Skip to main content
Movie poster for Tall Girl (2019)

Tall Girl

“When you don't fit in, stand tall”

2019
1h 41m
PG · English
Director: Nzingha Stewart
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

Jodi, the tallest girl in her high school, has always felt uncomfortable in her own skin. But after years of slouching, being made fun of, and avoiding attention at all costs, Jodi finally decides to find the confidence to stand tall.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

5 min read

Standing Tall in a World Built for Someone Else

I’ve seen this movie before. Not Tall Girl specifically—though I’ve now seen that too—but the story it’s telling. The awkward teen, the cruel jokes, the slow-burn romance that arrives just in time to teach our heroine that what makes her different is also what makes her special.

It’s a formula so familiar it’s practically a genre unto itself, the cinematic equivalent of a warm blanket on a cold night. And yet, here I am, two days after watching Tall Girl, still turning it over in my mind. Not because it’s groundbreaking, but because it’s so earnest—so determined to make its small, specific point that it forgets to ask whether the point is worth making in the first place.

Jodi (Ava Michelle) is sixteen and six foot one, a height that would be unremarkable in a WNBA player but in a high school sophomore is treated like a deformity. She slumps, she hides, she endures the same tired jokes about the weather being “up there” with her. The film’s opening minutes are a montage of these humiliations: Jodi ducking under doorframes, her knees pressed against the underside of her desk, a group of popular girls snickering as she walks by.

It’s all very She’s All That, if She’s All That were directed by someone who’d never seen a John Hughes movie but had read a lot of YA novel summaries.

Jodi walks down a high school hallway, her posture hunched, as students whisper and point around her

The problem isn’t that Tall Girl is bad—though, at a SensCritique rating of 4.3/10, it’s certainly not winning any awards. The problem is that it’s fine. It’s the kind of fine that makes you forget you’re watching a movie until the next musical cue kicks in to remind you.

Nzingha Stewart, making her feature directorial debut, seems content to let the script (by Sam Wolfson) coast on autopilot, trusting that the sheer familiarity of the premise will carry it through. And in a way, it does. There’s comfort in watching a story where the moral is already written on the chalkboard before the first bell rings.

But comfort isn’t the same as insight.

Take the film’s central romance, which arrives in the form of Stig (Luke Eisner), a Swedish exchange student who’s tall enough to look Jodi in the eye. Their meet-cute is so by-the-book it might as well have come with a publisher’s stamp: Jodi, humiliated after a disastrous school dance, flees to the soccer field, where Stig is practicing alone. He’s new, he’s foreign, he’s different—and, crucially, he doesn’t see her height as a punchline.

Their chemistry is pleasant enough, but it’s also entirely beside the point. The film wants us to believe that Jodi’s self-acceptance hinges on finding someone who gets her, but what it actually demonstrates is how little the script trusts her to grow on her own. Stig isn’t a person so much as a narrative device, a walking, talking validation machine.

Jodi and Stig sit on a soccer field at dusk, their faces half-lit by the fading light

This is where Tall Girl’s biggest flaw lies: its refusal to engage with the messiness of its own premise. Jodi’s height isn’t just a physical trait; it’s a metaphor for all the ways teenagers feel out of place. But the film treats it as a problem to be solved, not a reality to be lived with.

There’s no exploration of how Jodi’s height might shape her worldview, no acknowledgment that her insecurity might be about more than just inches on a measuring tape. Instead, we get a third-act makeover montage—because of course we do—where Jodi straightens her posture, trades her hoodies for fitted tops, and suddenly, miraculously, the world stops seeing her as a freak and starts seeing her as a person.

It’s a fantasy, and not a particularly interesting one.

That’s not to say the film is without its charms. Ava Michelle, who stands at six foot one in real life, brings a quiet dignity to Jodi that keeps the character from becoming a caricature. There’s a moment early on where Jodi, forced to stand in front of her class for a height comparison, locks eyes with the camera for just a beat too long.

It’s a small gesture, but it speaks volumes: she’s not just embarrassed, she’s tired. Tired of being measured, tired of being gawked at, tired of pretending it doesn’t hurt. Michelle sells that exhaustion without ever overplaying it, and for a few seconds, the film almost feels real.

