Skip to main content
Movie poster for Making Unorthodox (2020)

Making Unorthodox

2020
21m
English
Search on Netflix

Overview

Documentary about the making of the Netflix FIlm "Unorthodox"

Reviews

3 min read

The Making Of, or The Unmaking Of Authenticity

I’ve always been suspicious of behind-the-scenes documentaries. They’re the cinematic equivalent of a museum gift shop—selling you the story of how the art was made instead of letting the art speak for itself. Making Unorthodox, the 21-minute companion piece to Netflix’s Unorthodox miniseries, is no exception. But what makes it interesting isn’t its revelations about the production (though there are a few) but how it inadvertently exposes the tension between authenticity and artifice, between the lived experience of its source material and the polished drama that brought it to screen.

The documentary is, at its core, a series of talking-head interviews with the women behind Unorthodox: the director Maria Schrader, the writer Anna Winger, the Yiddish language consultant Eli Rosen, and others. They speak about the challenges of adapting Deborah Feldman’s memoir, the meticulous research into Hasidic customs, the decision to film in Berlin instead of New York. It’s all very earnest, very professional.

And yet, there’s something missing—a gap between the reverence for authenticity and the reality of what ends up on screen.

A still from *Making Unorthodox* showing the production team reviewing scripts and costumes, the weight of representation visible in their expressions.

The most revealing moment comes when the team discusses the use of Yiddish in the series. They talk about hiring native speakers, about the difficulty of finding actors who could both perform and speak the language fluently. It’s a fascinating detail, one that underscores the production’s commitment to getting things right.

But it also raises a question: How much of this effort is visible to the audience? Does the average viewer even notice the difference between a line delivered in flawless Yiddish and one that’s slightly off? The documentary doesn’t ask this question, and maybe it shouldn’t.

But it lingers in the air, a quiet reminder that authenticity is often more about the intent than the execution.

There’s a strange disconnect here. The documentary is framed as a celebration of the creative process, a peek behind the curtain. But the curtain is never fully pulled back.

We see the costumes, the scripts, the rehearsals—but we don’t see the moments of doubt, the arguments, the compromises. The filmmakers talk about the pressure of representing a community they’re not part of, but they don’t show us what that pressure looks like in practice. It’s as if the documentary itself is performing the same balancing act as the series: striving for authenticity while carefully controlling the narrative.

This isn’t a criticism, exactly. Making Unorthodox isn’t trying to be a deep dive into the ethics of cultural representation. It’s a promotional piece, a love letter to the craft of adaptation. But in its eagerness to highlight the care that went into the production, it inadvertently reveals the limits of that care.

Authenticity, after all, isn’t just about getting the details right. It’s about acknowledging the gaps between reality and representation, the things that can’t be captured no matter how hard you try.

I keep thinking about Deborah Feldman’s memoir, the source material for the series. The documentary mentions it only in passing, as if it’s a given that the audience already knows the story. But the memoir is a raw, unfiltered account of a woman’s escape from a life she didn’t choose.

The series, by contrast, is a carefully constructed drama, one that smooths out the rough edges of Feldman’s experience in the name of narrative coherence. The documentary doesn’t grapple with this tension. It doesn’t need to.

But it’s there, in the space between the interviews, in the way the filmmakers talk about “honoring” Feldman’s story without ever quite engaging with what that means.

Maybe that’s the point. Making Unorthodox isn’t a documentary about the making of a series. It’s a documentary about the making of a myth—the myth of authenticity, the myth of representation, the myth that art can ever fully capture the truth of a life. It’s a fascinating failure, if you can call it that.

Because in its attempt to show us how the sausage is made, it ends up reminding us that some things can’t be contained in a 21-minute featurette. Some things resist the very act of being made.

Audience Opinions

Broad evidence
Audience 6.5/10
"A concise behind-the-scenes look at the making of *Unorthodox*: authentic, but too brief to go deep."

