Skip to main content
Movie poster for A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter (2024)

A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter

2024
50m
PG-13 · English
Director: Sam Wrench
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Pop icon Sabrina Carpenter jingles all the bells in her first-ever variety music special full of holiday hits, unexpected duets and comedic cameos.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

3 min read

The Holiday Special That Doesn’t Give a Damn (And That’s the Point)

I'll admit I went into A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter expecting something safe: another glossy holiday special, all tinsel and no teeth. Within minutes, with Carpenter in a sequined Santa minidress trading "Last Christmas" with Chappell Roan, it was clear this wasn't going to be safe. It wasn't even trying.

Sabrina Carpenter and Chappell Roan performing "Last Christmas" in matching holiday outfits, mid-dramatic gesture

A Nonsense Christmas doesn't care if you "get" it, or if you find the humor too niche, the musical numbers too campy, or the sketches too absurd. It's a meta, self-aware romp that leans so hard into the chaos of its format that it circles back to feeling intentional. The Globe and Mail called it "cozy, comforting and familiar," but only if you accept that "familiar" now includes a guest list running from Shania Twain and Kali Uchis to Quinta Brunson, Cara Delevingne, Sean Astin, Megan Stalter, Owen Thiele, Nico Hiraga, and Kyle Mooney.

The special is a love letter to the variety-show format of The Sonny & Cher Comedy Hour or The Dean Martin Christmas Show. Where those were polished to a mirror shine, this one has a loose, near-improvised feel, exhilarating and uneven, like a live taping one missed cue from anarchy. That's the point.

Take the music. Carpenter's voice is a silky instrument, equally convincing on the saccharine and the silly, and her duets with Twain and Uchis manage to feel both nostalgic and fresh. But the real star is the energy.

The camera keeps returning to the live audience, a reminder that this is an event rather than a special recorded in a vacuum for Tuesday-afternoon laundry folding.

Sabrina Carpenter and Shania Twain performing "Santa Baby" on a glittery stage

The sketches reveal the special's DNA: rom-com parody, holiday-movie arguments, and fever-dream riffs on modern dating, with the guest comedians clearly having a good time.

It's all very much, which is both the special's biggest strength and its weakness. It's best when it embraces its absurdity, a holiday special that doesn't care about being one. But sometimes the chaos looks less like choice than lack of focus.

The pacing lurches from sketch to song with little transition, and some jokes land with the subtlety of a sledgehammer.

That unevenness is also what makes it feel alive. It's trying to be fun, not perfect, and it succeeds. Carpenter is magnetic throughout, whether belting a ballad or deadpanning a line, and her chemistry with the guests is palpable, particularly with Delevingne, whose unhinged energy seems capable of derailing the production at any moment.

Sabrina Carpenter and Cara Delevingne in the "Ghosts of Ghosted Past" sketch, mid-conversation

Decider called it "very self-aware" and noted that it "never once takes itself too seriously." True, but the self-awareness isn't cynical. There's genuine joy in how Carpenter and her collaborators poke fun at the holiday-special format while delivering on its core promise of music, laughter, and a little magic.

It could only exist in 2024, when the line between irony and sincerity has blurred beyond recognition.

A Nonsense Christmas isn't for everyone. If you want a traditional special with a heartwarming message and a neatly wrapped bow, look elsewhere. But if you're in the mood for something like a late-night hangout with your funniest friends, where no one is sure how the night will end, pull up a seat and lean into the nonsense.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.6/10
"A festive, chaotic musical romp with plenty of energy but little depth."

The holiday special delivers high-energy musical performances and a playful, absurd tone. The thin plot and reliance on inside jokes disappoint those expecting a structured narrative. The cast’s chemistry and Sabrina Carpenter’s charisma keep it engaging, but it plays more like a variety show than a cohesive story.

