Skip to main content
Movie poster for You Gotta Have Faith (2025)

You Gotta Have Faith

2025
1h 27m
Portuguese
Director: Tomás Fleck
Search on Netflix

Overview

After twenty years running a parish with more debt than parishioners, Father Steve ends up officiating the wedding of his high school sweetheart, Isabel. But when the groom bolts, Isabel is left homeless – and Steve takes her in, with one catch: only nuns are allowed to live in the church. What starts as a holy disguise soon stirs up old feelings, and Steve must choose between his vows to God… and his heart.

Cast

8 people

Reviews

7 min read

The Cassock and the Confession

I kept waiting for the punchline. Not the one in the script—the one about how a Brazilian romantic comedy about a priest falling for his high school sweetheart while she’s disguised as a nun could possibly work without collapsing into either sacrilege or schmaltz. But You Gotta Have Faith (or Os Infiéis, which translates more bluntly to The Unfaithful) doesn’t just avoid those pitfalls; it sidesteps them with the kind of grace that feels almost miraculous in a genre often content to coast on easy laughs and easier resolutions.

A dimly lit church interior, where Father Steve stands at the altar, his face half in shadow, half illuminated by the stained-glass light filtering through the windows.

The film opens with Father Steve (Rafael Pimenta) delivering a sermon to a congregation of exactly three people—two elderly women and a very bored-looking altar boy. The parish is drowning in debt, the roof leaks, and the bishop’s solution is to shut it down unless Steve can prove it’s viable. Enter Isabel (Luciana Paes), Steve’s high school sweetheart, whose wedding he’s strong-armed into officiating as a last-ditch fundraising effort.

When the groom bolts mid-ceremony, Isabel is left homeless, and Steve, in a moment of either divine inspiration or sheer desperation, offers her shelter. The catch? Only nuns are allowed to live in the church.

Cue the habit.

What follows isn’t just a farce about mistaken identities or a rom-com about rekindled love, though it has elements of both. Instead, You Gotta Have Faith becomes something rarer: a film about the quiet, daily negotiations of faith—not the grand, theological kind, but the kind that happens when a man who’s spent two decades in a cassock realizes he’s still just a guy who once slow-danced with a girl in a high school gym.

The brilliance of Tomás Fleck’s script (co-written with Lucas Abrahão, Luciana Paes, and Rafael Pimenta) is that it never treats Steve’s crisis of faith as a punchline. His struggle isn’t played for laughs; it’s the emotional core of the film, the thing that gives the comedy its weight.

Take the scene where Isabel, now posing as Sister Maria, helps Steve prepare for a baptism. The baby fusses, the parents are nervous, and Steve, flustered, keeps dropping the holy water. Isabel steps in, smoothly taking over, and for a moment, the two of them move in sync—her hands guiding his, their shoulders brushing.

It’s a small moment, but it’s electric. The camera lingers just long enough to let you feel the tension, the history between them, the way two people who once knew each other’s bodies as well as their own can still recognize the shape of a shared past in the way a hand hovers over a font. The humor isn’t in the situation; it’s in the way Steve’s face betrays him, the way his voice cracks when he tries to bless the baby.

He’s not a buffoon. He’s a man trying to do the right thing and failing, over and over, in ways that are both absurd and deeply human.

Isabel, dressed in a nun’s habit, stands in the church courtyard, her expression caught between amusement and something more complicated—nostalgia, maybe, or regret.

The film’s tone is a high-wire act, and Fleck, in his feature debut, walks it with surprising confidence. There’s a moment early on where Steve, trying to explain why he became a priest, says, “I thought it would be easier than being a regular person.” It’s a throwaway line, but it lands because it’s true. The film understands that faith, for many, isn’t about certainty—it’s about the search for something stable in a life that keeps shifting beneath your feet.

Steve’s parish is a mess, his congregation is dwindling, and his own heart is a minefield. But the film never mocks him for it. Instead, it treats his struggles with a kind of tender seriousness, the way you’d treat a friend who’s just admitted they don’t know what they’re doing.

This is where Luciana Paes and Rafael Pimenta shine. Paes, in particular, is a revelation. Isabel could have been a manic pixie dream nun, all quips and no depth, but Paes gives her a quiet resilience that grounds the film.

When she’s not in the habit, she’s just a woman trying to figure out her next move—humiliated by her runaway groom, broke, and suddenly dependent on the one man she never expected to see again. There’s a scene where she’s sitting in the church kitchen, eating a sandwich, and Steve walks in. She doesn’t say anything.

She just looks at him, and the look says everything: I can’t believe I’m back here. I can’t believe you’re still here. Paes plays it with such restraint that you can almost see the years between them, the life she’s lived without him, the choices she’s made. It’s the kind of performance that makes you lean forward in your seat, not because she’s doing anything flashy, but because she’s doing something far harder: she’s being real.

