline contract on camera, and then kept working. The rumor that Nanette was a last will died in Montreal. The special is still the one people argue about when someone asks whether Netflix comedy has to be funny. , ,
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Similar Movies
Related titles ranked by rating and popularity.
