Catherine Cohen
Overview
Put on your pink rhinestone rompers for a sparkling evening of comedy cabaret with Catherine Cohen filmed at the iconic Joe’s Pub in New York City.
Cast
Reviews
3 min readThe Twist? She’s Gorgeous—and That’s the Whole Point
I’ll admit it: I went into Catherine Cohen: The Twist...? She’s Gorgeous expecting a stand-up special with a few musical numbers sprinkled in. What I got instead was something closer to a one-woman Broadway show, if Broadway were run by a woman who treats her own life like a punchline and her own voice like a weapon.
Cohen doesn’t just perform—she performs performance, winking at the audience while somehow also making us feel like we’re in on the joke. The twist isn’t just that she’s gorgeous (though she is, in that effortless, “I woke up like this” way that only people who’ve spent years in front of mirrors can pull off). The twist is that she’s spent her entire career pretending to be the kind of woman who doesn’t know she’s funny, and now she’s letting us in on the con.
This is a special that refuses to sit still. One minute, Cohen is riffing on the absurdity of dating apps (“I swiped right on a guy because his profile said ‘I’m a feminist,’ and then I found out he meant he’s for feminism, like it’s a sports team”). The next, she’s belting out a torch song about her own mediocrity, her voice rich and full-throated, her face a mask of exaggerated despair.
The transitions are so seamless it’s easy to forget this isn’t a traditional stand-up set at all. It’s a cabaret, a confession, a vaudeville act—all rolled into one. And that’s where the polarizing energy comes in.
Audience Opinions
Broad evidence
Audience 6.0/10
"A niche comedy special with sharp wit and musical flair, but its appeal may be limited to fans of Catherine Cohen’s specific brand of humor. Viewers either loved her charm or found the material uneven."
Catherine Cohen’s 2022 Netflix special *The Twist...? She's Gorgeous* is a 61-minute comedy performance blending stand-up, musical numbers, and self-aware storytelling. Directed by Steven Brill, the special leans into Cohen’s background in cabaret and improv, delivering a mix of observational humor and theatrical flair. Audience reactions were polarized: some praised her confidence, quick wit, and ability to turn personal anecdotes into punchlines, while others felt the material lacked consistency or depth. Kinopoisk comments echoed this divide, with a few Russian viewers calling it "funny but not groundbreaking" and others appreciating the musical segments as a standout feature. The special’s runtime was noted as brief, leaving some wanting more substance. latestnetflix.com's take is that overall, it’s a solid but not universally appealing showcase of Cohen’s comedic style.
What viewers praise
- Sharp, self-aware humor Cohen’s writing is witty and meta, with jokes that play on her persona and the absurdity of performance itself. Viewers appreciated her ability to balance vulnerability with humor, particularly in segments about dating and self-image.
- Musical and theatrical elements The special incorporates songs and cabaret-style delivery, which many found refreshing compared to traditional stand-up. Cohen’s musical numbers were highlighted as a unique strength, adding variety to the performance.
- Cohen’s charisma and stage presence Audience members praised her confidence and ability to command the stage, with some calling her "magnetic" and "effortlessly funny." Her energy was cited as a key reason to watch.
Common complaints
- Uneven pacing and material Some viewers felt the special lacked a cohesive throughline, with jokes that didn’t always land or segments that dragged. A few Kinopoisk comments described it as "hit-or-miss," with some bits feeling underdeveloped.
- Niche appeal Cohen’s humor relies heavily on her specific persona and references, which may not resonate with everyone. Some audience members found her style too self-referential or insular, limiting the special’s broader appeal.
- Short runtime At just 61 minutes, the special left some viewers wanting more depth or content. A few Kinopoisk reactions noted it felt "rushed" or "like a teaser for a longer show".
Recommended for
Fans of musical comedy and cabaret-style performances Viewers who enjoy meta, self-aware humor Those who appreciate confident, charismatic female comedians Audiences looking for a light, 60-minute comedy special
Full Plot (Spoilers)
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Buzz & Rumors
Public reportsSteve Brill slid into her Facebook like a spam bot
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_qJVOJ_5Gw
Catherine Cohen thought the message was fake. This was 2019, right before she took The Twist...? She's Gorgeous to Edinburgh. A man named Steve Brill wrote that he had just directed Adam Sandler's Netflix hour and wanted to do another one. She told Allison Kugel she thought, is this spam? Then, this feels too good to be true. They got coffee. Robbie Praw from Netflix walked her Edinburgh run. The offer landed that year. They meant to tape in 2020. latestnetflix.com's read is that they taped in September 2021 at Joe's Pub instead, tests in, live crowd, no masks.Netflix put the hour up on 15 March 2022. 
, 
,
That origin story is funnier than half the specials sitting next to it. Brill already had a relationship with the platform. Cohen already had a five-year cabaret. She first did the show in 2017 at The Duplex in the West Village with pianist Henry Koperski, then a weekly night at Alan Cumming's Club Cumming, then 26 straight Edinburgh dates and a Best Newcomer trophy. Variety printed the credit block when the date dropped. Brill directed and executive produced. Cohen produced with Cait Taylor, Tony Hernandez, John Skidmore, and Seamus Murphy-Mitchell. Koperski stayed on the keys. , ,
The special opens on toddler Catherine in a tutu, yelling that she dances beautiful, then cuts to the 30-year-old in the dressing room. "I feel completely insane, but I look literally stunning." She drops a feather robe onto a hot-pink romper her friend Kelsey Randall covered in 25,000 hand-embroidered rhinestones. Daily Beast caught the Cher, Liza, Britney, Molly Shannon mix. Cohen grew up doing theater in Houston, then sat through Christian high school and youth-group camp in Arkansas, terrified of sex, until college. The trailer sells love, marathons, and burying someone alive. TMDB files it as comedy and music, 1 hour 1 minute. , , ,
The wait sanded off some of the bite
Vulture's critic wrote that the hour has the warmth of a show that improved with time, and that the ideas had lost some of the brittle transgression they had in 2019. The show was largely finished then. The pandemic just sat on the tape. Decider went further and said skip it, a cabaret from a privileged young white woman that felt late. Paste gave it 8 out of 10. Cohen told Glamour UK she knows some people will hate it. If you make something everyone likes, that's embarrassing. She also said the delay let her improvise on the night, and that the afterparty felt like her bar mitzvah and wedding combined. , ,
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
Similar Movies
Related titles ranked by rating and popularity.
