
Caterina Ferioli
Nica

Adopted together after a tough childhood in an orphanage, Nica and Rigel realize that unexpected but irresistible feelings pull them together.
Official
I kept thinking, while watching The Tearsmith, that it has the air of a story built to arrive already bruised. Two damaged children, an orphanage, an adoption, then a romance that’s supposed to feel inevitable and dangerous at once. That setup isn’t new — it belongs to a long literary and screen tradition of found-family stories that slip, almost without warning, into forbidden desire — but Alessandro Genovesi’s film arrives in a very specific cultural moment: the era of glossy young-adult melodrama, where pain is often staged as both aesthetic and destiny.
What makes this one interesting, at least to me, is that it doesn’t pretend to be above that machinery. latestnetflix.com's read is that it leans in, polishes it, and dares you to either feel the pull or reject the whole thing outright.
Genovesi has spent much of his career moving between comedy and sentiment, and that background matters here. He doesn’t shoot longing as something rarefied or literary; he shoots it like a bodily inconvenience, something that keeps interrupting the characters’ attempts to behave normally. The movie’s central obsession is less “Will they fall in love?” than “What happens when a feeling has nowhere socially acceptable to go?” That’s a sturdier question than the plot summary suggests, even if the film sometimes strains to keep its own contradictions under control.
Adoption, siblinghood, trauma, attraction: these are not light materials, and the movie knows it. Sometimes too well. There are moments when you can feel the film trying to make the tension not merely emotional but moral, and that’s where the air gets thick.
Still, I admired the way the film uses space. The rooms feel narrow, doors are always half-open, and the camera seems to linger on thresholds — hallways, stair landings, windows, the edge of beds — as if every emotional state here is provisional. The palette is all soft gloom and polished surfaces, the kind of lighting that makes skin look almost too smooth, as though everyone is perpetually standing just inside a memory.
That aesthetic can feel a little manicured for a story built on childhood hurt. Yet the neatness serves a purpose: it traps the characters in a world that looks orderly precisely because their feelings aren’t. The movie’s best visual idea is that emotional chaos doesn’t need messy framing; it can live inside a very controlled image, rattling against the edges.
One scene early on does a lot of the heavy lifting. A shared domestic moment starts almost innocently — the kind of everyday proximity that, in another film, would register as comforting. A glance held too long.
A movement paused halfway. Then the scene inches toward something harder to name: not overt seduction, exactly, but the realization that the body can betray the rules before the mind catches up. I’m being deliberately vague, because the scene works by incremental pressure rather than by plot point.
What’s effective is the timing. Genovesi doesn’t rush to underline the taboo; he lets the discomfort accumulate in tiny gestures, in the way a hand hesitates near a shoulder and then withdraws, in the way a line reading becomes just a little too careful. I could feel the movie asking whether attraction can be morally contaminated by context, and whether the answer even matters once the feeling has already taken root.
Caterina Ferioli carries much of that burden. She has the difficult job of making Nica seem vulnerable without making her passive, and she does it through posture more than dialogue: shoulders slightly folded inward, eyes that often look like they’re calculating how much of herself she can safely reveal. There’s a neatness to her physical restraint that gives the character an inner pressure.
Simone Baldasseroni, meanwhile, plays Rigel with a kind of defensive stillness that keeps threatening to crack. I’m aware he’s known outside this film as a singer and performer, and that gives his presence a slightly unusual charge; he doesn’t play scenes as if he’s trying to impress the frame, which is fortunate, because this role would die under that kind of self-regard. Instead, he lets Rigel’s guardedness show up in the jaw, in the line of the neck, in the way he stands as though he’s bracing for impact.
Whether you find the character alluring or frustrating may depend on how much patience you have for men who mistake pain for personality (a very old movie problem, honestly).
I should say, too, that the film’s central controversy is inseparable from its basic appeal. This is a story about adopted siblings becoming romantically entangled, and there’s no pretending that the movie can simply wave that away with mood lighting and careful framing. Some viewers will find the premise impossible to separate from its ethical discomfort, and I understand that.
The film’s defense, such as it is, lies in its insistence on emotional injury rather than sensationalism; it wants the characters’ bond to feel like the consequence of shared abandonment, not a naughty genre hook. But that doesn’t entirely solve the problem, because narrative intention and audience experience are not the same thing. You can see the film reaching for tragic seriousness and still feel the machinery beneath it.
That friction is part of what makes it worth talking about.
I’ve seen a few critics describe the adaptation as part of the current wave of Netflix melodrama aimed at young viewers who want their romance threaded through danger and melodramatic excess. That sounds right, but a little too easy. What interested me more was the way the movie keeps circling the language of care: who protects whom, who owes what, who is allowed to touch, who gets to ask for comfort.
