Skip to main content
Movie poster for A Classic Horror Story (2021)

A Classic Horror Story

2021
1h 35m
NC-17 · Italian
Director: Roberto De Feo
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Five people travelling by camper crash into a tree. When they recover, the road they were driving on has been replaced by an impenetrable forest and a wooden house.

Trailer

Official

Cast

11 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Forest That Watches Back

I’ve seen enough horror films to know the rules by heart. The road trip gone wrong, the isolated cabin, the strangers forced to confront their secrets—it’s all been done before. But A Classic Horror Story doesn’t just follow the script; it stares at it, smirks, and then sets it on fire.

What begins as a familiar nightmare quickly spirals into something far more unsettling: a horror film that knows it’s a horror film, and isn’t afraid to play with the audience’s expectations like a cat with a half-dead mouse.

The premise is deceptively simple. Five strangers—Matilda Lutz’s Elisa, a pregnant woman with a haunted past; Francesco Russo’s Mark, a cocky influencer; Peppino Mazzotta’s Riccardo, a middle-aged man with a secret; Will Merrick’s English tourist; and Yuliia Sobol’s foreign exchange student—crash their camper into a tree. When they wake up, the road has vanished, replaced by an endless forest and a wooden house that shouldn’t exist.

From there, the film takes a sharp left turn into territory that’s equal parts giallo, folk horror, and meta-commentary on the genre itself. (Or at least, that’s what it feels like—without spoiling the specifics, let’s just say the film isn’t content to let its characters, or its audience, off the hook.)

A lone figure stands in the eerie glow of a forest at night, the trees looming like silent sentinels.

Roberto De Feo and Paolo Strippoli, the film’s co-directors, have crafted something that feels distinctly Italian in its approach to horror. There’s a rawness to the violence, a willingness to let the camera linger on the grotesque in a way that American horror often softens with jump scares or CGI gloss. The influence of Italian horror masters like Dario Argento and Lucio Fulci is palpable, not just in the film’s aesthetic but in its refusal to hold the audience’s hand.

This is a film that trusts its viewers to keep up—or to squirm in their seats if they can’t.

The forest itself is the real star here. It’s not just a setting; it’s a character, one that breathes and shifts and watches. The cinematography leans into the uncanny, using the natural light (or lack thereof) to create a world that feels both hyper-real and dreamlike.

The trees are too tall, the shadows too deep, the silence too heavy. When the film does break its quiet, it’s with a suddenness that feels like a physical blow. (I flinched more than once, and I’ve seen Hereditary.) The sound design is equally effective, using the absence of noise to build tension before unleashing a cacophony of screams, whispers, and something far worse: the sound of something moving in the dark.

But what makes A Classic Horror Story more than just a well-crafted scare machine is its willingness to subvert expectations. Without giving too much away, the film plays with the idea of what horror is—not just in terms of its narrative twists, but in its exploration of who gets to be the victim, who gets to be the monster, and what happens when those roles blur. There’s a moment midway through the film where the characters realize they’re not just fighting for their lives; they’re fighting against something far more insidious, something that’s been lurking in the genre itself.

It’s a bold move, and one that could have easily backfired. But De Feo and Strippoli pull it off, largely because they never lose sight of the human element. Even when the film is at its most surreal, the characters remain grounded in their fear, their desperation, and their flaws.

A dimly lit room inside a wooden house, where shadows stretch unnaturally across the walls.

The performances are uniformly strong, but Matilda Lutz stands out as Elisa. There’s a quiet intensity to her performance, a sense of someone carrying a weight that’s about to break her. You can see the fear in her eyes, but also the determination—not just to survive, but to understand what’s happening to her.

It’s a role that could have easily tipped into melodrama, but Lutz keeps it grounded in something real. The rest of the cast holds their own, particularly Francesco Russo’s Mark, whose arrogance masks a deeper vulnerability, and Peppino Mazzotta’s Riccardo, whose secrets feel like they could unravel the entire film.

If there’s a flaw here, it’s that the film’s ambition occasionally outstrips its execution. The third act takes a turn that feels less like a natural progression and more like a swerve into the absurd. It’s not that the twist doesn’t work—it does, in a way that left me questioning everything I’d just seen—but it also feels like a gamble that doesn’t entirely pay off.

The film’s meta-commentary on horror tropes is clever, but it also risks alienating viewers who came for a straightforward scare. (Though, let’s be honest, if you’re watching an Italian horror film called A Classic Horror Story, you probably know what you’re signing up for.)

Still, even the missteps feel intentional. This is a film that wants to challenge its audience, to make them uncomfortable not just with what they’re seeing, but with why they’re seeing it. It’s a rare horror film that’s as interested in the psychology of fear as it is in the mechanics of it.

And in a genre that often relies on formula, that’s refreshing.

A close-up of a character's face, half-lit by flickering light, their expression a mix of terror and resignation.

