Skip to main content
Movie poster for Wild Mountain Thyme (2020)

Wild Mountain Thyme

“There's nothing more dangerous... than an Irish woman in love.”

2020
1h 42m
PG-13 · English
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Headstrong farmer Rosemary Muldoon has her heart set on winning her neighbour Anthony Reilly's love. The problem is, Anthony seems to have inherited a family curse, and remains oblivious to his beautiful admirer. Stung by his father's plans to sell the family farm to his American nephew, Anthony is jolted into pursuing his dreams.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

The Green Fields of Regret

I’ve driven through the Irish countryside once, on a day so damp the windshield wipers couldn’t keep up. The hedgerows blurred into a smear of green, and the radio played something mournful in Gaelic. It’s that same green—lush, relentless, almost aggressive—that opens Wild Mountain Thyme, John Patrick Shanley’s adaptation of his own play Outside Mullingar.

The film wants to be a romance, but it keeps tripping over its own hesitations, like a man who’s rehearsed a proposal in the mirror but freezes when the moment arrives. What should feel like a slow burn instead simmers at a temperature just shy of lukewarm, and by the time the credits roll, I’m left wondering if the real love story here is between the characters and the land itself—or if the land is just another obstacle, as stubborn and unyielding as the people who till it.

A wide shot of rolling green hills under a moody sky, two distant figures walking along a stone wall

Shanley, who also wrote Moonstruck and Doubt, has a knack for writing characters who talk in circles around their own desires. Here, that tendency curdles into something frustrating. Rosemary Muldoon (Emily Blunt) has spent decades pining for her neighbor Anthony Reilly (Jamie Dornan), a man so emotionally constipated he might as well be a character from a Beckett play.

Their courtship—if you can call it that—unfolds in a series of awkward encounters where words are both weapons and shields. "There’s nothing more dangerous than an Irish woman in love," the tagline teases, but the film never quite earns that danger. Instead, it settles for a kind of polite stalemate, where the most passionate thing anyone does is glare at a tractor.

The problem isn’t the premise. There’s something inherently compelling about two people who’ve known each other their whole lives, whose families have farmed the same patch of earth for generations, and who can’t seem to bridge the three feet of air between them. But Wild Mountain Thyme keeps undermining its own stakes.

Anthony’s father (Christopher Walken, gamely leaning into an accent that sounds like it was borrowed from a leprechaun) threatens to sell the family farm to his American nephew Adam (Jon Hamm), a move that should inject urgency into the story. Instead, it feels like a subplot the film forgets about for long stretches. Hamm, usually so effortlessly charming, is stranded in a role that asks him to be both the interloper and the voice of reason, and he can’t quite reconcile the two.

His scenes with Blunt crackle with a chemistry the rest of the film lacks, which only makes the central romance feel more anemic by comparison.

Rosemary and Anthony standing in a field, their backs to the camera, the space between them charged with unspoken tension

Blunt and Dornan are both capable actors, but they’re trapped in a script that mistakes reticence for depth. Rosemary is written as a force of nature—fiery, stubborn, unafraid to speak her mind—but Blunt’s performance is at its most compelling when she’s not saying anything at all. There’s a moment where she watches Anthony from across a field, her face a mask of quiet longing, and for a second, the film almost works.

Then the dialogue kicks in again, and the spell is broken. Dornan, meanwhile, plays Anthony as if he’s been told his character is "shy" and interpreted that as "catatonic." His line readings are so flat they make the surrounding green fields look positively animated.

It’s not that he’s bad; it’s that the role gives him nothing to work with beyond a series of variations on "I don’t know."

The film’s most interesting relationship isn’t between the lovers, but between the people and the land. The cinematography lingers on the rolling hills, the stone walls, the way the light slants across the fields in the late afternoon. There’s a real sense of place here, a feeling that the land is both a character and a curse.

The Reillys and Muldoons don’t just live on this land; they’re bound to it, for better or worse. It’s the one thing the film does consistently well—making the landscape feel alive, almost sentient. But even that becomes a problem.

The more the camera lingers on the beauty of the countryside, the more the human drama feels like an afterthought. The land is patient. The people?

Not so much.

A close-up of Rosemary’s face, half in shadow, her expression caught between hope and resignation

I kept waiting for the film to tip into something darker, something messier. Romance is rarely just about love; it’s about fear, pride, the things we inherit and the things we refuse to pass on. Wild Mountain Thyme flirts with these ideas but never commits. There’s a subplot about Anthony’s belief that he’s inherited his father’s "curse"—a fear of intimacy that’s never quite explained—and it’s the kind of detail that could have added depth if the film had the courage to explore it.

Instead, it’s treated like a quirk, something to be shrugged off by the third act. The ending, when it comes, is so tidy it feels like a betrayal of everything that came before. After spending 102 minutes with these people, watching them circle each other like wary animals, the resolution lands with the emotional weight of a postscript.

