Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Prom (2020)

The Prom

“Everyone deserves a chance to celebrate.”

2020
2h 11m
PG-13 · English
Director: Ryan Murphy
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

After the PTA of a conservative high school in Indiana bans same-sex couples from attending the annual prom, a gang of flamboyant Broadway stars try to boost their image by showing up to support two lesbian students.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

6 min read

The Glitter and the Grit: Ryan Murphy’s The Prom as Both Celebration and Cautionary Tale

I’ll admit it: I went into The Prom with low expectations. Not because of its premise—LGBTQ+ teens fighting for their right to dance at a high school prom is a story worth telling—but because of its pedigree. Ryan Murphy’s recent output has been a mixed bag of high-camp spectacle and well-intentioned but uneven social messaging, and the early buzz around this film leaned heavily on its star-studded cast rather than its substance.

What I found, though, was something more complicated than I’d anticipated: a movie that wants desperately to be both a joyful, glitter-soaked celebration of queer love and a sharp critique of performative allyship, but ends up tripping over its own good intentions.

That tension is there from the very first frame. The film opens with a Broadway marquee blazing the names of its stars—Meryl Streep, Nicole Kidman, James Corden—before cutting to a backstage meltdown. Dee Dee Allen (Streep) and Barry Glickman (Corden) have just been humiliated by a New York Times critic who called their latest vanity project "a self-indulgent mess."

Their careers are in freefall, and their egos are bruised. Enter Trent Oliver (Andrew Rannells), a Juilliard-trained actor reduced to playing the lead in a regional production of Godspell, and Angie Dickinson (Kidman), a chorus girl who’s been stuck in the ensemble of Chicago for two decades. Together, they hatch a plan: they’ll travel to small-town Indiana, insert themselves into the life of a lesbian teen barred from her prom, and turn the whole thing into a PR coup.

The goal isn’t justice; it’s relevance.

A Broadway marquee shines brightly, the names of the stars glowing in neon, as the camera pulls back to reveal the bustling theater district.

This is where The Prom starts to get interesting. The film’s first act is a masterclass in Murphy’s ability to balance satire and sincerity. The Broadway stars descend on Edgewater, Indiana, like a pack of peacocks in a henhouse, all feather boas and affected Southern drawls.

They’re ridiculous, but they’re also kind of wonderful—Streep, in particular, chews the scenery with a glee that’s infectious. Her Dee Dee is a hurricane of narcissism, but there’s a vulnerability there, too, a sense that her need to be the center of attention comes from a place of deep insecurity. When she belts out "It’s Not About Me" in the film’s first big musical number, the irony is so thick you could spread it on toast.

The song is a showstopper, all jazz hands and soaring harmonies, but it’s also a lie. Because for Dee Dee, it is about her. At least, it is at first.

The problem is that The Prom never quite decides whether it wants to skewer these characters or redeem them. The Broadway foursome’s journey from self-absorbed opportunists to genuine allies is the emotional spine of the film, but the script rushes through their arcs with a haste that undercuts their complexity. One moment, Barry is making cringe-worthy assumptions about queer identity ("I know what it’s like to be different—I played a gay man in La Cage aux Folles!"); the next, he’s delivering a heartfelt speech about the importance of visibility.

The transformation feels unearned, not because Corden can’t act (though his performance is the film’s weakest link, veering into caricature more often than not), but because the script doesn’t give him the space to wrestle with his own contradictions.

That’s a shame, because when The Prom slows down enough to let its characters breathe, it finds moments of real emotional power. Take the scene where Emma Nolan (Jo Ellen Pellman), the teen at the center of the controversy, sings "Dance with You" in an empty gymnasium. The number is simple—just Emma, a microphone, and a single spotlight—but it’s one of the film’s most affecting sequences.

Pellman, a newcomer, has a quiet intensity that grounds the film’s more outlandish elements. Her voice isn’t showy; it’s raw and a little shaky, the kind of singing that makes you lean in. The camera lingers on her face, on the way her fingers tremble around the mic, and for a moment, the film forgets about the Broadway stars and their antics.

This isn’t about them. It’s about Emma, and the quiet devastation of being told she doesn’t belong.

