
Christina Milian
Layla

On a quest to reconnect with the man of her dreams, Layla races across New York City to find a ticket to a sold-out Pentatonix Christmas Eve concert.
Official
I’ve always had a soft spot for holiday rom-coms—not because they’re good, exactly, but because they’re reliable. Like a favorite sweater that’s slightly too itchy but you wear it anyway, these films offer a kind of comfort that’s less about surprise and more about recognition. Meet Me Next Christmas, Netflix’s latest entry in the genre, is no exception. It’s a film that knows its audience: people who want to believe in serendipity, who sigh at the sight of twinkling lights, who don’t mind if the plot is as predictable as the arrival of a credit card bill in January.
And yet, for all its familiarity, there’s something oddly meta about it—like a holiday rom-com that’s aware it’s a holiday rom-com, winking at the audience even as it delivers the same old magic.

The premise is simple: Layla (Christina Milian), a self-described "hopeless romantic," is determined to reconnect with James (Kofi Siriboe), the man she’s convinced is her soulmate, by securing tickets to a sold-out Pentatonix Christmas Eve concert in New York City. Along the way, she teams up with Teddy (Devale Ellis), a concierge with a knack for problem-solving and a smile that suggests he’s hiding more than a few secrets.
Their chemistry is the film’s strongest asset—Milian and Ellis have an easy, playful rapport that makes their banter feel less like scripted dialogue and more like two people who actually enjoy each other’s company. It’s the kind of chemistry that makes you root for them, even when you know exactly where their story is headed.
And that’s the thing about Meet Me Next Christmas: you do know where it’s headed. The film leans hard into the tropes of the genre—the meet-cute that’s not quite a meet-cute, the race against time, the moment of self-realization that arrives just in time for the credits to roll. There’s a treasure hunt element to Layla’s quest, with clues hidden in the city’s holiday decorations, but it’s not so much a puzzle as it is a series of excuses to keep the plot moving.
The real treasure, of course, isn’t the concert tickets—it’s love, or something like it. The film’s emotional stakes are so low they’re practically subterranean, but that’s not necessarily a flaw. Sometimes, you don’t watch a holiday rom-com for depth; you watch it for the same reason you eat another cookie even though you’re full.
It’s not about hunger. It’s about the ritual.
What makes Meet Me Next Christmas interesting, if not exactly groundbreaking, is its self-awareness. The film doesn’t just rely on the usual holiday magic—it comments on it. The members of Pentatonix, playing fictionalized versions of themselves, follow Layla and Teddy’s journey via social media and Wikipedia, debating whether they should intervene in the couple’s love story.
It’s a clever twist on the "fate vs. free will" theme that often lurks beneath the surface of these films, and it gives the movie a playful, almost meta energy. At one point, the group’s bass, Kevin Olusola, deadpans, "We’re not Cupid," as if to remind the audience that even in a world where love is supposed to conquer all, someone still has to do the work.

The film’s musical set pieces are where this self-awareness shines brightest. There’s a scene where Layla, in a moment of desperation, performs a lip-sync version of "Santa Baby" in a drag show competition, complete with a sequined dress and a crowd that’s equal parts bewildered and delighted. It’s a moment that could have felt tonally jarring—too campy, too over-the-top—but Milian sells it with a mix of humor and vulnerability that makes it one of the film’s standout scenes.
It’s the kind of moment that feels like it belongs in a different, weirder movie, and I found myself wishing Meet Me Next Christmas had leaned harder into that weirdness. Instead, it pulls back, settling into the cozy, predictable rhythm of a Hallmark movie with slightly better production values.
But maybe that’s the point. Holiday rom-coms aren’t supposed to be weird. They’re supposed to be comforting, like a warm drink on a cold day.
And Meet Me Next Christmas delivers on that front, even if it occasionally stumbles over its own cleverness. The New York City setting is used to great effect—snow-covered streets, twinkling lights, the kind of holiday aesthetic that makes you want to book a last-minute flight to Manhattan, even if you know it’ll be crowded and overpriced. The film’s tone is relentlessly cheerful, to the point where it almost feels like a dare: Can you resist this much holiday spirit? The answer, for most viewers, will probably be no.
That said, the film isn’t without its missteps. The supporting characters, including Kalen Allen’s Jordy, feel underdeveloped, existing mostly to deliver punchlines or move the plot along. And while the Pentatonix subplot is fun, it’s also a bit baffling—why would a world-famous a cappella group care so much about the love life of a random woman in New York?
The film never quite justifies their involvement beyond the gimmick, and their scenes often feel like they belong in a different movie, one where the stakes are higher and the humor sharper.
The New York Times’ Brandon Yu called the writing "baffling," and I can see where he’s coming from. There’s a moment early in the film where Layla explains her grand romantic plan to Teddy, and the dialogue feels like it was written by someone who’s seen a lot of rom-coms but hasn’t actually lived in the world they’re trying to depict. It’s not that the lines are bad, exactly—it’s that they’re too on-the-nose, as if the script is afraid the audience won’t "get it" if it doesn’t spell everything out.
That kind of heavy-handedness is a common pitfall in the genre, and Meet Me Next Christmas doesn’t always avoid it.

