
B.J. Novak
Ben Manalowitz

Ben, a journalist from New York City, travels to West Texas in order to investigate the death of a girl he was hooking up with while recording a murder mystery podcast along the way.
Official
I’ll admit it: I went into Vengeance expecting a lark. B.J. Novak, the man who made us laugh as Ryan the temp on The Office, writing, directing, and starring in a dark comedy about a true-crime podcaster investigating a murder in West Texas?
It sounded like the kind of high-concept premise that could either be brilliantly self-aware or painfully tone-deaf. What I didn’t expect was a film that keeps shifting under your feet, like a desert mirage that refuses to resolve into something solid. Is it a satire of media exploitation?
A meditation on regional identity? A straight-up thriller with jokes? By the end, I still wasn’t sure—but I couldn’t stop thinking about it.

Novak plays Ben Manalowitz, a New York journalist who gets a call from a stranger informing him that a woman he barely knew—Abilene, a girl he’d hooked up with once—has died of a drug overdose. The family insists it was murder, and Ben, sensing a story (and maybe a podcast), drives out to Texas to investigate. What follows is a collision of worlds: the fast-talking, self-absorbed urbanite against the slow-burning, gun-toting locals.
The film’s early scenes lean hard into the fish-out-of-water comedy, with Ben’s incredulity at the customs of small-town Texas played for laughs. (The way he reacts to being handed a rifle at a family barbecue is worth the price of admission.) But the humor is uneasy, laced with something darker. You laugh, but you’re not entirely sure you should.
That tension—between comedy and thriller, between satire and sincerity—is the film’s defining feature. Novak has always been fascinated by the performative nature of identity, and Vengeance doubles down on that idea. Ben isn’t just investigating a murder; he’s performing the role of investigator, crafting a narrative in real time for his podcast.
The film’s most unsettling moments come when the line between story and reality blurs. Is Ben genuinely trying to solve a crime, or is he just mining tragedy for content? The answer, like so much else in Vengeance, is deliberately ambiguous.
The supporting cast is a revelation. Boyd Holbrook, as Abilene’s brother Ty, is a coiled spring of quiet menace, his easygoing drawl masking something far more dangerous. J.
Smith-Cameron, as the family matriarch Sharon, brings a weary warmth to a role that could have easily tipped into caricature. And then there’s John Mayer—yes, that John Mayer—playing a local radio host with a penchant for conspiracy theories. His presence is so bizarre, so delightfully off-kilter, that it feels like a meta-joke about celebrity itself.
(What is a Grammy-winning musician doing in a Texas murder mystery? The film never bothers to explain, and that’s part of the fun.)

The film’s visual language is just as slippery as its tone. The Texas landscape is shot with a stark, almost mythic beauty—wide shots of endless highways and sun-bleached plains that make Ben look even more out of place. But the cinematography also has a way of making the familiar feel uncanny.
A simple family dinner becomes charged with unease, the camera lingering just a beat too long on a character’s face, as if waiting for them to reveal their true intentions. It’s the kind of film that makes you hyper-aware of the space between people, both physically and emotionally.
And then there’s the ending. Without spoiling anything, I’ll say this: Vengeance pulls a bait-and-switch that left me reeling. It’s the kind of twist that doesn’t just reframe the story—it forces you to question whether the story was ever what you thought it was.
Some will call it clever. Others will call it cheap. I’m still not sure which side I’m on.
What I do know is that the film’s final act lingers in a way that most comedies don’t. It’s not just about the punchline; it’s about the silence after.