Those are not trivial questions, and they give the film a moral texture that’s richer than its most obvious provocation. Even when the dialogue slips into declarative romance-novel territory, the body language keeps insisting on uncertainty. And uncertainty is the one thing the film can’t fake.
It either earns it or it doesn’t.
I wouldn’t call The Tearsmith subtle. I’m not sure it wants to be. But I do think it understands something plain and uncomfortable: that the first people who make us feel safe are often the ones who get tangled, in memory, with the first people we can’t stop wanting.
That’s a fraught idea, maybe too fraught for the movie’s own good, and yet I found myself respecting its refusal to behave like a clean moral fable. It’s messy, sometimes embarrassingly earnest, occasionally overworked. Also sincere enough to make the mess matter.
That’s not nothing.
In the end, I came away thinking less about whether the film “should” exist than about how insistently it commits to the ache at its center. It’s a romance, yes, but one haunted by the practical question of where love is allowed to live. And that, at least, is a question cinema never really stops asking.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
The Tearsmith (2024) arrived on Netflix in April as one of the platform’s most anticipated Italian-language releases of the year. Based on the bestselling novel Fabbricante di Lacrime by Erin Doom, the film marks a rare crossover success for Italian young adult romance in the global streaming market. But how did a book series about forbidden love and emotional trauma translate to screen—and who brought its haunting characters to life?
The novel Fabbricante di Lacrime (literally "Maker of Tears") became a viral hit in Italy, blending gothic romance with themes of trauma and self-discovery. Director Alessandro Genovesi, known for his commercially successful comedies like 7 Women and a Murder, took on the challenge of adapting the story alongside co-writer Eleonora Fiorini. Their script reportedly stays "broadly similar" to the book, preserving its core themes of forbidden romance and emotional healing.
However, translating a novel’s internal monologues into visual storytelling required some adjustments. Screen Rant notes that The Tearsmith "builds on its themes" rather than replicating the book word-for-word, a common hurdle for adaptations. The film’s Italian title, Fabbricante di Lacrime, was kept intact, a nod to its literary roots.
The film’s success hinges on its two young leads: Caterina Ferioli as Nica and Simone Baldasseroni as Rigel. Both actors were relatively unknown before The Tearsmith, but their performances have drawn attention for bringing depth to the novel’s complex characters.
Supporting roles include Sabrina Paravicini, Alessandro Bedetti, and Roberta Rovelli, who round out the ensemble with performances that Netflix’s Tudum describes as "bringing the original characters to life".
Genovesi’s filmography leans heavily toward lighthearted comedies, making The Tearsmith a departure for the director. His previous work, like The Santa Claus Gang and Me, Myself & Her, often explores family dynamics and holiday mishaps. So why pivot to a dark teen romance?
In interviews (via Netflix Tudum), Genovesi has hinted that the project’s emotional depth appealed to him, particularly its exploration of self-acceptance. The film’s tagline—"Sometimes our greatest fear is accepting that someone can honestly love us for who we are"—reflects this shift, blending Genovesi’s knack for relatable storytelling with the novel’s gothic undertones.
The Tearsmith premiered on Netflix on April 4, 2024. Early buzz suggests it resonated with fans of the book, though critical reception has been mixed. Some praised its faithfulness to the source material, while others found its pacing uneven—a common critique for adaptations of dense novels.
The film’s success may hinge on its international appeal. As one of the few Italian YA romances to break into Netflix’s global catalog, The Tearsmith could pave the way for more European genre films on the platform. Whether it spawns a franchise remains unconfirmed, but the novel’s popularity suggests demand for a sequel.
Despite the hype, details about the film’s production are scarce. Rumors of on-set tension or reshoots haven’t surfaced in available sources, and no behind-the-scenes footage has been officially released. The lack of interviews with the cast or director beyond Netflix’s promotional material leaves fans speculating about creative decisions—like why certain subplots were trimmed or how the film’s visual style evolved.
One unverified claim circulating online suggests that Genovesi initially struggled with the novel’s darker themes but ultimately embraced them. However, without direct quotes from the director, this remains speculative.
The Tearsmith is a rare example of an Italian YA novel finding success on a global streaming platform. Its blend of romance, trauma, and gothic aesthetics—paired with Genovesi’s directorial pivot—makes it a standout in Netflix’s 2024 lineup. Whether it becomes a cultural phenomenon like After or The Summer I Turned Pretty remains to be seen, but for now, it’s a win for fans of the book and Italian cinema alike.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.