
Lana Condor
Lara Jean Song Covey

“Follow your heart like never before.”
Lara Jean and Peter have just taken their romance from pretend to officially real when another recipient of one of her love letters enters the picture.
Official
I have a weakness for love letters. The ink traps a version of the writer who no longer exists, a self caught mid-feeling. To All the Boys: P.S. I Still Love You gets that freeze. This sequel is about what happens when the person you wrote to finally writes back.
Jenny Han's first film was charming and slight. Lara Jean's private letters got mailed by accident. Fantasy hit the hallway.
This one picks up with Lara Jean, played by Lana Condor, and Peter Kavinsky, played by Noah Centineo, officially together. The lie is gone. Dating is what is left, and dating is messier than a premise.

Rom-com sequels are scarce because the fun is in the first act. Meet-cute, then rain. Once the couple exists, the movie has to invent weather. *P.S.
I Still Love You* brings back John Ambrose McClaren, played by Jordan Fisher, the boy who received one of those old letters. A love triangle. It feels inevitable and a little desperate, like the script is hunting for conflict because comfort will not sell tickets.
The quiet patches are better. The first movie loved spectacle. Slow-motion runs, confessions in the rain, gestures that feel borrowed from a John Hughes reel. This one stays in the in-between. Lara Jean and Peter in bed, talking about nothing. Not a trailer beat. The kind of nothing I have actually sat through.

Then the film gets nervous and yanks back. Jealous spikes. Misunderstandings on a timer.
The aquarium scene wants to be a showstopper, Lara Jean and John Ambrose under bioluminescent jellyfish. Pretty. Also effortful.
If the magic needs that much glow, it is already in trouble. I preferred Lara Jean volunteering at a retirement home with Holland Taylor, who steals every scene she walks into, and Kitty, played by Anna Cathcart, meddling with the blunt honesty only a little sister gets to use.
Condor is the reason the movie works as well as it does. She makes a cliche line sound like a thought she is having now. When Lara Jean tries to explain to Peter why John Ambrose still has a hook in her, the mix of frustration and softness feels unperformed.
Centineo is still spending the first film's charm. He is not bad. There is not much under the lovable-jock surface once the chase is over.
The look is aggressively pretty. Jewel tones, soft lamps, teal and pink stacked like a filter someone forgot to turn off. Everything a little too curated. To All the Boys has always liked the idea of romance more than the laundry of it. The sequel leans harder into the postcard.

Critics split on whether anyone needed this movie. Nick Allen at RogerEbert.com put it bluntly: "It's hard to get past the hope that Lara Jean will someday soon get something better, a better boyfriend, and a better movie." Variety called it "squeaky-clean."
The Hollywood Reporter went with "To all the bores: P.S. Still bored." Those lines land.
I still watched a film that likes its people. No irony shield. It wants to tell a love story even when the story is thinner than it believes.
The first movie was the terror of the letter being read. This one is the inbox after. Replies, mix-ups, a secret that has already been spent.
It is not as fresh. Love goes stale too. Sometimes it is two people trying to stay in the same room. *P.S.
I Still Love You* misses that more often than it hits it. When it hits, I was glad I had not bailed for the jellyfish.
"A charming but uneven sequel that struggles to recapture the magic of its predecessor, despite strong performances from its leads."
The chemistry between Lana Condor and Noah Centineo remains the film's highlight. The story lacks the freshness and emotional depth of the first movie, though, and leans on familiar teen romance tropes. A new love interest adds some intrigue but never fully engages, leaving the sequel a weaker retread of the original.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
The 2020 sequel To All the Boys: P.S. I Still Love You brought back the beloved romance of Lara Jean Covey (Lana Condor) and Peter Kavinsky (Noah Centineo), but this time with a twist: a new love interest, John Ambrose McClaren (Jordan Fisher), stirred the pot. While the film’s plot kept fans guessing, behind-the-scenes moments revealed just how much the cast enjoyed bringing the story to life—especially Condor and Centineo, latestnetflix.com argues, whose real-life friendship mirrored their characters’ playful dynamic.
The chemistry between Condor and Centineo wasn’t just for the cameras. A behind-the-scenes featurette showcased their easy rapport, with the two stars playfully teasing each other between takes. Centineo, known for his charm, seemed to relish his role as the lovable but flawed Peter, while Condor balanced Lara Jean’s sweetness with a newfound confidence. Their off-screen camaraderie likely made the romantic tension feel even more authentic on screen.
Jordan Fisher, who joined the cast as John Ambrose, also brought a fresh energy to the set. While the film’s love triangle kept fans debating Lara Jean’s choice, Fisher’s portrayal of the kind-hearted John added a layer of complexity to the story. Though the evidence doesn’t detail his interactions with Condor or Centineo, his character’s popularity suggests he held his own in the dynamic.
One of the biggest questions fans had was: Who would Lara Jean choose? But what about Condor’s personal take? In an interview clip, she playfully hinted at her own preference between Peter and John, though she kept it coy—likely to avoid spoiling the film’s ending. The ambiguity only fueled speculation, with fans dissecting every glance and line delivery in the movie.
Condor also opened up about the challenges of filming a sequel, noting how Lara Jean’s growth required her to step into a more assertive version of the character. In another interview, she discussed the pressure of living up to the first film’s success while keeping the story fresh. The sequel, after all, wasn’t just a retread—it introduced new conflicts, including Peter’s insecurities and Lara Jean’s struggle to balance her feelings.
Music played a key role in P.S. I Still Love You, with the soundtrack featuring dreamy pop tracks that amplified the film’s romantic and nostalgic vibes. The original score and licensed songs, including the single "As I’ll Ever Be", helped underscore Lara Jean’s emotional journey. The soundtrack was curated to match the film’s tone—sweet, bittersweet, and full of teenage longing—proving that even in a sequel, the right music could make the romance feel brand new.
While the first To All the Boys film was a near-universal hit, P.S. I Still Love You received mixed reactions. Some fans adored the deeper exploration of Lara Jean and Peter’s relationship, while others felt the love triangle with John Ambrose fell flat. Reviews on platforms like SensCritique reflected this divide, with ratings averaging around 4.8/10—far from the original’s near-perfect reception.
Still, the film’s behind-the-scenes moments offered a glimpse into why the cast and crew were so invested. From Condor’s playful interviews to the on-set chemistry between the leads, it was clear that even if the sequel didn’t land with everyone, the team behind it had fun making it.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.