
Kevin Guthrie
Fergus Suter

Two 19th-century footballers on opposite sides of a class divide navigate professional and personal turmoil to change the game — and England — forever.
Official
I’ll admit it: I came to The English Game expecting a Downton Abbey with shin guards. Julian Fellowes, after all, has made a career out of upstairs-downstairs melodrama, and here he was tackling the birth of professional football—a subject ripe for the same kind of class warfare he’s mined before. But what I found was something messier, more uneven, and ultimately more interesting than a simple period drama.
This is a show that wants to be both a rousing sports story and a social critique, and it stumbles precisely because it can’t decide which one it cares about more.
The series is set in 1879, a time when football was still the domain of wealthy amateurs who played for the love of the game (or, more accurately, the love of their own leisure). The working-class players, meanwhile, were barred from competing in the FA Cup—until Fergus Suter (Kevin Guthrie) and Jimmy Love (James Harkness), two Scottish mill workers, arrive in Lancashire and begin to change the rules.
Suter, in particular, is a fascinating figure: a man who sees football not just as a game but as a way out of poverty, even if it means bending the rules of amateurism. His rivalry and eventual friendship with Arthur Kinnaird (Edward Holcroft), the aristocratic captain of the Old Etonians, forms the emotional core of the series.

But here’s the problem: The English Game is far more interested in the upstairs than the downstairs. The working-class characters are often reduced to broad strokes—Fergus is the noble underdog, Jimmy is the hotheaded sidekick, and Martha Almond (Niamh Walsh), the mill owner’s daughter, is the spunky love interest who exists mostly to gasp at the injustices of the class system.
The aristocrats, meanwhile, get the juicier material. Arthur Kinnaird’s internal conflict—his loyalty to the old ways versus his growing respect for Suter—is the most compelling thread in the series, and Holcroft plays him with a quiet, aching restraint. There’s a scene in Episode 3 where Arthur, after losing a match to Fergus’s team, sits alone in his study, staring at a portrait of his father.
The camera lingers on his face, and you can see the exact moment he realizes that the world he’s inherited is already crumbling. It’s the kind of small, human moment that Fellowes excels at—when he bothers to write them.
The football itself, which should be the show’s beating heart, often feels like an afterthought. The matches are brief, choppy, and oddly unexciting, as if the show is embarrassed by its own premise. Screen Daily’s critic wasn’t wrong when they wrote that The English Game is “like a lumpy wet leather football that stubbornly refuses to lift.” The action is shot in a way that makes it hard to follow the flow of play, and the stakes—beyond the obvious class tensions—are rarely clear.
This is a show that wants to have its cake and eat it too: it wants the thrill of the game without the messiness of actual sports, the drama of revolution without the discomfort of real change.

And then there’s the issue of historical accuracy—or, more accurately, the show’s blithe disregard for it. The English Game is a “historically fictionalized account,” which is a polite way of saying it plays fast and loose with the facts. Fergus Suter never actually played for Darwen, the team he’s depicted as joining in the series, and the timeline of football’s professionalization is compressed and rearranged for dramatic effect.
This wouldn’t matter so much if the show didn’t present itself as a kind of history lesson, complete with title cards that ground the story in real events. But it does, and so the liberties it takes feel less like creative license and more like a betrayal of the very history it claims to honor.
That said, there’s something undeniably compelling about the way The English Game captures the tension between tradition and progress. The series is at its best when it focuses on the small, personal battles rather than the grand ideological ones. The scenes between Fergus and Arthur are electric, not because of any grand speeches about class struggle, but because of the quiet, unspoken understanding that passes between them.
There’s a moment in Episode 5 where the two men share a drink after a match, and the air between them is thick with everything they can’t say. It’s a rare instance where the show trusts its actors to do the work, and they deliver.
The women of The English Game, unfortunately, don’t fare as well. Martha and Alma Kinnaird (Charlotte Hope) are both strong-willed characters, but they’re given little to do beyond reacting to the men around them. Alma, in particular, is a frustrating figure—she’s sharp, ambitious, and clearly smarter than her husband, but the show keeps sidelining her in favor of Arthur’s internal monologues.
There’s a subplot about her involvement in the suffrage movement that feels tacked on, as if the writers remembered at the last minute that women existed in the 19th century and needed something to do.

