Skip to main content
Movie poster for Who Killed Santa? A Murderville Murder Mystery (2022)

Who Killed Santa? A Murderville Murder Mystery

2022
53m
R · English
Director: Laura Murphy
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A holiday-hating detective is forced to solve a murder — and save Christmas — with help from famous trainees who must improv their way through the case.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Improvised Nativity: How Who Killed Santa? Turns a Murder Mystery Into a Christmas Pageant Gone Wrong

I’ve seen Who Killed Santa? A Murderville Murder Mystery three times now, and each viewing leaves me with the same question: Is this a comedy, a crime procedural, or just an elaborate excuse for Will Arnett to wear a terrible sweater and gaslight his friends? The answer, of course, is yes.

All of it. At once. And somehow, that’s the point.

The premise is simple enough: Arnett plays Terry Seattle, a grumpy detective who hates Christmas and is forced to solve the murder of Santa Claus (Sean Hayes, looking like he raided a thrift store’s entire holiday section) with the help of a rotating cast of celebrity "trainees" who don’t know the script. The twist? The entire thing is improvised.

No one—except Arnett and his co-stars Maya Rudolph and Hayes—knows who the killer is, what the clues mean, or even what’s supposed to happen next. It’s like watching a group of very talented people play a game of telephone with a corpse.

Arnett and Rudolph in full detective mode, surrounded by holiday chaos

What makes Who Killed Santa? work (when it works) is the way it turns the mechanics of improv into its own kind of storytelling. There’s a scene early on where Jason Bateman, playing a bumbling elf, is asked to describe the crime scene. Instead of giving a coherent answer, he launches into a rambling, increasingly absurd monologue about Santa’s "suspiciously rosy cheeks" and the possibility that he was "taken out by a reindeer with a grudge."

Arnett, deadpan, keeps prompting him: "And what did you see, Jason?" Bateman’s face cycles through confusion, amusement, and the dawning horror of realizing he has no idea what he’s supposed to say. It’s a masterclass in comedic timing, but it’s also something rarer: a moment where the artifice of performance becomes the story itself.

We’re not just watching a murder mystery; we’re watching people invent a murder mystery in real time.

The best improv comedy feels like eavesdropping on a private joke, and Who Killed Santa? leans into that intimacy. The camera lingers on actors breaking character, laughing at their own mistakes, or visibly struggling to keep a straight face. In one scene, Rudolph—playing a medical examiner with the gravitas of a daytime soap star—delivers a line about "toxic mistletoe" with such conviction that Bateman completely loses it, his shoulders shaking as he tries (and fails) to hold back laughter.

The moment is left in, unedited, and it’s funnier for its rawness. This isn’t polished comedy; it’s the kind of thing that happens when you put a group of friends in a room and tell them to make each other laugh.

But here’s the thing about improv: it’s only as good as the people doing it. And that’s where Who Killed Santa? starts to wobble. The special is structured around three guest stars—Bateman, Pete Davidson, and Tawny Newsome—each taking a turn as Terry’s clueless partner.

Bateman and Newsome (who plays a hyper-competent but equally clueless detective) rise to the occasion, committing fully to the bit and feeding off Arnett’s energy. Davidson, however, feels like he wandered in from a different project entirely. His segment is the shortest, and it shows.

He barely engages with the premise, instead defaulting to a series of half-hearted jokes about his own reputation. When Arnett asks him to name the killer, Davidson shrugs and says, "I don’t know, man. I just got here."

It’s a funny line, but it also feels like a cop-out—a way to avoid actually playing the game.

Bateman as a wide-eyed elf, mid-improv breakdown

The unevenness isn’t just about the guests, though. The special’s biggest flaw is that it never quite decides what it wants to be. Is it a murder mystery?

A holiday special? A showcase for Arnett’s improv skills? The answer, again, is all of the above, but the balance is off.

The mystery itself is thin, more of an excuse to string together a series of comedic set pieces than a compelling whodunnit. The holiday elements—snow, carols, a dead Santa—feel like window dressing, there to justify the special’s existence rather than deepen its themes. And while the improv is often hilarious, there are stretches where it feels like the actors are just spinning their wheels, waiting for the next punchline to land.

That said, there’s something oddly charming about the whole endeavor. Who Killed Santa? isn’t trying to be Knives Out or Die Hard; it’s not even trying to be a "good" episode of Murderville. It’s a holiday special in the truest sense—a messy, imperfect, occasionally brilliant piece of entertainment that feels like it was made by people who were having fun. And in a year where so much holiday content feels focus-grouped into oblivion, that’s its own kind of gift.

