
Judah Lewis
Cole Johnson

“Face your demons. Survive the night.”
Two years after defeating a satanic cult led by his babysitter Bee, Cole's trying to forget his past and focus on surviving high school. But when old enemies unexpectedly return, Cole will once again have to outsmart the forces of evil.
Official
I’ll admit it: I went into The Babysitter: Killer Queen expecting to hate it. Not because I disliked the first film—quite the opposite. The original Babysitter was a scrappy, self-aware slasher-comedy that knew exactly what it was: a high-energy, blood-soaked romp with a killer soundtrack and a cast that seemed to be having the time of their lives.
It was dumb, but it was fun dumb. The sequel, though? It feels like someone took that same recipe, microwaved it for 90 seconds, and served it up with a side of existential dread.
McG has called this film a "mixtape" of influences, blending Faustian bargains with Mel Brooks-style humor and an ‘80s aesthetic. That’s a bold claim, but the execution lands somewhere between a fever dream and a clearance-rack Stranger Things knockoff. The problem isn’t that Killer Queen tries too hard—it’s that it doesn’t try enough.
The first film thrived on its scrappy charm, its willingness to lean into the absurdity of a satanic cult operating out of a suburban living room. This sequel, by contrast, feels desperately designed, like it’s constantly checking its reflection to make sure it’s still cool. Take the opening sequence, for instance.
Cole (Judah Lewis) is now two years removed from his battle with Bee’s cult, but he’s still haunted—literally, in one scene where the undead cult members reappear in his bedroom like a bad acid flashback. The film tries to sell this as horror-comedy, but the tone is all over the place. One minute, it’s a slapstick chase through a high school hallway; the next, it’s a gory bloodbath with practical effects that look like they were borrowed from a Troma film.
The editing is so choppy it gives you whiplash, and the jokes land with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer. (A sledgehammer wielded by someone who’s never swung one before.)

The film’s biggest sin, though, is its reliance on nostalgia. Not the good kind—the kind that feels like a studio note. The original Babysitter worked because it was fresh, even if it was derivative. Killer Queen leans so hard into callbacks that it forgets to build anything new.
The cult members return, but their deaths are recycled almost beat-for-beat from the first film. The needle drops are still fun (a well-placed Toto track is always a win), but the references feel bizarrely dated, like the film is stuck in 2017 and refusing to move forward. RogerEbert.com’s critic put it best: "It’s a defiantly stupid movie, with references so bizarrely dated that it verges on fascinating." That’s one way to put it.
Another way? It’s like watching someone try to recapture lightning in a bottle by shaking the bottle really hard. There are moments where the film almost remembers what made the first one work.
Jenna Ortega’s Phoebe is a welcome addition, bringing a dry wit and a refreshing lack of self-awareness to the proceedings. (Her deadpan delivery of the line "I don’t know what’s happening, but I’m into it" is the closest the film comes to recapturing that original spark.) And the practical effects for the cult members’ deaths are genuinely fun, a throwback to the kind of over-the-top gore that made ‘80s slashers so delightful.
But these moments are few and far between, drowned out by the film’s relentless need to do more—more gore, more jokes, more references, more everything.

The real tragedy here is that Killer Queen could have been something interesting. McG has talked about wanting to make a film that feels like a grindhouse experience, and there’s a kernel of a good idea in that. The problem is that grindhouse films—real ones—were scrappy, low-budget affairs that embraced their limitations. Killer Queen has the budget, but it lacks the soul.
It’s all surface, no substance. And yet. I can’t bring myself to hate it entirely.
There’s something almost admirable about a film that commits this hard to its own absurdity. It’s not good, but it’s something—a mess, sure, but a mess with a pulse. The question is whether that pulse is worth feeling.
For most viewers, the answer will be a resounding no. But if you’re the kind of person who can find joy in a film that’s so unapologetically itself that it loops back around to being fascinating, then Killer Queen might just be your kind of trainwreck.

In the end, The Babysitter: Killer Queen is a film that doesn’t know when to quit. It’s exhausting, frustrating, and often just plain dumb. But it’s also weirdly endearing in its refusal to be anything other than what it is: a sequel that doesn’t deserve to exist, but does anyway.
And maybe that’s enough. Or maybe I’m just a sucker for a film that tries this hard, even when it fails this spectacularly. Either way, I’ll be thinking about it for all the wrong reasons.
"A messy but entertaining horror-comedy sequel that delivers fun moments but struggles with consistency and originality."
The movie leans into its over-the-top horror-comedy tone, with chaotic energy and nostalgic callbacks to the first film. The plot is disjointed and the humor often falls flat, leaving little substance behind the style. The cast’s chemistry keeps it watchable, but the predictable story and thin character development hold it back.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
The Babysitter: Killer Queen (2020) returned with more chaos, more gore, and a cast still game for McG’s over-the-top horror-comedy antics. latestnetflix.com's read is that Two years after the original cult hit, the sequel doubled down on its mix of teen slasher tropes and self-aware humor—but not without a few behind-the-scenes twists.
Judah Lewis reprised his role as Cole, the now-older teen still haunted by the satanic babysitter’s legacy. Sources suggest Lewis leaned into the absurdity, with one review calling his performance "a perfect blend of exasperation and survival instinct". Bella Thorne returned as the fiery, knife-wielding Allison, though her role was reportedly scaled back compared to the first film—rumor has it due to scheduling conflicts with other projects (unconfirmed).
Newcomers like Jenna Ortega (Wednesday) joined the fray as Phoebe, a sharp-tongued classmate who quickly became a fan favorite. Ortega’s chemistry with Lewis was a standout, with one critic noting her "effortless balance of sarcasm and heart". Meanwhile, Robbie Amell and Andrew Bachelor brought the laughs as grown-up versions of the original cult members, Max and John, respectively.
Director McG didn’t hold back on the sequel’s tone. The film leaned harder into its horror-comedy roots, with practical effects and gory set pieces that divided audiences. Some called it "a bloody good time", while others felt it lacked the original’s surprise factor. The runtime clocked in at 101 minutes, a slight stretch from the first film’s 85, but McG kept the pacing tight with rapid-fire jokes and over-the-top kills.
One behind-the-scenes tidbit: the lake house setting was reportedly chosen for its eerie isolation, allowing the cast to film night scenes with minimal light pollution. However, no major on-set mishaps or delays were documented in the available evidence.
Critics were split. SensCritique gave it a middling 5/10, with users praising the cast’s energy but criticizing the plot’s predictability. Rotten Tomatoes’ audience score (not listed in the evidence) remains unverified here, but YouTube reviews leaned into the film’s campy charm. One reviewer called it "worth all the blood sacrifice", while another dismissed it as "a messy but fun ride".
The trailer, released in two versions, teased the sequel’s escalation—more cult members, more supernatural stakes, and a finale that left fans debating whether Cole’s luck had finally run out.
The Babysitter: Killer Queen didn’t reinvent the wheel, but it delivered exactly what its niche audience wanted: gore, laughs, and a cast clearly having fun. Whether it’ll spawn another sequel remains unclear—though with Netflix’s track record, stranger things have happened.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.