
Jon Hamm
DJ Slizzard

In the probing documentary "Party Monster," DJ Fingablast investigates what became of his childhood hero, DJ Slizzard.
I’ll admit it: I went into Party Monster: Scratching the Surface expecting a lark. The runtime alone—33 minutes—suggests something closer to a glorified SNL sketch than a proper film, and the pedigree of Tina Fey and Robert Carlock (30 Rock, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt) promised at least a few sharp, absurdist laughs. But what I got instead was a mockumentary so thin it might as well have been written on a napkin during a cab ride to the studio.
The premise, such as it is, follows DJ Fingablast (Derek Klena) as he investigates the mysterious disappearance of his childhood hero, DJ Slizzard (Jon Hamm). It’s the kind of high-concept setup that could work—if the execution had any teeth.

The first red flag? The runtime. Thirty-three minutes is barely enough time to establish a joke, let alone sustain one.
Mockumentaries thrive on accumulation—on the slow burn of absurdity, the way This Is Spinal Tap or Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping build their worlds through layered gags and escalating ridiculousness. Here, the humor feels like it was reverse-engineered from a whiteboard brainstorm: What if a DJ was a washed-up has-been? What if his name was Slizzard? The problem isn’t that the jokes are dumb; it’s that they’re there, like a party where no one bothered to show up.
The cast, stacked with 30 Rock alumni (Bobby Moynihan, Tituss Burgess, Ellie Kemper), seems to be operating on autopilot, delivering lines with the energy of people who know they’re in a project that won’t matter in a week. Jon Hamm, usually a master of deadpan charm, sleepwalks through his role as the titular Slizzard, a man so devoid of personality he might as well be a hologram.
What’s most frustrating is how little the film seems to care about its own premise. Mockumentaries succeed when they commit to their bit—when the world they’re satirizing feels lived-in, even if it’s absurd. Party Monster doesn’t bother. The club scenes are populated by extras who look like they were pulled from a casting call for “generic partygoers,” their movements stiff, their expressions blank.
The neon lights and fog machines are there, but the energy isn’t. It’s like watching a stage play where the actors forgot to turn on the sound system. The satire, if you can even call it that, is toothless.
There’s no edge, no subversion—just a vague sense that the filmmakers think DJ culture is silly, and that’s the extent of their insight.
I’ve seen this trick before. It’s the kind of project that gets greenlit because the talent is bankable, not because the idea is. The involvement of Fey and Carlock suggests they were drawn to the idea of a mockumentary—maybe they even pitched it as a 30 Rock-style takedown of EDM culture—but somewhere between the pitch meeting and the final cut, the ambition got lost.
The result feels less like a film and more like a placeholder, something to fill out a streaming queue. The TMDB audience score of 2.0/10 (from a grand total of three votes) suggests I’m not alone in this assessment, but even that feels generous. A 2.0 implies there’s something there to hate. Party Monster doesn’t even rise to that level.
The most damning thing about it isn’t that it’s bad—it’s that it’s nothing. A 33-minute shrug. A joke that forgot to be funny.
In an era where comedy is increasingly defined by its willingness to take risks, to punch up, to mean something, Party Monster is content to exist in the background, a blip on the radar of a cast that’s moved on to bigger and better things. It’s not offensive, it’s not memorable, it’s not even bad in an interesting way. It’s just… there.
Like a party you didn’t realize was over until you looked around and realized everyone else had left.
"A short, lighthearted comedy that offers brief amusement but leaves little lasting impact."
Feedback on this 33-minute comedy is sparse; it registers as a quick, inoffensive watch. The humor is mild and forgettable, with little depth or standout moments. Its brevity cuts both ways: the runtime is concise, but there isn't much substance.
Party Monster: Scratching the Surface is the third episode of Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt's fourth season. Netflix also filed it as a separate special, which is why catalogs treat the 33-minute mockumentary as a movie. latestnetflix.com's take is that Wikipedia's episode list dates it to May 30, 2018, credits Rhys Thomas as director and Meredith Scardino as writer, and notes the standalone listing.The plot, in one line, is DJ Fingablast hunting a wedding DJ and landing on his childhood hero, DJ Slizzard, the prison name for Reverend Richard Wayne Gary Wayne.,
Tina Fey had wanted a documentary defense of the Reverend as background texture. Once the writers made it a whole episode, Scardino could write unreliable narration. Robert Carlock told TV Guide the format let them invent people "who take the Reverend's side and who want to present a half-hour of documentary as a defense of him." Derek Klena, the Broadway actor who had played Jacqueline's dog-masseur Douglas and then DJ Fingablast on a Mets party cruise, became the camera. Carlock compared bringing him back to how he and Fey reused Tituss Burgess on 30 Rock. Scardino's shorter version: a guy named DJ Fingablast is that guy.
Thomas came from Documentary Now!. He told the Kimmy crew to break their professional habits and shoot like amateurs who did not know the next beat. Some scenes were filmed by the actors. Some were shot on Thomas's own iPhone. He said jokes that would play with cameras on Jon Hamm, Bobby Moynihan, and Klena at once had to be restaged, because a real documentary would not cover everyone. The Reverend clocks the crew and starts performing innocence. Hamm plays a criminal playing a wrongly accused man.
The clip of young Reverend Wayne losing a dating show is not a pastiche. It is Hamm, age 25, on The Big Date in 1996, talking about "fabulous food," "fabulous conversation," and a "fabulous foot massage for an evening of total fabulosity." Decider and Digital Spy both reported that producers changed the name tag to Richard and left his dialogue intact. Carlock told TV Guide he did not even mention the clip to Hamm first. They cleared it, sent the rewritten script, and Hamm texted, "You people are monsters." He stayed on board. Decider notes ADR that addresses him as Richard. In the episode, that rejection becomes the Reverend's origin story for kidnapping women.,,
Aidy Bryant appears as Tabby Bobatti. Moynihan plays Fran Dodd of the Innocence Broject. Ellie Kemper is mostly the subject of the smear, then the last shot of her watching the cut. Carlock said the remaining six episodes of season 4 would not bring Fingablast back. "He's touring right now." Scardino added, "He's in Dubai on an island shaped like his face." That is the gossip around a sitcom episode so self-contained that Netflix sold it twice.,
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.