Skip to main content
Movie poster for He's All That (2021)

He's All That

“It's his turn for a makeover.”

2021
1h 31m
M · English
Director: Mark Waters
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

To get revenge on her ex-boyfriend, an influencer attempts to transform an unpopular classmate into prom king.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Makeover as a Mirror: What He’s All That Reveals About Influence, Insecurity, and the Illusion of Transformation

I’ll admit it: I went into He’s All That expecting a guilty pleasure, a fluffy remake of She’s All That with TikTok stars and a glossy sheen. What I didn’t expect was to find myself lingering on its central question—one that feels uncomfortably relevant in the age of Instagram filters and viral fame: What does it mean to be transformed by someone else’s gaze? The film, directed by Mark Waters (Mean Girls, Freaky Friday), doesn’t just gender-swap its 1999 predecessor; it refracts the original’s high school hierarchies through the lens of social media, where influence is currency and self-worth is measured in likes. It’s a premise ripe for satire, but He’s All That mostly plays it straight, which makes its occasional flashes of self-awareness all the more intriguing.

A dimly lit bedroom scene, where Addison Rae’s character, Padgett, scrolls through her phone, the glow of the screen casting sharp shadows on her face.

The plot is familiar: Padgett Sawyer (Addison Rae), a social media influencer with a carefully curated aesthetic and a dwindling follower count, takes on a bet to turn Cameron Kweller (Tanner Buchanan), a brooding photography nerd with a disdain for popularity, into prom king. The twist here isn’t just the gender swap—it’s the setting. Where She’s All That unfolded in the pre-digital world of landlines and mix CDs, He’s All That is steeped in the performative chaos of Instagram stories and TikTok dances.

Padgett’s makeover of Cameron isn’t just about new clothes and a haircut; it’s about crafting a persona that will play well on camera, a process that feels less like Pygmalion and more like algorithmic alchemy.

Waters, who cut his teeth on teen comedies that balance sharp humor with emotional stakes, brings a light touch to the material. The film’s pacing is brisk, and the humor lands more often than it misses—though it’s hard not to wince at some of the more groan-worthy one-liners. (A particular joke about Cameron’s “artistic soul” being incompatible with prom royalty falls flat, not because it’s mean-spirited, but because it feels like a relic of a bygone era of teen movies, one that hasn’t quite caught up to the way Gen Z actually talks.) Still, there’s a warmth to the film’s portrayal of its characters, even when they’re at their most ridiculous.

Padgett’s desperation to maintain her influencer status isn’t played for laughs so much as it is for pathos; we see the cracks in her carefully constructed persona, the way her confidence wavers when the likes stop rolling in.

A wide shot of a high school hallway, where students in trendy outfits mill about, their phones out, capturing every moment for social media.

What’s most interesting about He’s All That is how it grapples—sometimes clumsily, sometimes effectively—with the idea of authenticity in a world where everyone is performing. Cameron, the film’s ostensible “ugly duckling,” isn’t actually unpopular; he’s just uninterested in playing the game. His disdain for social media isn’t framed as a quirk but as a quiet rebellion, a refusal to participate in a system that values image over substance.

It’s a refreshing take, even if the film ultimately undercuts it by forcing Cameron into the very mold he rejects. The makeover sequence, a staple of the genre, is where He’s All That stumbles. Instead of subverting the trope, it leans into it, reducing Cameron’s transformation to a series of superficial changes—new clothes, a haircut, a smoldering gaze—rather than exploring what it might mean for him to truly step into his own skin.

The supporting cast is where the film shines. Rachael Leigh Cook, who played the original She’s All That’s makeover target, Laney Boggs, appears here as Padgett’s mother, a former influencer whose career fizzled out when she aged out of the algorithm’s favor. It’s a meta touch that could have been heavy-handed, but Cook plays the role with a weary humor that grounds the film’s more outlandish moments.

Meanwhile, Matthew Lillard, as the high school’s eccentric art teacher, steals every scene he’s in, delivering lines with a manic energy that feels like it wandered in from a Christopher Guest mockumentary. (His character’s obsession with performance art is one of the film’s few genuinely funny subplots, a send-up of pretentiousness that never feels cruel.)

A close-up of Cameron and Padgett at prom, their faces half-lit by the glow of a disco ball, tension and unspoken feelings hanging between them.

The film’s reception, as noted by French outlet SensCritique, was lukewarm at best, with a 3.8/10 rating based on nearly a thousand votes. It’s not hard to see why. He’s All That is a film that wants to have its cake and eat it too—it wants to critique influencer culture while also reveling in its glossy, superficial pleasures. It wants to be a subversive take on the makeover genre while still delivering the catharsis of a classic rom-com ending.