In the end, The English Game is a show of contradictions. It’s gorgeously shot, with a production design that immerses you in the grime and grandeur of 1870s England, but it’s also oddly bloodless, as if it’s afraid to fully commit to the messiness of its own story. It wants to be a tale of revolution, but it’s far more comfortable with the status quo.
It wants to celebrate the working class, but it can’t resist the allure of the aristocracy. And yet, for all its flaws, I found myself oddly moved by it. Maybe it’s because, at its core, this is a story about people who are trying to change the rules of a game that was never meant to include them.
That’s a story worth telling, even if The English Game doesn’t always tell it well.
The Sydney Morning Herald called the series “gorgeously shot,” and it’s hard to disagree. The costumes, the sets, the way the light filters through the windows of a Lancashire pub—it’s all undeniably beautiful. But beauty isn’t enough. The English Game is a show that looks like a masterpiece but often plays like a rough draft.
It’s entertaining, sure, but it’s also a reminder that good intentions don’t always make for good television. What lingers isn’t the football, or the revolution, or even the romance. It’s the quiet moments—the ones where the characters forget to perform their roles and just exist.
Those are the moments that make The English Game worth watching, even if they’re not enough to make it great.
Netflix’s The English Game (2020) isn’t just a period drama about the birth of modern football—it’s a story of class divides, unlikely friendships, and the messy, human side of sports history. latestnetflix.com's view is that while the series has drawn praise for its gripping narrative, the behind-the-scenes details reveal just as much about the show’s ambition to balance authenticity with drama.
At the heart of The English Game is the tension between working-class players and the aristocratic elite who dominated 19th-century football. Actors Kevin Guthrie (Fergus Suter) and Edward Holcroft (Arthur Kinnaird) have spoken about how this dynamic shaped their performances. In interviews, the duo discussed the challenges of portraying characters whose backgrounds were worlds apart—both on and off the pitch. Holcroft, who plays the privileged Kinnaird, and Guthrie, as the working-class Suter, emphasized how their real-life friendship helped bridge the gap between their characters’ rivalry. The series doesn’t just dramatize class conflict; it leans into the personal stakes, making the audience root for both sides.
One of the most talked-about aspects of The English Game is its attention to period detail, particularly in the costumes. Kevin Guthrie, who plays the trailblazing Suter, joked in a behind-the-scenes feature about his character’s signature look: denim flares. While the comment was lighthearted, it underscored how the show’s wardrobe team used clothing to reinforce the class divide. Suter’s practical, slightly scruffy attire contrasts sharply with Kinnaird’s polished, upper-class ensembles, a visual shorthand for their opposing worlds. The costumes weren’t just about aesthetics—they were a storytelling tool, grounding the characters in their social realities.
The English Game takes creative liberties with history, but how much? According to a deep dive into the series’ accuracy, the show blends real events with fictionalized drama. While Fergus Suter and Arthur Kinnaird were real figures, some plotlines—like the romantic subplots and certain match outcomes—were embellished for narrative effect. The series’ creators have defended these choices, arguing that the spirit of the era matters more than strict adherence to every detail. Still, for purists, the show’s blend of fact and fiction has sparked debate.
The production faced unique challenges in bringing 1870s football to life. Unlike modern sports dramas, The English Game had to recreate a version of the game that looked nothing like today’s Premier League. The "Making Of" featurette reveals how the cast trained extensively to mimic the physicality and style of Victorian-era football, which was far rougher and less structured than the modern game. The actors’ dedication to authenticity—from learning period-accurate ball-handling techniques to enduring the physical demands of the sport—added a layer of realism that resonates with fans.
Despite the rich behind-the-scenes content, some details remain elusive. There’s little public information about the show’s budget, the exact number of episodes (though it’s a limited series), or the creative tensions that might have arisen during filming. Rumors about potential sequels or spin-offs have circulated, but nothing has been confirmed. For now, The English Game stands as a self-contained story, leaving fans to speculate about what could have been.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.