I walked out of A Classic Horror Story with that familiar post-horror buzz—the kind where your skin feels too tight, your pulse too fast, and your mind too full of images you can’t quite shake. But I also walked out thinking. About the stories we tell ourselves to make sense of the dark.

About the monsters we create when we’re too afraid to look at the real ones. And about how, sometimes, the scariest thing isn’t the forest at all. It’s the realization that you’ve been lost in it long before the story even began.

The film’s reception has been mixed, with some viewers praising its boldness and others dismissing it as too convoluted or self-indulgent. SensCritique gives it a 5.3/10, a score that feels harsh but not entirely undeserved. It’s not a perfect film, but it’s a memorable one—and in a genre that often prioritizes formula over originality, that’s something.

Whether you love it or hate it, A Classic Horror Story will linger with you long after the credits roll. And really, isn’t that what horror is supposed to do?

Audience Opinions

Audience 5.3/10
"A divisive Italian horror film with gore and atmosphere, a messy plot, and uneven pacing."

Viewers like the eerie setting and creative gore effects. The twists are convoluted and the tone shifts abruptly, frustrating many. The cast is serviceable but can't lift the material.

What viewers praise
  • Creative gore and effects Creative, impactful practical effects and gore.
  • Atmospheric setting An eerie, isolated location builds dread.
  • Strong opening act A suspenseful first half raises expectations.
  • Unique Italian horror vibe Its Italian horror roots set it apart from Hollywood fare.
Common complaints
  • Confusing plot Overcomplicated, hard-to-follow twists.
  • Uneven pacing Some scenes drag, others rush key moments.
  • Weak character development Thin characters.
  • Disappointing ending An unsatisfying ending.
  • Mixed tone Horror, dark humor, and drama clash.
Recommended for
Gore and horror effects enthusiasts Fans of Italian horror cinema Viewers who enjoy atmospheric thrillers Those who like unpredictable plots Horror fans open to messy storytelling

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s A Classic Horror Story: The Italian Slasher That Divided Fans

A Classic Horror Story (2021) arrived on Netflix with a bold premise: an Italian horror flick blending folk terror with modern slasher tropes. Directed by Roberto De Feo (with co-director Paolo Strippoli, per the credits), the film promised a fresh take on the genre—one that left audiences sharply divided. With a middling 5.latestnetflix.com's read is that 3/10 rating on SensCritique and a cast led by Rings survivor Matilda Lutz, the movie’s behind-the-scenes story is almost as chaotic as its on-screen twists.

A Dual-Director Gamble

The film’s most unusual detail? It had two directors. Roberto De Feo, known for The Nest (2019), helmed the project alongside Paolo Strippoli, a name less familiar in horror circles. Sources confirm the collaboration, but the division of labor remains unclear. Did the duo clash over tone? Was it a creative partnership or a logistical necessity? Netflix hasn’t spilled the tea, but the dual credit is rare for a single film—especially one marketed as a tight, 95-minute thriller.

Strippoli’s involvement is barely mentioned in promotional materials, which leaned heavily on De Feo’s name. Trailers and teasers spotlighted the film’s eerie Italian countryside setting and Lutz’s lead role, but the co-director’s contributions? A mystery. Rumor (unconfirmed) suggests Strippoli handled second-unit work, but without official statements, it’s pure speculation.

The Cast’s Survival Horror

Matilda Lutz, fresh off her Rings (2017) notoriety, anchored the film as Elisa, a woman trapped in a nightmarish road trip. The ensemble—including The Young Pope’s Peppino Mazzotta and British actor Will Merrick—delivered performances that critics called "serviceable" but not groundbreaking. Behind the scenes, however, the shoot might’ve been its own horror story.

  • Language Barriers: The film was shot in Italian with English subtitles, but the cast included non-Italian speakers like Merrick and Yuliia Sobol. How did they navigate dialogue? Dubbing? On-set translators? The evidence is silent. - Giallo Homage or Mess? A Classic Horror Story leans into Italy’s giallo tradition, but its abrupt tonal shifts (folk horror to slasher to meta-commentary) left some viewers baffled. Was this intentional or a sign of creative disarray? - Netflix’s Gamble: The streamer released the film on July 14, 2021, burying it in a crowded summer slate. Did Netflix botch the rollout, or was the film’s divisive nature the real issue?

The Missing Backstory

For a movie with this much intrigue, A Classic Horror Story’s production details are frustratingly scarce. No cast interviews reveal on-set drama, no director’s commentary explains the dual-helming, and no behind-the-scenes footage (like the Netflix backstage clip) offers real insight. The film’s biggest mystery might be why its creators stayed so quiet.

One thing’s clear: A Classic Horror Story wasn’t the breakout hit Netflix hoped for. With a 5.3/10 rating and a legacy as "that weird Italian horror movie," it’s now a footnote in 2021’s horror lineup. But for fans of offbeat slashers, its chaotic energy might just be its charm.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.