
Ulrich Thomsen
Erik

“You Choose Your Family”
A funny and moving story of family and free love set in a freewheeling 1970s commune. When Anna and Erik inherit a huge house, they gather a motley crew of cohabitants to reinvigorate their lives, forcing them to reconcile their new values with old habits.
Official
I’ve been thinking about The Commune for days, not because it’s a great film—it isn’t, quite—but because it’s the kind of movie that lingers like a half-remembered dream. You wake up still feeling the weight of its rooms, the way the light slanted through the windows, the way the people inside them kept bumping into each other like furniture that hadn’t been arranged properly.
Thomas Vinterberg, the Danish director who gave us the brutal family reckoning of Festen and the devastating The Hunt, has always been obsessed with the ways we fail each other in private. Here, he trades the claustrophobia of a single dinner table for the sprawl of a shared house, a place where ideals go to die slowly, quietly, over cups of coffee and half-finished conversations.

The premise is simple: Anna (Trine Dyrholm) and Erik (Ulrich Thomsen) inherit a rambling Copenhagen mansion in the 1970s and decide to turn it into a commune, filling its rooms with friends, artists, and hangers-on. The idea is freedom—from convention, from loneliness, from the stifling expectations of bourgeois marriage. But freedom, as Vinterberg knows, is just another word for people getting in each other’s way.
The film’s first act is its most alive, a messy, warm tangle of bodies and voices, the camera darting between rooms like an overcaffeinated guest at a party. There’s a real joy in watching these people try to build something together, even as the cracks start to show. Erik, a professor, brings home a much younger student, Emma (Helene Reingaard Neumann), and the house’s fragile equilibrium begins to tilt.
What’s fascinating about The Commune is how little it actually feels like a commune. For all the talk of shared living and collective ideals, the film is really about the ways we hoard our own misery. The house becomes a stage for private dramas, each character retreating into their own corner when the going gets tough.
Vinterberg shoots the interiors with a kind of restless intimacy, the camera often lingering just a beat too long on a face or a gesture, as if waiting for someone to finally say what they mean. But they never do. The film’s most devastating moments aren’t the big confrontations—they’re the small, quiet ones, like the scene where Anna, drunk and raw, confesses to the group that she’s been sleeping with someone else.
Not in a fit of rage, not in a moment of triumph, but in a slurred, sloppy admission that feels less like liberation and more like a surrender. Dyrholm plays it with a terrifying vulnerability, her body slumped in a chair, her voice thick with alcohol and regret. It’s the kind of performance that makes you want to look away, not because it’s bad, but because it’s too real.

The problem with The Commune is that it never quite decides what it wants to be. Is it a satire of 1970s idealism? A domestic drama about the slow unraveling of a marriage?
A character study of a woman who can’t decide whether she wants to be free or just wants to be left alone? The film tries on all these hats, and none of them fit quite right. The commune itself, which should be the heart of the story, often feels like a backdrop rather than a living, breathing entity.
The other residents—played by a solid ensemble that includes Lars Ranthe and Fares Fares—are sketched in broad strokes, their personalities reduced to quirks rather than fully realized people. It’s hard to care about the fate of the house when the house itself feels like a prop.
And then there’s the affair. Oh, the affair. It’s the kind of plot development that feels inevitable from the moment Emma walks into the room, all youth and easy charm, a living, breathing rebuke to Anna’s weary middle age.
Vinterberg has always had a knack for writing men who are their own worst enemies, and Erik is no exception. Thomsen plays him with a kind of clueless arrogance, a man who thinks he’s smarter than he is, who mistakes selfishness for self-awareness. The scenes between him and Emma are shot with a queasy intimacy, the camera lingering on their bodies in a way that feels less erotic than clinical.
This isn’t passion; it’s a transaction. And when Anna finds out, the film lurches into melodrama, complete with shouting matches and slammed doors. It’s the least interesting part of the movie, not because the emotions aren’t real, but because the mechanics feel so familiar.