Emma stands alone in an empty gymnasium, bathed in a single spotlight, as she sings into a microphone.

If only the film trusted those moments more. Instead, it keeps defaulting to the kind of broad, cartoonish humor that Murphy has built his brand on. The villains—a PTA mom played by Tracey Ullman and a smug school board member (Kerry Washington, oddly underused)—are drawn with such broad strokes that they feel like they’ve wandered in from a Saturday Night Live sketch.

Ullman’s character, in particular, is a walking punchline, a suburban Karen whose bigotry is played for laughs rather than as a real threat. It’s a miscalculation, because the film’s message about the dangers of small-town conservatism loses its bite when the opposition is reduced to a caricature. Real homophobia isn’t always a mustache-twirling monologue; sometimes it’s a quiet, insidious thing, the kind of thing that makes a teenager like Emma afraid to hold her girlfriend’s hand in public.

That’s not to say The Prom doesn’t have its heart in the right place. The film’s climactic prom scene is a riot of color and movement, a defiant celebration of queer joy that feels earned after all the chaos that precedes it. The choreography is energetic, the costumes are a feast for the eyes, and the sheer exuberance of the moment is hard to resist.

But even here, the film can’t help but undercut itself. The Broadway stars, now fully redeemed, take center stage one last time, their egos seemingly forgotten in the glow of their newfound activism. It’s a neat resolution, but it’s also a little too tidy, a reminder that The Prom is, at its core, a fairy tale.

And maybe that’s the point. Maybe The Prom isn’t trying to be a gritty, realistic portrayal of queer life in America. Maybe it’s a fantasy, a wish-fulfillment story where the good guys win and the bad guys are humiliated in a public spectacle.

If that’s the case, then it succeeds on its own terms. But I can’t shake the feeling that the film could have been more—that it could have taken its own themes seriously enough to let them breathe, to let its characters be messy and contradictory and real.

A vibrant, chaotic prom scene unfolds, with students dancing under a disco ball, their faces lit with joy and defiance.

In the end, The Prom is a movie that wants to have it both ways. It wants to be a scathing satire of performative allyship and a feel-good celebration of queer love. It wants to critique the very celebrity culture it’s a part of, while also basking in the glow of its own star power.

It wants to be subversive, but it also wants to be safe. That tension is what makes the film so fascinating, but it’s also what keeps it from being truly great.

I left The Prom feeling conflicted. There’s a lot to love here—the music, the performances, the sheer audacity of its premise—but there’s also a sense that the film is holding back, that it’s too afraid of offending anyone to really dig into the complexities of its own story. It’s a movie that wants to change the world, but it’s not quite brave enough to risk making anyone uncomfortable in the process.

And maybe that’s the most telling thing about The Prom. In its rush to celebrate, it forgets to challenge. It gives us a world where everyone gets a happy ending, but it doesn’t ask us to confront the messy, difficult realities that make those endings so hard to come by.

That’s not nothing. But it’s not enough, either.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.2/10
"A well-intentioned but uneven musical comedy with standout performances and cringe-worthy moments."

The film's vibrant energy, catchy musical numbers, and star-studded cast, particularly Meryl Streep and Nicole Kidman, earn praise. The uneven tone, some over-the-top performances, and a script that can't reconcile its humor with its social message leave it short of its potential.

What viewers praise
  • Strong lead performances Meryl Streep and Nicole Kidman are praised for charismatic, entertaining performances.
  • Catchy musical numbers The musical sequences are lively and well choreographed, and the songs add to the upbeat tone.
  • Heartfelt message Its inclusive, supportive message about LGBTQ+ rights and acceptance is widely appreciated.
  • Vibrant visuals The colorful, dynamic cinematography enhances the musical and comedic elements.
Common complaints
  • Uneven tone The comedic and dramatic moments clash, making the film feel disjointed.
  • Over-the-top performances Some performances, particularly James Corden's, are criticized as overly broad and cringe-inducing.
  • Predictable plot The story follows familiar musical-comedy tropes with few surprises.
  • Weak character development Supporting characters rely on stereotypes rather than depth.
Recommended for
Musical comedy fans Meryl Streep and Nicole Kidman fans LGBTQ+ themed movie lovers Feel-good movie seekers Ryan Murphy enthusiasts

