Skip to main content
Movie poster for 5 Star Christmas (2018)

5 Star Christmas

2018
1h 32m
T · Italian
Director: Marco Risi
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

When the Italian Premier and his companion find a dead body in his hotel suite, while on a trip to Hungary, they find themselves embroiled in a series of comedic situations as they try to avoid a scandal.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

A Farce That Forgets to Be Funny

I’ll admit it: I went into 5 Star Christmas expecting a certain kind of chaos. The premise—a dead body in a luxury hotel suite, a philandering prime minister, a Christmas setting that feels more like an afterthought—sounded like the kind of farce that could either collapse under its own weight or, if executed with enough manic energy, become something gloriously unhinged. Instead, it lands somewhere in the middle: a film that mistakes motion for momentum, where the doors slam, the lies pile up, and the jokes… well, the jokes mostly don’t land.

The setup is pure farce, the kind that thrives on confinement and escalation. A single location—a high-end Budapest hotel—becomes a pressure cooker for a group of characters who are, without exception, terrible people. The Italian prime minister (Massimo Ghini) is a lecherous buffoon; his mistress (Martina Stella) is a rival politician with her own agenda; the hotel staff are either incompetent or complicit; and the corpse in the closet is, of course, the least of their problems.

In theory, this should be a recipe for disaster comedy, the kind where every misstep leads to another, more absurd misstep, until the whole thing spirals into delightful nonsense. In practice, it’s a lot of people standing around talking, occasionally hiding behind furniture, and waiting for the next joke to arrive.

And that’s the problem: the jokes don’t arrive. Or, when they do, they’re so telegraphed that you can see them coming from a mile away. The film leans heavily on the kind of broad, physical comedy that feels like it belongs in a much older Italian farce—think slamming doors, exaggerated double takes, and characters tripping over their own lies.

But where those older films (the ones by the Vanzina brothers, whom this movie is clearly trying to emulate) had a certain rhythmic precision to their chaos, 5 Star Christmas feels sluggish, as if the cast is working through the motions without any real conviction. The dialogue is fast, but it’s not sharp; the situations are ridiculous, but they’re not inventive. It’s the cinematic equivalent of a stand-up comedian telling a joke you’ve heard a hundred times before, but with less energy.

A cluttered hotel suite with characters in various states of panic, doors ajar, and a sense of barely contained chaos.

Take, for example, the film’s centerpiece sequence: the prime minister and his mistress trying to smuggle the corpse out of the hotel without being seen. It’s a scene that should be the height of the film’s absurdity, a moment where the farce finally tips over into something genuinely funny. Instead, it’s a series of near-misses and awkward shuffles, with characters whispering frantically to each other while the camera lingers just a little too long on their panicked expressions.

There’s no sense of timing, no escalation—just a lot of running around that goes nowhere. The corpse, which should be the film’s MacGuffin, becomes little more than a prop, a thing to be moved from one hiding spot to another without any real stakes. Even the Christmas setting, which the title promises will be central, feels like an afterthought.

There are a few decorations in the background, a couple of mentions of the holiday, but it’s all so half-hearted that you could swap out Christmas for any other time of year and the plot wouldn’t change at all.

The cast, for their part, seems to be having a better time than the audience. Massimo Ghini, as the prime minister, is the closest thing the film has to a lead, and he throws himself into the role with a kind of desperate energy, as if he’s trying to will the comedy into existence through sheer force of personality. Martina Stella, as his mistress, is given less to do—her character is mostly there to look glamorous and occasionally deliver a withering put-down—but she at least brings a certain poise to the proceedings.

The rest of the ensemble is a mixed bag: Ricky Memphis, as the prime minister’s long-suffering aide, has a few moments where his exasperation feels genuinely funny, but too often he’s just another body in the room, reacting to things that aren’t as amusing as the film thinks they are.

What’s most frustrating about 5 Star Christmas is that it’s not without its charms. There are a few moments where the farce almost clicks—where the absurdity of the situation and the energy of the performers align just enough to make you laugh. But these moments are few and far between, and they’re drowned out by long stretches of dialogue-heavy scenes that go nowhere.

