Skip to main content
Movie poster for In for a Murder (2021)

In for a Murder

2021
1h 44m
14 · Polish
Director: Piotr Mularuk
Play trailer
Search on Netflix

Overview

A stay-at-home mom and avid reader of crime stories discovers the deepest secrets of a small town's residents while investigating a woman's murder.

Trailer

Cast

12 people

Reviews

4 min read

A Small-Town Murder, a Big-Screen Mess

I’ll admit it: I went into In for a Murder expecting a Polish Knives Out—a witty, twisty whodunit with sharp dialogue and a dash of social satire. The premise had all the right ingredients: a stay-at-home mom with a nose for crime fiction stumbling into a real-life murder investigation, uncovering the rot beneath a picturesque town’s surface. It sounded like the kind of film that could balance humor and suspense, the way The Nice Guys or Kiss Kiss Bang Bang do—stories where the mystery is almost beside the point, just an excuse to watch flawed, funny people bumble their way toward some kind of truth.

But somewhere between the script’s good intentions and the screen, something went wrong. In for a Murder isn’t a bad film, exactly. It’s just a film that doesn’t seem to know what it wants to be. Is it a comedy?

A thriller? A character study? The answer, frustratingly, is all of the above—and none of them quite land.

A dimly lit room where a group of characters huddle around a table, their faces half in shadow, tension palpable in the air

The biggest issue is the tone. Polish cinema has a long tradition of blending dark humor with even darker subject matter—think The Lure or Spoor—but here, the shifts between comedy and suspense feel jarring rather than organic. One minute, we’re watching Anna Smołowik’s protagonist, Magda, deliver a deadpan line about the absurdity of small-town gossip; the next, the film lurches into a scene of genuine menace, as if it forgot to signal the gear change.

It’s the cinematic equivalent of someone telling a joke at a funeral—you’re not sure whether to laugh or wince.

That’s not to say there aren’t moments that work. Smołowik, who carries the film almost single-handedly, has a knack for physical comedy that feels effortless. There’s a scene early on where Magda, mid-investigation, tries to casually eavesdrop on a conversation while pretending to browse a grocery store aisle.

The way she fumbles with a jar of pickles, her eyes darting between the shelf and the suspects, is the kind of small, human detail that could have anchored the film if the script had given her more to work with. Instead, she’s often saddled with dialogue that feels like it was written for a different movie—one where the stakes were lower, the humor broader, and the mystery less convoluted.

The supporting cast doesn’t fare much better. Paweł Domagała, as Magda’s husband, oscillates between baffled spouse and comic relief without ever settling into a rhythm. Piotr Adamczyk, usually a reliable presence in Polish films, is wasted here as a smug local official whose motivations are as murky as the film’s genre identity.

Even the town itself, which should feel like a character in its own right, comes across as a series of clichés: the nosy neighbor, the corrupt mayor, the reclusive artist with a secret. It’s as if the filmmakers skimmed the Wikipedia page for "small-town tropes" and called it a day.

A wide shot of a quaint Polish town square, cobblestone streets glistening under a gray sky, the camera lingering on a single, ominous storefront

There’s a kernel of something interesting here—a story about how women, especially those relegated to the domestic sphere, are often the ones who see the truth while the men around them blunder through life with their eyes closed. Magda’s obsession with crime novels isn’t just a quirk; it’s a way for her to assert control in a world that’s otherwise dismissive of her. But the film never digs deep enough into that idea.

Instead, it settles for a series of red herrings and half-baked reveals, as if the mystery itself is an afterthought.

I kept waiting for the moment when In for a Murder would commit to its own vision, when the pieces would click into place and the film would reveal itself as something more than the sum of its parts. But that moment never came. The ending, in particular, feels like a cop-out—a twist that’s neither surprising nor satisfying, just a way to wrap up the plot before the credits roll.

It’s the kind of resolution that makes you wonder if the filmmakers lost faith in their own story halfway through.

That’s not to say there isn’t enjoyment to be found here. The cinematography, at least, is a bright spot. The film’s small-town setting is captured with a moody, almost gothic beauty—all misty streets and shadowy interiors—that contrasts nicely with the lighter moments.

And there are a few scenes where the humor lands, like a running gag about Magda’s husband’s terrible cooking, that remind you of what this film could have been if it had just picked a lane and stuck to it.