Pimenta, meanwhile, has the unenviable task of playing a priest who’s not a caricature. He’s not the bumbling Father Ted type, nor is he the saintly, untouchable figure of more serious religious dramas. He’s just a guy who took a vow and is now realizing that vows, like people, are complicated.

Pimenta’s background in improv comedy (he’s a staple of Brazil’s Porta dos Fundos collective) serves him well here. There’s a physicality to his performance, a way of holding his body that suggests both the weight of his role and the lightness of his spirit. When he’s delivering a sermon, he stands tall, his voice steady, but when he’s alone with Isabel, his posture loosens, his shoulders slump just a little.

It’s as if the cassock itself is a costume he’s forgotten how to wear.

The supporting cast is hit-or-miss. Leandro Firmino, best known for his role as Li’l Zé in City of God, shows up as a gruff but kind-hearted parishioner, and while his presence adds a layer of grit to the film’s otherwise light tone, his character feels underdeveloped. The same goes for the rest of the ensemble—there are glimpses of interesting dynamics, but they’re never fully explored.

It’s a shame, because the world of the film feels rich enough to support more than just its two leads. The church itself is almost a character, with its peeling paint and flickering candles, its quiet corners where secrets can fester. You get the sense that Fleck knows this world intimately, that he’s drawn from real places and real people.

But the film doesn’t always trust its audience to linger in those spaces long enough to feel their texture.

Father Steve and Isabel sit on a bench outside the church, the late afternoon sun casting long shadows. They’re not looking at each other, but the space between them feels charged, like a question neither is ready to answer.

Where You Gotta Have Faith stumbles is in its pacing. The middle act drags, weighed down by a subplot involving a rival love interest (Paula Silvestre) that feels tacked on, as if the filmmakers worried the central romance wasn’t enough to sustain the story. It’s not that the subplot is bad—it’s just unnecessary.

The film’s emotional core is already so strong, so specific, that it doesn’t need the extra clutter. When it finally sheds these distractions and returns to Steve and Isabel, it regains its footing, but the detour feels like a lack of faith in its own material.

That’s the thing about this film, though: it’s not afraid to ask big questions, even if it doesn’t always have the answers. What does it mean to be faithful—to a person, to an institution, to God? Is it possible to love someone and still choose something else?

Steve’s crisis isn’t just about Isabel; it’s about the life he’s built, the promises he’s made, and whether those promises still mean anything in a world that’s moved on without him. The film doesn’t offer easy resolutions. Instead, it lets its characters sit with their doubts, their regrets, their small, stubborn hopes.

In a genre that often treats love as a problem to be solved, You Gotta Have Faith treats it as something messier, something that doesn’t always fit neatly into the boxes we build for it.

I keep thinking about that scene in the church kitchen, the one where Isabel and Steve don’t say anything. There’s a moment like that in every great romantic comedy—the moment where the characters realize they’re not just playing roles anymore, that the story they’ve been telling themselves (and each other) isn’t enough. It’s the moment where the mask slips, even just for a second, and you see the person underneath. You Gotta Have Faith is full of those moments.

They’re not grand gestures. They’re not even particularly dramatic. But they’re real.

And in a genre that often mistakes noise for emotion, that’s something like a miracle.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.9/10
"A heartfelt but uneven romantic comedy that struggles to balance its spiritual themes with humor."

The film's exploration of faith and love lands through sincere performances and emotional moments. The blend of comedy and drama often feels forced, with a script that wants tighter construction and more consistent pacing. Lead chemistry is frequently praised, but supporting characters and plot twists come off underdeveloped or clichéd.

What viewers praise
  • Strong lead performances Luciana Paes and Rafael Pimenta deliver compelling and emotionally grounded portrayals that anchor the film.
  • Thoughtful themes The exploration of faith, duty, and love adds depth to the romantic comedy framework.
  • Heartfelt moments Several scenes strike an authentic emotional chord, particularly those focusing on personal sacrifice and redemption.
Common complaints
  • Uneven tone The mix of comedy and drama feels disjointed, with humor often falling flat or feeling out of place.
  • Predictable plot Story twists and resolutions feel too familiar and short on originality.
  • Underdeveloped side characters Supporting roles, including the priest's confidants and the rival love interest, feel shallow and underutilized.
  • Pacing issues The film drags in the middle, with some scenes feeling unnecessary or overly drawn out.
Recommended for
Fans of romantic dramas with spiritual themes Luciana Paes admirers Indie comedy-drama enthusiasts Viewers who enjoy character-driven stories

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

HOLY TEA, BATINA BOY: THE SURPRISINGLY SCANDAL‑FREE SAGA OF YOU GOTTA HAVE FAITH (2025)

A priest in love, a church in crisis, a goat named Bita… and almost NO real-world scandal? While Hollywood is busy catching fire on Twitter every other day, Brazil’s rom‑com You Gotta Have Faith (aka Os Infiéis) has quietly snuck through the festival circuit like a well‑behaved altar boy. We went looking for chaos. We found… competence. Still, there is some fun, latestnetflix.com contends, if extremely wholesome, tea to spill.