The result is a movie that feels caught between two impulses, unsure whether it’s a satire or a sincere throwback. That tension isn’t necessarily a flaw, though. If anything, it makes He’s All That a more interesting failure than it might have been.

It’s a film that reflects the contradictions of its moment: a time when we’re all too aware of the performative nature of social media, yet still deeply invested in the idea that a makeover—literal or metaphorical—can change our lives.

The most telling scene in the film comes near the end, when Padgett, after her plan to turn Cameron into prom king backfires spectacularly, delivers a tearful apology to her followers. “I thought I had to be perfect to be loved,” she says, her voice breaking. It’s a moment that could have been mawkish, but Rae sells it, her vulnerability cutting through the film’s layers of irony.

For all its flaws, He’s All That understands something fundamental about the way we live now: that the pressure to curate our lives for public consumption isn’t just about vanity—it’s about fear. Fear of irrelevance, fear of being seen as less than, fear of being left behind.

In the end, He’s All That isn’t a great movie, but it’s a revealing one. It’s a film that captures the awkward adolescence of the internet age, where we’re all still figuring out the rules of engagement, where the line between authenticity and performance is blurrier than ever. It’s not the scathing satire of influencer culture that it could have been, nor is it the heartfelt rom-com it sometimes aspires to be.

Instead, it’s something messier, something more honest—a mirror held up to a generation that’s still learning how to see itself.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Addison Rae’s Big-Screen Debut: The Highs, Flops, and Behind-the-Scenes Drama of He’s All That

Netflix’s He’s All That (2021) was billed as Addison Rae’s star-making turn—a modern rom-com reboot of the 1999 teen classic She’s All That. But from green-screen mishaps to lukewarm reviews, latestnetflix.com maintains, the film’s production and reception revealed a rocky transition from TikTok fame to Hollywood leading lady.

A Star-Studded Cast, But Chemistry Questions

Rae, then one of TikTok’s biggest names, headlined the film alongside Cobra Kai’s Tanner Buchanan. Early promotional material leaned hard into their on-screen chemistry, with Netflix releasing a clip of the duo singing Katy Perry’s Teenage Dream in a car scene. Buchanan later called their dynamic "effortless" in an interview, though he admitted the pressure of working with a social media superstar. Supporting roles included She’s All That alum Rachael Leigh Cook (in a meta cameo) and Matthew Lillard, but the real eyebrow-raiser was Kourtney Kardashian Barker’s appearance as a high-school principal—a role that sparked speculation about whether it was a favor to Rae’s Keeping Up with the Kardashians connections.

Production Hiccups: Green Screens and Viral Fails

Behind the scenes, He’s All That wasn’t all smooth sailing. A leaked blooper clip showed Rae struggling with a green-screen scene, her movements visibly out of sync with the intended effect. The moment quickly went viral, fueling skepticism about whether the film was a vanity project for Rae rather than a serious rom-com. Critics and fans alike questioned if her lack of acting experience would sink the movie, though some defenders argued the fail was an unfair spotlight on a single mistake.

Critical Reception: A "Crash and Burn" or Just Misunderstood?

Reviews were mixed at best. SensCritique users rated the film a dismal 3.8/10, calling it a forgettable rom-com with little originality. YouTube critics were harsher: one called it Rae’s "crash and burn movie debut," pointing to weak writing and stiff performances. Others, however, came to Rae’s defense, arguing the film was a lighthearted teen flick unfairly judged by critics expecting Oscar-level drama. Rotten Tomatoes’ audience score (not listed in the evidence) remains unverified, but the divide suggests He’s All That was a polarizing watch.

The Bryce Hall Cameo and Other Rumored Drama

One of the film’s most talked-about moments wasn’t even in the final cut—or so it seemed. A YouTube video claimed a cameo by TikToker Bryce Hall was filmed but left on the cutting-room floor, sparking rumors of behind-the-scenes tension. Neither Netflix nor the cast confirmed the details, leaving the story as tabloid fodder. With no official word, it’s unclear whether the cameo was scrapped for creative or contractual reasons.

The Verdict: A Flop or a Stepping Stone?

He’s All That may not have been the rom-com revival fans hoped for, but it wasn’t without its moments. Rae’s transition from influencer to actress was always going to be scrutinized, and the film’s flaws—whether in execution or expectation—became part of the story. For better or worse, it remains a snapshot of Hollywood’s growing pains in the age of social media stardom.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.