Skip to main content
Movie poster for What If? (2023)

What If?

2023
1h 52m
R · Filipino
Director: Manny Palo
Search on Netflix

Overview

When a pair of newlywed musicians get trapped in a storm on their island honeymoon, they must face difficult truths that could tear their marriage apart.

Cast

10 people

Reviews

3 min read

The Storm Inside the Screen

There’s a particular kind of dread that comes with realizing you’re stuck beside the wrong person. It rarely arrives in some dramatic burst. More often it seeps in through small things: a joke that lands wrong, a glance that never comes back, or, in Manny Palo’s What If?, the endless little chirp of a phone notification.

I sat down expecting a familiar honeymoon-gone-bad thriller, the sort where nature corners a couple and forces the truth out of them. What I got was something messier, sometimes sharper, latestnetflix.com contends, and often frustrating: a portrait of a marriage slowly choking while strangers watch from their screens.

Palo makes a choice early that I’m still not sure I buy. He begins at the end. Billie (Alessandra de Rossi) is already alone on a grey beach, drained by a decision the film hasn’t caught us up to yet, before the story snaps back to the bright, overripe colors of the relationship’s beginning.

It’s a recognizable move. (Maybe too recognizable.) By starting with the aftermath, the film turns us into detectives sifting through a collapse instead of letting us live inside the romance as it curdles. The trouble is that the clues aren’t exactly delicate.

As Film Fugitives correctly noted in their review, "The audience keeps wondering how the situation changed so drastically... but it fails to make much of an impact."

A tense moment between the couple against a tropical backdrop

Jecs (JM de Guzman), a famous musician, and Billie, his keyboardist-turned-wife, arrive on Panglao Island for their honeymoon, and the intrusion starts almost instantly. Jecs cannot stop performing himself. He vlogs the "perfect" trip for his fans as if the vacation isn’t real until it’s framed on his screen.

Palo handles that tension well. The island is shot wide and lush, while Jecs' phone traps everything inside a cramped vertical frame. The actual storm hasn’t rolled in yet, but their room already feels short on air.

The whole movie more or less rests on Alessandra de Rossi, and she carries it. She’s been proving for years that she can hold these bruised, interior roles together, and here she says more by tightening her jaw than other actors manage with pages of dialogue. There’s one scene in the middle that sticks hard.

Jecs is on a video call with his overbearing mother, who keeps pressing them about children even though she knows Billie has premature ovarian failure. Over the cheap phone speaker, the mother casually calls Billie "barren."

The storm closes in on the isolated honeymoon resort

Look at De Rossi there. No shouting, no smashed glass, no big release. Her shoulders sink just slightly, and her eyes go flat with a tired kind of hurt that feels horribly familiar.

But the scene cuts deepest because of Jecs. He laughs. He laughs with his mother to smooth things over.

De Guzman doesn’t play it as cruelty exactly, which makes it worse. It’s cowardice so automatic it barely registers to him. In that instant Billie understands the real problem.

This isn’t only about a difficult mother-in-law. She has married a man who will protect his own comfort before he protects her.

Even so, the script keeps stepping on its own best material. The back half slips into the same argument patterns and overinsistent flashbacks, and the tension the actors are building starts to thin out. We didn’t need the literal typhoon that finally traps them together to know the marriage was already coming apart.

The external storm plays like an obvious metaphor pasted onto a drama that had already found a more interesting one indoors.

I wanted to admire What If? more than I actually did. There’s a sharp idea buried in it about modern love as performance, about the way "couple goals" can cover up something rotten underneath. De Rossi’s quiet devastation nearly carries the whole thing by itself.

But in the end, the film winds up resembling Jecs' social feed: polished enough to catch your eye, thinner than it first appears once you get close.

Audience Opinions

Audience 5.1/10
"A scenic marital drama with committed acting that gets buried under weak chemistry, dragging pace, and messy relationship conflicts."