On-Set Drama (Or Lack Thereof)

  • The movie started life as a pandemic project. Director Tomás Fleck first created a short, Confessionário Online, during COVID lockdowns with Rafael Pimenta as a priest. The feature film expands that idea into a full “not‑so‑divine romantic dramedy” about a priest forced to marry off the only woman he ever loved to another man. Very “what if Fleabag had stayed in the confessional” energy.
  • Fleck openly talks about how the film was written around Pimenta’s vibe, stemming from their earlier collaboration. Translation: this wasn’t some random casting; he basically tailor‑stitched the cassock for Rafael.
  • At festivals, the director and cast are constantly shown side‑by‑side in cheerful Q&As and selfies, with no reports of screaming matches, walk‑offs or script rewrites in the middle of the night. Posts from Fantaspoa and other events show Fleck describing it as a light romantic comedy about a priest “between the cassock and love,” with the team joking together onstage like an actually functional family.
  • Instagram posts from producers and festival organizers hype the film as “a not‑so‑divine romantic comedy” and emphasize the fun, quirky tone rather than any production struggle or “troubled shoot” narrative.

Bottom line: if there was on‑set drama, they locked it up tighter than the church tabernacle. Everything public-facing screams smooth shoot, happy crew.


Cast Feuds & Tea

  • Rafael Pimenta (Father Steve): a well‑known improv comic and actor from Porta dos Fundos circles, Pimenta’s public image around the film is 100% “goofy theatre guy thrilled his indie priest rom‑com got into big festivals.” His socials show him joking about his game show Quem Quer Ser Cancelado? (Who Wants To Be Cancelled?) and poking fun at cancel‑culture “tribunals” of the internet, but no beef with co‑stars or the director attached to You Gotta Have Faith.
  • Luciana Paes (Isabel): critics keep saying the film basically turns into a “Luciana Paes show,” praising her comedic timing and emotional range in reviews on Brazilian sites and Letterboxd. If anything, the gossip is that she might be too good—stealing scenes without stealing anyone’s boyfriend.
  • Interviews and mentions about the cast frame them as well-loved pros, with no “difficult” labels slapped on. Paes has lately been thriving in theater, comedy and even directing, and Pimenta is riding high off his TV and stage work. If they hate each other, they deserve Oscars just for pretending not to.

Verdict: No public feuds, no subtweets, no “sources say” shade. This is one of those rare casts that seems to… like each other. How rude.


Romance Rumors (The Ship That Isn’t Sailing)

You’d THINK a rom‑com about a priest and his old flame would spark wild shipping—and we looked for it.

Rafael Pimenta + Luciana Paes IRL?

Despite very cute red‑carpet and festival photos, there are no solid rumors or tabloid items claiming they’re dating off‑screen. Brazilian coverage talks about their “humor and humanity” and chemistry in the story, not in the dressing room.

  • Both actors maintain active online presences, but keep personal relationships off‑limits or unrelated to the film. No “caught leaving a bar together at 2 a.m.,” no anonymous blind items linking them romantically, nothing on Brazilian gossip portals tying them together beyond work.

So if you were hoping for a forbidden priest‑and‑leading‑lady love story spilling over into reality… consider it fanfiction territory only, and clearly unconfirmed.


Scandals & Controversies: A True Non‑Event

We went hunting for classic tabloid bait:

  • lawsuits,
  • offended religious groups,
  • casting outrage,
  • leaks of “too spicy” scenes,
  • festival meltdowns.

For You Gotta Have Faith? Nada.

  • Brazilian outlets like Poltrona de Cinema, Midia Ninja and others frame the film as a warm, humorous story about faith, affection, and second chances in a struggling parish, explicitly comparing it to Fleabag, Father Ted and The Vicar of Dibley in tone—but with care not to mock belief itself. Reviews actually praise it for mixing religion and comedy without offending believers.
  • Despite its premise (a priest in love, debt‑ridden parish, messy hearts), there are no reports of Catholic organizations or conservative commentators attacking it in mainstream or social media coverage. It seems to have threaded that needle perfectly.
  • Director Tomás Fleck’s profile in industry write‑ups and interviews is squeaky‑clean: he’s talked about as a rising Brazilian filmmaker and writer with previous TV and streaming work, fellowships and residencies—not as the center of any scandal.

Scandal scorecard: 0/10. The movie is spicier than the press around it.


Festival Buzz, Awards… and a Little Goat

Where this film does get interesting is its path through festivals and the quirky trivia around it.