The film’s biggest sin isn’t that it’s bad; it’s that it’s boring. For a comedy, that’s the worst crime of all.

A close-up of Massimo Ghini’s character, looking flustered and sweaty, as he tries to explain away yet another lie.

It’s worth noting that the film is dedicated to Carlo Vanzina, the late director of some of Italy’s most beloved Christmas comedies, and you can feel the weight of that legacy pressing down on 5 Star Christmas. The Vanzina brothers’ films were never high art, but they had a certain irreverent energy, a willingness to embrace the ridiculousness of their premises without apology. 5 Star Christmas, by contrast, feels like it’s trying to replicate that energy without understanding what made it work in the first place. It’s a film that wants to be a farce but doesn’t know how to be funny, a Christmas movie that forgets to feel like the holidays, and a comedy that, for all its running around, never quite gets off the ground.

I kept waiting for it to find its footing, for the chaos to cohere into something resembling a rhythm. But by the time the credits rolled, I realized it had never even tried. The doors kept slamming, the lies kept piling up, and the corpse stayed in the closet. The only thing that was missing was the punchline.

Audience Opinions

Audience 4.7/10
"A labored hotel-room farce with a flimsy story and mostly mirthless gags that rarely earn its Christmas branding."

A weak sex-and-politics farce where jokes seldom land, the story feels padded, and long stretches of chatter in a single hotel suite make it drag. The plot is close to non-existent, the humor boring or joyless, and the characters grating stereotypes. A minority takes it as a mildly amusing, old-fashioned stage-style comedy with some lively wordplay and a few charming performances.

What viewers praise
  • Farce-style setup The limited-location, door-slamming hotel farce format brings affairs, misunderstandings and escalating chaos.
  • Quick verbal exchanges Fast-talking dialogue and wordplay recall older Italian comedies and stage pieces.
  • Likeable leads for some Massimo Ghini and Martina Stella are occasional bright spots; the cast can be fun even when the script is not.
  • Light, undemanding tone A harmless, cute little comedy for passing the time without high expectations.
Common complaints
  • Not funny enough Easy to watch stone-faced; it plays as one of the most boring comedies around, with very few jokes that work.
  • Thin or absent plot The story is nonsense or non-existent, with little narrative drive beyond characters hiding a corpse and sneaking around.
  • Slow and talky Long stretches confined to a hotel room with nonstop chatter are tedious, chaotic and exhausting rather than brisk and witty.
  • Stereotyped characters Shallow caricatures, especially lecherous men and decorative women, make the humor feel dated and mean-spirited.
  • Weak Christmas element The holiday angle is largely cosmetic; it barely feels like a Christmas movie despite the title.
Recommended for
Italian farce completists Low-stakes holiday background viewing Light political sex-comedy dabblers

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Surprisingly Tame Tea Behind Netflix’s 5 Star Christmas

Turns out the wildest scandal in 5 Star Christmas is still the one in the plot. We went digging through Italian press, reviews, interviews and fan chatter for any hint of on‑set chaos, secret romances or Netflix-level controversy—and the truth is more “lukewarm prosecco” than “exploding champagne.latestnetflix.com's read is that ” Still, there’s some real‑world drama swirling around the people and the moment the film was made.


Bittersweet Origins & A Ghost in the Credits

  • 5 Star Christmas (Natale a 5 stelle) was heavily marketed in Italy as Netflix’s first Italian Christmas movie, with the local press pointing out that the streamer was essentially inheriting the Italian “cinepanettone” tradition—the loud, silly, often raunchy Christmas comedies the Vanzina brothers made famous for decades. - The movie is dedicated to Carlo Vanzina, the hugely popular director of those holiday comedies, who died in July 2018 after a long illness. Articles about the film stressed that brother Enrico Vanzina wrote this script as a kind of farewell to Carlo and to their brand of Italian Christmas farce. - Italian outlets framed the film as Netflix stepping into very “lowbrow but beloved” territory: a farcical sex‑and‑politics Christmas romp, now dressed up for streaming instead of a theatrical release. The “controversy,” such as it was, came from critics and cinephiles grumbling that Netflix was embracing the same cheesy formulas it was supposed to be “disrupting.”