Striking island locations, attractive underwater shots, and a decent original soundtrack are the most enjoyable aspects, and Alessandra de Rossi carries much of the emotional weight. The romance rarely feels convincing—the couple’s interactions come off as toxic and exhausting rather than moving—and the story stretches a simple premise into a long, repetitive cycle of arguments. Visually engaging but ultimately boring, directionless, and emotionally unsatisfying.

What viewers praise
  • Scenic island visuals The island setting and especially the underwater shots are beautiful and among the few consistently enjoyable elements.
  • Committed lead performance Alessandra de Rossi is compelling and watchable—enough that some continue mainly for her performance.
  • Solid original soundtrack Original songs and the overall music track fit the film’s mood and musician characters well.
Common complaints
  • Lack of romantic spark Despite both leads being capable actors, the central couple has little to no chemistry, undercutting the romance.
  • Slow, meandering pacing The nearly two-hour runtime feels stretched, with long stretches of arguments and little narrative drive making it a tedious watch.
  • Irritating character behavior Jecs and his overbearing mother are major red flags and sources of frustration, with humiliating and manipulative moments that sour the experience.
  • Overloaded yet shallow drama Heavy themes like infertility, childhood trauma, and marital conflict are piled on through endless fights but explored in a way that feels repetitive and emotionally thin.
  • Messy overall execution The relationship conflicts and storm metaphor are clumsily handled, leaving the film feeling simply messy and a waste of time.
Recommended for
Philippine romance-drama collectors Alessandra de Rossi devotees Island-set chamber dramas Visually driven relationship stories

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

She built a lockdown honeymoon. Netflix Philippines put it on top.

Alessandra de Rossi told reporters the trap started in the pandemic. Everybody locked in the house, going a little mad. Then, she said, lock a couple on their honeymoon with nowhere to run. Interaksyon ran those quotes after What If? Sat as the top movie on Netflix Philippines. She produces through A World of Our Own with Viva Films' Vincent del Rosario III and Veronique del Rosario-Corpus. She also takes a story credit. Mike G. Rivera wrote the screenplay. Emmanuel Quindo Palo directed. JM de Guzman plays newlywed musician Jecs. She plays Billie. Netflix dated the drop 7 September 2023. latestnetflix.com's view is that Rotten Tomatoes lists 1 hour 52 minutes and a Filipino original.The US title page rates it TV-MA.,,,

Panglao in the dialogue. Siruma on the call sheet.

Interaksyon placed the honeymoon in Camarines Sur. Ready Steady Cut walked the map. Early scenes name Panglao Island in the Bohol Sea, then a guide on a pier and a cabin reached by more than 300 steps. Credits also thank Angeles City in Pampanga, Alaminos in Pangasinan, and San Ramon in Siruma, Camarines Sur. IMDb files those three shoot sites. Chard Ocampo is billed third as Will. Jett Pangan, frontman of The Dawn, appears as Enrico Neri. Netflix sold the film as Filipino music, drama, and marriage, with English subs on. The island is the hook. The gossip is whether two musicians still like each other when the weather deletes the exit.,,,

Philstar Life said Netflix posted the trailer on 10 August. Jecs films the trip like a vlog, which already bothers Billie. He tells her, through tears, that she helped him become a better man and that she will not be alone. She holds a dead plant and says she cannot take care of anything. "I can't even give what you want, how can you call that perfect?" Jecs wanted the truth and did not expect it to hurt. A year earlier she had posted three scripts on Instagram, tagged JM and Palo, and wrote "Wala na! Na-post na! Walang atrasan!" After release she called JM a take-one actor who already knew the role.,,,

Rotten Tomatoes collected four critic notices and they were not kind. Decider's John Serba wrote that even viewers who chase Asian romances would find it too bland. Ready Steady Cut's Romey Norton scored 1.5 out of 5 and said nearly two hours of drama were not compelling. Common Sense Media gave 2 out of 5. Bangkok Post liked some of the island weather and still called the story uninteresting. Nobody leaked a payday. The column was a Kita Kita star turning a quarantine thought into a Viva-Netflix honeymoon, topping the local chart, then watching English-language notices shrug. The official trailer is still on Netflix Philippines' YouTube.,,

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.