But in the end, In for a Murder feels like a missed opportunity. It’s not offensive, not boring, not even particularly bad—just disappointingly there. Like a dinner party where the conversation never quite takes off, where the host keeps changing the music halfway through a song, and you leave feeling vaguely unsatisfied, wondering what might have been if someone had just made a decision and stuck with it.

Maybe that’s the real mystery here: not who killed whom, but why a film with this much potential ended up feeling so half-baked. If you’re in the mood for a Polish crime comedy with a side of existential confusion, In for a Murder might scratch an itch. But if you’re looking for something with a little more bite, you’d be better off revisiting The Hater or Clergy—films that, for all their flaws, at least know what they want to be when they grow up.

Full Plot (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning

This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.

Buzz & Rumors

Public reports

Behind the Scenes of In for a Murder: A Polish Crime Comedy-Drama with a Twist

Piotr Mularuk’s In for a Murder (2021) blends crime, comedy, and drama in a story that flips the script on traditional whodunits. Based on Katarzyna Gacek’s novel W jak morderstwo, the film follows Magda, a stay-at-home mother whose life takes a chaotic turn when her passion for true-crime stories collides with reality. latestnetflix.com's take is that but what went into bringing this Polish production to life?Here’s what we know—and what remains under wraps.


From Page to Screen: The Adaptation Game

In for a Murder marks a rare adaptation of Gacek’s novel, a detail that might intrigue fans of the source material. The film’s Polish title, W jak morderstwo, directly mirrors the book’s name, suggesting a faithful—if not inventive—translation of its tone. Mularuk, known for his work in both Polish cinema and international co-productions, took the helm as director and likely played a role in shaping the screenplay. His background in independent filmmaking hints at a hands-on approach, though specifics about script changes or creative liberties remain unconfirmed.

The shift from novel to film often involves trimming subplots or amplifying visual elements, but the evidence doesn’t reveal whether In for a Murder streamlined Gacek’s story or expanded it. What’s clear is that the film leans into a mix of genres, described as a "crime comedy-drama", a label that sets it apart from darker, grittier crime thrillers.


Casting Choices: Who Brought Magda to Life?

Anna Smołowik stars as Magda, the film’s frustrated protagonist whose obsession with murder mysteries spirals into real-life chaos. Smołowik, a recognizable name in Polish cinema, shares the screen with a cast that includes Paweł Domagała (The Hater), Szymon Bobrowski (The Woods), and Piotr Adamczyk (Chopin: Desire for Love). The ensemble suggests a balance of dramatic weight and comedic timing, though the evidence doesn’t specify how the actors prepared for their roles or whether improvisation played a part.

One standout detail: the film’s Rotten Tomatoes page lists Smołowik and Bobrowski as leads, but Domagała’s inclusion—despite his prominence in Polish film—isn’t highlighted. This could imply a supporting role for the actor, or simply an oversight in the snippet. Either way, the cast’s chemistry (or lack thereof) isn’t detailed in the available sources, leaving room for speculation about on-set dynamics.


Reception and Ratings: A Mixed Bag?

Early audience reactions to In for a Murder appear lukewarm. On SensCritique, the film holds a 5.6/10 rating based on 24 votes, a modest score that hints at divisive opinions. The description tags it as a "comedy-drama-thriller," but whether it delivers on all three fronts remains subjective. Rotten Tomatoes, typically a go-to for critical consensus, doesn’t provide a score or review tally in the snippet, leaving its reception in the English-speaking world unclear.

The film’s 105-minute runtime suggests a tight narrative, but without deeper reviews, it’s hard to gauge whether the pacing works or if the genre-blending lands as intended. For now, In for a Murder seems to occupy a niche: a Polish crime story with comedic undertones, appealing to fans of lighter mysteries but perhaps not breaking out as a standout in its category.


The Unanswered Questions

Despite the available snippets, In for a Murder leaves plenty of blanks. Here’s what we don’t know:

  • Behind-the-scenes drama: No reports of on-set conflicts, creative clashes, or production challenges. - Box office or streaming performance: The evidence doesn’t mention how the film fared commercially or where it’s available to watch. - Director’s vision: Mularuk’s approach to adapting Gacek’s novel—whether he aimed for faithfulness or reinvention—isn’t detailed. - Audience reactions in Poland: The SensCritique rating is based on a small sample, and broader Polish reception isn’t covered.

For now, In for a Murder remains a curiosity: a crime-comedy with a solid cast and a novel-based premise, but one that hasn’t yet sparked widespread discussion or acclaim.


Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.

More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.