Skip to main content
Movie poster for Untold: The Fall of Favre (2025)

Untold: The Fall of Favre

2025
1h 4m
R · English
Director: Rebecca Gitlitz
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

This eye-opening documentary delves into Brett Favre's controversial career, the dark side of sports stardom, and the scandals that marred his legacy.

Trailer

Official

Cast

12 people

Reviews

6 min read

The Myth That Wouldn’t Die

I’ve seen this trick before. A sports documentary starts with the highlight reel—slow-motion touchdowns, roaring crowds, the kind of footage that makes you forget, just for a second, that the man at the center of it all is flawed. Untold: The Fall of Favre opens exactly this way: Brett Favre, young and grinning, launching a football into a Wisconsin sky that seems to bend just for him.

The music swells. The legend is intact. And then, like a bad pass in the fourth quarter, the film yanks the ball away.

What follows isn’t just a takedown. It’s a postmortem of a myth that refused to die, even as the evidence piled up. Director Rebecca Gitlitz, a two-time Emmy winner with a knack for dissecting the dark side of fame (Under Pressure, When Truth Isn’t Truth), doesn’t waste time.

In a brisk 64 minutes, she traces Favre’s rise from small-town Mississippi to NFL immortality, then pivots to the scandals that should have buried him: the sexting allegations involving Jets reporter Jenn Sterger, and his alleged role in the misdirection of a reported budget in Mississippi welfare funds to a volleyball facility tied to his name. The film doesn’t just rehash the headlines; it forces you to sit with the details—the texts, the voicemails, the legal documents—that make the story feel uncomfortably real.

A grainy, slow-motion shot of Brett Favre mid-throw, his face half-lit by stadium lights, the ball frozen in the air like a question mark.

The first act plays like a standard sports hagiography. Favre’s early years at Southern Miss, his disastrous stint with the Falcons, the trade to Green Bay that turned him into a legend—it’s all here, told with the kind of reverence that makes you wonder if Gitlitz is setting us up for a fall. And then, abruptly, the tone shifts.

The Sterger scandal arrives like a cold front, and suddenly the film is less about football and more about power: who has it, who abuses it, and who pays the price. Sterger herself is the film’s moral center, her interviews raw and unflinching. She doesn’t just recount the harassment; she describes the aftermath—the media circus, the career derailment, the way the story was twisted to make her the villain.

It’s the kind of testimony that lingers, not because it’s shocking (though it is), but because it’s human. Here’s a woman who did nothing wrong, yet bore the brunt of a scandal that should have ended a man’s career. And yet.

And yet.

Favre, of course, is nowhere to be found. He doesn’t participate on camera, and the film doesn’t pretend otherwise. This absence isn’t just a narrative choice; it’s the story’s central irony.

The man who was once the most visible player in the NFL, the guy who never missed a game in the season count, the quarterback who turned "retirement" into a running joke—he’s silent now. The film fills the void with voices: journalists, teammates, Sterger, even Michael Vick, who delivers the film’s most damning line: "People go to jail for stealing money every day… I just think that’s how the system is rigged." It’s a moment that lands like a sack, and it’s the closest the film comes to a thesis.

Favre’s fall wasn’t just about bad decisions; it was about a system that let him get away with them.

The welfare scandal, which takes up the film’s final act, is where The Fall of Favre feels most urgent. Gitlitz doesn’t just lay out the facts—she shows the receipts. Text messages between Favre and Mississippi officials, financial records, the kind of paper trail that makes you wonder how this man isn’t in prison.

(He repaid a reported budget, the film notes, as if that’s supposed to make it okay.) The documentary’s tight runtime works against it here; there’s so much to unpack, and the film races through it like a two-minute drill. I found myself pausing, rewinding, trying to absorb the sheer scale of the alleged misconduct. It’s a lot.

And yet, again, Favre skates. No charges. No real consequences.

Just a civil suit and a reputation that, for many, remains untarnished.

This is where the film’s biggest flaw—and its most fascinating tension—lies. The Fall of Favre wants to be a reckoning, but it’s also a product of the same system it critiques. Netflix, after all, is in the business of making myths as much as dismantling them. The Untold series thrives on scandal, but it also needs stars.

