Skip to main content
Movie poster for The Turnaround (2024)

The Turnaround

2024
25m
R · English
Director: Kyle Thrash
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A devoted Philadelphia Phillies fan inspires his city to give a struggling shortstop a game-changing standing ovation in this rousing short documentary.

Trailer

Official

Cast

8 people

Reviews

3 min read

The Standing Ovation That Changed Everything

I didn't expect to be moved by a short documentary about a Philadelphia Phillies fan, or to care about Trea Turner's batting average. But The Turnaround isn't really about baseball. It's about the stubborn hope that keeps people showing up when the game, or life, isn't going their way.

It opens on Citizens Bank Park, packed and roaring, but the camera settles on the stands and on Jon McCann, a man in a Phillies cap known to fans as "The Philly Captain." He's the kind of superfan who turns fandom into a second job and believes, against all evidence, that this year will be the year. When star shortstop Trea Turner fell into a slump in 2023, McCann did something unexpected: he rallied the crowd to give Turner a standing ovation, not after a home run but during his struggles.

The gesture went viral, Turner broke out of his funk, and the Phillies made it to the NLCS.

A sea of Phillies fans in red, their faces a mix of hope and exhaustion, filling the stands of Citizens Bank Park.

What makes the film work is how directors Kyle Thrash and Ben Proudfoot (the latter a two-time Oscar winner for short documentaries) frame McCann's act as both a personal and communal reckoning. It's about a city's reputation. Philadelphia fans have long been stereotyped as ruthless, the kind who boo Santa Claus, and McCann's ovation was a deliberate counter-narrative: We can be better than that. The film cuts between archival footage of Phillies fans at their most ferocious and intimate interviews with McCann, who speaks candidly about his own battles with depression and suicidal ideation.

Just as Turner needed a break, so did McCann, and his story suggests that kindness, even in a stadium, can be its own redemption.

The craft is subtle. The score, soaring strings and Rocky-montage horns, could tip into schmaltz, but the directors let the silence between McCann's words do as much work as the music. When he describes first hearing the ovation echo through the stadium, the camera holds on his face with no cuts.

It's a small choice that makes you lean in.

Jon McCann, in a Phillies cap, stands in front of the stadium, his expression a mix of pride and vulnerability.

The biggest gamble is the brevity. The film skips Phillies history and career stats to zero in on the bond between a fan and a player and how it ripples outward. Mostly it works, but sometimes the short runtime is a limitation.

It touches on local sports radio's role in amplifying McCann's message without exploring it, and some of the bigger-name contributions feel more like cameos than essential pieces, a soundbite about the power of fan support that lands a little too neatly.

Still, the strengths outweigh the omissions. The Turnaround is a snapshot, a moment of grace in a game often defined by its brutality. Decider called it "an odd, unexpected little piece of sports joy," and that's about right. It won't change how you think about baseball, but it might change how you think about the people next to you in the stands.

A close-up of Trea Turner at bat, his posture tense, the weight of expectation visible in his stance.

What's surprising is how universal it feels, even if you don't care about baseball: a man turning his own struggles into a reason to reach out, refusing to let the game or the world harden him. It leaves you asking who in your life needs a standing ovation right now, and whether you'd be brave enough to give one.

Audience Opinions

Audience 7.5/10
"A heartfelt, inspiring short documentary for baseball fans and anyone who loves an underdog story."

The film has real emotional depth in its authentic portrayal of Jon McCann’s effort to rally support for Trea Turner during a tough season. Its focus on community and fandom works, though the brevity leaves out detail about the broader impact of McCann’s campaign. Well-known baseball figures add credibility and appeal, but the short runtime limits deeper exploration of the story.