So where does that leave Vengeance? It’s not a perfect film. The pacing lags in places, and some of the jokes land with a thud.
But its imperfections feel like part of its design—a film that’s as messy and contradictory as the people it portrays. Novak has always been a writer who thrives in the gray areas, and Vengeance is no exception. It’s a film that wants to have its cake and eat it too: to be a comedy and a thriller, a satire and a character study, a story about storytelling and a story that resists being pinned down.
In the end, I think that’s why it stuck with me. Vengeance doesn’t just ask who killed Abilene. It asks who gets to tell the story—and what happens when the storyteller becomes part of the story. It’s a question that feels especially urgent in an era where true crime is big business and everyone with a microphone thinks they’re a detective.
The film doesn’t offer easy answers, but it does something rarer: it makes you sit with the discomfort of not knowing. And maybe, just maybe, that’s the point.
"A darkly comedic thriller with sharp writing and strong performances that can't settle its tone or give the story enough depth."
Witty dialogue and B.J. Novak's performance anchor the film's mix of mystery and dark comedy. The story is uneven, though: tonal shifts undercut the thriller elements, and the plot doesn't fully deliver on its early promise.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
B.J. Novak’s Vengeance (2022) isn’t just another dark comedy—it’s a high-stakes experiment in multitasking. The actor-writer-director took on all three roles for the film, a move he later admitted left him “triple-scared”. The project, which blends true-crime satire with a Texas-set mystery, marks Novak’s feature directorial debut, and the pressure was palpable. In a rare behind-the-scenes reveal, Novak described the experience as a “crash course in humility,” juggling script rewrites, on-set decisions, latestnetflix.com maintains, and his own performance—all while navigating the expectations of a cast that includes Issa Rae and Ashton Kutcher.
Vengeance follows Ben Manalowitz (Novak), a New York journalist who travels to West Texas after a casual fling (played by Lio Tipton) dies under mysterious circumstances. What begins as a personal quest spirals into a media-fueled frenzy, with Novak’s character launching a true-crime podcast to unravel the truth. The film’s tone—equal parts satire and suspense—mirrors the real-life boom of true-crime storytelling, a theme Novak leans into with sharp, self-aware humor.
Critics have noted how the movie captures the absurdity of podcast culture, with Novak’s character becoming increasingly entangled in the very narrative he’s trying to exploit. One reviewer called it a “love letter to the genre, warts and all”, praising its ability to balance dark comedy with genuine tension. The Texas setting, too, plays a crucial role, offering a stark contrast to Novak’s fish-out-of-water protagonist.
Novak’s co-stars bring their own flair to the project. Issa Rae, as Ben’s producer, delivers dry wit and no-nonsense energy, while Ashton Kutcher appears in a supporting role that subverts his usual comedic persona. Lesser-known but standout performances come from Boyd Holbrook as the deceased woman’s brother and J. Smith-Cameron as her mother, both adding emotional weight to the film’s darker moments.
A surprise cameo from musician John Mayer—playing himself in a meta twist—adds another layer of humor, though some viewers found it more distracting than clever. Dove Cameron and Isabella Amara round out the cast, with Cameron’s role as a local teen providing a grounded counterpoint to Novak’s neurotic outsider.
Despite its ambitious premise, Vengeance has divided audiences. Some praise Novak’s direction as confident and inventive, particularly his ability to blend genres. Others argue the film’s tonal shifts—from satire to thriller to family drama—don’t always cohere, leaving it feeling uneven. A common critique is that the movie’s third act struggles to stick the landing, with some viewers calling the ending “rushed” or “too neat”.
Still, Novak’s willingness to take risks has earned him respect. Directing, writing, and starring in a film is a rare feat, and his self-deprecating admission of being “triple-scared” suggests he approached the project with both ambition and vulnerability. Whether Vengeance is a cult hit or a flawed experiment, it’s undeniably a bold step for Novak’s career.
The film’s journey to theaters wasn’t without hurdles. Originally slated for a wider release, Vengeance faced delays before landing a July 29, 2022, debut. The trailer teased a mix of dark humor and suspense, promising a fresh take on the true-crime genre. While box office numbers remain scarce, the movie’s streaming presence has kept it in the conversation, with some fans dissecting its themes in deep-dive videos.
For Novak, the project seems less about commercial success and more about creative exploration. In an era where true-crime podcasts dominate pop culture, Vengeance offers a wry, self-aware critique—one that only someone deeply embedded in the genre could pull off.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.