Favre is both. The film’s promotional materials tease "never-before-seen footage" and "explosive interviews," but the reality is more complicated. The footage is mostly archival, the interviews are compelling but not exactly explosive, and the film’s biggest "reveal" is the sheer audacity of Favre’s alleged actions.

There’s nothing here that will surprise anyone who’s followed the story, but that’s not the point. The point is to make you feel it—the anger, the frustration, the way Sterger’s voice cracks when she talks about the media’s treatment of her.

The audience reaction has been predictably split. On Letterboxd, the average rating is a lukewarm 2.8/5, with some viewers calling it a "scumbag takedown" and others dismissing it as a "one-sided hit job." Wisconsin Right Now, a conservative outlet, went so far as to call it "a terrible outing" from Untold, arguing that it rehashes old news without adding anything new.

But that’s not entirely fair. The film doesn’t uncover new facts, but it consolidates them in a way that’s hard to ignore. It’s one thing to read about the Sterger scandal in a news article; it’s another to hear her describe it in her own words, to see the texts and voicemails laid out like evidence in a trial.

The film’s power isn’t in revelation; it’s in accumulation.

And yet, I can’t shake the feeling that something’s missing. The welfare scandal, in particular, feels rushed. The film touches on Favre’s ties to Prevacus, the concussion-treatment company that received millions in misdirected funds, but it doesn’t dig deep enough.

What was Favre’s actual role? How much did he know? The film doesn’t say, and that’s frustrating.

It’s as if Gitlitz is so focused on the Sterger story that she doesn’t give the financial scandal the space it deserves. Or maybe she’s just working with what she has. Favre’s silence looms over everything, and the film can’t escape it.

What The Fall of Favre does best is expose the double standards that protect men like Favre. The film contrasts his treatment with that of Michael Vick, who served 21 months in prison for his role in a dogfighting ring. Vick’s crime was heinous, but Favre’s alleged actions—harassment, financial impropriety—are, in their own way, just as damning.

And yet, Favre remains a beloved figure, a "legend," while Vick’s career was nearly destroyed. The film doesn’t spell this out, but it’s there, in the subtext, like a bad pass that everyone pretends not to see.

The craft here is solid, if unremarkable. Gitlitz relies on a familiar documentary playbook: archival footage, talking heads, a propulsive score that ratchets up the tension. The film’s visual style is functional, not flashy.

There are no dramatic reenactments, no stylized flourishes—just the facts, laid out with a journalist’s precision. It’s effective, but it’s not art. This isn’t O.J.: Made in America; it’s a brisk, no-nonsense indictment.

And maybe that’s enough.

I kept thinking about something Jenn Sterger says near the end of the film. She’s talking about the media’s treatment of her, the way they painted her as the villain, but her words could just as easily apply to Favre himself: "It’s like they wanted to believe the worst about me, but the best about him." That’s the heart of The Fall of Favre—not just the story of one man’s fall from grace, but the story of how we choose what to believe, and who we choose to protect.

The film doesn’t offer easy answers, but it does something more important: it forces you to ask the questions. And in a world where myths die hard, that might be the most radical act of all.

Audience Opinions

Audience 6.9/10
"A revealing but uneven dive into Brett Favre’s scandals that leaves some viewers wanting deeper accountability."

Access to key figures, including Favre himself, gives rare insight into the controversies that tarnished his legacy. Some feel it goes easy by leaning on Favre's perspective, leaving questions about systemic issues in sports culture unanswered. The South Mississippi angle adds a personal touch but won't satisfy those wanting a harder-hitting exposé.

What viewers praise
  • Strong access to subjects Interviews with Brett Favre and other central figures give a rare inside look at the scandals.
  • Engaging storytelling Archival footage and personal anecdotes keep it flowing.
  • Local perspective Favre's ties to South Mississippi humanize the story.
  • Balanced tone It avoids sensationalism and presents the facts in a measured way.
Common complaints
  • Lacks depth on accountability Some feel it pulls punches on the broader implications of Favre's actions.
  • Uneven focus It shifts between Favre's personal story and the scandals without always connecting them.
  • Missed opportunities More voices from those directly affected would have strengthened it.
  • Predictable structure It follows a familiar documentary formula.
Recommended for
Sports documentary fans Brett Favre followers True crime and scandal enthusiasts NFL history buffs South Mississippi locals

