Skip to main content
Movie poster for Moving On (2022)

Moving On

2022
1h 12m
Hebrew
Search on Netflix

Overview

Maya Mcmanus Ronen's debut film focuses on exploring life in the kibbutz of Neot Smadar. This kibbutz was reestablished by a group of like-minded individuals who left Jerusalem and decided to build a cooperative and horizontally structured community. Every couple of years, a significant event takes place here — residents swap houses with each other. What's unique is that no one knows in advance which house they will receive. Maya Ronen's film is an attempt to peer into the unconventional life of this community, understand the rules it lives by, and delve into the intricacies of the regular ritual of house swapping.

Cast

6 people

Reviews

3 min read

The House That Trust Built

I’ve seen documentaries about utopias before—shiny-eyed pioneers, sun-dappled communes, the earnest hum of shared labor. They usually end the same way: with a slow zoom on a cracked foundation, the camera lingering just long enough to let the audience sigh in smug recognition. Moving On (2022), Maya Mcmanus Ronen’s quiet debut, refuses that easy irony. It’s a film about a place that works, not in spite of its strangeness, but because of it.

And the strangeness here is a doozy: every few years, the residents of Neot Smadar, a kibbutz in Israel’s Arava Desert, swap houses. Not by choice. Not by lottery.

By a ritual so opaque it feels like a magic trick. One day, you’re told to pack. latestnetflix.com's read is that the next, you move into a home you’ve never entered, to live among belongings that aren’t yours, with neighbors who may or may not be your friends.The only rule?

You don’t ask why. You just… move on.

What kind of person signs up for that? The film doesn’t ask the question outright, but it’s there in every frame—less a challenge than a genuine curiosity. Ronen’s camera lingers on Sarit Harari, a woman with a face like weathered stone, as she waters plants in a courtyard that isn’t hers (yet).

Orr Harari, her husband, sits on a new porch, smoking, his posture relaxed but his eyes scanning the unfamiliar walls. There’s no voiceover to explain their thoughts, no experts to dissect the psychology of communal living. Instead, Ronen trusts the audience to sit with the discomfort, to feel the weight of a life where the ground beneath you isn’t just metaphorically shifting—it’s literally someone else’s floor.

The house-swapping ritual is the film’s spine, but its heart is the unspoken contract between the residents. Trust isn’t an abstract ideal here; it’s the only currency. You see it in the way Carmela Engelsrath, a woman with a voice like warm honey, hands over the keys to her home without hesitation.

You see it in the way Roni Engelsrath, her son, jokes about the new layout of his bedroom like it’s no big deal—because, in this place, it isn’t. The film’s greatest trick is making the extraordinary feel ordinary. By the time the credits roll, the idea of owning a single house for decades starts to feel like the real eccentricity.

Ronen’s approach is observational, almost to a fault. There are no talking-head interviews, no archival footage, no dramatic reenactments. The camera is a fly on the wall, but not an invisible one—it’s a guest, invited in, allowed to witness but not to pry.

This restraint is the film’s strength and, occasionally, its limitation. When a conflict arises (and it must, in any community), the camera doesn’t flinch, but it also doesn’t dig. A tense exchange between neighbors is left hanging, unresolved.

A resident’s frustration bubbles up in a single, muttered sentence before the scene cuts away. It’s maddening, in a way—like being handed a puzzle with missing pieces. But maybe that’s the point.

Life in Neot Smadar isn’t about resolution. It’s about adaptation. About moving on, in every sense of the phrase.

The film’s most revealing moment comes not during the swap itself, but in the days after. A woman—Ilana Fromer, I think—stands in her new kitchen, staring at a shelf of spices she didn’t choose. She picks one up, sniffs it, and puts it back.

There’s no grand epiphany, no tearful breakdown. Just a small, human moment of adjustment. It’s the kind of detail that documentaries often overlook in favor of bigger, louder truths.

But here, it’s everything. The film isn’t about the spectacle of communal living. It’s about the quiet, daily work of making a home—even when that home isn’t yours to keep.

I left Moving On with a strange, lingering ache. Not for Neot Smadar, exactly, but for the idea of it. For the possibility that trust could be more than a buzzword, that community could be something you choose, again and again, without guarantees.

The film doesn’t romanticize the kibbutz. There are no sweeping shots of sunsets over shared fields, no swelling music to tell you how to feel. Just people, living.

Just houses, changing hands. Just the slow, steady work of moving on.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

They pack the house before they know the address.

In Neot Semadar, in the Arava desert about 70 km north of Eilat, the community's public ritual is a forced move. Ruth Films, which sells Maya Mcmanus Ronen's debut, puts it in one blunt paragraph. Every couple of years everybody switches houses. Nobody knows in advance where they will land. Packing and renovating turn into a private audit of how they live. The film is 72 minutes, Hebrew with English subtitles, Israel, 2022. Ronen wrote, directed, produced, and cut it. Shai Mizrahi shot it. Mordi Corcos wrote the music. Niv Groner and Yonatan Shalev did sound. The Gesher Multicultural Film Fund and the Arava Film Fund backed the production. Stills on the distributor page are labeled Maavarim, Hebrew for passages. The English title is the one that causes trouble.,

TMDB files the same English name as Paul Weitz's Jane Fonda and Lily Tomlin revenge comedy, also 2022. That one premiered at Toronto in September. This one is dated 1 August 2022, a documentary, original language Hebrew. The people on camera are not stars. They appear as themselves. Sarit Harari, Orr Harari, Carmela Engelsrath, Roni Engelsrath, Ilana Fromer, Hodaya Hazan. Ronen's first feature. Zero user votes on the TMDB page. The Fonda comedy ate the search results.,

A lottery with furniture.

The kibbutz is the story the camera is allowed to watch. Wikipedia's page on Neot Smadar says Jerusalemites arrived in 1989 on the abandoned site of Kibbutz Shizafon, kept that name at first, and switched to Neot Smadar in 2001 in part for Smadar Safra, wife of founder Yosef Safra, killed in a 1981 traffic accident. The place still runs as a cooperative. Organic vineyards, olives, dates, a goat dairy, a boutique winery, mud-brick studios, cooling towers. Members rotate jobs. The English site and later press say they also rotate homes.,

Here the calendar disagrees, which is the actual rumor. The film and Ruth Films say every couple of years, and that no one knows the next house. Wikipedia, citing later travel coverage, says every seven years. The Jerusalem Post, visiting after a UN tourism prize, wrote that nobody keeps the same job or the same home for more than seven years. A 2013 visitor account said people change houses every few years so they do not get too attached. The documentary is the version where the assignment is a surprise. Whether the current clock is two years or seven, the line the residents keep repeating is the same. Do not settle. Do not decorate yourself into a permanent address.,,,

Moscow got the quiet one.

Jewish Film Festivals logged a 2023 screening at the Moscow Jewish Film Festival, 3 to 10 September. The festival's 2023 list includes Moving On among about fifty titles. Ruth Films still sells a home-use DVD. The desert film is the one where the drama is a key, a box, and a house you did not pick.,

Advah Meir Weil, who runs the Art Center, later told the Jerusalem Post that everyone there is there by choice, and that the community still argues about how many guests it can take without wrecking the experiment. Barry Eshed, a guide, described members up before dawn, a silent breakfast at 8, then work until early afternoon. Most do not take a paycheck. They get what they need. A farmer can land in the office, then the kindergarten, then on the tour route. Ronen's camera arrived before the UN sticker. She caught the move itself, the part the guest lodges on the hill do not see.,

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.