What saves The Commune from being just another forgettable relationship drama is Dyrholm, whose performance is nothing short of extraordinary. She’s one of those actors who can convey entire worlds with a single glance, and here, she’s given the kind of role that demands everything from her. Anna is a woman who wants to be free but doesn’t know how, who loves her husband but can’t stand him, who craves connection but pushes people away.
Dyrholm plays her with a rawness that’s almost painful to watch, her body language shifting from defiant to defeated in the space of a single scene. There’s a moment near the end of the film where Anna, drunk and heartbroken, dances alone in the kitchen while the rest of the house sleeps. It’s a small gesture, but it’s the kind of thing that stays with you—this woman, trying to reclaim some scrap of joy in a life that’s falling apart around her.
The film’s biggest flaw, in the end, might be that it’s too gentle with its characters. Vinterberg has made a career out of exposing the rot beneath the surface of polite society, but here, he pulls his punches. The commune doesn’t collapse in a blaze of glory; it just sort of… fades away.
The house is sold, the dream is abandoned, and everyone goes back to their lives, a little older, a little more cynical. It’s a realistic ending, but it’s also a disappointing one. After spending two hours with these people, you want something more than a quiet dissolution.
You want fire. You want blood. You want the kind of emotional devastation that Vinterberg is so good at delivering.
But maybe that’s the point. The Commune isn’t Festen. It’s not a film about the explosive moments that shatter lives; it’s about the slow, creeping realization that the life you built isn’t the one you wanted. It’s about the way love curdles into resentment, the way freedom can feel like a cage, the way even the most radical ideas can be undone by the oldest human failings.
It’s a film that understands, in its bones, that the most interesting stories aren’t the ones where everything changes—they’re the ones where nothing does, and you’re left picking through the ruins, wondering what went wrong.
I keep coming back to that kitchen scene, the one where Anna dances alone. It’s not a triumphant moment. It’s not even a sad one, really.
It’s just a woman, in the middle of the night, trying to remember what it felt like to be happy. And for a little while, she does. That’s the tragedy of The Commune.
It’s not that the dream fails. It’s that it was never enough.
"Strong performances and lived-in 1970s detail prop up a slow, predictable relationship drama that never reaches the director's usual emotional intensity."
Trine Dyrholm’s award-winning turn as Anna is the emotional core; the ensemble and textured recreation of 1970s Copenhagen give the story a believable, sometimes gripping atmosphere. The initial commune and group-dynamics setup is intriguing, but the plot narrows into a familiar affair storyline that feels clichéd, slow, and less affecting than the director’s more acclaimed work.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
Thomas Vinterberg's The Commune, Danish title Kollektivet, opened in Denmark on January 14, 2016. Ulrich Thomsen is Erik, the architecture lecturer who inherits a huge house in an upmarket Copenhagen district. Trine Dyrholm is Anna, the TV newsreader who talks him into filling it with friends. Helene Reingaard Neumann plays Emma, the student Erik falls for. latestnetflix.com's view is that Cineuropa's Berlin notice named the extra fact the press kit did not scream.Neumann is Vinterberg's spouse. They married in 2010. She had already been in his Submarino. Here she is the younger woman the house votes to absorb.,
Vinterberg told The Hollywood Reporter he moved into a Copenhagen commune at seven. "It wasn't like free sex and drugs everywhere." His father was a film critic. The household was academics, TV people, "a few too many beers." He lived there until 19. The movie began as a play he improvised at Vienna's Burgtheater after staging The Celebration there. Tobias Lindholm, his Hunt collaborator, helped turn it into a film. Vinterberg keeps saying it is "based on a true feeling," not his parents' diary. Screen Daily printed the line he grins through. "I grew up among genitals in a big house, and it was absolutely fabulous and wonderful.",,
The film competed for the Golden Bear at the 66th Berlinale. Dyrholm won Best Actress. The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw called her performance the thing that carries a tense 1970s Copenhagen experiment until the affair blows the vote. Denmark named it one of three films that could go up for the foreign-language Oscar, then picked something else. TrustNordisk sold it. Magnolia put it in U.S. Theaters and on VOD on May 19, 2017. Zentropa produced with Toolbox Film. Festival notes kept repeating the reunion. Dyrholm and Thomsen had already detonated a family in The Celebration.,,,
A month before Berlin, Vinterberg sat down with people he had not seen in 20 years. In his head they were still young. They were divorced and older. "I had somehow lived under the idea that one day I could move back. But I realize that isn't going to happen," he told THR. That is the gossip under the period clothes. The director who grew up sharing a house cast his wife as the woman who splits one, then watched Dyrholm take the prize for surviving it. The international trailer still opens on 450 square meters and the argument about whether the house is too big to keep for two.,
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.