Scandals & Controversies (Mostly Around Tone, Not Behavior)

  • Reviews in Italian media had sharp claws. Several called the film dated and stuck in the aesthetics of 1980s Vanzina comedies, criticizing the reliance on bedroom farce and stereotypical politicians rather than fresh satire. - The political angle—an incompetent prime minister, his mistress who’s also a rival politician, and a corpse in a luxury hotel—sparked some comment as a thinly veiled riff on real‑world Italian scandals, but this stayed in the realm of critique, not outrage. No big lawsuits, boycotts or calls for bans surfaced in mainstream outlets. - In short: the “scandal” was artistic, not legal. Critics groaned; nobody sued.

Cast Feuds & On‑Set Drama: The Dog That Didn’t Bark

  • Across Italian coverage (interviews, press conferences, reviews), there’s no reported on‑set blow‑up, no feuds between Massimo Ghini, Ricky Memphis, Martina Stella or the rest of the ensemble. - Press pieces and video interviews from the Italian promo tour show a pretty standard vibe: cast joking, reminiscing about older Vanzina projects, and selling the film as light holiday entertainment. - No social‑media threads, Reddit posts, or fan‑forum “I worked on this movie, here’s the tea” confessions turned up that tied any backstage meltdown directly to 5 Star Christmas.

The Real-Life Drama: Massimo Ghini’s Messy Past

While this film’s set seems squeaky‑clean, its star walked in with a back catalogue of tabloid‑worthy history:

  • Italian gossip pages and later profiles have long revisited Massimo Ghini’s explosive marriage and divorce with actress Nancy Brilli, which began in the late ’80s but keeps being rehashed in interviews. - Reports describe their split as “burrascosa” (stormy), with some outlets mentioning legal clashes and Ghini allegedly accusing his ex of financial misconduct—though these stories are about their relationship in general, not tied to 5 Star Christmas in particular. - More recent interviews frame the whole saga as water under the bridge, but it still follows Ghini around in Italian media whenever his name resurfaces.

So while there’s no evidence of him bringing that chaos to Budapest hotel hallways on this shoot, his off‑screen reputation definitely adds spice for anyone watching him play a philandering prime minister.


Martina Stella’s Image & Press-Tour Edge

  • Coverage surrounding Martina Stella around this period leans heavily on her long‑standing image as a glamorous Italian “bombshell” with a sometimes complicated love life, regularly dissected by lifestyle and gossip outlets. - However, for 5 Star Christmas specifically, the press materials and interviews focus on her role and career highlights—no viral moment, no public feud, no mysteriously “too hot” scene being whispered about. - If any sparks flew between Stella and co‑stars, they didn’t make it into the Italian gossip ecosystem in connection with this film.

Missing: Deleted Scenes, Leaks, and Conspiracy‑Level Fan Theories

  • No credible coverage or fan‑discussion threads surfaced about deleted scenes, leaked alternative cuts, or Netflix censoring content specifically from 5 Star Christmas. - Likewise, there are no prominent fan theories getting media traction—no “the corpse is secretly X real politician,” no “this is connected to another Netflix universe” chatter outside of generic speculation in reviews that the set‑up nods to Italy’s long line of political sex scandals. - The film’s reputation online is mostly as a minor, slightly naughty seasonal watch: noted in lists of Netflix Christmas titles, occasionally dunked on for being broad or dated, but not treated as a lightning rod.

So… Where’s the Juice?

For fans hoping 5 Star Christmas hid a secret Hallmark‑style on‑set romance or a Netflix‑sized scandal: the receipts just aren’t there. What is real:

  • A poignant dedication to a beloved comedy legend (Carlo Vanzina) whose shadow hangs over every frame. - A star (Massimo Ghini) with a messy, much‑discussed romantic past, adding extra irony to his cheating‑PM role. - A film that stirred up critical side‑eye more than moral panic, with reviewers bemoaning its old‑school style but not uncovering any off‑camera sins.

In other words: the film itself is the farce. Off screen, everyone seems to have behaved themselves—for once, the corpse in the Santa suit is the most dramatic thing in the room.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.