Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Merry Gentlemen (2024)

The Merry Gentlemen

“A little sizzle could save the season.”

2024
1h 28m
PG · English
Director: Peter Sullivan
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

To save her parents' small-town nightclub, a Broadway dancer stages an all-male, Christmas-themed revue — and meets a guy with all the right moves.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

6 min read

The Merry Gentlemen, or the Art of Looking Without Touching

I’ll admit it: I went into The Merry Gentlemen expecting a guilty pleasure. A Christmas rom-com with a male revue premise? That’s catnip for anyone who’s ever rolled their eyes at a Hallmark movie but still craved the cozy, predictable comfort of one.

And for the first twenty minutes, it delivers exactly what it promises—a glossy, lens-flare-drenched fantasy of small-town America, where the biggest problem is a struggling nightclub and the solution is, inevitably, a little sizzle. But somewhere between the first rehearsal montage and the third time the love interest “accidentally” walks in on the dancers mid-routine, I realized the film’s fatal flaw: it’s all sizzle, no steak.

Or rather, it’s sizzle without the heat.

A group of men in festive, slightly ridiculous costumes—think Santa hats and tool belts—strike a synchronized pose under warm stage lights, their faces frozen in rehearsed grins.

Peter Sullivan’s film wants to have its fruitcake and eat it too. It borrows the male-stripper premise of The Full Monty and Magic Mike, but strips it (pun intended) of any real sensuality or edge. The dancers here aren’t men with bodies and desires—they’re mannequins, sculpted and shiny, posed for the female gaze but never allowed to feel like anything more than set dressing.

The film’s TV-PG/TV-14 rating isn’t just a content warning; it’s a creative straitjacket. The camera lingers on Chad Michael Murray’s abs, sure, but it never dares to suggest that those abs might belong to a person with agency, flaws, or even a personality. He’s a prop, and the film treats him like one.

This isn’t just a problem of tone—it’s a problem of stakes. The Full Monty worked because its characters were desperate, using their bodies to claw back some dignity in a world that had left them behind. Magic Mike had a rawness, a sense of men navigating their own vulnerabilities under the neon lights. The Merry Gentlemen, by contrast, is a film where the biggest crisis is that the nightclub’s Christmas revue might not sell enough tickets to cover the mortgage. The dancers aren’t struggling with anything more pressing than stage fright, and even that’s played for a quick laugh. The result is a movie that feels hollow, like a gingerbread house with nothing inside.


Britt Robertson’s Ashley is the closest thing the film has to a real character. She’s a Broadway dancer who’s been let go for her “advancing age”—a line that lands with a thud, not because it’s untrue, but because the film never bothers to explore what that rejection means to her. Robertson, to her credit, tries to sell the emotional beats.

There’s a moment where she watches the dancers rehearse, her face a mix of exhaustion and reluctant hope, and for a second, you think the film might actually dig into the tension between her professional pride and her desperation to save her parents’ business. But then the scene cuts to another joke about someone’s tool belt, and the moment is gone.

Ashley (Britt Robertson) stands in the wings of the nightclub stage, watching the dancers with a mix of skepticism and cautious optimism, her arms crossed as if bracing herself.

The supporting cast fares even worse. Marla Sokoloff, who also wrote the screenplay, plays Ashley’s sister Marie, but the character exists solely to deliver exposition and react to the male dancers with exaggerated shock. Maxwell Caulfield, as the nightclub’s owner, gets a few decent one-liners, but his character’s backstory—a former performer clinging to the past—is introduced and then abandoned.

The dancers themselves are barely distinguishable from one another, save for their costumes (construction worker, firefighter, Santa’s “helper”). Even Chad Michael Murray, who’s built a second career out of playing the brooding romantic lead in holiday movies, feels oddly adrift here. His character, Luke, is a carpenter with a heart of gold and a six-pack, but the film never gives him a reason to exist beyond being Ashley’s love interest.

Their chemistry is as flat as the film’s Midwestern backlot, which, as several critics have pointed out, is clearly a Burbank soundstage dressed up with a few fake snowflakes.


The film’s most frustrating quality is its refusal to commit to anything. It wants to be a raunchy comedy but won’t risk offending anyone. It wants to be a heartfelt holiday movie but can’t be bothered to develop its characters.

It wants to be a showcase for male sensuality but treats its dancers like objects to be admired and then ignored. Even the choreography, which could have been a saving grace, feels half-hearted. The routines are competently executed, but there’s no sense of joy or abandon in them.

The dancers move like they’re following instructions, not losing themselves in the music.

This isn’t to say the film is entirely without charm. The visuals are, as several critics have noted, “pretty to look at.” The nightclub is bathed in warm, saturated lighting, and the Christmas decorations are abundant without being overwhelming. There’s a certain pleasure in watching a film that knows exactly what it is—a disposable holiday confection—and doesn’t try to be anything more.

But that pleasure is fleeting, the cinematic equivalent of eating a box of chocolates and realizing halfway through that they all taste the same.

The nightclub stage is lit up for the big performance, with red and green spotlights casting a festive glow over the dancers, who are mid-routine in matching Santa-themed outfits.

