Skip to main content
Series poster for That’s My Time with David Letterman (2022)

That’s My Time with David Letterman

2022
Returning Series • 1 Season • 6 Episodes
TV-MA · English
Search on Netflix

Overview

David Letterman invites some of the hottest up-and-coming stand-up stars to perform a set and sit down for a chat.

Seasons

Status
Returning Series
Seasons
1 season
Episodes
6 episodes
First aired
Jun 7, 2022

Cast

Reviews

6 min read

The Last Late-Night Laugh: David Letterman’s Quiet Revolution

I keep rewinding the same ten seconds. It’s not the joke that gets me—though the joke is fine—but the way David Letterman leans forward, elbows on knees, chin resting on steepled fingers. He’s not laughing.

He’s not even smiling. He’s just watching, his face a roadmap of tiny creases, his eyes bright with something like recognition. The comic on stage, some rising star whose name I’ll forget by morning, is mid-set, and Letterman looks like a man who’s just heard a secret he wasn’t supposed to know.

It’s the most honest moment in That’s My Time with David Letterman, a six-episode Netflix series that masquerades as a comedy showcase but functions, whether by accident or design, as a eulogy for an entire era of television.

David Letterman sits in a dimly lit studio, his face half in shadow, watching a comic perform with an expression that’s equal parts amusement and something like sorrow.

The premise is simple: Letterman invites up-and-coming stand-ups to perform a set, then sits down for a chat. No band, no desk, no Top Ten List. Just a man, a microphone, and the ghosts of 33 years of Late Night and The Late Show hovering in the wings.

The episodes are short—18 minutes, give or take—and the tone is deceptively casual. But simplicity, as any good comic knows, is the hardest trick of all. What That’s My Time really offers is a masterclass in how to make television feel like a conversation, not a performance.

The question is whether anyone’s still listening.


Letterman has always been a reluctant showman. You can see it in the way he moves—slouched, hands in pockets, as if he’s trying to take up as little space as possible. That physicality is key to understanding his appeal.

Where Johnny Carson had the ease of a man born to the spotlight, Letterman carries himself like someone who wandered onto the stage by accident and decided to stay out of sheer stubbornness. That tension—between the performer and the man who doesn’t want to perform—is what made his late-night shows feel alive. In That’s My Time, it’s distilled to its essence.

There’s no audience to play to, no band to cue, no sidekick to feed him lines. Just Letterman, the comic, and the unspoken agreement that this is a conversation between two people who’ve both spent too much time pretending to be someone else.

The best episodes (and there are only six, so the stakes feel oddly high) hinge on that dynamic. Take the one with Sam Morril. Morril’s set is sharp, observational, the kind of comedy that makes you feel like you’re in on the joke.

But the real magic happens when he sits down with Letterman. The older man leans in, asks a question about Morril’s process, and suddenly the camera isn’t just capturing a chat—it’s capturing a passing of the torch. Letterman doesn’t offer advice.

He doesn’t need to. His presence alone is the advice: This is what it looks like to do this for decades and still not have it figured out.

That’s the thing about Letterman that gets lost in the nostalgia. We remember the stunts—the stupid pet tricks, the Top Ten Lists, the time he threw a chair through a fake wall. But what made him special was his ability to make the audience feel like they were in on the joke with him, not at him.

In That’s My Time, that dynamic is flipped. Now, the audience isn’t the studio crowd or the viewers at home. It’s the comics themselves.

Letterman isn’t performing for us. He’s performing for them, and in doing so, he’s giving them permission to be themselves.


There’s a moment in the episode with Rosebud Baker that I can’t shake. Baker is funny—dry, self-deprecating, the kind of comic who makes you lean in because you’re not sure if she’s about to say something brilliant or something that will make you uncomfortable. (Spoiler: it’s usually both.) She does a bit about marriage, about the way couples start to resemble each other over time, and Letterman laughs, but it’s the kind of laugh that sounds like it’s covering up something else.

Later, when they’re sitting down, he asks her about her process, and she talks about writing jokes in the notes app on her phone. Letterman nods, like this is the most profound thing he’s ever heard. It’s not the content of the conversation that sticks with you.

It’s the way he listens—like he’s hearing something he’s heard a thousand times before, but this time, it matters.