What viewers praise
  • Energetic musical numbers The performances are lively and well-choreographed, making the musical segments the standout.
  • Star-studded cast chemistry The interplay between Sabrina Carpenter, Cara Delevingne and the rest of the ensemble adds charm and humor.
  • Playful, absurd tone The chaotic, nonsensical take on Christmas themes is a fun twist on holiday specials.
  • Visually festive Production design and costumes create a vibrant holiday look.
Common complaints
  • Thin and disjointed plot Without a coherent storyline it feels more like a sketch show than a movie.
  • Over-reliance on inside jokes Some humor falls flat if you don’t know the cast’s dynamics or the pop-culture references.
  • Uneven pacing Parts feel rushed and others drag, disrupting the flow.
  • Lack of emotional depth The absurdity leaves little room for meaningful moments or character development.
Recommended for
Fans of Sabrina Carpenter Holiday variety show lovers Musical comedy enthusiasts Cara Delevingne admirers Lighthearted absurdity seekers

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Sabrina Carpenter’s ‘A Nonsense Christmas’ Brings Star-Studded Holiday Chaos to Netflix

Sabrina Carpenter is ringing in the holidays with her first-ever variety special, A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter, a star-packed, music-filled romp that premiered on Netflix December 6, 2024. Directed by Sam Wrench—known for his work on high-energy concert specials like Taylor Swift: The Eras Tour—the project blends holiday cheer, unexpected duets, and comedic cameos into a festive spectacle. But behind the tinsel and jingle bells, the special’s creation hints at Carpenter’s growing clout as both a performer and producer.

A Holiday Special Born from Carpenter’s ‘Fruitcake’ EP

The special isn’t just a one-off performance—it’s a companion piece to Carpenter’s 2024 Christmas EP, Fruitcake. The project features her performing tracks from the EP alongside holiday classics, reimagined with her signature pop flair. Sources suggest the special was designed to showcase Carpenter’s versatility, blending scripted sketches with live musical performances. While details about the setlist remain scarce, the inclusion of duets with high-profile guests (more on that below) suggests a mix of original material and crowd-pleasing covers.

Carpenter executive-produced the special alongside a team including Michael D. Ratner, Scott Ratner, and Simone Spire, signaling her hands-on approach to shaping her public image. The collaboration with Wrench, whose resume includes visually dynamic concert films, likely ensured the special’s fast-paced, cinematic energy—a departure from traditional holiday variety shows.

A Star-Studded Guest List (and Some Wild Cameos)

A Nonsense Christmas isn’t just about Carpenter’s vocals—it’s a showcase for her ability to assemble an A-list ensemble. Confirmed cast members include model-turned-actress Cara Delevingne, singer-songwriter Chappell Roan, and Broad City alum Jillian Bell. The special also features Kali Uchis, Kyle Mooney, Megan Stalter, Nico Hiraga, Owen Thiele, and Abbott Elementary star Quinta Brunson, though their exact roles remain under wraps.

ScreenRant’s cameo guide teases that the special leans into “brief holiday-themed sketches” alongside musical performances, suggesting the guests may pop up in both comedic and musical segments. Teen Vogue’s coverage hints at “unexpected duets,” though specifics—like whether Delevingne or Roan join Carpenter on stage—haven’t been confirmed. Given Carpenter’s recent rise as a pop powerhouse (and her history of collaborating with friends, like her Espresso tour opener Chappell Roan), the special could double as a reunion of sorts for her inner circle.

Behind the Scenes: A Passion Project or Strategic Move?

While the special’s tone is lighthearted—“nonsense” is right there in the title—its timing feels deliberate. Carpenter’s 2024 has been a breakout year, from her Espresso tour to her chart-topping album Short n’ Sweet. A holiday special positions her as a multifaceted entertainer, not just a singer but a host and producer capable of curating a major event.

The Netflix release also aligns with the streaming giant’s push into holiday content, following successes like The Christmas Chronicles and Jingle Jangle. Carpenter’s involvement as an executive producer suggests she had creative control, a rarity for artists in their first variety special. Whether this is a one-off experiment or the start of a larger foray into TV remains to be seen, but the special’s star power and Carpenter’s growing industry influence make it a notable entry in her career.

What’s Next?

For now, A Nonsense Christmas stands as a festive capper to Carpenter’s blockbuster year. Fans can expect a mix of original music, holiday standards, and chaotic cameos—though without a full setlist or behind-the-scenes footage, the special’s surprises are still under wraps. If the project’s reception is strong, it could pave the way for more Carpenter-led productions, holiday or otherwise.

One thing’s certain: Sabrina Carpenter isn’t just jingling bells this Christmas—she’s rewriting the rules of the holiday special.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.