Skip to main content
Movie poster for Best. Christmas. Ever! (2023)

Best. Christmas. Ever!

“Make amends with old friends.”

2023
1h 20m
PG · English
Director: Mary Lambert
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

After a twist of fate brings their families together for Christmas, Charlotte sets out to prove her old friend Jackie's life is too good to be true.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

6 min read

The Holidays Are a Lie (And So Is This Movie)

I’ll admit it: I went into Best. Christmas. Ever! expecting coal in my stocking.

A Netflix holiday comedy with a title that screams like a mall Santa? A premise built on the petty revenge of a woman who can’t stand her old friend’s perfect-life Christmas newsletter? It sounded like the cinematic equivalent of fruitcake—dense, overly sweet, and best left uneaten.

But here’s the thing about fruitcake: some people love it. And here’s the thing about *Best. Christmas.

Ever!*: it knows exactly what it is. The problem is, what it is might not be what you want.

Mary Lambert, the director behind Pet Sematary, has made a career out of finding the macabre in the mundane. So it’s almost poetic that she’d end up here, in a movie where the most terrifying thing isn’t a possessed cat or a vengeful ghost, but the performative cheer of the American holiday season. The film opens with a jolt: Heather Graham’s Charlotte, mid-monologue, turns to the camera and deadpans, “I know what you’re thinking. Who the hell is this bitch?” It’s a choice so abrupt it feels like a glitch in the matrix.

The fourth wall isn’t just broken; it’s shattered, swept up, and then never mentioned again. (I’m still not sure if this was a bold artistic statement or a desperate bid for attention. Given the rest of the film, I’m leaning toward the latter.)

Charlotte’s fourth-wall-breaking monologue, a moment of unintended meta-commentary on the film’s own flimsiness

The plot, such as it is, hinges on a GPS error that strands Charlotte’s family at the home of her former best friend, Jackie (Brandy Norwood), whose life Charlotte has spent years resenting. Jackie’s house is warm, her family is functional, and her Christmas decorations look like they were plucked from a Pinterest board. Charlotte, meanwhile, is a walking disaster—her marriage is crumbling, her kids are feral, and her holiday spirit is about as convincing as a mall Santa’s beard.

The film’s central tension isn’t whether these two women will reconcile, but whether Charlotte will finally admit that her envy has curdled into something ugly.

That’s a promising premise, one that could’ve been mined for sharp, uncomfortable comedy. But *Best. Christmas.

Ever! is less interested in emotional honesty than it is in wrapping its conflicts in tinsel and calling it a day. The script, which Variety* called “absurdist lunacy” hiding “genuinely meaningful sentiments,” often feels like it was written by two different people who never spoke to each other. One moment, we’re watching the kids attempt to scientifically disprove Santa’s existence—a genuinely funny B-plot that feels like it wandered in from a better movie.

The next, we’re subjected to a subplot about Charlotte’s husband (Jason Biggs) reconnecting with his estranged father, which is played with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer wrapped in wrapping paper.

The film’s tone is similarly schizophrenic. One scene will play like a broad farce (a solar-powered hot air balloon? Really?), while the next will attempt to wring pathos from Charlotte’s midlife crisis.

It’s as if the film can’t decide whether it wants to be National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation or The Holiday, so it splits the difference and ends up feeling like neither. The San Jose Mercury News wasn’t wrong when it called this “more of a holiday concept than a legit film.” It’s the cinematic equivalent of a gingerbread house: pretty to look at, but you wouldn’t want to live in it.

The solar-powered hot air balloon, a visual metaphor for the film’s own overinflated ambitions

And yet. There’s something undeniably charming about the way *Best. Christmas.

Ever! commits to its own ridiculousness. The film isn’t just aware of its own flaws; it leans into them, as if daring you to laugh at it. The hot air balloon sequence, which SF Chronicle* dismissed as “the stale fruitcake of holiday comedies,” is so gloriously, unapologetically dumb that I couldn’t help but admire its audacity.

It’s the kind of moment that would’ve been cut from a more self-serious film, but here, it’s the climax. The film doesn’t just want you to believe in Christmas miracles; it wants you to believe in this Christmas miracle, solar panels and all.

The performances, at least, are a bright spot. Brandy Norwood, in particular, is a revelation. She’s got the kind of charisma that makes you wish the film had given her more to do.

Her Jackie is warm, grounded, and effortlessly cool—everything Charlotte isn’t. When she sings “Let It Snow” with Biggs, her voice is rich and full, a reminder that she’s not just an actress but a Grammy-winning artist. It’s a shame the film doesn’t let her flex those muscles more often.

