Daniel Roebuck

as Capt. Finn Lombardi

as Jake Bauer

as Reggie Sinclair

as Clayton Carver

as Heinrich Himmler

as Self

as Nick

as Pastor Hopkins

as Mr. Wayman

as Charlie Johnson / Santa Claus

as Dirk

as Harry

as Self

as Russ

as Howard

as Captain Rhodes

as Himself

as Mr. Todd

as Self

as Senator Tobias

as Sherrif John

as Artie • 2 eps

as Norman Peterson • 5 eps

as Ernie Portnoy • 1 eps

as Glenn • 1 eps

as Arnold Walker • 10 eps

as Michael Cordero Sr. • 1 eps

as John Donnelly • 1 eps

as Hamilton G. Skales • 1 eps

as Ed • 1 eps

as B.J. • 4 eps

as Peter Orson • 2 eps

as Dewey Barber • 1 eps

as Director Perkins • 1 eps

as Shadow Man • 22 eps

as Paul Barnes • 1 eps

as Paul Tivnan • 1 eps

as Paul Karofsky • 3 eps

as Joe Silva • 1 eps

as Mr. Condor • 4 eps

as Principal Craig • 1 eps

as Det. Wade • 1 eps

as Josh • 1 eps

as Jeff • 1 eps

as Adam Emerson • 1 eps