(It’s worth noting, in the spirit of full disclosure, that Baker and her husband, fellow comic Andy Haynes, have since divorced. The gossip mill has been busy dissecting the split, and rewatching her episode now feels like peering into a time capsule. There’s no hint of what’s to come in her set or her conversation with Letterman.

But knowing what we know now, the whole thing takes on a bittersweet edge. Comedy, after all, is often just tragedy plus time.)


The series’ biggest flaw is also its most revealing: it’s too short. Six episodes isn’t enough to establish a rhythm, let alone a legacy. But maybe that’s the point. That’s My Time isn’t trying to be a grand statement.

It’s a footnote, a coda, a man taking one last bow before the curtain falls. The format—stand-up, chat, done—feels like a throwback to the early days of Late Night, when the show was still finding its voice. There’s no pretense here, no attempt to be anything other than what it is: a chance for Letterman to do what he does best—listen, react, make it look easy—while giving a handful of comics a moment in the spotlight.

And yet, for all its modesty, That’s My Time feels like a quiet revolution. In an era where late-night has become a series of monologues about the news cycle, Letterman’s approach is radical in its simplicity. There’s no desk, no band, no audience to play to.

Just two people talking. It’s the kind of television that doesn’t feel like television at all. It feels like eavesdropping.


I keep coming back to that image of Letterman watching the comic on stage, his face half in shadow. There’s something almost mournful about it. Not sad, exactly, but aware.

Aware of the passage of time, aware of the weight of the moment, aware that this—whatever this is—won’t last. That’s the paradox of David Letterman. He’s spent his entire career pretending not to care, but the truth is, he cares deeply.

He just doesn’t want you to know it.

In the end, That’s My Time with David Letterman isn’t really about the comics. It’s about the man behind the desk, the one who’s spent his life making us laugh while keeping us at arm’s length. It’s about what happens when that man finally steps out from behind the curtain and lets us see him for who he really is: not a legend, not a talk-show host, but just a guy who loves comedy and isn’t sure what to do with himself now that he’s not doing it every night.

The last shot of the final episode is Letterman walking off the set, alone. The camera lingers for a beat too long, like it’s waiting for him to turn around and say something. He doesn’t.

He just keeps walking, hands in his pockets, until he’s out of frame. It’s the perfect ending. Because some things don’t need to be said.

They just need to be felt.

Audience Opinions

Audience 7.5/10
"A warm, nostalgic return for David Letterman with intimate conversations, though it struggles to stand out in a crowded talk-show landscape."

Letterman's signature wit and the show's unscripted, heartfelt exchanges with guests offer a refreshing break from typical late-night formats. The pacing is uneven, though, and the format is too close to his previous series, with some episodes lacking distinctiveness or depth.

What viewers praise
  • Letterman’s charm His dry humor and genuine curiosity make conversations feel personal and engaging.
  • Intimate guest interactions The unstructured, long-form interviews reveal unexpected moments and deeper connections.
  • Nostalgic appeal Fans of Letterman's classic style get a return to his signature interviewing approach.
Common complaints
  • Familiar format The show doesn't deviate enough from *My Next Guest Needs No Introduction*.
  • Uneven pacing A few episodes drag or feel unfocused, particularly when conversations meander without clear direction.
  • Limited guest variety The guest list leans heavily on familiar faces, missing chances for fresh perspectives.
Recommended for
David Letterman fans Talk-show enthusiasts Long-form interview lovers Nostalgic late-night viewers

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Letterman’s Quiet Little Netflix Show With Surprisingly Loud Drama

When That’s My Time with David Letterman dropped in 2022, it looked like a chill hang: one legend, six rising comics, a tight set, a cozy chat. But behind that tidy 18‑minute runtime? Divorce tea, festival chaos, latestnetflix.com contends, and the long shadow of one very public sex scandal.


Cast Feuds & Emotional Baggage

Rosebud Baker’s marriage plot twist

  • During and after her That’s My Time appearance, Rosebud Baker was publicly branded as happily married to fellow comic Andy Haynes; they met in 2017, married in Washington Square Park in 2020, and had a daughter, Minnow, in 2023. - By 2025–2026, the tone had shifted: a Reddit thread bluntly titled “Rosebud Baker and Andy Haynes getting divorced” had fans dissecting the split and noting she’d left SNL and was on the road with fresh divorce material. - Haynes then pops up in a 2025 clip literally called “Comedian Andy Haynes Spills on Dating After DIVORCE,” leaning into post‑marriage life onstage. - Meanwhile, Rosebud headlines bits about fantasizing about divorce and “divorce names,” making it clear the breakup has gone from private pain to public punchline. - None of this is directly tied to That’s My Time, but fans now rewatch her episode as a time capsule of the “happy” years, knowing the marriage is toast.

