Joe Eldred
Self

Six men who were sexually abused by Catholic clergy as boys become a makeshift family and find empowerment by creating films inspired by their trauma.
Official
I’ve seen documentaries about trauma before—too many, probably. The formula is familiar: talking heads, archival footage, a slow zoom on a face as the subject chokes back tears. The camera lingers, the music swells, and the audience is left with the vague, unsatisfying sense that they’ve witnessed something important, though they’re not entirely sure what.
Robert Greene’s Procession refuses that formula. It doesn’t just document trauma; it hands the survivors the tools to reshape it, to carve something new from the wreckage. And in doing so, it becomes something rare: a film about healing that actually feels like it might help.
The premise is deceptively simple. Six men—Joe, Mike, Ed, Dan, Michael, and Tom—all survivors of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy, come together to create short films inspired by their experiences. These aren’t reenactments in the traditional sense, where actors play out the horrors while the real subjects watch from the sidelines.
Instead, the men themselves step into the roles, scripting, directing, and performing scenes that mirror their own traumas. The result is a documentary that blurs the line between therapy and art, between testimony and creation. It’s messy, uneven, and sometimes uncomfortable to watch—not because of what’s shown, but because of how raw the process feels.

Greene has always been a filmmaker who plays with the boundaries of documentary. In Bisbee ’17, he had residents of a small Arizona town reenact a violent labor strike from a century earlier, forcing them to confront the ghosts of their community’s past. In Kate Plays Christine, he followed actress Kate Lyn Sheil as she prepared to play a real-life news anchor who died by suicide, blurring the lines between performance and reality. Procession feels like the logical next step in that evolution—a film that doesn’t just document a process but becomes part of it.
The men aren’t just subjects; they’re collaborators, shaping the narrative as they go. And Greene, to his credit, doesn’t shy away from the awkwardness of that collaboration. There are moments when the camera lingers a little too long, when the silence between takes feels heavier than the dialogue, when you can almost hear the unspoken question hanging in the air: Is this actually helping?
That question haunts the film, and it should. Therapy is a slow, nonlinear process, and Procession doesn’t pretend otherwise. There’s no neat resolution here, no moment where the men stand up and declare themselves healed.
Instead, there are small victories—a shared laugh, a scene that finally comes together after multiple takes, a moment of unexpected tenderness between two men who have every reason to distrust each other. One of the most striking sequences comes when Mike Foreman, a former Marine, directs a scene where he confronts the priest who abused him. The priest is played by another survivor, Dan Laurine, and the tension between them is palpable.
Mike’s hands shake as he delivers his lines, his voice cracking with rage. It’s not a performance; it’s a release. And when the scene ends, the room is silent.
No one knows what to say. That silence, more than any monologue or dramatic reveal, is where the film’s power lies.
What makes Procession different from other documentaries about trauma is its refusal to treat the survivors as victims. Yes, their pain is central to the story, but so is their agency. They’re not just recounting what happened to them; they’re reshaping it, reclaiming it.
In one scene, Joe Eldred—a soft-spoken man with a quiet intensity—directs a moment where a young boy (played by an actor) is led into a basement by a priest. The camera lingers on the boy’s face, his fear palpable. But then Joe interrupts the take. “No, no,” he says. “He’s not scared enough.
He needs to look like he knows what’s coming.” It’s a small moment, but it’s revelatory. Joe isn’t just telling his story; he’s controlling how it’s told. And in that control, there’s power.
The film’s structure mirrors that sense of reclamation. It jumps between the men’s individual projects and their group dynamic, between moments of levity and crushing sadness. There’s no clear narrative arc, no three-act structure to guide the viewer.
Instead, it feels like a series of vignettes, each one a step in a longer, ongoing journey. That can make Procession feel disjointed at times, but it also makes it feel honest. Healing isn’t linear, and neither is this film.