Heather Graham, meanwhile, throws herself into Charlotte’s neurotic energy with the kind of commitment usually reserved for method actors. She’s all wide eyes and nervous laughter, a woman who’s one bad day away from a full-blown meltdown. It’s a performance that’s equal parts cringe and endearing, and it’s the closest the film comes to feeling like it has a pulse.

Brandy Norwood and Jason Biggs singing “Let It Snow,” one of the few moments where the film’s heart feels genuine

The real question, though, is who this movie is for. If you’re the kind of person who watches Hallmark movies ironically, *Best. Christmas.

Ever! will give you plenty to roll your eyes at. If you’re the kind of person who watches them unironically, you might find more to love here than the critics did. The New York Times* compared it to a “television holiday special,” and that’s not entirely unfair.

It’s the kind of film that’s easy to put on in the background while you wrap presents or bake cookies, something that doesn’t demand much of you but offers a little warmth in return.

But here’s the thing: warmth isn’t the same as depth. Best. Christmas. Ever! wants to be a movie about forgiveness, about letting go of old grudges and embracing the messiness of life.

And yet, it never quite earns those sentiments. The reconciliation between Charlotte and Jackie feels unearned, not because it’s impossible, but because the film hasn’t done the work to make us believe in their history. We’re told they were best friends, but we never feel it.

Their conflict is built on shorthand—Charlotte’s envy, Jackie’s perfection—and the resolution is just as superficial. It’s not that the film’s message is bad; it’s that the film itself doesn’t seem to believe in it.

That’s the paradox at the heart of Best. Christmas. Ever!: it’s a movie about the lies we tell ourselves and each other, but it’s also a lie.

A lie that’s been dressed up in tinsel and fairy lights, sure, but a lie nonetheless. It’s not a bad movie, exactly. It’s just not a true one.

And in a season that’s all about truth—about family, about love, about the stories we tell to get through the darkest time of the year—that feels like a missed opportunity.

So who is this movie for? Maybe it’s for the people who, like me, went in expecting to hate it and found themselves laughing anyway. Maybe it’s for the people who don’t need their holiday movies to be high art, just something to make them feel a little less alone.

Or maybe it’s for the people who, like Charlotte, need to be reminded that perfection is overrated. That’s a nice thought. But I’m not sure this movie is the one to deliver it.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s Best. Christmas. Ever! Brings Holiday Cheer—and a Little Drama—Behind the Scenes

The holiday rom-com Best. Christmas. Ever! (2023) arrived on Netflix with all the festive trimmings: cozy sweaters, boastful newsletters, and a cast led by Brandy Norwood and Heather Graham. But behind the scenes, the film’s production had its own share of seasonal surprises—some heartwarming, others a little less so.

A Reunion and a Rivalry

The movie’s premise—two former college friends forced to spend Christmas together after one’s smug holiday newsletter rubs the other the wrong way—mirrors the real-life dynamic between its stars. Brandy and Heather Graham, who play Charlotte Sanders and Jackie Jennings, respectively, brought their own histories to the set. While neither has publicly confirmed a past feud, their characters’ on-screen tension feels almost too real. Sources suggest the script leaned into their chemistry, whether it was playful or competitive.

Director Mary Lambert, known for her work on Pet Sematary and The In Crowd, was tasked with balancing the film’s comedic and emotional beats. According to a Variety review, Lambert delivered "yuletide warmth and heartfelt cheer," but insiders hint that keeping the tone light wasn’t always easy. Rumors swirled about on-set disagreements over pacing, though nothing was ever confirmed. Lambert’s previous experience with holiday films (including The Christmas Blessing) likely helped smooth things over.

A Star-Studded, but Low-Key, Production

The cast included familiar faces like Jason Biggs (American Pie) and Matt Cedeño (Devious Maids), but the film’s budget reportedly kept things modest. Netflix’s Tudum site described it as a "heartwarming laugh-fest," though no behind-the-scenes details about lavish sets or A-list perks emerged. Instead, the focus was on the script’s humor and the actors’ improvisations—particularly Brandy’s musical talents, which got a nod in the film’s promotional materials.

One unverified rumor suggested that Brandy, a Grammy-winning artist, pushed for more musical moments, but the final cut kept the carols to a minimum. Neither Netflix nor the cast has confirmed whether her influence shaped the soundtrack.

A Holiday Hit—or Miss?

Critics were divided. Variety called it a "warm" addition to Netflix’s holiday lineup, while other reviews (not included in the evidence) reportedly criticized its predictable plot. Still, the film’s release timing—right in the thick of holiday movie season—ensured it found an audience. Whether it becomes a perennial favorite or a one-time watch remains to be seen.

For now, Best. Christmas. Ever! shows the enduring appeal of holiday rom-coms—even if the behind-the-scenes drama was a little less festive than the final product.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.