
David Spade
Tim Morris

“There’s no untexting her now.”
A guy meets the woman of his dreams and invites her to his company's corporate retreat, but realizes he sent the invite to the wrong person.
Official
I’ll admit it: I went into The Wrong Missy expecting to hate it. Not because I have some highbrow disdain for Adam Sandler’s brand of comedy—I’ve laughed at enough Happy Gilmore reruns to know better—but because the premise sounded like the kind of lazy, algorithm-friendly sludge that Netflix pumps out to keep us scrolling. A guy accidentally texts the wrong woman to join him on a corporate retreat, and hilarity ensues?
It’s the kind of setup that could’ve been scribbled on a napkin during a three-martini lunch in 1998. And yet, somewhere in the middle of this 90-minute exercise in cringe and slapstick, I found myself doing something unexpected: I was laughing. Not at the jokes, exactly—most of them land with the grace of a whoopee cushion in a library—but at Lauren Lapkus.

There’s something almost heroic about the way Lapkus commits to this role. Missy isn’t just a manic pixie dream girl gone rogue; she’s a force of nature, a human tornado of bad decisions and unfiltered id. In one scene, she hijacks a jet ski to chase down David Spade’s Tim, her face contorted into a rictus of determination, as if she’s not just trying to catch up to him but to outrun the very concept of shame.
Lapkus doesn’t just play the part—she inhabits it, throwing herself into every gag with the kind of reckless abandon that makes you wonder if she’s secretly a stunt performer moonlighting as an actress. The critics were right to single her out. Variety’s Owen Gleiberman called her performance “a grenade of happy insanity tossed into the middle of every scene,” and that’s not hyperbole.
She’s the only reason this film doesn’t collapse under the weight of its own laziness.
Because lazy is the word that keeps coming to mind. Not in the sense that the filmmakers didn’t try—there’s a certain technical competence to the editing and pacing—but in the way it recycles every tired trope of the Sandlerverse without adding anything new. The vacation resort setting?
Check. The ensemble of Happy Madison regulars phoning in their usual schtick? Check.
The gross-out gags that mistake bodily fluids for wit? Oh, you better believe there’s a checkmark next to that one. There’s a scene involving a shark cage, a bucket of chum, and a strategically placed stream of vomit that’s supposed to be the film’s big set piece.
It’s the kind of moment that would’ve been edgy in a Jackass spin-off in 2005, but here it just feels like the filmmakers are going through the motions. (And yes, I’m aware that describing a vomit scene in a film review is a new low for me. I regret nothing.)

Spade, for his part, seems content to coast on autopilot. He’s playing the same variation of the same character he’s been doing since Joe Dirt: the smug, slightly dim everyman who’s just one bad decision away from disaster. It’s not that he’s bad—he’s fine, in the way that a fast-food burger is fine—but there’s no spark, no sense that he’s actually engaged with the material.
He’s the straight man in a comedy that doesn’t deserve one, and the mismatch is glaring. When Missy drags him into a hot tub fully clothed or forces him to participate in a threesome that’s less erotic than it is surreal, his reactions are so muted they feel like they were recorded in a different movie. Maybe that’s the point—maybe Tim is supposed to be the audience surrogate, the only sane person in a world gone mad—but if so, it’s a miscalculation.
We don’t need a straight man when the film itself is already so straight-laced in its approach to comedy.
And that’s the real problem with The Wrong Missy: it’s a comedy that doesn’t trust its own jokes. The script is so afraid of silence that it fills every moment with noise—literal noise, in the form of a soundtrack that blares like a carnival barker, and figurative noise, in the form of dialogue that explains the punchline before the punchline even lands. There’s a scene where Missy, in a moment of vulnerability, confesses to Tim that she’s “not good at being a person.” It’s the closest the film comes to having something resembling a heart, but it’s immediately undercut by a slapstick gag involving a knife named Sheila.
(Yes, a knife. Named Sheila. I wish I were making this up.) The moment doesn’t land because the film can’t commit to it.
It’s too busy trying to be everything—a romance, a farce, a gross-out comedy, a character study—that it ends up being nothing.

