Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Book Club Murders (2024)

The Book Club Murders

2024
1h 30m
English
Director: Logan Giese
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Natalie joins a book club to regain normalcy after tragedies in her life. However, things take a dark turn when members of the book club start receiving threats.

Trailer

Cast

12 people

Reviews

3 min read

The Book Club That Kills the Fun

I went into The Book Club Murders expecting the guilty pleasure Lifetime has perfected: over-the-top acting, a plot that unravels like a cheap sweater, and just enough camp to be fun. What I got was a film that can't decide between cozy mystery and full-blown thriller, and ends up feeling like neither. It's not terrible, and it's not good.

It's a book club meeting where everyone forgot to read the book and pretends they did.

A dimly lit bookstore, shelves of books casting long shadows, as a woman in the foreground clutches a threatening note.

The premise is promising. Natalie (Brittany Underwood), a mother rebuilding her life after a house fire and a series of tragedies, joins a local book club to reconnect with her daughter, Gwen (Eva Igo), and find some normalcy. The club, led by the warm, slightly eccentric Wendy (Ainsley Burch), seems the perfect escape until its members start receiving anonymous threats, and the cozy gatherings become a hunt for a killer hiding in plain sight.

The execution is about as subtle as a sledgehammer wrapped in a bow.

Logan Giese, who wrote and directed, clearly likes the material, but his script doesn't trust the audience. The dialogue is clunky, at times laughable, and the exposition so heavy that characters seem to be reciting summaries of their own lives. Early on, Natalie and Gwen sit in a diner, and Gwen, supposedly a teenager, delivers a monologue about their strained relationship that sounds written by a therapist.

It's painfully on-the-nose. (I half-expected someone to turn to the camera and announce the foreshadowing.)

The bigger sin is that the film builds no real tension. For a thriller it's surprisingly tame, the stakes never high enough and the mystery so predictable I guessed the killer within twenty minutes. A few moments land, notably a clever asphyxiation murder shot in a single continuous take, the one time the film seems to be trying to be clever.

But such flashes are quickly undermined by fight choreography that looks rehearsed for ten minutes and editing gaps that feel like leftover commercial breaks.

The performances are mixed, with bright spots. Underwood, a soap veteran from One Life to Live, brings a melodramatic energy that suits the film's heightened reality, and a sincerity that keeps Natalie from caricature. Burch's Wendy has a warmth and charisma that make her the book club's most compelling presence, and it's easy to see why Natalie is drawn to her.

The rest of the cast is largely forgettable, some so stiff they seem to be reading cue cards.

Most frustrating is that the ingredients for something engaging were there. The focus on platonic female friendship, especially between Natalie and Wendy, is a refreshing change from the usual romantic subplots. When Wendy confesses to Natalie that she's been lonely, the film briefly seems ready to say something about connection and isolation.

Then it cuts away to the same tired tropes, as if afraid to commit to its emotional core.

Reception has been lukewarm at best. Common Sense Media gave it 1/5, calling it "unsatisfying" and "all talk," which is fair: the exposition repeats and the mystery feels like boxes being ticked. Bloody Disgusting was more generous at 3/5, praising the "great over-the-top killer reveal" and Burch's performance.

The reveal could work in a campier, more self-aware film, but here it lands like a punchline in a movie that forgot to set up the joke.

Near the end, Natalie reflects that the book club was supposed to be a fresh start and brought only more chaos. The line could have been poignant if the film had earned it. The Book Club Murders is the airport paperback you pick up for its cover, only to realize halfway through that you've already read it, and it wasn't great the first time.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.2/10
"A lightweight thriller with a promising premise that struggles to deliver enough tension or depth."

The cozy mystery setup—a book club unraveling dark secrets—hooks interest, but execution often feels predictable and short on suspense. Cast performances are decent but not enough to elevate the thin plot, leaving more of a missed opportunity than a gripping whodunit.

What viewers praise
  • Engaging premise A book club targeted by anonymous threats and dark secrets is intriguing and hooks initial interest.
  • Decent performances Lead actors, particularly Brittany Underwood, give believable portrayals of the book club members.
  • Cozy mystery vibe Small-town, book-club setting is a refreshing backdrop for lighthearted thrillers.
Common complaints
  • Predictable plot Follows familiar thriller tropes, making twists easy to guess early.
  • Lacks tension Fails to build enough suspense or stakes to stay fully engaged.
  • Thin character development Supporting characters are underdeveloped; book club members feel more like archetypes than real people.
  • Weak payoff Resolution is anticlimactic rather than satisfying or surprising.
Recommended for
Cozy mystery fans Light thriller enthusiasts Brittany Underwood admirers Weekend TV movie watchers

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

They shot the poison-pen movie in a real bookstore on Lake Superior

Producer Keely Kemp told Mix 108 that The Book Club Murders was filmed mostly in Duluth and Hermantown, plus the Back Forty Bookstore in Two Harbors. She also said the production leaned on Minnesota talent and crew. Writer-director Logan Giese is from that scene. latestnetflix.com's read is that Eva Igo and Aaron Goehle share top billing with Brittany Underwood.Lifetime played the picture in October 2024. Kemp said October 1, 2025, was the Netflix debut.

That is a local-industry story first. The twist ending can wait. Underwood, known from One Life to Live and Hollywood Heights, plays Natalie Johnson, a woman who joins a book club at the local shop after a fire that took her home and killed her husband, and after the disappearance of her daughter Gwen's best friend. Members start getting letters that dump their secrets. Recipients start dying. The author signs as "Aletheia." Lifetime's own copy says Gwen is the next target. Mix 108 uses Johnston for the last name. Lifetime and Rotten Tomatoes use Johnson. Either way, the daughter is fifteen in the trailer copy.,,

The official trailer, posted by Logan Toxic, dates the LMN airing to October 3 at 8 p.m. Eastern and slots the picture into the network's 2024 Shocktober lineup. The logline on that clip is nastier than the poster. One letter arrives "falsely accusing her 15-year-old daughter of a heinous crime." Underwood's Natalie has to clear the kid's name or lose her. Runtime listings sit around 90 minutes. Giese wrote and directed.,

The ending is the thing people argue about

Rotten Tomatoes has almost no critic pile. The snippet that stuck says Giese cuts back and forth between adult and teen storylines, that the plot is "slightly convoluted," and that "the killer reveal (and accompanying over the top performance) makes for a great ending." That is a reviewer's take, not a leaked finale. Treat it as rumor if you have not watched. It is also the only widely quoted verdict, which is why it keeps getting copied.

There is no confirmed on-set feud in the trades. What is confirmed is the geography. A Minnesota writer-director, a Duluth-area shoot, a Two Harbors bookstore as the club's nest, and a Lifetime Saturday slot that Netflix later treated as catalog bait. If you came looking for Hollywood screaming matches, this is not that file. The noise is a northern Minnesota crew getting a national window twice, a year apart, on a mystery that sells letters, secrets, and a kid in the crosshairs.,

Giese's own trailer post called it a feature on LMN and asked for shares. Kemp's Netflix-day note called it a village production. Those are the quotes that exist. The rest of the chatter, about budget theatrics or an intentional camp villain, has no named source beyond that one Rotten Tomatoes line. Print the Duluth locations. Print the Shocktober slot. Leave the killer's performance for people who sat through the last reel.,,

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.