Still, there’s something endearing about the film’s willingness to embrace its own silliness. The Tribune called it a "passable romcom," and that feels about right—it’s not a film that’s going to change the way you think about love or holiday movies, but it’s also not trying to. It’s a film that knows its place in the world: a cozy, inoffensive distraction, the cinematic equivalent of a Christmas cookie.
And sometimes, that’s enough.
What Meet Me Next Christmas does best is remind us why these kinds of movies endure. They’re not about realism or complexity; they’re about the idea of love, the kind that arrives just in time, wrapped in a bow and tied with a promise. It’s a fantasy, sure, but it’s a fantasy that feels good to believe in, even if just for a little while.
The film’s final act, in which Layla and Teddy finally make it to the concert, is as predictable as it is satisfying—a reminder that sometimes, the best part of a holiday rom-com isn’t the destination, but the journey. Even if that journey is as well-trodden as a department store Santa’s lap.
In the end, Meet Me Next Christmas is a film that delivers exactly what it promises: a lighthearted, feel-good holiday romance with just enough charm to make you forget, for 105 minutes, that the world outside is anything but cozy. It’s not a movie that will linger in your mind long after the credits roll, but it’s not trying to be. It’s a snow globe of a film—pretty to look at, fun to shake up, and ultimately, just a little too fragile to hold onto for long.
And maybe that’s okay. After all, how many of us really need another holiday movie to remember? Sometimes, it’s enough to just enjoy the moment—and the cookies.
"A lighthearted holiday rom-com with festive charm but a predictable plot and underdeveloped side characters."
The cozy Christmas atmosphere and lead chemistry provide enough warmth to keep it enjoyable, though the plot is overly familiar. The feel-good tone works, but the supporting cast lacks the depth to match the leads' energy.
Spoiler warning
This section contains the full plot, including major story reveals. Overview above stays spoiler-free.
The holiday rom-com Meet Me Next Christmas (2024) is already generating buzz—not just for its festive premise but for its blend of rising stars and unexpected musical talent. Directed by Rusty Cundieff, the film promises a fresh twist on the genre, with a cast that includes Christina Milian in the lead role and a surprise appearance by the Grammy-winning a cappella group Pentatonix. Here’s what we know so far about the making of this Netflix-bound holiday treat.
Christina Milian takes center stage as Layla, a woman on a mission to secure the hottest ticket in New York City for a chance at a fairytale romance. But the real draw might be the supporting cast, which includes Devale Ellis (The Wonder Years) and Kofi Siriboe (Queen Sugar), adding depth to the film’s romantic and comedic beats.
The biggest surprise? Pentatonix members Mitch Grassi, Scott Hoying, Kirstin Maldonado, Kevin Olusola, and Matt Sallee appear in the film, though their roles remain under wraps. Given the group’s holiday music dominance (their That’s Christmas to Me album went platinum), their inclusion suggests a musical element—perhaps a performance or a cameo that ties into the plot’s New York City setting. Rumor has it their scenes were filmed during a break in their tour schedule, though Netflix hasn’t confirmed details.
Cundieff, known for his work in comedy and horror (Tales from the Hood, Chappelle’s Show), brings a unique edge to Meet Me Next Christmas. While holiday rom-coms often lean into saccharine sweetness, Cundieff’s filmography suggests he might balance the genre’s tropes with sharper humor or social commentary. The script, penned by Molly Haldeman and Camilla Rubis, follows Layla’s frantic quest through NYC, but whether Cundieff’s direction will add a satirical or meta layer remains to be seen.
Production wrapped in late 2023, with filming reportedly taking place in New York during the holiday season—likely adding authenticity to the film’s wintry aesthetic. No behind-the-scenes drama has surfaced, but Cundieff’s reputation for efficient shoots might explain the lack of on-set gossip.
Despite the hype, key details about Meet Me Next Christmas remain scarce. Here’s what’s still unconfirmed:
Holiday rom-coms are a dime a dozen, but Meet Me Next Christmas has two potential trump cards: 1. Diversity: With a predominantly Black and Latinx cast, the film reflects a push for more inclusive holiday stories. Milian, Ellis, and Siriboe bring charisma that could resonate with audiences tired of the genre’s usual homogeneity. 2. Music: Pentatonix’s involvement is a smart marketing hook. If the film leans into their a cappella style—even for a single scene—it could set it apart from competitors like Holiday in the Wild or The Holiday Calendar.
Entertainment rumors and trivia aggregated from public reporting. Treat speculation as unverified unless a cited source confirms it.
More titles in the same genres and with the same cast.