The special’s final scene is a microcosm of everything that works and doesn’t. After Davidson’s half-hearted attempt to solve the case, Arnett gathers everyone together for the big reveal. The killer?

Santa’s disgruntled former elf, played by Hayes, who murdered his boss because he was "tired of the gig." It’s a dumb punchline, but the way Arnett delivers it—with the exhausted satisfaction of a man who’s just survived a three-day improv marathon—makes it land. The cast breaks into laughter, the credits roll, and for a brief moment, it feels like we’ve been let in on a secret.

The cast mid-laugh, the case solved, the holiday chaos unresolved

In the end, Who Killed Santa? is less about solving a murder and more about the joy of watching people try (and sometimes fail) to make each other laugh. It’s a reminder that comedy, at its best, is a collaborative act—one that requires trust, spontaneity, and a willingness to look foolish. And if that’s not the spirit of Christmas, I don’t know what is.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.5/10
"A loose, silly holiday whodunit powered by Will Arnett’s improv and Jason Bateman’s deadpan, undercut by uneven guest work and sketch-level roughness."

Improvised chaos, visible corpsing, and a playful mystery format create a goofy, easy-watch Christmas special that can be genuinely hilarious. Will Arnett’s quick-fire riffing and Jason Bateman’s timing carry the laughs, especially if you already enjoy the Murderville format. The improv can feel forced, some guests just giggle or coast through scenes, and the special never quite matches the stronger episodes of the main show.

What viewers praise
  • Will Arnett carries His in-character improv, constant prompting, and ability to stay funny in every situation hold the whole special together.
  • Jason Bateman standout One of the funniest parts, nailing the tone and getting big laughs from his reactions and bits.
  • Genuine improv energy Actors trying not to laugh, breaking character, and reacting in real time give it a loose, infectious feel.
  • Fun dumb holiday vibe Short, stupid, and unserious in a way that works well as a light Christmas mystery you can just relax and enjoy.
Common complaints
  • Weak Pete Davidson turn Barely engages with the premise, breaks scenes, and comes off as too disengaged from the game.
  • Inconsistent guest chemistry Some guest moments rely on childish giggles or overdone accents instead of sharp improv, dragging down otherwise strong setups.
  • Feels like rough improv class Stretches of the special resemble try-hard improv exercises, with heavy prompting and jokes that do not quite land.
  • Below series high points Not as tight or satisfying as the better regular Murderville episodes.
Recommended for
Improv comedy enjoyers Murderville completionists Will Arnett devotees Jason Bateman comedy fans Casual holiday mystery watchers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Who Killed Santa? And Who Killed the Vibe? The Real-Life Tea Behind Murderville’s Messiest Christmas

A dead Santa, three clueless celebs, and one totally unhinged detective… but the real crime is how much chaotic gossip was hiding behind Netflix’s improv holiday special Who Killed Santa? A Murderville Murder Mystery (2022). From fan-outrage over Pete Davidson to crew members laughing so hard it made the final cut, latestnetflix.com contends, consider this your naughty-list dossier.


On-Set Drama & Chaos

Shot like a festive hostage situation

The Christmas special was green-lit in late June 2022 and shot in just two and a half days in September, with the team racing to lock a cut by early November to hit the holiday window. Showrunner Krister Johnson openly described the vibe as a “surprise party” and “a train that is barely staying on the tracks and occasionally hops right off”. Translation: everyone was improvising for real, including the schedule.

The laughter they didn’t edit out

Fans on Reddit clocked something rare for a Netflix production: you can literally hear crew members losing it during takes. In particular, when Jason Bateman confidently offers “suicide” as his theory of what happened to Santa, “you can hear the crew in the back laughing” on the actual audio. Instead of smoothing it over, production left the chaos in, which only made the special feel more like barely controlled live theater.

“How can I humiliate Jason Bateman and call it a Christmas special?”

One highly upvoted Reddit comment framed Will Arnett’s whole pitch as: “how can i completely humiliate jason bateman and disguise it as a christmas special?”. While that’s fan snark, it does line up with how often Bateman is the butt of the bit—getting dragged through cat gags, fake accents, and relentless riffing from Arnett and Maya Rudolph.