There are moments when the men seem to regress, when old wounds reopen, when the weight of what they’re trying to do threatens to crush them. But there are also moments of unexpected grace—a shared meal, a joke that cuts through the tension, a look of understanding between two people who have every reason to feel alone.
I keep coming back to the title. Procession. It’s a word that implies movement, a journey from one place to another. But it’s also a word tied to ritual, to the slow, deliberate progression of a ceremony.
That duality is at the heart of the film. The men are moving forward, but they’re also circling back, revisiting the past in order to move beyond it. And Greene, by giving them the tools to tell their own stories, becomes part of that ritual.
He’s not just a filmmaker; he’s a witness, a participant, a collaborator. That’s a tricky line to walk, and Procession doesn’t always get the balance right. There are moments when the camera feels intrusive, when the film’s need to document the process threatens to overshadow the healing itself.
But those moments are outweighed by the ones where the film gets it exactly right—where the act of creation becomes an act of defiance, where the men’s anger and pain are transformed into something else entirely.
In the end, Procession isn’t just a film about trauma. It’s a film about what comes after. Not healing, exactly—at least, not in the way we usually think of it.
These men aren’t “fixed” by the end of the documentary. But they’re no longer alone. They’ve found a way to turn their pain into something else, something they can share, something that might, just might, help someone else.
That’s not a small thing. In fact, it might be the most important thing a film can do.
"A raw, emotionally powerful documentary that gives survivors a voice through creative collaboration."
The film takes a deeply personal, healing approach: the survivors' involvement in reenacting their trauma becomes a source of catharsis. It is emotionally heavy and slow-paced, which won't suit everyone, but the authenticity and courage of the participants leave a lasting impact.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Robert Greene’s Procession (2021) isn’t just a documentary—it’s a radical act of collaboration. The film follows six men who survived sexual abuse by Catholic clergy as they work with Greene to stage dramatic reenactments of their trauma. What emerges is a raw, unflinching portrait of healing, latestnetflix.com contends, but the behind-the-scenes process was anything but straightforward.
Greene, known for blending documentary and fiction (Bisbee ’17, Kate Plays Christine), pushed boundaries by having the survivors write and perform scenes based on their experiences. In interviews, he described the process as a way to "unlock deeper truths". The men—Joe Eldred, Mike Foreman, Ed Gavagan, Dan Laurine, Michael Sandridge, and the Trobough brothers—weren’t just subjects; they were co-creators. Greene’s method involved therapy sessions, scriptwriting workshops, and even location scouting at the sites of their abuse.
The result? A film that feels less like traditional documentary and more like a collective exorcism. One standout moment: Eldred, a former altar boy, reenacts his abuse in the same church where it happened, using a child actor as his younger self. The scene is harrowing, but Greene has said the survivors found it cathartic.
The men in Procession weren’t actors—they were survivors first. Their involvement went beyond interviews; they shaped the film’s narrative. Gavagan, a former Marine, used the project to confront his past after decades of silence. Foreman, a father of five, described the process as "like therapy, but with a camera".
The Trobough brothers—Ryan, Terrick, and their sister Vanessa—also participated, highlighting how abuse ripples through families. Their scenes, filmed in their Missouri hometown, underscore the film’s theme of community healing.
Procession premiered at the 2021 Telluride Film Festival and later streamed on Netflix, sparking both acclaim and debate. Some critics praised Greene’s empathetic approach, while others questioned whether reenacting trauma could retraumatize. Greene addressed these concerns, insisting the men were in control of their stories.
The film’s Rotten Tomatoes page lists it as a documentary starring Eldred, Foreman, and Gavagan, but its real stars are the survivors themselves. Their willingness to revisit pain—on their own terms—makes Procession a groundbreaking work.
Procession isn’t just about abuse; it’s about reclaiming agency. Greene’s film blurs the line between documentary and drama, but the real story is how these men turned their trauma into art. As Gavagan put it, "We’re not victims. We’re survivors".
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.