That’s not to say there aren’t flashes of something interesting here. The film’s best moments are the ones where it leans into the absurdity of its premise without trying to force a laugh. There’s a quiet scene near the end where Tim and Missy sit on a beach at night, and for once, the soundtrack drops out.
Missy talks about her fear of being alone, and for a brief moment, it feels like the film might actually say something. But then the music swells, the camera pushes in for a dramatic close-up, and the moment is ruined. It’s as if the filmmakers are afraid that if they let the scene breathe, the audience might realize they’re watching a movie that doesn’t know what it wants to be.
In the end, The Wrong Missy is a film that’s hard to hate but impossible to love. It’s not offensive, just forgettable—except for Lapkus, who deserves better. She’s the reason the film works at all, and the reason it’s so frustrating that it doesn’t work more often.
There’s a version of this movie where Missy isn’t just a collection of tics and quirks but a fully realized character, where the humor comes from the tension between her chaos and Tim’s order, rather than from the sheer volume of gross-out gags. That version of The Wrong Missy might’ve been something special. Instead, we get this: a film that’s content to be a footnote in the Sandler canon, a blip on Netflix’s algorithm, and a reminder that sometimes, the wrong person can still be the right one for the job.
"A raucous but uneven comedy built on absurdity and cringe humor, though it rarely sustains laughs beyond its best gags."
The over-the-top premise and chaotic energy produce sporadic amusement, particularly when Lauren Lapkus’s unhinged performance steals the show. The humor is repetitive and thinly stretched, with many jokes falling flat or leaning on shock value rather than clever writing. David Spade’s familiar schtick and the thin supporting characters leave the comedy one-note despite its high energy.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Netflix’s The Wrong Missy (2020) is a comedy built on a simple, cringe-worthy premise: a man accidentally invites the wrong woman on a tropical getaway—only to realize his mistake when it’s far too late. Starring David Spade as the hapless Tim Morris and Lauren Lapkus as the chaotic Missy, the film leans into slapstick, awkward humor, and a cast of familiar faces from the Happy Madison Productions universe. latestnetflix.com's read is that but behind the scenes, the movie’s production had its own share of chaos, quirks, and a few surprises.
The Wrong Missy marks another collaboration between David Spade and Happy Madison, the production company founded by Adam Sandler, known for churning out raunchy comedies. Director Tyler Spindel, a frequent Happy Madison collaborator, helmed the project, bringing his signature style of fast-paced, joke-heavy filmmaking. Spindel’s background in comedy—including work on The Package (2018) and Father of the Year (2019)—made him a natural fit for the film’s tone, which blends physical humor with Spade’s trademark sarcasm.
The cast is packed with Happy Madison regulars, including Nick Swardson, Rob Schneider, and Jackie Sandler (Adam’s wife), alongside newcomers like Lauren Lapkus, who brought her improvisational chops from Orange Is the New Black. The chemistry between Spade and Lapkus became a focal point, with their contrasting personalities—Spade’s deadpan cynicism vs. Lapkus’s unhinged energy—driving much of the film’s humor.
The film’s central gag—Tim accidentally texting the wrong woman—wasn’t just a plot device; it reportedly influenced the casting process. Lauren Lapkus was brought on to play the titular "wrong" Missy, a role that required her to embody a character who is equal parts endearing and disastrous. In interviews, Spade hinted at the challenges of working with Lapkus’s improvisational style, which clashed (in a good way) with his more scripted delivery.
One behind-the-scenes tidbit suggests that Lapkus’s performance was so unpredictable that some scenes required multiple takes to nail the right balance of chaos. While the evidence doesn’t confirm whether this led to on-set tension, it’s clear that her portrayal of Missy—described in one review as "a human tornado of bad decisions"—was a key selling point.
The Wrong Missy arrived on Netflix in May 2020, a time when the streaming giant was doubling down on original comedies to keep audiences entertained during lockdowns. The film’s trailer, which racked up millions of views, promised a mix of slapstick, awkward romance, and Spade’s signature one-liners. Reviews were mixed, with some critics calling it "predictable but fun" and others dismissing it as "low-effort Happy Madison fare".
Audience reactions were similarly divided. While the film earned a modest 4.7/10 on SensCritique, it found a loyal following among fans of Spade’s brand of humor. One YouTube review described it as "a guilty pleasure," noting that the chemistry between Spade and Lapkus saved an otherwise formulaic plot.
Despite the film’s lukewarm reception, rumors swirled about a potential sequel, though nothing has been officially confirmed. Spade has joked in interviews about the possibility of The Wrong Missy 2, but given the film’s mixed reviews, it’s unclear whether Netflix will greenlight another installment.
One unverified claim suggests that the film’s budget was relatively low, allowing Netflix to take a risk on a raunchy, star-driven comedy. However, without concrete numbers, this remains speculation.
The Wrong Missy may not be a critical darling, but it delivers exactly what it promises: 90 minutes of chaotic, often cringe-worthy comedy. For fans of David Spade’s brand of humor—or anyone who’s ever sent a text to the wrong person—it’s an easy watch. Whether it’s a one-off or the start of a franchise remains to be seen, but for now, it’s a solid addition to Netflix’s comedy lineup.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.