*Making Unorthodox* (2020), a 21-minute documentary directed by Marlene Melchior, is a straightforward companion piece to the Netflix miniseries *Unorthodox*. It offers a glimpse into the creative process behind the series, with cast and crew interviews and production footage. It works as a supplementary feature for fans of the miniseries, particularly those interested in the real-life inspiration behind the story, but it is too short to fully explore the themes or production challenges. The 6.5/10 rating reflects a mixed but generally positive reception: authentic, limited in scope.

What viewers praise
  • Authentic behind-the-scenes content Interviews and production footage offer genuine insight into the making of *Unorthodox* and add to an understanding of the miniseries.
  • Valuable for fans of the miniseries A worthwhile watch for *Unorthodox* fans, deepening the connection to the story and its real-life roots.
Common complaints
  • Too short and lacking depth The 21-minute runtime is not enough to fully explore the production process or the miniseries' themes.
  • Limited appeal beyond miniseries fans Niche: it mainly serves those who have already watched *Unorthodox* and want its backstory.
Recommended for
Fans of the *Unorthodox* miniseries Fans of behind-the-scenes documentaries about real-life inspired dramas Those curious about the creative process behind Netflix productions

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

The 20-minute film admits the Berlin half is invented.

Netflix put Making Unorthodox up the same day as the four-part series, 26 March 2020. TMDB lists a 21-minute English documentary directed by Marlene Melchior. The official blurb calls it a look at one of the first series to portray a Hasidic community as it bears on women's lives. latestnetflix.com's read is that The YouTube cut on Still Watching Netflix runs 21:01 and walks through Deborah Feldman, Anna Winger, Alex Reid, Amit Rahav, Jeff Wilbusch, Delia Mayer, and Langston Uibel.

The gossip is the confession. Winger, on camera in the short, says they changed the present-day story because Feldman is a young public figure and a public intellectual, and they wanted Esther's Berlin life to be very different from Deborah's. Flashbacks follow the 2012 memoir. The Berlin plot is entirely made up. ScreenRant and Esquire both pull that line from the extra. Feldman told the New York Times the team argued over when they could sacrifice accuracy, and agreed they could if it did not hit the narrative.

That is a rare thing to put in a companion film. Most making-ofs sell authenticity. This one sells the split. Williamsburg, the arranged marriage, the Satmar rules, those stay close to Feldman's book. The music conservatory, the scholarship, Yanky and Moishe hunting her through Berlin, those are cover so a living writer would not watch her real German life play out in four hours.

They cast Jews, then taught them Williamsburg Yiddish.

Winger told Variety they would only cast Jewish actors in Jewish roles, partly for the language. People who spoke Yiddish, or whose grandparents had, would have a feeling for it. Shira Haas and Amit Rahav had to learn the Hungarian-inflected Williamsburg dialect. Of the four leads, Jeff Wilbusch was the native speaker, from a Satmar background via Jerusalem's Mea Shearim. Actor and Yiddish specialist Eli Rosen translated the scripts, coached the floor, and played the rabbi. Wikipedia files Unorthodox as the first Netflix series primarily in Yiddish.

Producer Henning Kamm joined in October 2018. Delivery was 20 January 2020. Fourteen months to write, shoot two continents, and finish post. They shot 45 days in Berlin with a full crew and five days in New York. Most New York interiors, including a wedding that took three days, were built in Germany. The wedding hall was a Palestinian venue in Berlin. Netflix, Kamm said at Sarajevo, sat in on scripts and piled on post-production meetings even though the show is not post-heavy. Maria Schrader directed all four hours and later won the Emmy for Outstanding Directing for a Limited Series, the first Primetime Emmy for a German production.

Feldman is on camera in the short talking about a community founded by people carrying immense trauma. Winger has said the story doubled back on history, a Jewish woman escaping her life by going to the source of that trauma. The 20-minute extra is where they tell you which half to trust.

Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.