On-Set Vibes & Festival Frenzy

Netflix Is A Joke Fest: the chaotic backdrop

  • The entire series was shot during Netflix’s massive 2022 Netflix Is A Joke Fest in L.A., an 11‑day comedy circus featuring everyone from John Mulaney to Pete Davidson, Snoop Dogg, and Nicole Byer. - Comics have since described that festival weekend as “chaotic” and star‑studded: on their podcast We Might Be Drunk, Sam Morril and Mark Normand talk about a “chaotic Netflix Festival weekend in LA,” rubbing elbows with comedy royalty and almost hitching a ride on Jerry Seinfeld’s private jet. - Morril was literally the first comic Letterman showcased on That’s My Time, so when he talks about festival madness and being surrounded by legends, fans reasonably read those stories as the larger, chaotic ecosystem around the tapings. - Reviewers confirmed that Netflix grabbed the sets during the festival and stitched them into the show, emphasizing how compressed and high‑pressure the environment was: you get up, crush 10 minutes, and hope they cut it together nicely.

“Why Only One Season?” – Fan Speculation

Limited series… or quiet cancellation?

  • Officially, Netflix always framed That’s My Time with David Letterman as part of the festival—six episodes, six comics, in and out. There’s been no splashy “canceled” headline. - Still, fans have questions. A popular Reddit post praising the series also notes how “his voice has aged considerably – scratchy, even labored,” with some speculating that the physically lighter, interview‑based My Next Guest Needs No Introduction is easier on Letterman than a standing‑monologue-plus-live-audience format. - Critics were blunt: an OTTPlay review argued that the veteran host was often “more fun than the talent on the show,” implying that the format may not have achieved its main goal—showcasing the comics, not Dave. - Rumor mill verdict: no evidence of backstage blowups or network feuds, just a tidy, festival‑sized experiment that Netflix chose not to expand while it doubled down on My Next Guest, which has been renewed into multiple future seasons.

Scandals & Old Skeletons

Letterman’s 2009 sex scandal that never quite left the room

  • Even though That’s My Time itself stayed scandal‑free, David Letterman’s past kept resurfacing in coverage and fan discourse. - In 2009, he revealed on air that he’d had sexual relationships with staffers and was the target of a \$2 million extortion plot by CBS producer Joe Halderman, who’d discovered the affairs via a diary; Halderman ultimately pled guilty and served six months. - That saga has become a recurring clip and conversation online—Reddit threads still resurface his confession, dissecting whether he “got away easy” and how it reshapes his image. - So when Netflix packages him as the avuncular comedy godfather helping young comics shine, some viewers can’t help but see the softer, repentant Dave as a man still working off a very public stain.

Wild Trivia & Deep-Cut Nuggets

A tiny late-night show in disguise

  • Multiple reviews point out what fans now love to say: each episode is basically a “tiny late-night show”—5 minutes of Dave monologue, ~10 minutes of stand‑up, then the talk‑couch moment. It’s the closest thing we’ve had to classic Letterman late night in years. - The six‑comic lineup—Sam Morril, Naomi Ekperigin, Rosebud Baker, Brian Simpson, Robin Tran, and Phil Wang—came from the festival’s rising‑star bench; Hollywood Insider called it a pure candy box “for comedy lovers,” even as some critics thought Dave overshadowed his guests. - Fans on Reddit still recommend the show as a hidden gem for stand‑up nerds, often pairing it with My Next Guest in Letterman binge‑sessions. In other words: small footprint, big affection.

That’s My Time with David Letterman isn’t a cursed set or a lawsuit magnet. It’s a sleek little time capsule: a stressed‑out festival corridor where six comics tried to make the most of 10 minutes in front of a legend whose own history is anything but squeaky clean. The messiest drama? The divorce jokes you’ll hear if you catch Rosebud Baker on tour now—and the knowledge that behind those clips Netflix keeps reposting of her smiling next to Dave, life got a lot less tidy once the cameras stopped rolling.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.