Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Devil on Trial (2023)

The Devil on Trial

“Did the devil do it?”

2023
1h 21m
R · English
Director: Chris Holt
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Explore the first – and only – time “demonic possession” has officially been used as a defense in a U.S. murder trial. Including firsthand accounts of alleged devil possession and a shocking murder, this extraordinary story forces reflection on our fear of the unknown.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

The Devil in the Details

I’ve watched The Devil on Trial twice now, and both times I found myself leaning forward in my chair, not because the film is particularly scary, but because it’s so damn slippery. It wants to be a true-crime documentary, a supernatural horror flick, and a courtroom drama all at once—and in the gaps between those ambitions, something unsettling emerges. Not the devil, necessarily, but the way we humans cling to stories that explain the unexplainable.

The film opens with a grainy home video of a young boy, David Glatzel, writhing on a couch while his family looks on in horror. His voice is distorted, guttural, the kind of sound that makes the hairs on your arms stand up. The camera lingers just long enough to make you uncomfortable, then cuts to present-day interviews with the Glatzel brothers—David, now a grown man, and Carl, who watches the footage with a skepticism that borders on disgust.

"That’s not possession," Carl says flatly. "That’s a kid being coached." The film never quite resolves this tension, and maybe that’s the point.

A dimly lit reenactment of David Glatzel’s alleged possession, his face contorted in shadow

What The Devil on Trial does best is expose the machinery of belief. The Warrens—Ed and Lorraine, the paranormal investigators made famous by The Conjuring franchise—are here in archival footage, their presence looming over the case like specters themselves. Lorraine, in particular, is a study in quiet conviction, her voice steady as she describes the "evil" she sensed in the Glatzel home.

The film doesn’t mock her, but it doesn’t fully endorse her either. Instead, it lets her words hang in the air, unchallenged, while Carl Glatzel’s voiceover undercuts them: "They were con people. They knew how to work a room."

This push-and-pull is the film’s most compelling quality. It’s not just about whether Arne Cheyenne Johnson was possessed when he killed Alan Bono in 1981; it’s about why we want to believe he was. The documentary leans into the lurid details—the audio recordings of David’s "possession," the reenactments of Johnson’s trial—but it also undercuts them with a third-act reveal that feels almost like a bait-and-switch.

Carl Glatzel, the most vocal skeptic in the family, suggests that David’s behavior was the result of trauma, not demons. The Warrens, he claims, exploited his brother’s mental health for fame and money. The film doesn’t outright agree with him, but it doesn’t have to.

The doubt is already there, planted like a seed.

A courtroom reenactment, the jury’s faces half-lit by the harsh overhead lights

Critics have been divided on whether this ambiguity works. The New York Times’ Calum Marsh called the film "superficial shock value and lurid titillation," and it’s hard to argue with that assessment when you consider how much time is spent on the sensational aspects of the case—the audio of David’s voice, the dramatic reenactments of the murder. But I think there’s something more interesting at play here.

The film isn’t just mining the case for scares; it’s exposing how easily we conflate mystery with malevolence. The devil isn’t in the details, but in our need to assign blame—to something, to someone, to anything—when the world doesn’t make sense.

That’s what makes the final act so fascinating. After spending most of its runtime building up the supernatural narrative, the film pivots to a more grounded explanation: David Glatzel was a troubled kid, the Warrens were opportunists, and Arne Johnson was a man who snapped under pressure. It’s not as cinematic as demonic possession, but it’s a hell of a lot more human.

The film doesn’t fully commit to this version of events, though. It can’t. To do so would be to admit that the devil was never in the room—that the real horror was the way we let ourselves be fooled.

A close-up of Arne Cheyenne Johnson’s face, his expression unreadable in the dim light

I keep coming back to Carl Glatzel’s face during his interview. He’s not angry, not exactly. More like exhausted.

"I was there," he says. "I know what I saw." But the film doesn’t let him—or us—off the hook.

It forces us to sit with the uncertainty, to question not just what happened in that Connecticut home in 1981, but why we’re still talking about it over 40 years later. Maybe it’s because the devil makes for a better story. Or maybe it’s because the alternative—that the world is just as cruel and random as it seems—is too much to bear.

The Devil on Trial doesn’t give us answers. It gives us a mirror. And that, in the end, might be the scariest thing of all.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Devil on Trial: The Real-Life Horror Behind Netflix’s Chilling Doc

Netflix’s The Devil on Trial (2023) isn’t your typical horror flick—it’s a bone-chilling dive into one of America’s most infamous legal cases, where demonic possession was used as a defense in a murder trial. Directed by Chris Holt, the documentary blends reenactments, home videos, and firsthand accounts to unravel the terrifying story of Arne Cheyenne Johnson, a man who claimed the devil made him do it. But how much of the film’s eerie atmosphere is Hollywood polish, latestnetflix.com contends, and how much is raw, unfiltered truth?

The Case That Shocked a Nation

At the heart of The Devil on Trial is the 1981 trial of Arne Cheyenne Johnson, who was accused of fatally stabbing his landlord, Alan Bono. Johnson’s defense? He was possessed by a demon at the time of the murder. The case became the first—and only—time in U.S. Legal history that demonic possession was officially entered as a defense. The documentary leans heavily into the supernatural, featuring interviews with Johnson’s family, including his fiancée at the time, Debbie Glatzel, and her brother, David Glatzel, whose alleged possession reportedly triggered the chain of events.

Judge Robert Callahan wasn’t having it. He dismissed the possession defense outright, and Johnson was convicted of first-degree manslaughter in 1983. But the case left an indelible mark on true crime and horror fans alike, inspiring books, films, and now this Netflix deep dive.

Behind the Scenes: Reenactments and Real-Life Trauma

The Devil on Trial doesn’t just rely on talking heads—it uses dramatic reenactments and archival home videos to bring the story to life. The cast includes actors like Carlo Adamo and Hannah Mae Beatty, but the real stars are the survivors and witnesses, including Johnson himself, who appears on camera to recount his version of events. The documentary’s use of grainy home footage adds a layer of authenticity, making the supernatural claims feel uncomfortably real.

But how much of the film’s narrative is shaped for maximum horror? The documentary frames the case as a battle between good and evil, but legal experts and skeptics have long argued that Johnson’s defense was more about desperation than demonology. The film doesn’t shy away from this tension, presenting both sides of the story while letting viewers draw their own conclusions.

The Director’s Vision: Fact or Fiction?

Chris Holt, the film’s director, isn’t a horror specialist—his name might ring a bell for baseball fans. Before The Devil on Trial, Holt was known as a former MLB pitcher, not a filmmaker. His pivot to documentary directing is a surprising one, but his approach to the material is straightforward: let the story speak for itself. The film doesn’t sensationalize the case, but it doesn’t downplay the horror, either. Instead, it leans into the ambiguity, leaving audiences to grapple with whether Johnson was a victim, a criminal, or something in between.

Why This Case Still Haunts Us

Decades after the trial, The Devil on Trial proves that the case of Arne Cheyenne Johnson hasn’t lost its power to unsettle. The documentary taps into our fascination with the unknown, blending true crime with supernatural horror in a way that feels fresh—even if the events themselves are over 40 years old. Whether you believe in possession or not, the film’s chilling reenactments and firsthand accounts make it impossible to look away.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.