LABRFF (Los Angeles Brazilian Film Festival) 2025

You Gotta Have Faith/Os Infiéis had its U.S. Premiere at LABRFF’s 18th edition in Los Angeles, heavily spotlighted as a key feature. It left with serious hardware:

  • Best Supporting Actor for Edu Mendas, who plays a fellow clergyman (Padre Jesus). - Best Editing for Joana Bernardes. None of that is gossip, but it’s the kind of success that usually breeds jealousy. Publicly, at least, everyone’s just clapping.

Fantaspoa 2026 & Beyond

The film was selected for Fantaspoa 2026, a major Brazilian genre festival where it’s billed as a “not‑so‑divine romantic dramedy” and part of a line‑up that includes horror, cult and off‑beat titles. International coverage of the Fantaspoa program lists You Gotta Have Faith among Latin American premieres, emphasizing its quirky premise, not any turmoil.

Cinequest 2026

Posts from Cinequest highlight You Gotta Have Faith as part of their 2026 program, again with friendly coverage and no whiff of behind‑the‑scenes disaster.

The GOAT of Supporting Players

In a delightfully random tidbit, Rafael Pimenta posted about receiving his first acting award abroad, gushing that the film even has “a goat, Bita” in it—yes, an actual goat in the supporting cast. Fans and friends in the comments treat Bita like a minor celebrity. If there’s any on‑set diva, it might have been the livestock.


Leaks, Deleted Scenes & Fan Theories

In an era when every movie has a leaked cut on some sketchy corner of the internet, You Gotta Have Faith is… eerily contained.

No leaked workprints or nudes

There are no reports of hacked drives, early torrents or “uncensored” versions floating around. Festival screenings and trailers are the only publicly discussed material.

Deleted-scenes discourse? Not really.

Fans occasionally mention in festival comments that the runtime (around 86–87 minutes) and snappy pacing suggest trims were made, but there’s no specific, widely-circulated talk of a notorious deleted scene tied to this film. The most concrete “editing story” is simply that the film won Best Editing at LABRFF.

Wild fan theories?

Outside of standard Letterboxd and festival write‑ups, we don’t see big viral threads or TikTok breakdowns turning You Gotta Have Faith into some grand conspiracy allegory. The general vibe is:

  • sweet,
  • funny,
  • a little irreverent,
  • but ultimately straightforward.

Wild Trivia & Soft Gossip

No cheating scandals, no rehab stints, but here’s the lighter gossip‑adjacent trivia that does exist:

Tone-Perfect Comparisons

Multiple Brazilian pieces emphasize that Os Infiéis “dialogues with the spirit of Fleabag” and echoes the dramatic gaze of The Two Popes and The New Pope, while still feeling very Brazilian—“faith, friendship and second chances in the heart of a crisis‑ridden parish”. For fans, that’s catnip.

Church as a Main Character

Coverage notes that the film is set almost entirely inside a church and parish environment, leaning into the idea of the church itself as a character in the story. The production uses that single primary location to stretch a modest budget into something atmospheric.

From Short to Feature

Fleck and Pimenta had already experimented with a priest + confessional story in the short Confessionário Online, shot during the pandemic. That project’s success and tone apparently pushed them to go feature‑length. In industry gossip circles, that’s the dream arc: “tiny lockdown experiment → multi‑festival rom‑com.”

Career Glow-Up for the Cast

  • Edu Mendas’s festival win for Os Infiéis at LABRFF is frequently highlighted in entertainment pieces about the actor, framing the film as a key career booster. - Rafael Pimenta’s interviews around the same time talk about this feature and his cancel‑culture game show as signs he’s in his “most creative phase yet”.

In other words, if there’s drama, it’s the “my career is going well and I’m tired but happy” kind, not the throwing‑chairs kind.


So… Where’s the Trashy Gossip?

Here’s the unsexy truth your tabloid‑loving heart may hate:

For You Gotta Have Faith (2025), there is no credible, documented real‑world gossip about:

  • on‑set screaming matches,
  • cast feuds,
  • secret romances or breakups tied directly to the film,
  • lawsuits,
  • religious boycotts,
  • cancelled releases,
  • or headline‑making leaks.

What we do have is:

  • a pandemic‑born idea turned into a feature,
  • a tight‑knit Brazilian cast and crew apparently enjoying themselves,
  • festival love and awards,
  • and a goat that may be the closest thing this production has to a diva.

For fans, that might actually be its own kind of scandal: in 2025, a movie about messy faith and forbidden love managed to be made by people who seem… pretty healthy.

If any real tea ever spills, we’ll be first in the pew taking notes. Until then, you don’t just gotta have faith in Father Steve—you gotta have faith that sometimes, the most shocking thing about a movie is that nobody sabotaged it.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.