Skip to main content
Movie poster for The School for Good and Evil (2022)

The School for Good and Evil

“There are two sides to every story.”

2022
2h 29m
PG-13 · English
Director: Paul Feig
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Best friends Sophie and Agatha navigate an enchanted school for young heroes and villains — and find themselves on opposing sides of the battle between good and evil.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

How to Build a Fairy Tale and Then Trip Over It

Paul Feig’s The School for Good and Evil has the look of a movie that was assembled in a room full of storyboards, costume sketches, and very expensive mood boards — and then left to argue with itself. You can feel the machinery working almost all the time. The color palette is dutifully split between warm golds and cold blues; the camera keeps wandering through vaulted halls and storybook exteriors as if it’s trying to convince you that enchantment is a matter of architecture.

latestnetflix.com's take is that but the deeper problem is that the movie is too interested in labels — good, evil, princess, witch, hero, villain — to trust the messier thing those labels are meant to hide.People.

What’s most interesting, to me, is that Feig isn’t an obvious choice for this material, at least not on paper. He came up through character-driven comedy (Bridesmaids, Spy) and has a gift for staging social discomfort — for letting vanity, panic, and resentment leak out in a room before the plot even notices. Here, working from Soman Chainani’s popular YA novels, he’s in more overt fantasy territory, but he keeps trying to smuggle in that old interest in people performing the versions of themselves that they think will be rewarded.

That’s the movie’s real subject, even when the script pretends it’s destiny or magic. I suspect Feig understands that a school for heroes and villains is just a more theatrical version of adolescence: the costume you’re handed, the role you’re expected to play, the fear that the wrong face will decide your future.

The trouble is that the film often explains itself instead of letting its images do the work. It announces the system, the hierarchy, the ancient split between light and dark, and then repeats the explanation with the persistence of a school assembly. When the movie finally relaxes, though, it occasionally finds a sharper rhythm.

One of the widely discussed pleasures is simply the production design itself — those candy-colored but slightly antiseptic spaces that make the institution feel less like Hogwarts than a luxury brand’s idea of moral education. Everything looks polished enough to be suspicious. Even the beauty has rules.

That’s why the film’s best moments tend to be the ones where the surfaces crack. The training sequences, the sorting rituals, the little acts of social pressure among the students — these are where the movie briefly resembles something less generic and more observant. You can almost feel Feig’s comic timing trying to push through the fantasy varnish.

There’s a nice irony in a story about good and evil being most alive when it’s about embarrassment, envy, and the terror of being misread. I kept thinking that if the movie had trusted that angle harder, it might have become something sly rather than merely busy.

The cast is part of the reason the movie doesn’t collapse under its own glitter. Sofia Wylie brings a grounded, almost athletic directness that helps keep the fantasy from floating away; she has the bearing of someone who’s used to being physically precise, and that matters in a film where emotions are often externalized through movement. Sophia Anne Caruso, by contrast, has a more brittle, inward quality that suits a character under constant self-surveillance.

She’s been working since she was very young, including onstage, and you can feel that discipline in the way she holds tension in her shoulders and jaw — as if even standing still is an argument with the world. Together, they create the movie’s most believable friendship, which is also its central bet: that intimacy can survive asymmetry, rivalry, and bad narrative design.

Charlize Theron and Kerry Washington, meanwhile, know exactly what kind of movie they’re in, which is to say they understand that camp is only fun when it’s committed to with a straight face. Theron gives her role a sleek, amused severity; Washington adds warmth without turning the whole thing syrupy. Laurence Fishburne has the rare gift of making exposition sound like lore instead of homework.

I wish the script had given him more to do besides supervise the mythology, but even in reduced form he lends the proceedings a little gravity. That’s useful here, because the movie often feels as if it’s glancing toward depth and then remembering it has another transformation scene to get to.

A scene near the center captures both the film’s strengths and its limitations. A ritualized confrontation — all heightened expectation, formal language, and students arranged like pieces on a board — should, in theory, be where the story clarifies itself. Instead, what lands is the awkwardness of the bodies inside the system.

Faces freeze. Postures stiffen. The camera lingers just long enough for uncertainty to become a visual fact.

Then the editing hurries us onward, as if it’s afraid to sit with the discomfort it has just created. That’s the movie in miniature: a flash of something socially and emotionally legible, followed by another burst of narrative obligation.

There’s been a fair amount of talk about the film as an adaptation that flattens the richness of its source material, and I get that complaint, though I’m always a little wary of treating adaptation as a math problem. The more useful question is whether the movie creates its own reason for existing. Here, I’m not entirely sure it does.

It has some impressive surfaces, a few committed performers, and enough visual confidence to suggest a stronger movie somewhere inside it. But it also has the restless, over-explained feeling of a story that doesn’t trust the audience to recognize meaning unless it’s printed in large type and illuminated. The Guardian’s review called it “an overcooked fairy tale,” and that sounds right to me.

Not dead. Just overworked.

What lingers for me isn’t the grand battle between good and evil — fantasy movies love that stuff too much anyway. It’s the smaller anxiety underneath it: what if the role assigned to you is wrong, or only half right, or right in a way that costs you something? That’s a real adolescent fear, and not just an adolescent one.