Maybe that’s the point. Maybe Shanley is saying that love, in the end, is just another kind of work—something you do because you have to, not because it’s grand or passionate or cinematic. But if that’s the case, the film doesn’t earn its own quietness.

It’s one thing to tell a story about people who can’t articulate their feelings; it’s another to make a film that can’t either. The best romances—even the sad ones—leave you with a sense of what was lost, or what might have been. Wild Mountain Thyme leaves you with the feeling that you’ve just spent an hour and a half watching two people argue about the weather. The fields are beautiful, though.

That much, at least, is true.

Audience Opinions

Audience 5.2/10
"A visually lush but tonally uneven romance hampered by exaggerated accents and clichéd storytelling."

The picturesque Irish setting and Emily Blunt’s singing scene are charming and beautiful, with moments of genuine warmth. The over-the-top accents, predictable plot, and tired romantic tropes are frequent frustrations, and the movie never rises above its own clichés.

What viewers praise
  • Stunning cinematography The Irish countryside looks beautiful, giving the romance a rich visual backdrop.
  • Emily Blunt’s singing Blunt’s rendition of the folk song 'Wild Mountain Thyme' has emotional depth and authenticity.
  • Chemistry between leads Blunt and Dornan’s dynamic is a highlight and brings some genuine warmth to the relationship.
Common complaints
  • Exaggerated accents The cast’s Irish accents are distracting and unrealistic, pulling you out of the story.
  • Predictable plot Well-worn romantic tropes with few surprises or fresh twists.
  • Overuse of clichés Leans heavily on familiar romantic and dramatic clichés, making it formulaic.
  • Uneven tone Shifts between whimsy, drama, and romance are jarring, leaving the film’s emotional core unclear.
Recommended for
Fans of romantic dramas Emily Blunt admirers Lovers of scenic landscapes Traditional folk music enthusiasts

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Behind the Scenes of Wild Mountain Thyme: Emily Blunt, Jamie Dornan, and the Magic of Ireland

Wild Mountain Thyme (2020) brought together a star-studded cast for a romantic drama set against the lush backdrop of rural Ireland. Directed by John Patrick Shanley, the film stars Emily Blunt and Jamie Dornan as mismatched lovers navigating family feuds, unspoken feelings, and the weight of tradition. latestnetflix.com's take is that while the movie divided critics, the behind-the-scenes stories reveal a cast deeply charmed by their time on set—and a few playful rivalries.

A Cast Under Ireland’s Spell

The film’s Irish setting wasn’t just a backdrop; it became a character in its own right. Jon Hamm, who plays the wealthy American heir Adam, admitted the cast fell hard for the country’s beauty and culture. In a behind-the-scenes feature, Hamm gushed about the experience, calling Ireland “magical” and praising the warmth of the locals. Blunt and Dornan, who play the film’s central couple, Rosemary and Anthony, echoed the sentiment, with Dornan joking that the real challenge was resisting the urge to spend all day in the pubs.

Christopher Walken, who plays Anthony’s eccentric father, Tony, also seemed to embrace the role with his signature quirky energy. While the evidence doesn’t detail his specific antics, Walken’s presence alone added a layer of unpredictability to the set—something the cast likely relished.

Blunt and Dornan’s Playful Chemistry

The dynamic between Blunt and Dornan was a highlight of the film, both on and off screen. In an interview, Dornan revealed that Blunt’s intensity nearly “killed” him during a particular scene, though he didn’t specify which one. The comment hints at the playful, high-energy rapport between the two, which translated into their characters’ bickering yet undeniable chemistry.

Blunt, known for her sharp wit, also took center stage in a memorable moment when she sang the film’s titular folk song, Wild Mountain Thyme. A clip of her performance showcases her vocal talent, adding a layer of authenticity to her character’s emotional journey. Dornan, meanwhile, leaned into Anthony’s gruff charm, though some critics argued his character’s arc was overshadowed by Blunt’s fiery portrayal.

Mixed Reviews, Unforgettable Moments

Despite the cast’s enthusiasm, Wild Mountain Thyme received a lukewarm critical reception. Reviewers praised its picturesque cinematography and the leads’ performances but criticized the script for veering into melodrama. The French review site SensCritique gave it a middling 5/10, calling it a “sweet charmer” but noting its uneven tone.

Still, the film’s trailer and promotional clips generated buzz, particularly for its romantic and comedic moments. The official trailer, released by Bleecker Street, teased the film’s blend of humor, heartache, and stunning Irish landscapes, promising a cozy, if slightly chaotic, love story.

The Verdict: A Labor of Love

While Wild Mountain Thyme may not have been a critical darling, the behind-the-scenes stories paint a picture of a cast and crew who genuinely enjoyed the experience. From Hamm’s love letter to Ireland to Blunt and Dornan’s playful banter, the film’s production seemed as warm and inviting as the countryside it was set in.

For fans of Blunt, Dornan, or just a good old-fashioned romantic drama, Wild Mountain Thyme offers a charming—if imperfect—escape.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.