The supporting cast, too, deserves credit for elevating the material. Steve Zahn, as Jodi’s well-meaning but clueless father, has a knack for physical comedy that keeps his scenes from feeling too saccharine. And Griffin Gluck, as Jodi’s best friend Jack, steals every scene he’s in—not because he’s given much to work with, but because he commits to the bit with a kind of manic energy that’s impossible to look away from.

(Jack’s crush on Jodi is the film’s most interesting subplot, if only because it’s the one place where the script allows itself to be a little bit weird. His grand romantic gesture involves a drone, a boombox, and a level of public humiliation that borders on performance art. It’s the only time Tall Girl feels like it might actually be about something.)

But these flashes of life are quickly smothered by the film’s insistence on playing it safe. The soundtrack is a parade of forgettable pop songs, the cinematography is functional at best, and the dialogue is so packed with exposition it’s a wonder the characters don’t just turn to the camera and start reading from cue cards. There’s no sense of place, no texture to the world—just a series of backdrops that could be swapped out for any other generic high school without anyone noticing.

Even the film’s title feels like a miscalculation. Tall Girl isn’t about Jodi learning to stand tall; it’s about her learning to fit in, to shrink herself just enough to make the world comfortable. The irony is almost too much to bear.

Jodi stands in front of a mirror, her reflection staring back as she practices standing up straight

So why am I still thinking about this movie? Maybe it’s because, for all its flaws, Tall Girl taps into something real—something about the way we’re all, at some point, the odd one out. The film’s heart is in the right place, even if its execution is clumsy.

It wants to tell kids that they’re enough, that they don’t have to change to be loved. That’s a message worth hearing, even if it’s delivered with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer.

But here’s the thing: messages don’t exist in a vacuum. They’re shaped by the stories we tell, the details we choose to include (or exclude), the voices we center. Tall Girl’s message is a good one, but it’s wrapped in a story that doesn’t trust its audience—or its protagonist—enough to let them breathe. Jodi’s journey isn’t about learning to stand tall; it’s about learning to stand still, to wait for the world to catch up.

And that, in the end, might be the most frustrating fantasy of all.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Tall Girl Turned A Homecoming Wrap Into A Headline Fight

Directed by Nzingha Stewart, the Netflix Original teen rom-com released on Sept. 13. It follows 6-foot-one-and-a-half-inch high school junior Jodi (Ava Michelle), and the trials and tribulations that stem from her height related insecurities. Listed as a 101-minute U.S. Comedy, with Ava Michelle, Griffin Gluck, Luke Eisner among the billed stars. The available evidence is snippet-level only, latestnetflix.com maintains, so full behind-the-scenes detail stays thin.

From Dance Moms To First-Ever Lead

Ava Michelle got her start on Dance Moms. She spoke about starring in her first-ever movie, Tall Girl.

That first-lead pressure broke on the dance floor. After wrapping Tall Girl’s climactic homecoming scene — practically a teen rom-com requirement, director Nzingha Stewart kept the party going.

  • Lead role: Jodi, played by Ava Michelle
  • Co-stars noted in listings: Griffin Gluck, Luke Eisner
  • Key setpiece: climactic homecoming scene
  • Director on set: Nzingha Stewart

No salaries, episode counts, or private on-set conversations appear in the snippets. What is documented is momentum: a reality-dance alum carrying her first film, and a director choosing celebration over wrap-and-go.

A Debut That Landed In A Backlash

Tall Girl is an upcoming Netflix romantic comedy, but Twitter wasn't happy about the trailer. The feature, described as Nzingha Stewart's feature film debut, sparked significant public backlash on social media platforms prior to its release.

The debate quickly turned to opportunity. Stewart was identified as one of Shonda’s frequent directors for her television series, talking about how hard it is to get opportunities. The same discussion flagged Tall Girl as her directorial debut.

That context matters. A 6-foot-one-and-a-half-inch junior navigating height insecurity became a proxy argument about who gets to direct Netflix rom-coms, and what stories count as worthy of a debut.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.