Amy Nicholson’s assessment in LAist/FilmWeek that The Merry Gentlemen is “really, really boring” might be a bit harsh, but it’s not entirely wrong. The film isn’t offensively bad—it’s just forgettable, the kind of movie you put on while wrapping presents and then can’t remember the plot of by New Year’s. Courtney Howard’s observation in Variety that the film “would’ve been more merry and bright” if it had evolved beyond the expected is closer to the mark.

There’s a kernel of something interesting here—a story about women reclaiming their agency, about performers using their bodies to take control of their narratives—but the film never bothers to explore it. Instead, it settles for the easy laughs and the easy romance, the kind of story that’s been told a hundred times before and will be told a hundred times again.


In the end, The Merry Gentlemen is a film that’s content to exist in the background, a cinematic equivalent of elevator music. It’s not terrible, but it’s not memorable either. It’s the kind of movie that will find its audience—people who want something light and festive to watch while scrolling through their phones, or who are just in it for the shirtless scenes.

But for anyone looking for something with a little more substance, a little more bite, it’s hard to recommend.

I keep thinking about that moment where Ashley watches the dancers rehearse, the way her face betrays a flicker of something real. It’s the closest the film comes to feeling alive, and it’s over in a second. Maybe that’s the point.

Maybe The Merry Gentlemen is just a movie about surfaces, about the way we look but don’t touch, about the stories we tell ourselves to get through the holidays. If so, it’s a fitting metaphor for the film itself—a pretty package with nothing inside.

Audience Opinions

Audience 4.0/10
"A forgettable romantic comedy with weak execution and uninspired storytelling."

The plot feels recycled from better romantic comedies. The leads’ chemistry is underwhelming and fails to elevate the material, and the supporting cast feels wasted or underdeveloped. The lighthearted tone has its fans, but the film leaves no lasting impression.

What viewers praise
  • Lighthearted tone A breezy, feel-good atmosphere that partly offsets its flaws.
  • Decent production value Competent, if unremarkable, visuals and production design.
Common complaints
  • Unoriginal plot Relies on tired romantic comedy tropes without fresh twists.
  • Weak chemistry The lead pair’s on-screen dynamic is flat and unconvincing.
  • Underdeveloped characters Supporting roles are shallow, with few memorable moments.
  • Low stakes The conflict and resolution lack emotional weight or urgency.
Recommended for
Undemanding rom-com fans Peter Sullivan completists Light background viewing

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Peter Sullivan’s The Merry Gentlemen (2024): A Rom-Com Reunion with Familiar Faces

Peter Sullivan’s latest holiday rom-com, The Merry Gentlemen, hit screens in 2024 with a cast that reads like a reunion of early-2000s teen drama alums. The film, billed as a romantic comedy, brings together Britt Robertson (The Secret Circle), Chad Michael Murray (One Tree Hill), latestnetflix.com contends, and Marla Sokoloff (The Practice) for a festive tale that’s already sparking chatter—though not all of it glowing.

A Star-Studded Throwback Cast

The ensemble is packed with recognizable names, many of whom rose to fame in the 2000s. Chad Michael Murray, who became a household name as Lucas Scott on One Tree Hill, reunites with Sullivan after their collaboration on The Christmas Contract (2018). Britt Robertson, known for her roles in The Secret Circle and Tomorrowland, takes the female lead, while Marla Sokoloff—best remembered as Lucy Hatcher on The Practice—adds a touch of dramatic flair.

Rounding out the cast are Maxwell Caulfield (Grease 2), Michael Gross (Family Ties), and Beth Broderick (Sabrina the Teenage Witch), lending the film a nostalgic, TV-movie vibe. The inclusion of Colt Prattes (Dirty Dancing: The Remake) and Hector David Jr. (Power Rangers) suggests a mix of classic charm and modern appeal, though early reviews hint that the chemistry may not fully deliver on the hype.

Mixed Early Reactions

The Merry Gentlemen has already faced a lukewarm reception, at least according to early metrics. On SensCritique, the film holds a modest 4/10 rating based on 309 votes, with critics and audiences alike questioning whether the script lives up to its star power. Rotten Tomatoes, meanwhile, has yet to aggregate a full consensus, but the lack of buzz suggests the film may struggle to stand out in a crowded holiday rom-com market.

The 87-minute runtime—shorter than the average rom-com—has also raised eyebrows, with some speculating that the film might feel rushed or underdeveloped. Whether this brevity is a deliberate stylistic choice or a sign of a tighter budget remains unconfirmed, but it’s a notable departure from Sullivan’s typically more expansive holiday fare.

What’s Next for the Cast?

While The Merry Gentlemen may not be a breakout hit, its cast members are no strangers to the holiday movie circuit. Murray, in particular, has become a staple of the genre, with credits including A Christmas Romance (2020) and Switched for Christmas (2017). Robertson, too, has dipped her toes into festive films, though her recent work leans more toward drama (The Wilds).

For now, The Merry Gentlemen serves as a reminder of the enduring appeal of holiday rom-coms—and the risks of relying too heavily on nostalgia. Whether it becomes a cult favorite or fades into the background of Sullivan’s filmography remains to be seen.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.