We all spend too much of our lives trying to stay inside the script we think other people have written for us. The School for Good and Evil keeps reaching for that idea, then hiding it under capes, castles, and catalog-perfect costumes. When it forgets to lecture, you can almost see the better movie struggling to get out.

Audience Opinions

Broad evidence
Audience 4.6/10
"Critics dismissed the fantasy adaptation as a convoluted young-adult misfire, but general audiences received it far more warmly."

Paul Feig's 147-minute fantasy drew a clear split on its October 2022 release. Reviewers faulted its lack of cleverness and its unoriginal, overcomplicated story, while regular viewers enjoyed its comedic moments and rated it significantly higher than critics did.

What viewers praise
  • Comedic Touches The film lands some genuinely funny moments amid its grand fantasy backdrop.
  • Stronger Crowd Reception Regular audiences were noticeably more enthusiastic than critics.
Common complaints
  • Convoluted Plotting The story is weighed down by an overstuffed YA structure across 147 minutes.
  • Derivative Concept Both audiences and critics found the material lacking in originality and wit.
Recommended for
Fans of big-budget young-adult fantasy Fans of lighthearted magical comedies

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Inside the Magic: Behind-the-Scenes of The School for Good and Evil (2022)

Netflix’s The School for Good and Evil (2022) brought Soman Chainani’s bestselling fantasy series to life under the direction of Paul Feig, blending fairy-tale whimsy with Hollywood star power. While the film’s reception was mixed—garnering a modest 4.6/10 on SensCritique —the behind-the-scenes buzz reveals a production packed with playful energy, unexpected challenges, latestnetflix.com contends, and a cast that leaned into the story’s quirky charm.

A Cast That Played as Hard as They Worked

The film’s young leads, Sofia Wylie (High School Musical: The Musical: The Series) and Sophia Anne Caruso (Beetlejuice), didn’t just act opposite each other—they turned the set into a playground. In a series of Netflix-hosted challenges, the co-stars and their castmates hammed it up for the camera, trading pick-up lines in a "Charm Battle" and debating hypotheticals in an "Ever or Never" game. Clips show Wylie and Caruso cracking up over absurd scenarios, like whether they’d rather kiss a frog or a villain, while co-stars Jamie Flatters and Earl Cave egged them on. The chemistry wasn’t just for the screen; it spilled into off-camera antics, with the cast bonding over everything from rehearsals to shared inside jokes.

Charlize Theron and Kerry Washington, playing the film’s more sinister figures, kept things light too. In interviews, Wylie and Caruso gushed about Theron’s warmth, calling her a "second mom" on set. The veteran actress reportedly brought a mix of discipline and humor, balancing the film’s darker tones with her own playful energy. Meanwhile, Washington, who played the enigmatic Professor Dovey, was praised for her mentorship, particularly with the younger cast members.

Paul Feig’s Vision: A Director’s Playground

Feig, known for his work on Bridesmaids and Spy, brought his signature blend of comedy and heart to the fantasy genre. But adapting a book series with a cult following wasn’t without pressure. Chainani’s novels—six books deep with over 4.5 million copies sold —had a devoted fanbase, and condensing the first installment into a single film required creative liberties. Feig leaned into the story’s inherent absurdity, encouraging the cast to embrace the campiness of a world where children are trained to become fairy-tale heroes and villains.

The director’s hands-on approach extended to the film’s visuals. The School for Good and Evil’s gothic-meets-whimsical aesthetic demanded elaborate sets and costumes, and Feig reportedly pushed for practical effects where possible. In a behind-the-scenes clip, Caruso and Wylie raved about the film’s creature designs, particularly Reaper, the school’s ominous black cat. The feline became an unexpected scene-stealer, with the cast joking about its diva-like behavior between takes.

Soundtrack and Style: A World of Its Own

The film’s soundtrack, composed by Theodore Shapiro (Trance, The Devil Wears Prada), aimed to match its duality—equal parts enchanting and eerie. The score, released as an OST, blended orchestral swells with modern flourishes, mirroring the story’s clash between light and dark. While the soundtrack didn’t make major waves, it underscored the film’s attempt to straddle genres, much like the book’s tone.

Visually, the movie leaned into its fairy-tale roots, with the School for Good’s pristine towers contrasting sharply with the School for Evil’s jagged spires. Costume designer Renee Ehrlich Kalfus (Ocean’s 8) crafted looks that reflected each character’s arc, from Wylie’s Sophie’s evolving wardrobe (shifting from frilly pink to darker hues) to Theron’s Lady Lesso’s regal villainy. The attention to detail extended to the film’s magical effects, though some critics noted the CGI occasionally fell short of the book’s vivid descriptions.

The Verdict: A Mixed Bag with Heart

Despite its star-studded cast and high-energy set, The School for Good and Evil struggled to win over audiences or critics. SensCritique’s 4.6/10 rating and Rotten Tomatoes’ sparse audience scores suggest the film’s ambitious blend of comedy, fantasy, and drama didn’t quite land. Yet, the behind-the-scenes moments paint a picture of a production that was, at the very least, a labor of love.

For fans of the books, the adaptation may have felt like a missed opportunity, but for the cast and crew, it was a chance to dive headfirst into a world of magic—and a little mischief. Whether it was Theron’s maternal pep talks, Feig’s comedic touch, or the cast’s off-camera shenanigans, the film’s legacy might ultimately lie in its behind-the-scenes stories, not its box-office numbers.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.