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Ryan Murphy’s Star-Studded Musical "The Prom" Brings Broadway Glam to Netflix

Ryan Murphy’s 2020 film The Prom arrived with all the hallmarks of his signature style: a glittering ensemble cast, a splash of social commentary, and a whole lot of musical razzle-dazzle. Adapted from the Tony-nominated Broadway show of the same name, the movie marked Murphy’s latest foray into the world of musicals, following the success of Glee and Pose. But this time, he had an A-list lineup to bring the story to life—led by Meryl Streep, Nicole Kidman, latestnetflix.com contends, and James Corden in a tale of Broadway stars crashing a small-town prom to champion LGBTQ+ rights.

A-List Casting and Murphy’s Musical Ambitions

Murphy assembled a powerhouse cast for The Prom, with Streep and Kidman taking top billing as Dee Dee Allen and Angie Dickinson, two fading Broadway divas desperate for a comeback. James Corden co-starred as Barry Glickman, a flamboyant actor whose career is on the rocks, while Kerry Washington played Mrs. Greene, a no-nonsense PTA mom with a secret. Rounding out the ensemble were Keegan-Michael Key, Andrew Rannells, Ariana DeBose, and newcomer Jo Ellen Pellman as Emma Nolan, the Indiana teen at the center of the prom controversy.

Murphy’s pivot to musicals wasn’t new—he’d already left his mark on the genre with Glee and The Boys in the Band—but The Prom was his first major film musical. The project was announced in 2019, with Murphy directing and producing under his Netflix deal, which had already yielded hits like The Politician and Hollywood. The casting alone generated buzz, particularly Streep’s return to musical comedy after Mamma Mia! and Corden’s turn as a scene-stealing theater queen.

Behind the Scenes: Streep’s Rap and Corden’s Camp

While the film’s plot—Broadway stars descending on a conservative Indiana town to help a lesbian student attend prom—was a clear vehicle for Murphy’s love of camp and activism, the behind-the-scenes stories added to the intrigue. Streep, ever the chameleon, surprised fans by rapping in one of the film’s numbers, a moment she later called "terrifying" in an interview. "I’m not a rapper," she admitted, "but Ryan said, ‘Just go for it’". The sequence, a showstopping number called "It’s Not About Me," became one of the film’s most talked-about moments.

Corden, meanwhile, leaned into the campiness of his character, Barry Glickman, a role that divided critics but delighted fans of Murphy’s over-the-top style. The actor’s chemistry with Streep and Kidman was a highlight, with the trio’s dynamic evoking the classic Hollywood odd-couple energy Murphy often favors. Kidman, too, embraced the film’s theatricality, playing Angie Dickinson as a lovably delusional diva with a heart of gold.

**Controversy and Reception: Did The Prom Hit the Right Notes?**

Despite its star power and feel-good message, The Prom received mixed reviews. Critics praised the performances—particularly DeBose’s scene-stealing turn as Alyssa Greene—but some found the film’s tone uneven, oscillating between broad comedy and earnest social commentary. The SensCritique audience rating of 5.2/10 reflected the divide, with some viewers calling it a "guilty pleasure" and others dismissing it as overly saccharine.

The film’s handling of its LGBTQ+ themes also sparked debate. While Murphy has built a career on championing marginalized voices, some critics questioned whether The Prom’s approach—centering straight Broadway stars in a story about queer youth—was the right one. Common Sense Media noted that the film "has something important to say about intolerance," but whether it landed the message effectively remained a point of contention.

A Netflix Gamble with Murphy’s Signature Flair

The Prom was a quintessential Ryan Murphy production: bold, star-studded, and unapologetically campy. Whether it was Streep’s rap, Corden’s diva antics, or the film’s rainbow-soaked finale, the movie delivered exactly what Murphy fans have come to expect—high drama, higher energy, and a whole lot of glitter. While it may not have been a critical darling, it reinforced Murphy’s knack for turning even the most unlikely material into a spectacle.

For better or worse, The Prom was pure Murphy: a love letter to Broadway, a rallying cry for inclusivity, and a reminder that sometimes, the best way to make a statement is to do it with a song and dance.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.