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Netflix’s Untold: The Fall of Favre Exposes the Dark Side of a Gridiron Legend

Brett Favre’s legacy has long been defined by his gunslinging arm, Super Bowl glory, and folksy charm. But Netflix’s latest Untold documentary, The Fall of Favre (2025), directed by Rebecca Gitlitz, promises to dismantle the myth—revealing how unchecked power and privilege collided with scandal to tarnish one of the NFL’s most enduring stars. Premiering May 20, 2025, as the third installment of Untold’s fifth volume, the film dives into the controversies that reshaped Favre’s reputation, latestnetflix.com contends, from workplace misconduct allegations to financial impropriety.

A Reckoning Two Decades in the Making

Favre’s fall from grace wasn’t sudden—it was a slow unraveling. The documentary zeroes in on two major scandals: the 2010 sexting allegations involving New York Jets reporter Jenn Sterger, and his later entanglement in Mississippi’s welfare fraud case, where he was accused of misusing millions in public funds for personal projects. Sterger, a key figure in the film, reportedly provides firsthand accounts of Favre’s inappropriate behavior, while journalists like Jemele Hill and Peter King offer broader context on how the NFL’s culture of impunity enabled such conduct.

The film’s title—The Fall of Favre—isn’t just dramatic flair. Sources suggest it frames Favre’s downfall as a cautionary tale about celebrity, accountability, and the cost of silence. "The documentary doesn’t just rehash old headlines; it connects the dots between Favre’s on-field dominance and his off-field entitlement," notes The Viewers Perspective. Whether it will sway public opinion remains to be seen, but the inclusion of Favre himself—alongside former teammates like Ron Wolf and Don Majkowski—hints at a rare, unfiltered look at the man behind the myth.

Behind the Scenes: Who’s Talking—and Who’s Not

Gitlitz’s approach appears to blend investigative rigor with emotional weight. The cast list reads like a who’s who of Favre’s orbit: sports radio host Bill Michaels, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel columnist Rick Cleveland, and Packers historian Reggie Warnsley all contribute, suggesting a mix of local insight and national perspective. Notably absent from the confirmed lineup? Michael Vick, whose name appears in IMDb’s cast list but isn’t mentioned in other sources—a discrepancy that could hint at a last-minute edit or a minor role.

The documentary’s timing is no accident. With Favre’s legal battles still fresh in the public mind (he settled a defamation lawsuit in 2023 but denied wrongdoing in the welfare scandal), Untold arrives as the NFL grapples with its own reckoning over player conduct and institutional cover-ups. Whether Favre cooperated fully—or at all—remains unclear. Netflix hasn’t confirmed his level of involvement, but his presence in the cast list implies at least some participation.

Why This Story Still Stings

For Packers fans, Favre’s legacy is sacred. For critics, it’s a case study in how fame insulates the powerful. The Fall of Favre doesn’t just revisit scandals—it asks why they were allowed to fester. The film’s promotional materials tease "never-before-seen footage" and "explosive interviews," though specifics are scarce. If the Untold series’ track record is any indication (past installments tackled the Duke lacrosse scandal and the rise of Tiger King), Gitlitz’s documentary won’t pull punches.

One question looms: Will Favre’s loyal fanbase watch? The Untold series thrives on controversy, and this entry is no exception. As Grokipedia puts it, the film "chronicles Favre’s trajectory from gridiron stardom to entanglement in off-field scandals"—a narrative that’s as much about the NFL’s failures as it is about one man’s.

The Verdict: Too Soon or Overdue?

Nearly 15 years after the Sterger scandal and five years after the welfare fraud allegations surfaced, The Fall of Favre arrives at a moment when sports documentaries are increasingly holding icons accountable. Whether it’s a necessary reckoning or a sensationalist takedown depends on who you ask. But with Netflix’s global reach and the Untold brand’s reputation for hard-hitting storytelling, this film is poised to reignite debates about Favre’s legacy—and the systems that protected him.

For now, the trailer remains under wraps, and Netflix has stayed tight-lipped about key details. But one thing is certain: The Fall of Favre won’t let the past stay buried.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.