Cast Feuds & Tea (Mostly Friendly… Mostly)

Bateman vs. The improv gauntlet

Fans were shocked by how hard Jason Bateman committed. He’s known more for dry, controlled performances, but Reddit praised him for being “really killed it with the commitment” and noted he broke character less than almost anyone. One viewer joked the episode felt like Will Arnett’s personal mission to torture his Smartless co-host on camera.

Pete Davidson: the controversial closer

If the special has a villain in fandom lore, it’s not the murderer—it’s Pete Davidson. In threads about the episode, multiple viewers said the whole thing was “hysterical… but the ending almost ruined it for me,” specifically blaming Pete’s late arrival. - He appears only at the end, with zero context, and is suddenly asked to solve the case. - Fans dragged his improv chops, calling him “awful” and saying he laughed too much through scenes. - One comment referenced writer Krister Johnson mentioning Pete being sequestered in his trailer for four hours before filming—fuel for speculation that integrating him was a production headache. None of this is confirmed on the record, but in fan circles, the “Pete ruined the ending” narrative is very much canon.


Romance & Real-Life Connections

The Smartless triangle: Jason, Will, and… the dead Santa

The murdered Santa, Johnny Blaze, is played by Sean Hayes—who in real life co-hosts the Smartless podcast with Will Arnett and Jason Bateman. Redditors gleefully pointed out that Bateman was investigating the “death” of his own real-life podcast co-host. It turned the whodunnit into a weird meta in-joke: Arnett essentially staged a Christmas homicide for his best friend.

Will Arnett’s emotional baggage era

Around the time Murderville was launching, Arnett was publicly talking about the emotional fallout of his divorce from Amy Poehler, admitting in one interview that he “cried for an hour” during a particularly rough moment. While not directly tied to Who Killed Santa?, fans on the Murderville subreddit referenced that profile when discussing how Arnett throws himself into these absurd, high-energy projects with close friends—like Bateman and Hayes—as a kind of creative therapy.


Scandals, Controversies & Fan Backlash

The Ending That Broke Christmas

The big discourse: should Pete Davidson have even been in the special? - Some fans loved the surprise cameo. - Many others felt the “mystery” format broke when Pete, who’d seen nothing, was forced to name the killer, calling it “unfair” and “a gimmick that undercut everything Bateman and Rudolph built”. - One user said the episode was great “but the ending almost ruined it for me”.

Who’s laughing now? (Answer: still Maya Rudolph)

Maya Rudolph’s absolute refusal to stay serious became part of the legend. Her outbursts—like screaming “How the fuck was I supposed to know that?”—were celebrated by fans as the moments where the already thin line between actor and character completely evaporated. Netflix later leaned into this by promoting reels of Rudolph openly cracking up on set.


Leaks, Bloopers & Wild Trivia

Bloopers that confirm nobody was in control

Netflix’s official blooper reel shows Will Arnett, Jason Bateman, Maya Rudolph, Pete Davidson and more constantly breaking, corpsing, and derailing scenes. Sean Hayes, in full Santa gear, can’t stop laughing at his own death scenario, which fans cited as proof that even the “corpse” couldn’t keep it together.

The four-camera improv trap

Behind-the-scenes coverage notes that the special was shot with four handheld cameras to catch every spontaneous reaction. Cast members were basically trapped in a 360° improv surveillance dome—no angle to hide a break, no chance to reset without everyone seeing.

Cat gags, Italian cops & MacGruber deep cuts

Fans singled out:

  • Bateman’s running cat bit, including an instinctive move to “lick” an actress’s leg, as peak unhinged improv. - Maya Rudolph’s alter ego “Donna Foccacias,” complete with over-the-top accent and the line “Olive Garden, when you’re here you’re family,” becoming an instant fandom favorite. - Her shout of “50 Seconds, MacGruber!” as the kind of hyper-specific comedy-nerd reference you’d never see in a scripted Christmas movie.

Marshawn Lynch, the improv MVP

Fans lit up when Marshawn Lynch popped up to help solve the case, with one beloved moment where he recognizes Bateman mid-scene as “the dude from Ozark!”—a completely organic break in the fiction that everyone gleefully rolled with.


In the end, Who Killed Santa? didn’t just stab a jolly icon with a candy cane—it sliced open a very specific kind of Hollywood chaos: best friends roasting each other on Netflix’s dime, a polarizing late-arriving comedian, and a crew laughing so loudly they accidentally became part of the cast.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.