What viewers praise
  • Emotional and inspiring Jon McCann’s dedication to supporting Trea Turner makes for a powerful underdog narrative.
  • Authentic portrayal of fandom The film captures the passion and loyalty of baseball fans in a genuine, relatable way.
  • Strong cast involvement Appearances by Alex Rodriguez, Trea Turner, and other baseball figures add credibility and interest.
  • Short but impactful The concise runtime keeps it accessible and engaging without overstaying its welcome.
Common complaints
  • Limited runtime The short length prevents a deeper dive into the story’s broader implications.
  • Niche appeal It's less engaging if you're unfamiliar with baseball or the specific context.
  • Lacks depth in places It skimps on the behind-the-scenes efforts and outcomes of McCann’s campaign.
Recommended for
Baseball fans Documentary lovers Underdog story enthusiasts Phillies supporters Short film audiences

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The Turnaround: How a Phillies Fan’s Viral Moment Became a Netflix Doc with A-List Backing

The Turnaround (2024) isn’t your typical sports documentary. Clocking in at just 25 minutes, the short film—now streaming on Netflix—centers on Jon McCann, a die-hard Philadelphia Phillies fan known as "The Philly Captain," and his unexpected role in rallying support for struggling shortstop Trea Turner during the 2023 season. But the story behind the film’s creation is just as compelling as its subject, blending local fandom, Oscar-winning talent, latestnetflix.com argues, and a surprise partnership with Barack and Michelle Obama’s production company.

From Viral Moment to Oscar-Backed Short

McCann, a content creator from Philadelphia’s Bridesburg neighborhood, became a minor internet sensation in 2023 when he led a standing ovation for Turner during a rough stretch for the star player. The gesture, captured on video and shared widely, was more than just fan enthusiasm—it was a turning point for Turner, who later credited the support for helping him break out of his slump. The Phillies went on to reach the NLCS, and Turner finished the season with 26 home runs and a standout postseason.

That viral moment caught the attention of Kyle Thrash, a Lehigh Valley native and lifelong Phillies fan, who teamed up with two-time Oscar winner Ben Proudfoot (The Queen of Basketball, The Last Repair Shop) to direct the film. The project quickly gained high-profile backing: it was produced by Higher Ground, the Obamas’ production company, adding a layer of prestige to what could have been a niche sports story.

A Star-Studded Cast of Interviewees

While McCann is the emotional core of The Turnaround, the film features appearances from a who’s who of baseball, including:

  • Alex Rodriguez, former MLB star and analyst
  • Trea Turner, the Phillies shortstop at the center of the story
  • J.D. Drew, former Phillies outfielder
  • Kyle Schwarber, Phillies outfielder
  • John Kruk, former Phillies first baseman and current broadcaster
  • Tom McCarthy, Phillies play-by-play announcer
  • Larry Andersen, former Phillies pitcher and longtime broadcaster

The inclusion of these figures—particularly Rodriguez, a frequent critic of Turner’s performance—adds depth to the narrative, framing McCann’s gesture as a pivotal moment in Turner’s redemption arc.

Premiere and Reception: A Festival Favorite

The Turnaround premiered at the Telluride Film Festival earlier in 2024, a prestigious platform for documentaries and indie films. The festival’s selection suggests the film was positioned as more than just a sports story—it’s a character-driven piece about fandom, mental health, and the power of community.

Netflix’s involvement likely helped amplify its reach, though the streaming giant hasn’t released viewership numbers. Still, the film’s connection to Higher Ground and its Oscar-winning directors give it a built-in audience beyond baseball fans.

The Bigger Story: McCann’s Personal Struggle

While the film celebrates McCann’s role in Turner’s turnaround, it also looks at his personal life. According to reports, The Turnaround explores McCann’s own battles with mental health, adding a layer of vulnerability to his public persona. The film’s dual focus—on Turner’s slump and McCann’s journey—elevates it from a simple sports narrative to something more universal.

Why This Short Film Matters

At a time when sports documentaries often focus on superstars or historic teams, The Turnaround stands out for its grassroots angle. It’s a story about an everyday fan who, through one act of kindness, became part of a larger narrative. The involvement of Proudfoot and Higher Ground suggests the film was always meant to resonate beyond Philadelphia, framing McCann’s story as a sign of the power of sports fandom.

For Phillies fans, the film is a love letter to the city’s passion. For everyone else, it’s a reminder that sometimes, the most impactful moments in sports don’t happen on the field—they happen in the stands.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.